Indonesia cuts outlay on giant free meals programme to 350 trillion rupiah
[JAKARTA] Indonesia has trimmed spending plans for what could still be the world's second-most expensive free meals programme, offering modest relief from fiscal pressures as President Prabowo Subianto advances a host of big-ticket projects.
Planned spending on the programme, which targets reaching 83 million people in the coming months, is now forecast at 350 trillion rupiah (S$27 billion) next year after officials revised ingredient cost estimates lower by a third, said Dadan Hindayana, head of the newly created National Nutrition Agency. That marks a 22 per cent drop from spending plans earlier this year.
This year's expenditures are expected to total about US$7.5 billion, Hindayana said. That represents a 29 per cent reduction from prior plans.
The recalibration of the five-days-a-week programme, aimed at improving health outcomes for students, children under five, and pregnant or breastfeeding women in the world's fourth-most populous nation, could ease some investor concerns about Indonesia's budget deficit outlook as the president presses for big projects early in his presidency.
Prabowo has backed consumer stimulus measures, started rolling out tens of thousands of new community cooperatives and floated plans for an US$80 billion sea wall off the north Java coast.
Indonesia's free meals initiative could be the world's most expensive after the US, which budgeted US$29.4 billion for meals in the school year ended 2023, according to the Global Child Nutrition Foundation, a Seattle-based non-profit that surveys such programmes. The third most expensive programme that year, at a little over US$10 billion, was in France.
A NEWSLETTER FOR YOU
Friday, 8.30 am Asean Business
Business insights centering on South-east Asia's fast-growing economies.
Sign Up
Sign Up
One challenge will be to meet demand for food inputs, with the meals initiative sourcing eggs, chicken, fish, vegetables and fruit locally, Hindayana said. He added that milk demand will soon outstrip supply, and that the government plans to import as many as 1.5 million dairy cows in the coming years – potentially tripling the nation's existing herd – from countries such as Australia, New Zealand, Brazil, the US and European nations.
'We need time to induce people or farmers and everyone to produce food locally,' he said. 'Right now we still have no problem, but in the near future we need more supply.'
Hindayana said officials are still seeking to roll out meals to all 83 million recipients by the end of the year, even though it will require a 16-fold increase from five million currently. The drive thus far has been complicated by instances of food poisoning and logistical challenges in a country of more than 17,000 islands. He said the imminent deployment of some 30,000 university graduates to serve as managers of kitchen units would help accelerate efforts.
Private investment is another hurdle. The government is banking on the private sector to set up the bulk of some 32,000 kitchens to source foods and cook and distribute meals. Currently, fewer than 1,900 are in operation.
That's been a hard sell in the early going, with a single kitchen costing as much as US$183,000 and needing perhaps two years to break even, said Aditya Perdana, a political lecturer at the University of Indonesia.
'People are not convinced with the investment model and prefer to just wait and see the progress,' he said.
He added that while there has not been serious opposition to the free meals programme from political parties or citizens, implementation remains a question. 'You can be ambitious, but you must also be rational to avoid adding a burden to the state budget,' he said.
Analysts at Nomura Holdings last week reiterated their forecast for Indonesia to post a fiscal deficit this year of 2.9 per cent of gross domestic product, higher than a budgeted 2.5 per cent and close to the country's legal limit of 3 per cent. They cited weak economic growth and low commodity prices, along with plans to accelerate spending in the second half of the year, including for the free meals programme.
They added that they expect the government to announce a wider fiscal deficit outlook in July, when finance officials typically submit a mid-year budget review to parliament. Ministries will also begin discussing their budgets and work plans for 2026 with lawmakers next month.
Prabowo has acknowledged the challenges of the free meals drive while describing it as a long-term investment in Indonesia's future.
'Many people already express much negativity surrounding the free nutritious meal programme; they say it is an impossible programme,' he said in a Cabinet meeting last month, according to a statement. 'We need to prove them wrong.'
'We will call it a success, God willing, in December 2025,' he said. BLOOMBERG
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Times
2 hours ago
- Business Times
Vietnam's imprisoned tycoon seeks government nod for 930 trillion dong restructuring plan
[HO CHI MINH CITY] Imprisoned for orchestrating Vietnam's biggest financial fraud, property mogul Truong My Lan is seeking the government's nod for a 12-year, 930 trillion dong (S$45.5 billion) restructuring plan that proposes the involvement of global financial heavyweights Rothschild and UBS, as well as consulting firm Alvarez & Marsal and Singapore-based Greenmark Construction. According to recent local media reports, the proposal – submitted separately by Lan from jail and by her real estate group Van Thinh Phat (VTP) to the authorities – outlines a road map to mobilise capital for property projects and restructure Saigon Joint Stock Commercial Bank (SCB), from which she embezzled 304 trillion dong. The road map includes asset recovery, project revenue generation, and strategic investor participation in a bid to remedy the losses and reduce Lan's sentence by repaying at least three-fourths of the embezzled money. On Jun 18, Lan, currently detained at the T17 Detention Centre in Ho Chi Minh City, held a working session with representatives of her group and two German advisory firms that have agreed in principle to provide US$3 billion to fund the proposed plan. In a May letter to the authorities, she said that her decades of real estate experience and deep knowledge of the 1,166 secured assets for loans from SCB put her in the best position to turn them into 'golden geese' – income-generating assets that could help the state recover its losses. The latest 12-year plan reflects a last-ditch bid to secure leniency, as Vietnamese law allows a death sentence to be commuted if at least three-fourths of the embezzled funds are repaid. A NEWSLETTER FOR YOU Friday, 8.30 am Asean Business Business insights centering on South-east Asia's fast-growing economies. Sign Up Sign Up Rothschild, Alvarez & Marshal, and UBS were invited as strategic partners for international capital mobilisation, while Germania Helvetica Group and Milcon Gulf are being tapped for their expertise in corporate and bank restructuring, according to VTP's proposal cited by online outlet VnExpress. Singapore-based Greenmark Construction also features among the invited partners, along with local property developers NovaGroup and Hung Thinh. Lan was sentenced to death in 2024 for embezzling billions of dollars, bribery, bond fraud, and money laundering. She will be spared from the death penalty following a law change on Jun 25. Lan has been ordered to repay 674 trillion dong to SCB and an additional 30 trillion dong to bond investors. The Business Times had reported that Lan's prior effort to secure foreign support saw Malaysian tycoon Vincent Tan, founder of the Berjaya Group, agree to acquire the Sterling Residence development. This was part of her broader asset-recovery strategy, but there has been no official announcement on the progress or outcome of that plan. A three-pronged plan Under the proposed remedy scheme, VTP and its group of investors will disburse an initial US$2 billion in capital immediately upon receiving government approval. This first phase aims to stabilise SCB's operations, ensure liquidity for deposited funds, repay overdue debts, supplement working capital, and fund the completion of several large-scale, viable projects. The second phase, spanning the next five years, will see investors deploy some US$8 billion raised from partners and investment funds to develop legally cleared projects, with the aim of generating revenue from these assets. In the final phase, over the following seven years, investors plan to raise additional financing from domestic and international lenders to support major development projects, projected to yield around 680 trillion dong in revenue. Key projects include prime real estate in Ho Chi Minh City, such as 87 Cong Quynh Street, 289 Tran Hung Dao Street, the Nguyen Hue-Amigo Quadrangle, and Mui Den Do (the Saigon Peninsula). During this period, VTP expects to use the generated income from the three phases to repay the special loans from the State Bank of Vietnam – the country's central bank – and fulfil other financial obligations. SCB had previously received a multibillion-dollar bailout from the central bank following a 2022 bank run, which was triggered by the arrest of Lan, the lender's de facto owner, Reuters reported in March. No further rescue from central bank VnExpress noted that under Lan's 12-year remedy plan, SCB would not require additional loans from the central bank. This differs from an earlier proposal made by Sun Group, which was mandated by the central bank in November 2023 to assist SCB, the Reuters report indicated. In February this year, the developer submitted a 15-year rescue road map that indicated the central bank's lending could reach 657 trillion dong in the first year of restructuring the troubled lender, which could then start repaying the debts from year 14, subject to market conditions. In April, Dau Tu newspaper reported that the central bank was also drafting a plan to restructure SCB and was seeking suggestions from relevant bodies, though details of the plan and its submission timeline were not disclosed. The central bank and government have consistently appealed to the private sector, particularly foreign investors, to support the troubled lender. Vietnam's standard foreign ownership cap in commercial banks is 30 per cent, recently extended to 49 per cent for selected lenders that have taken over struggling peers. As at end-February this year, the non-performing loan ratio at SCB – one of the five ailing banks that are under special supervision by the authorities – stood at 98.5 per cent, Viet Dragon Securities Corporation wrote in a recent analysis, citing a report from the central bank.
Straits Times
2 hours ago
- Straits Times
Europe placates Trump with NATO pledges it can ill afford
NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte and Dutch Prime Minister Dick Schoof pose for a family photo with NATO leaders during a NATO leaders summit in The Hague, Netherlands June 25, 2025. REUTERS/Claudia Greco LONDON - In their rush to retain Donald Trump's support for NATO, the alliance's European members have promised to more than double the amount of wealth they set aside for military spending. The snag is that most can ill-afford to spend 5% of output on defence - so while there will be some unpalatable sacrifices in national budgets, there will also be some creative accounting to divert existing spending to the effort. "They will not get there," Guntram Wolff, senior fellow of the Bruegel think-tank, said of the 5% goal. "If you are a highly indebted country you can't issue more debt, it means very difficult budgetary choices," he said of the hefty tax hikes or spending cuts that it would require. As a piece of political theatre, the Hague summit at least won over its intended audience: Trump himself. Amid concerns about his commitment to NATO's mutual defence clause, he said the United States stood with its European allies "all the way". While few dispute that Europe needs to do more to ensure its own security as tensions with Russia rise, the fixation on the 5% target cut short a separate debate about how it could be using its existing military budgets more efficiently, for example with national governments agreeing on joint procurement. Now it has saddled itself with pledges which - with the notable exception of Germany, whose finances are solid after years of fiscal frugality - most members will find hard to keep. To hit the 5% threshold, European Union countries, whose debt pile already tops 80% of output, would between them have to nearly triple the 325 billion euros ($377 billion) they spent on defence last year to more than 900 billion. Non-EU Britain - whose debt is 100% of output and which already pays more in debt servicing than for every spending item apart from health - would need an extra 30 billion pounds ($41 billion). "The potential losers are not just future generations saddled with huge debts, but today's societies," said Nick Witney at the European Council on Foreign Relations. "Disgruntled populations, whose sense of economic wellbeing has never recovered from the global economic crash of 2008, will likely become even easier prey for populist or nationalist politicians gathering strength across Europe." GUNS OR BUTTER? To be sure, the closer a country sits next to Russia, the less domestic angst there is about finding the extra cash - Poland, the Baltics and Finland are all cases in point. Years of rivalry with neighbouring Turkey have meanwhile attuned Greek public opinion to accept higher defence spending. But Spain's Socialist Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez - whose country is alone in not expressly signing up to the new target - voiced the concerns of others when he said the goal was "incompatible with our welfare state". Slovakia, one of the central European countries whose budgets face the greatest strains from the defence build-up, has also baulked at the target, arguing that raising living standards and cutting its borrowing were equally important. Bruegel's Wolff said it remained to be seen whether countries increase their defence quotas by shaving the odd billion here and there off other areas, or whether big-ticket areas such as pensions take a sizeable hit. "But keep it in proportion - there will still be a welfare state but perhaps less generous," he said of social protections across Europe that can account for anything up to 30% of the economy. As leaders depart the Hague summit venue, the national conversations on defence will sound strikingly different to those that were had in the run-up to the gathering. The 5% breaks down into 3.5% to be spent on "core" defence - troops and weapons - and 1.5% on defence-related measures such as adapting roads and bridges to handle military vehicles. The room to wedge existing spending items into the second category will likely prove generous. In France, for example, there is discussion about whether that could include the gendarmes policing country lanes, who are formally part of the defence ministry but whose existing running costs currently lie outside the defence cost tally. The long deadlines aired for hitting the target - in some cases up to a decade - are also an opportunity for those pledges to be fudged as the political spotlight shines elsewhere. "Spending goals will simply be missed," said Witney. "The transformation required will begin to take shape, but less rapidly and less coherently than if more realistic targets had been set." REUTERS Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Straits Times
2 hours ago
- Straits Times
'Flexible' NATO spending targets affordable for Italy, PM Meloni says
Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni speaks to the media at a NATO summit in The Hague, Netherlands June 25, 2025. REUTERS/Claudia Greco ROME - New NATO targets for higher defence and security spending are affordable for Italy as they give countries "total flexibility" on how to reach them, Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni said on Wednesday. Speaking to reporters at the end of a NATO summit in the Netherlands, Meloni said "not a single euro" would be diverted from other budget priorities to fund the planned increase in defence spending. NATO leaders backed a plan to raise overall defence spending to 5% of gross domestic product (GDP) by 2035, from the current 2% goal, to heed demands from U.S. President Donald Trump that Europe pay more for its own security. Countries would have to spend 3.5% of GDP on core defence - mainly troops and weapons - and 1.5% on broader defence-related measures such as cyber security, protecting pipelines and adapting roads and bridges to handle heavy military vehicles. "I am persuaded that the new targets are sustainable, there is total flexibility," Meloni said, adding no minimum annual spending increase would be required. She did not elaborate on how heavily-indebted Italy would fund the new commitments. Only 17% of Italian supporting increasing defence spending, according to a poll by the European Council of Foreign Relations, the lowest proportion among 12 European countries surveyed. Meloni said her government had no immediate intention to use an EU flexibility clause that halts disciplinary measures for countries that break the bloc's deficit rules in order to spend more on defence. "For 2026, we do not think we need to use the clause, for the years to come we will evaluate based on what the economic situation is," she said. Meloni also said she was confident the European Union and the U.S. could end a trade dispute with an agreement on reciprocal 10% tariffs. "A 10% tariff base would not be particularly impactful for our firms," she said. REUTERS Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
