The Irish Times view on infrastructure delivery: radical solutions are needed
Reform in the way State cash is allocated is one change which we are told is already in train. And the new Planning Act may also help. But more will be needed. To help plan this, Minister for Public Expenditure, Jack Chamber,
has appointed the Accelerating Infrastructure Taskforce
, chaired by Sean O'Driscoll, the former chief executive of Glen Dimplex, to advise on how to proceed.
Following
the receipt of a report
drawn up by his Department reflecting the views of interests involved in infrastructure delivery, the taskforce is getting to work. The analysis is clear enough. Infrastructure and housing projects are mired in regulations and increasingly threatened by judicial review. This has led the administrative and regulatory system to take an overly-cautious approach – in part for fear of not ticking all the boxes and facing legal challenges. Beyond that, there have been clear issues in terms of project planning and oversight, of which the National Children's Hospital is just one example.
Finding the solutions is not straightforward, but there are a few guiding principles which the taskforce needs to abide by.
READ MORE
The first is a recognition that the whole system is now dysfunctional. The wider national interest is taking second place to that of objectors. A balance is needed, for sure, but as of now the impact of the system of regulation and previous legal decisions is to cause endless delay and uncertainty. A State in which it takes seven years to deliver an electricity substation is not an efficient one.
The second and related imperative for the group is the need to be radical. Fiddling around at the edges will achieve little. Addressing some of the key issues is not straightforward in a common law system and the committee will need to consider to what extent legislation can help , particularly relating to major national projects. But these projects are so central to people's lives and to economic progress that delays are hugely costly. Ireland is, for example, judged as the slowest county in the EU for consents for renewable energy projects. Again, it is a question of balance.
The third job for the taskforce will be to ruffle feathers - it needs to be unpopular. As it is composed of private and public sector appointees, consensus may not be easy. But successive governments, departments, State agencies, regulators , the legal system– and the private sector – have all come up short. Failures need to be called out. With billions extra to be spent in the years ahead , Ireland needs to recognise its shortcomings honestly and then address them .
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
5 hours ago
- Irish Times
Spending on EVs and retrofitting homes pushes growth in green personal lending, BPFI report finds
Consumers are increasingly going green with their personal loans, according to new figures on personal lending from the Banking and Payments Federation of Ireland (BPFI). The value of the average green personal loan rose by €474 in the first quarter, reaching €22,906 – more than double the value of the average personal loan in the period, at €11,239. Green personal loans made up €35.1 million of all borrowing between January and March. The growth in green loans coincides with the highest value of personal loan drawdowns of any quarter since BPFI began to compile the data in 2020. In total, Irish consumers drew down €683 million in personal loans in the three-month period. READ MORE Green borrowing is made up of car loans, for vehicles with electric batteries and plug-in hybrids, and home improvement loans such as for heat pumps or solar panels, and insulation upgrades. In the year to the end of Q1 2025, 5,500 green loans were issued, valued at €127 million. This represented nearly 900 more such loans than the previous 12-month period, as such lending saw the 'biggest increase in value' of any loan category. 'While increases were seen across all categories,' it was green personal loans that had the 'highest relative jump in value of 29.3 per cent year on year to €35.1 million in Q1 2025 and in volume by 26.6 per cent to 1,531," said Anthony O'Brien, BPFI's head of sector research and analysis. Mr O'Brien said there has been 'continued strong demand for personal loans' with the first three months of the year marking 'a new high for overall drawdown volumes and values'. There were 60,770 personal loans taken out in the period, with growth in the number of loans and their value of 22.1 per cent and 24.1 per cent on a year-on-year basis. On an annual basis, Irish consumers have drawn down 240,423 personal loans in the past four quarters at a value of €2.6 billion. Against this backdrop, the value of car loans reached a record €259 million in the first quarter of the year, following a 25 per cent increase on the €208 million figure in Q1 2024. Mr O'Brien said there has been a 'continued surge in car loans' with the category seeing 21.5 per cent year-on-year growth in numbers to 19,552, alongside an increase in value of 25.0 per cent in the same period. 'These are the highest car loan volumes and values since the data series began in 2020,' he said, noting that growth in electric and plug-in hybrid electric vehicles 'is likely contributing to these increases'. Home improvement loans increased in value by just over 19 per cent, while other loans, which include education, holidays and special occasions, rose in value by 27.5 per cent to €226 million.
Irish Times
7 hours ago
- Irish Times
Wirtz must reach Salah's level to meet Liverpool expectations, says Slot
Arne Slot has said Florian Wirtz must reach the standards set by Mohamed Salah to realise Liverpool 's expectations of their new record signing. Wirtz will make his Premier League debut when the champions open the season at home to Bournemouth on Friday. Slot claimed the Germany international's 'adjustment went better than expected, and we already expected a lot', but admitted a more accurate gauge would come in the Premier League. Liverpool consider the 22-year-old a transformative signing in the mould of Virgil van Dijk and Alisson. Their head coach believes Wirtz can have a similar impact by following the example of Salah, who continues to set the standards at Liverpool and has scored nine goals in seven opening-day fixtures, a Premier League record. READ MORE Slot, asked whether Wirtz was a signing to take Liverpool to the next level, replied: 'That is something I can only answer in the upcoming years. Everything we expect is very positive but between expecting and realising something is different. 'Why are Messi and Ronaldo and Mo so highly regarded? Because they are always fit. Every single game they are fit and that is something that Florian first has to show in a league like ours. If he is able to stay fit then our fans will see great moments.' Liverpool paid a club record £100 million (€116 million) to sign the attacking midfielder from Bayer Leverkusen and he could cost a British record £116 million (€135 million) with add-ons. Slot, however, denies Wirtz is a statement signing by the club, who beat Bayern Munich and Manchester City to his signature. 'Liverpool have done this before,' he said. 'With Alisson Becker we spent so much money, with Virgil we spent so much money, and with inflation I think it is the [level of] Liverpool signing. We mainly make these signings. But we also sell players. If we make these signings, we also have to sell players. 'He is a different profile to what we have. That is what we wanted – to bring a different profile in rather than adding something that we already had. It is very positive that we could bring in such a highly regarded player but I think Liverpool has always been able to bring in these kinds of players.' Liverpool's summer spending will pass the £300 million (€349 million) mark when the 18-year-old defender Giovanni Leoni joins from Parma for an initial £26 million (€30 million). The club also want to add Marc Guéhi and Alexander Isak. On a summer of change at Anfield, Slot reflected: 'I would have preferred Trent [Alexander-Arnold] to stay but unfortunately he didn't. Then you have to replace him. Then you have situations like Caoimhín Kelleher and Jarell Quansah. It is always hard for a player to have two or three seasons like this in a row [not being a regular] and if a player is not able to do this mentally then it is best to split ways and you have to replace. 'The Luís Diaz and Darwin Núñez situations are quite clear so then you have to replace. We had to replace and I think we did that really well. From the options we could get we got all the ones we would like to bring in.' – Guardian
Irish Times
8 hours ago
- Irish Times
The Irish Times view on the presidential election: the race now looks very different
The presidential election now looks very different after the shock withdrawal of the Fine Gael candidate Mairead McGuinness. The front-runner among the candidates declared so far, McGuinness said in a statement yesterday that she was dropping out of the race for health reasons. Her departure leaves just one candidate, Independent TD Catherine Connolly, who has enough support to be sure of a place on the ballot paper. She has the backing of the Social Democrats, Labour and People Before Profit. A number of potential Independent candidates are circling, though it is unclear how many could achieve a nomination. The race for the presidency was already slow getting under way, with Fianna Fáil and Sinn Féin still considering their options. Now Fine Gael needs to think again, too. Potential Independent candidates will also be mulling the changed outlook for the poll. The big parties need to realise that choice is important for the voters. McGuinness, with a long and high-profile career in public life – most recently as a European commissioner – had shown up well in initial opinion polls. Of course, the field has not yet been declared and past experience shows that the campaign can change everything, in what has often been a brutal process. Nonetheless, Fine Gael would have been confident of a strong showing and for voters the presence of McGuinness and Connolly would have provided two contrasting options. READ MORE Fine Gael, which always seemed well-placed to put forward a candidate, will now need to look to its 'bench' and figures like Seán Kelly and Frances Fitzgerald may come back into the frame. Observers have felt all along that Fianna Fáil would, eventually, put up a nominee. With a left-wing candidate already in the field, Sinn Féin's intentions will also be closely watched. Any nominee from one of the big three parties starts with a support base – and would thus have to be taken seriously. As they are able to guarantee a nomination, the big parties, while not in complete control of the process, have a strong hand to play. And they can also – between them – block Independents from entering the race, if they choose to do so. This does not mean Independents will not feature – nor that one or two might not do well. But they first have to jump the high bar of getting on the ballot. Voters will need to consider what they want from the president and what qualities they value. And it is important that the process delivers them a good choice. The job requires a mix of political nous, judgment and an ability to reflect the national mood. Michael D Higgins has been popular in part because of his willingness to speak out. With the departure of McGuinness, the race to succeed him has now got even more unpredictable.
