How Supreme Court May Play a Role in Jeffrey Epstein Saga
Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content.
The Supreme Court may play a key role in the ongoing Jeffrey Epstein saga, as associate Ghislaine Maxwell has appealed her conviction to the nation's highest court.
Maxwell was convicted on multiple charges, including sex trafficking of a minor and transporting a minor with the intent to engage in criminal sexual activity, in 2021. She was sentenced to 20 years in prison.
Maxwell filed a petition for a writ of certiorari to the Supreme Court in April.
"Despite the existence of a non-prosecution agreement promising in plain language that the United States would not prosecute any co-conspirator of Jeffrey Epstein, the United States in fact prosecuted Ghislaine Maxwell as a co-conspirator of Jeffrey Epstein," David Oscar Markus, attorney for Maxwell, said in the filing.
A general overall exterior view of the Supreme Court, Sunday, Jan. 1, 2023, in Washington.
A general overall exterior view of the Supreme Court, Sunday, Jan. 1, 2023, in Washington.
Aaron M. Sprecher via AP
Why It Matters
The Epstein case recently made headlines after the Department of Justice (DOJ) and the FBI concluded there is no "client list" of prominent individuals linked to Epstein and said no further disclosure would be appropriate or warranted.
A Reuters/Ipsos poll showed 69 percent of respondents thought the federal government was hiding details about Epstein's clients.
Epstein, a financier and convicted sex offender, was found dead at New York's Metropolitan Correctional Center in August 2019 while awaiting trial on sex trafficking charges. His death was ruled a suicide.
What To Know
Maxwell's attorney argued she was shielded by a 2007 non-prosecution agreement between Epstein and the U.S. government covering alleged co-conspirators.
"I think her lawyers have made a credible argument that she should be entitled not to be prosecuted given that the agreement between Epstein and the government supposedly immunized co-conspirators from criminal prosecution." Michael Gerhardt, the Burton Craige distinguished professor of jurisprudence at the University of North Carolina, told Newsweek. "It makes no sense to treat her as if she were not a co-conspiration. Her role in facilitating Epstein's misconduct makes her a co-conspirator."
The DOJ argued Maxwell was not a party to this agreement in a brief filed July 14.
"There is no evidence that the parties to the NPA intended for the coconspirators clause to benefit petitioner," Solicitor General D. John Sauer, Acting Assistant Attorney General Matthew R. Galeotti and attorney Ethan A. Sachs wrote in the filing.
Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche formally requested federal courts to unseal grand jury transcripts in the criminal cases against Epstein and Maxwell on Friday, one day after Trump said on Truth Social that he asked Attorney General Pam Bondi to "produce any and all pertinent Grand Jury testimony, subject to Court approval."
"Grand jury proceedings are typically confidential and not subject to public inspection. But given the public interest in this case, the federal court might agree to the government's request especially if there are no privacy interests to protect," Wayne Unger, an assistant professor of law at Quinnipiac University, said in comments sent to Newsweek.
What People Are Saying
Michael Gerhardt, the Burton Craige distinguished professor of jurisprudence at the University of North Carolina, in comments to Newsweek: "It is hard to say whether the Court will take the appeal. The Court usually takes appeals if there is a split among the circuits and/or if the case presents a compelling issue for the Court to decide. Obviously, Maxwell's issue is important to her, but it may not be important to most of the justices."
David Oscar Markus, attorney for Ghislaine Maxwell, in a petition for a writ of certiorari: "This inconsistency in the law by which the same promise by the United States means different things in different places should be addressed by this Court."
Solicitor General D. John Sauer, Acting Assistant Attorney General Matthew R. Galeotti and attorney Ethan A. Sachs, in a brief filed July 14: "At all events, the case-specific interpretation of a particular NPA is not a matter that warrants this Court's review."
What Happens Next
The Supreme Court has yet to decide whether it will hear Maxwell's appeal.
Federal judges have also yet to rule on the release of grand jury transcripts in the cases of Epstein and Maxwell.
Do you have a story that Newsweek should be covering? Do you have any questions about this story? Contact LiveNews@newsweek.com.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Los Angeles Times
15 minutes ago
- Los Angeles Times
Virginia Giuffre's family expresses shock over Trump saying Epstein ‘stole' her
The family of Virginia Giuffre, who was among Jeffrey Epstein's most well-known sex trafficking accusers, said that it was shocking to hear President Trump say the disgraced financier 'stole' Giuffre from him and urged that Epstein's former girlfriend Ghislaine Maxwell remain in prison. Giuffre, who had accused Britain's Prince Andrew and other influential men of sexually exploiting her as a teenager trafficked by Epstein, has been a central figure in conspiracy theories tied to the case. She died by suicide this year. Her family's statement is the latest development involving Epstein, who took his own life in a New York jail in 2019 while facing federal sex trafficking charges, and the Republican president, who was his one-time friend. Trump denied prior knowledge of Epstein's crimes and said he cut off their relationship years ago, but he still faces questions about the case. Trump, responding to a reporter's question on Tuesday, said that he got upset with Epstein over his poaching of workers and that Epstein had stolen Giuffre from his Palm Beach, Florida, club. 'It was shocking to hear President Trump invoke our sister and say that he was aware that Virginia had been 'stolen' from Mar-a-Lago,' the family's statement said. 'We and the public are asking for answers; survivors deserve this,' it continued. White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt noted the president was responding to a reporter's question and didn't bring up Giuffre himself. 'The fact remains that President Trump kicked Jeffrey Epstein out of his club for being a creep to his female employees,' she said. The family's statement comes shortly after the Justice Department interviewed Maxwell, who was convicted in 2021 on sex trafficking and other charges and is serving a 20-year sentence in Tallahassee, Florida. Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche interviewed Maxwell in a Florida courthouse, though details about what she said haven't become public. Maxwell's lawyers have said she testified truthfully and answered questions 'about 100 different people.' They have said she's willing to answer more questions from Congress if she is granted immunity from future prosecution for her testimony and if lawmakers agree to satisfy other conditions. A message seeking comment about the Giuffre family's statement was sent to Maxwell's attorney Thursday. A Trump administration official said the president is not currently considering clemency action for Maxwell. Giuffre said she was approached by Maxwell in 2000 and eventually was hired by her as a masseuse for Epstein. But the couple effectively made her a sexual servant, she said, pressuring her into gratifying not only Epstein but his friends and associates. Giuffre said she was flown around the world for appointments with men including Prince Andrew while she was 17 and 18 years old. The men, including Andrew, denied it and assailed Giuffre's credibility. She acknowledged changing some key details of her account. The prince settled with Giuffre in 2022 for an undisclosed sum, agreeing to make a 'substantial donation' to her survivors' organization. The American-born Giuffre lived in Australia for years and became an advocate for sex trafficking survivors after emerging as a central figure in Epstein's prolonged downfall. Her family's statement said she endured death threats and financial ruin over her cooperation with authorities against Epstein and Maxwell. Catalini writes for the Associated Press.
Axios
15 minutes ago
- Axios
What the Epstein documentaries tell us about his case
The investigation into Jeffrey Epstein has become a centerpiece for documentaries. The big picture: Streaming services like Netflix, Hulu and Peacock offer multi-part series about the disgraced financier and his notoriety. Many of them include interviews with his accusers, like Virginia Giuffre, while also sharing information about the conspiracy theories surrounding Epstein's death. The Epstein saga has received renewed attention in recent weeks as the Trump administration deals with the intense public pressure to release court files related to the Epstein probe. Tensions rose after a Wall Street Journal report alleged a "bawdy" birthday letter to Epstein bore President Trump's name. Trump has repeatedly deemed the ongoing Epstein story a "hoax." Trump also accused Epstein of poaching spa workers from Mar-a-Lago, including Giuffre, who previously alleged that Epstein's associate Ghislaine Maxwell recruited her from Mar-a-Lago for Epstein when she was a teenager. Giuffre died by suicide earlier this year. Maxwell is currently serving a 20-year sentence in a Florida federal prison. By the numbers: U.S. viewership of Netflix's "Jeffrey Epstein: Filthy Rich" documentary surged amid all the news, according to data sent to Axios from Luminate. The series jumped from 13.6 million total minutes watched from July 11 to July 17 to 73.1 million minutes watched from July 18 to July 24 — a 430% spike, per Luminate. Netflix published an article on Wednesday that pointed viewers to the documentary, too. Here's a look at the prominent documentaries about Epstein, his accusers and the investigation available on streaming. "Surviving Jeffrey Epstein" What to know: The documentary was released in 2020 through Lifetime's "Stop Violence Against Women" initiative, which included documentaries about R. Kelly as well. "Surviving Epstein," which includes interviews with Giuffre, features explicit details of sexual abuse of minors and "delves into the aftermath the survivors are experiencing with no justice to be served," according to Lifetime's description. Where to watch: Amazon Prime Video "Jeffrey Epstein: Filthy Rich" Zoom in: This documentary is based off James Patterson's best-selling book "Filthy Rich: The Shocking True Story of Jeffrey Epstein." The 2020 four-part series includes interviews with accusers, like Giuffre, and explains how Epstein earned his wealth and fortune. " Outlining Epstein's unlikely rise to the highest echelons of wealth and power, the series dissects his years of sexual abuse of minors and the network of enablers who supported him," Netflix said in a press release. The Epstein-centered project inspired a second "Filthy Rich" documentary centered around Maxwell. Where to watch: Netflix "Prince Andrew, Maxwell & Epstein" Details: This documentary from Discovery+ runs less than an hour and focuses on Prince Andrew, who ran in Epstein's social circles and was accused by Giuffre of sexually abusing her. Andrew has denied the allegations. It also includes body language experts who examine the connection between Prince Andrew, Maxwell and Epstein. Where to watch: Apple TV, Prime Video "Who Killed Jeffrey Epstein?" Reality check: This three-part series has a rather provocative title, but the project centers around how Epstein earned his wealth and the allegations he faced. The piece also covers the widespread conspiracy theories about his death, with the final episode titled: "Suicide or Murder?" Where to watch: Hulu, Apple TV "Epstein's Shadow: Ghislaine Maxwell" Maxwell, who is still in prison after she was found guilty on multiple counts of conspiring to sex traffic minors, has been at the center of the Epstein probe recently as investigators seek more information about the financier.
16 minutes ago
Virginia Giuffre's family wants to know what Donald Trump knew about Jeffrey Epstein
The family of Virginia Giuffre, one of Jeffrey Epstein 's most well-known victims, said it was outraged at comments made by President Donald Trump about her and Ghislaine Maxwell, the Epstein associate convicted of sex trafficking. Trump on Wednesday told reporters that Giuffre, who died by suicide in April, may have been one of several employees at his Mar-a-Lago club who were "stolen" by Epstein. "I think she worked at the spa. I think so. I think that was one of the people," Trump said of Giuffre. "He stole her. And by the way, she had no complaints about us, as you know, none whatsoever." Giuffre's family in its statement rejected the characterization, saying she wasn't "stolen" by Epstein. "We would like to clarify that it was convicted sex trafficker Ghislaine Maxwell who targeted and preyed upon our then 16-year-old sister, Virginia, from Mar-a-Lago, where she was working in 2000, several years before Epstein and President Trump had their falling out," the family said. Trump's comments came amid growing calls for federal authorities to release records related to the Epstein case. Democrats in the Senate on Wednesday said they are attempting to force the release of those files through a little-known, decades-old law. Giuffre's family in their statement said it was "shocking" to hear Trump discuss Giuffre, saying he was aware of her being "stolen." Their statement called into question whether the president knew at that time about Epstein and Maxwell's actions. "It makes us ask if he was aware of Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell's criminal actions, especially given his statement two years later that his good friend Jeffrey 'likes women on the younger side . . . no doubt about it,'" the family said in its statement, referencing a quote attributed to Trump in a 2002 New York Magazine profile of Epstein. The family added, "We and the public are asking for answers; survivors deserve this." Epstein was arrested in July 2019 on federal charges of sex trafficking. He died by suicide that August while in custody, federal authorities said. Maxwell was convicted in 2021 of sex trafficking and sentenced the following year to 20 years in prison. The Department of Justice said she "assisted, facilitated, and participated" in Epstein's abuse of girls between 1994 and 2004. Giuffre had said that Maxwell recruited Virginia from Mar-a-Lago when she was 16 -- and also accused Maxwell of abusing her. Maxwell denied the allegations levelled against her and claimed in a 2016 deposition that Giuffre had "lied repeatedly." Maxwell this month met with Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche, answering questions for about nine hours over two days, sources told ABC News. Maxwell initiated those meetings with the Department of Justice, sources said. Giuffre's family in its statement said Virginia would be "most angered" by those meetings, adding that the "government is listening to a known perjurer. A woman who repeatedly lied under oath and will continue to do so as long as it benefits her position." The family described Maxwell as a "monster who deserves to rot in prison for the rest of her life." Trump was asked on Monday about whether Maxwell could be pardoned. "Well, I'm allowed to give her a pardon," Trump said. "But nobody's approached me with it, nobody's asked me about it. It's in the news, that -- that aspect of it. But right now, it would be inappropriate to talk about it."
