logo
‘Military Keynesianism'? Reeves faces British defence dilemma after EU spending surge

‘Military Keynesianism'? Reeves faces British defence dilemma after EU spending surge

The Guardian09-03-2025
As the Nobel laureate Robert Lucas quipped during the 2008 financial crisis: 'I guess everyone is a Keynesian in a foxhole.' Donald Trump's upending of the postwar security consensus has underlined the enduring wisdom of Lucas's observation. But now, instead of bank bailouts and emergency bond buying, European firepower is being directed at bombs, tanks and drones in the desperate fight to secure the continent's border with Russia.
Berlin and Brussels – typically capitals of financial orthodoxy – have been convinced that this approach is required once again. Under the plan put forward by Germany's chancellor-in-waiting, Friedrich Merz, Berlin is on the brink of relaxing its 'debt brake' rule to pave the way for spending on defence and infrastructure worth an additional €1tn (£840bn) over the coming decade.
The EU, too, is at a 'watershed moment', having agreed an €800bn plan allowing member states to ramp up borrowing for their defence spending, under an 'escape clause' from its stability and growth pact debt rules. It is being chalked up as one of the most remarkable shifts in European economic policy in decades.
But for Britain, a more old-fashioned approach still prevails, with the chancellor, Rachel Reeves, insisting that her self-imposed fiscal rules remain 'non-negotiable'. Rather than allow for a rise in borrowing, Labour's plan to increase defence expenditure from 2.3% of GDP to 2.5% by 2027 involved a corresponding cut for the overseas aid budget.
Pushing spending higher still would require further 'difficult decisions', Reeves has suggested.
The Treasury accepts the world has changed and that higher defence spending is a necessity, but with a tight fiscal position in advance of an already tough spring statement for the chancellor, paying for it will involve difficult decisions to find savings elsewhere.
There are hopes in Labour circles that Britain will follow Germany's 'military Keynesianism', but the Treasury view has not shifted that much. Reeves still believes in it enough to stick to fiscal rules that, after all, were only announced less than six months ago.
That is, in part, understandable. Fresh in Reeves's mind will be the bond market turbulence at the start of this year, in which the British government was in the eye of a global storm. Mostly that was driven by investor fears over Trump's inflationary policies. But there was also a UK-specific overlay.
Reeves could point to the sharp rise in German yields last week. On Wednesday, the yield – in effect, the interest rate – on Germany's 10-year bonds rose by the largest amount in a single day since March 1990. She could also point to France, where even with newfound EU political cover, Emmanuel Macron could find he is still restricted by a rumbling political and fiscal crisis. In a divided Bundestag, Merz, too, has domestic roadblocks to overcome.
Britain and Germany are at different starting points. Despite its deep economic troubles, Berlin, unlike London, has a recent history of recording budget surpluses before the onset of the Covid pandemic. Its debt-to-GDP ratio is close to 63%, compared with almost 100% for Britain. Even though German borrowing costs have risen sharply, yields remain significantly below those of the US and the UK, at about 2.8% for 10-year borrowing, compared with 4.6% for the UK.
That said, Reeves is being held back by politics more than economics. The government could make the case that higher borrowing today can be a down payment on stronger economic growth. Across the Channel, that is exactly what investors anticipate.
Before this month's spring statement, it is widely thought higher government borrowing costs will break Reeves's fiscal rules, fuelling speculation about cuts to the welfare budget.
But the Institute for Fiscal Studies reckons a small breach could be overlooked: 'There is no meaningful economic difference between a forecast for a small current budget surplus in 2029-30 and a forecast for a small current budget deficit,' the thinktank suggests.
Still, the chancellor is hamstrung after promising before the election not to increase taxes, and having signalled the virtue of balancing the books to draw a neat dividing line with the Tories' Liz Truss experiment.
That position may not be tenable for much longer. Whittling away at government spending threatens to undermine Labour's other promises: of fixing public services, avoiding a return to austerity and growing the economy.
It is a point made clearer by ­growing disquiet within Labour ranks, and by the government's sliding opinion poll rating. So watch this space: it may not be wise to burrow much further into a fiscal foxhole.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Starmer raises case of Briton detained in India during meeting with Modi
Starmer raises case of Briton detained in India during meeting with Modi

South Wales Guardian

time26 minutes ago

  • South Wales Guardian

Starmer raises case of Briton detained in India during meeting with Modi

Prime Minister Sir Keir met Narendra Modi on Thursday as the two countries signed a trade deal It is understood that Sir Keir raised the case of Jagtar Singh Johal, a Sikh activist from Dumbarton near Glasgow, who was arrested while in India for his wedding in 2017. Mr Johal's brother Gurpreet had suggested the meeting was a 'golden' chance for the UK Government to seek to secure his release. Thankful to PM Keir Starmer for the warm welcome at Chequers. Our discussions reflect a shared commitment to deepen India-UK ties across sectors.@Keir_Starmer — Narendra Modi (@narendramodi) July 24, 2025 Mr Johan is being held in custody by the Indian authorities, despite having been cleared of one of the cases against him earlier this year. He still faces charges at a federal level, which his supporters, who claim an initial confession he made was as a result of torture, fear could take years to come to a conclusion. Speaking on BBC Radio Scotland on Thursday, Scottish Secretary Ian Murray said the issue was 'complex' but the Government was working to resolve it. 'The Government are doing all we possibly can to get this resolved,' he said. 'There was a recent meeting, just at the start of June, between the Foreign Secretary and his counterpart in India to try and get these issues resolved. 'So it's right at the top of the agenda and we can assure and reassure that we're doing everything we possibly can to get these issues resolved as quickly as possible.' Gurpreet Singh Johal, a Labour councillor in West Dunbartonshire, had earlier told BBC Radio Scotland: 'Raising the case is not enough, it's what we've been saying since day one. 'There's a golden opportunity here for the Prime Minister now, prior to the deal being signed or as the deal is being signed, that he strongly calls for Jagtar to be returned to his family so he can continue his married life.' Mr Murray said: 'The call is for these issues to be resolved and we're all fully on the same page in terms of having to get them resolved as quickly as possible.'

Starmer raises case of Briton detained in India during meeting with Modi
Starmer raises case of Briton detained in India during meeting with Modi

Rhyl Journal

time26 minutes ago

  • Rhyl Journal

Starmer raises case of Briton detained in India during meeting with Modi

Prime Minister Sir Keir met Narendra Modi on Thursday as the two countries signed a trade deal It is understood that Sir Keir raised the case of Jagtar Singh Johal, a Sikh activist from Dumbarton near Glasgow, who was arrested while in India for his wedding in 2017. Mr Johal's brother Gurpreet had suggested the meeting was a 'golden' chance for the UK Government to seek to secure his release. Thankful to PM Keir Starmer for the warm welcome at Chequers. Our discussions reflect a shared commitment to deepen India-UK ties across sectors.@Keir_Starmer — Narendra Modi (@narendramodi) July 24, 2025 Mr Johan is being held in custody by the Indian authorities, despite having been cleared of one of the cases against him earlier this year. He still faces charges at a federal level, which his supporters, who claim an initial confession he made was as a result of torture, fear could take years to come to a conclusion. Speaking on BBC Radio Scotland on Thursday, Scottish Secretary Ian Murray said the issue was 'complex' but the Government was working to resolve it. 'The Government are doing all we possibly can to get this resolved,' he said. 'There was a recent meeting, just at the start of June, between the Foreign Secretary and his counterpart in India to try and get these issues resolved. 'So it's right at the top of the agenda and we can assure and reassure that we're doing everything we possibly can to get these issues resolved as quickly as possible.' Gurpreet Singh Johal, a Labour councillor in West Dunbartonshire, had earlier told BBC Radio Scotland: 'Raising the case is not enough, it's what we've been saying since day one. 'There's a golden opportunity here for the Prime Minister now, prior to the deal being signed or as the deal is being signed, that he strongly calls for Jagtar to be returned to his family so he can continue his married life.' Mr Murray said: 'The call is for these issues to be resolved and we're all fully on the same page in terms of having to get them resolved as quickly as possible.'

Woody Johnson completes purchase of Crystal Palace shares
Woody Johnson completes purchase of Crystal Palace shares

Rhyl Journal

time26 minutes ago

  • Rhyl Journal

Woody Johnson completes purchase of Crystal Palace shares

American businessman Johnson – who is co-owner of the New York Jets – joins chairman Steve Parish, Josh Harris and David Blitzer as a partner and director of the Eagles, and has also signed the Premier League's Owners' Charter. 'I am honoured and privileged to be joining the ownership group of Crystal Palace Football Club,' Johnson told the Eagles website. We are pleased to confirm that Woody Johnson's purchase of Eagle Football's shareholding in the club has now been completed.#CPFC — Crystal Palace F.C. (@CPFC) July 24, 2025 'It is an organisation with a proud history, tradition, and deep roots in English football in South London, which I came to admire during my time as US Ambassador to the United Kingdom. 'Eagles fans have demonstrated extraordinary loyalty, passion, and unwavering dedication and I am excited to meet and get to know them. 'I have great respect for Steve Parish and the leadership he has provided over the years. 'I look forward to working with him and the entire ownership group to build on the club's recent successes and help shape an exciting future for Crystal Palace. 'This is more than an investment – it's a commitment to realising the vision for the club, the community, and the culture around Selhurst Park.' Johnson's arrival at Palace comes with the club in dispute with UEFA over which European competition they will play in next season after winning the FA Cup in May. The Eagles were demoted from the Europa League to the Conference League after falling foul of UEFA's rules governing multi-club ownership, but have submitted an appeal to the Court of Arbitration for Sport. UEFA determined that as of March 1, American businessman John Textor had control or influence in Palace and French club Lyon. Textor said he had agreed to sell his stake in Palace to Johnson, but the move came too late to satisfy UEFA. Parish said: 'At this exciting time for Crystal Palace, we are delighted to be welcoming Woody to the ownership of the football club, and we very much look forward to working alongside him to build on our historic recent success moving forwards.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store