Beef Plan ‘frustrated' at exclusion from TB eradication forum
Beef Plan Movement chairperson, Eamon Corley, has expressed deep annoyance at this state-of-affairs
Corley said: 'I would like to thank everyone who contributed with their feedback to Beef Plan, regarding TB.
'We compiled a submission based on the views that were expressed to us. It was submitted to the minister, Martin Heydon, ahead of the TB Forum meeting.'
Beef Plan has 2,300 farmer members and is committed to the retention of a viable suckler sector in Ireland.
Corley continued: 'While we are grateful that the minister has accepted our submission, we are frustrated and find it very unsatisfactory that the people who are making decisions on TB eradication have not invited our representatives to the forum.'
According to the Beef Plan chairperson, there were stakeholders at the forum representing badgers, deer, vets, and factories, yet he said an organisation specifically representing beef and suckler farmers was excluded.
'Whatever decisions that were taken will affect our beef and suckler farmers and those who make these decisions will not make make any progress in reducing TB levels in cattle by excluding key stakeholders.
'They should realise after 70 years of failure that measures to reduce TB will continue to fail without buy-in from farmers.
'They should also realise that they won't get buy in by excluding them: they are also forgetting who foots the bill,' Corley said.
Beef Plan's TB submission
Beef Plan's proposed TB eradication submission is based on three guiding principles – that an evidence-based strategy should be developed; that this strategy should be scientifically supported; and that the strategy should also prioritise the protection of farms and public health over the profits of the industry.
The organisation's submission references a number of key actions that must be taken by all relevant stakeholders.
These include the need for further clear and unambiguous research, as well as a thorough debate on the potential role of TB vaccines must take place.
In addition, the proposed restriction on the sale of fat cows to factories only will be strongly opposed by the organisation.
In regard to the control of TB in wildlife, Beef Plan contends that progress on the reduction of TB in cattle will never be successful without a more effective approach than the current one.
The organisation also proposes that no further restrictions on cattle and farms should be forced on farmers until a radical overhaul in the control of TB within wildlife populations is achieved.
Beef Plan is also calling for the issue of TB resistance within cattle populations to be carried out as a matter of priority.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
a day ago
- The Irish Sun
Row at the top of Armed Forces after Defence Secretary dishes out senior command job in secret
The news came in an email blunder sent by Mr Healey's private office ARMY ROW Row at the top of Armed Forces after Defence Secretary dishes out senior command job in secret THE Defence Secretary has caused a row at the top of the Armed Forces by dishing out a senior command job in secret. John Healey was forced to U-turn after Strategic Commander General Sir Jim Hockenhull found out Royal Marine General Rob Magowan was to get his job when he leaves the post next April. 2 The Defence Secretary has caused a row at the top of the Armed Forces by dishing out a senior command job in secret Credit: Getty The news came in an email blunder sent by Mr Healey's private office. Advertisement Healey had promised the post of Strategic Commander, which oversees cyber and special forces, to Royal Marine General Rob Magowan. It is one of the most powerful posts in the military, on par with commands of the Army, Navy and RAF. Chief of Defence Staff Admiral Sir Tony Radakin forced Mr Healey to back down, defence sources told The Sun. Our source said: 'This was a spectacular own goal. Advertisement "Hockenhull was furious. He stormed out. 'Then Magowan was told the deal was off — he was livid as well.' Hockenhull regularly briefed Sir Kier Starmer on Ukraine and was well liked in Downing Street Brit & French generals to lead rebuilding of Ukraine army with team sent in DAYS 2 Strategic Commander General Sir Jim Hockenhull, above, found out Royal Marine General Rob Magowan was to get his job when he leaves the post next April
Agriland
3 days ago
- Agriland
Ireland elected to council of UN Food and Agriculture Organisation
Ireland has been elected to join the governing council of the Food and Agriculture Organisation (FAO) of the United Nations (UN) for a two-year term. The council is the governing body of the FAO, which is the specialised agency of the UN for leading "international efforts to defeat hunger and improve nutrition and food security". During the 44th session of the FAO conference, the election to fill two vacant seats for the Europe and Central Asia region resulted in Ireland topping the poll and gaining a seat on the council for the first time since 2013. As a member of the FAO council, Ireland will play a key role in shaping the strategic direction, policy and oversight of the organisation. The Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine said that Ireland and the FAO are aligned through shared priorities in sustainable food systems, global food security, rural development, and environmental protection. Following the election, Minister for Agriculture, Food and Marine Martin Heydon said: "Ireland's agricultural expertise, particularly in sustainable food systems and out strong commitment to end global food insecurity, closely aligns us to the work of the FAO. "This is evident throughout our Food Vision 2030 strategy and our focus on the UN Sustainable Development Goals. Ireland looks forward to bringing a strong voice to the FAO council and working alongside FAO members to achieve these goals." The minister said that Ireland's role on the council will be "amplified" when we hold the rotating presidency of the Council of the EU in the second half of 2026. Minister Heydon added: "The significance of Ireland being a member of the FAO Council is that it will enable us to help to shape global food and agriculture policy, increase Ireland's visibility within the UN system, and to engage in high-level decision-making that supports sustainable development and multilateral cooperation to assist countries that can avail of our agriculture expertise. "My department, through the FAO, has already funded a number of key projects including in Sudan and Ukraine," he said. "Ireland has also joined the Global Network Against Food Crisis where not only are we the only country to do so, but joining with my department as the focal point of contact is very significant and has triggered interest from other national ministries of agriculture." Ireland's election to the FAO council follows on from Minister Heydon's recent participation at the sixth African Union-European Union Agriculture Ministerial Conference in Rome. At the time, Minister Heydon met with FAO director-general, Qu Dongyu, and both reflected on the need for coordinated global action to ensure food security and for transformation to sustainable agri-food systems.
Irish Examiner
4 days ago
- Irish Examiner
From one in four to one in 25: Ireland's shrinking farming workforce
The farmers, foresters, and fishers responsible for Ireland's primary production are now only one in 25 of the working population, and about one in 50 of the total population. They are the 108,450 working in "agriculture, forestry, and fishing" in 2024, according to the Central Statistics Office's Labour Force Survey. However, calculating farmers as a percentage of the working population depends on which of the CSO's surveys you follow, as explained by agriculture minister Martin Heydon, when asked for the number of people engaged in the food production industry as part of a parliamentary question before the Dáil broke up for the summer recess. Mr Heydon also gave the results of the CSO's Farm Structure Survey 2023, which indicated that 299,725 people worked on 133,174 farms across Ireland in 2023. The holders of these farms were 86.8% men and 13.2% women. Only 5,791 were aged under 35, while 50,392 were aged over 65. The Farm Structure Survey differs from the Labour Force Survey because it includes all people working on 133,174 farms, including those for whom it is not their main occupation. Mr Heydon added that for the purposes of calculating the agricultural labour force in 2023, 127,976 farm holdings of a defined size were included. Sole full-time Of these, 67,362 of farm holders defined farm work as their sole full-time occupation; 28,886 described farm work as a major occupation; and 31,728 as a subsidiary occupation. Excluding farm holders, 171,749 people worked on farms. Of these, some 132,278 were spouses and other family members, and 39,471 were non-family workers. This figure includes both part-time and full-time workers. Mr Heydon also gave the breakdown of the country's 299,725 people working on farms, both family and non-family workers, by region. Most are in the West, with 66,182; the border area has 56,249; the South-West has 49,814; the Midlands has 28,515; and the Mid-East and Dublin region has 27,704. In his parliamentary question, Dublin Fingal West Labour Party TD Robert O'Donoghue also enquired about age demographics, and the minister's reply included the mean age of farm holder by county and region. Nationally, this averaged 59.4, with relatively little variation, from a low of 58 in Donegal to a high of 60.9 in Galway. The youngest farmers are in the South-West, averaging 58.6. The oldest are in the West, averaging 60.7. Main occupation To complete the Labour Force Survey information, the minister said the 169,300 who worked in the agri-food sector as a main occupation in 2024 (representing 6.1% of total employment in Ireland), included 56,850 in the "manufacture of food and beverages" category, along with the 108,450 in the "agriculture, forestry, and fishing" category. Of those people employed in the manufacture of food and beverages, some 50,225 worked in food and 6,625 worked in beverages. Including them, and assuming that 75% of Irish-produced food is exported (it's about 90% for livestock products; however, Ireland also has large food imports), each worker in the Irish agri-food sector can be said to contribute to the nutrition of 30 people in Ireland, plus 90 overseas.
