logo
‘Military Keynesianism'? Reeves faces British defence dilemma after EU spending surge

‘Military Keynesianism'? Reeves faces British defence dilemma after EU spending surge

The Guardian09-03-2025
As the Nobel laureate Robert Lucas quipped during the 2008 financial crisis: 'I guess everyone is a Keynesian in a foxhole.' Donald Trump's upending of the postwar security consensus has underlined the enduring wisdom of Lucas's observation. But now, instead of bank bailouts and emergency bond buying, European firepower is being directed at bombs, tanks and drones in the desperate fight to secure the continent's border with Russia.
Berlin and Brussels – typically capitals of financial orthodoxy – have been convinced that this approach is required once again. Under the plan put forward by Germany's chancellor-in-waiting, Friedrich Merz, Berlin is on the brink of relaxing its 'debt brake' rule to pave the way for spending on defence and infrastructure worth an additional €1tn (£840bn) over the coming decade.
The EU, too, is at a 'watershed moment', having agreed an €800bn plan allowing member states to ramp up borrowing for their defence spending, under an 'escape clause' from its stability and growth pact debt rules. It is being chalked up as one of the most remarkable shifts in European economic policy in decades.
But for Britain, a more old-fashioned approach still prevails, with the chancellor, Rachel Reeves, insisting that her self-imposed fiscal rules remain 'non-negotiable'. Rather than allow for a rise in borrowing, Labour's plan to increase defence expenditure from 2.3% of GDP to 2.5% by 2027 involved a corresponding cut for the overseas aid budget.
Pushing spending higher still would require further 'difficult decisions', Reeves has suggested.
The Treasury accepts the world has changed and that higher defence spending is a necessity, but with a tight fiscal position in advance of an already tough spring statement for the chancellor, paying for it will involve difficult decisions to find savings elsewhere.
There are hopes in Labour circles that Britain will follow Germany's 'military Keynesianism', but the Treasury view has not shifted that much. Reeves still believes in it enough to stick to fiscal rules that, after all, were only announced less than six months ago.
That is, in part, understandable. Fresh in Reeves's mind will be the bond market turbulence at the start of this year, in which the British government was in the eye of a global storm. Mostly that was driven by investor fears over Trump's inflationary policies. But there was also a UK-specific overlay.
Reeves could point to the sharp rise in German yields last week. On Wednesday, the yield – in effect, the interest rate – on Germany's 10-year bonds rose by the largest amount in a single day since March 1990. She could also point to France, where even with newfound EU political cover, Emmanuel Macron could find he is still restricted by a rumbling political and fiscal crisis. In a divided Bundestag, Merz, too, has domestic roadblocks to overcome.
Britain and Germany are at different starting points. Despite its deep economic troubles, Berlin, unlike London, has a recent history of recording budget surpluses before the onset of the Covid pandemic. Its debt-to-GDP ratio is close to 63%, compared with almost 100% for Britain. Even though German borrowing costs have risen sharply, yields remain significantly below those of the US and the UK, at about 2.8% for 10-year borrowing, compared with 4.6% for the UK.
That said, Reeves is being held back by politics more than economics. The government could make the case that higher borrowing today can be a down payment on stronger economic growth. Across the Channel, that is exactly what investors anticipate.
Before this month's spring statement, it is widely thought higher government borrowing costs will break Reeves's fiscal rules, fuelling speculation about cuts to the welfare budget.
But the Institute for Fiscal Studies reckons a small breach could be overlooked: 'There is no meaningful economic difference between a forecast for a small current budget surplus in 2029-30 and a forecast for a small current budget deficit,' the thinktank suggests.
Still, the chancellor is hamstrung after promising before the election not to increase taxes, and having signalled the virtue of balancing the books to draw a neat dividing line with the Tories' Liz Truss experiment.
That position may not be tenable for much longer. Whittling away at government spending threatens to undermine Labour's other promises: of fixing public services, avoiding a return to austerity and growing the economy.
It is a point made clearer by ­growing disquiet within Labour ranks, and by the government's sliding opinion poll rating. So watch this space: it may not be wise to burrow much further into a fiscal foxhole.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

How Labour minister's attack on quality of Scotland's water backfired badly
How Labour minister's attack on quality of Scotland's water backfired badly

Scotsman

time23 minutes ago

  • Scotsman

How Labour minister's attack on quality of Scotland's water backfired badly

Sign up to our daily newsletter – Regular news stories and round-ups from around Scotland direct to your inbox Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Westminster went into recess this week, a time of year when MPs can take a breath, undertake summer surgery tours and constituency visits, and generally catch up with work back home that can be difficult with the weekly commute to London. It is also historically when we enter what is known as 'silly season', described in the Collins dictionary as 'the time around August when the newspapers are full of unimportant or silly news stories because there is not much political news to report'. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad This week it arrived a few days early as a Labour Cabinet minister sought to make the case against water nationalisation using inaccurate figures about Scottish water quality. A Labour politician, Environment Secretary Steve Reed no less, arguing against a successfully nationalised public utility and showing a courageous streak by criticising Scots over the quality of their tap water. Just 16 per cent of England's water bodies are in good ecological status, compared to 66 per cent in Scotland (Picture: Christopher Furlong) | Getty Images Swimming in sewage Now, there are times, when stories that the political bubble, politicians and journalists alike, think are terribly serious fail to capture the public imagination. The quality of Scotland's water is not one of them. People in Scotland, of all political persuasions and none, take some pride in the quality of Scotland's water – not least those of us who drink London tap water during our weekly London commute! The Secretary of State was swimming in sewage of his own making and gave Scottish Government Cabinet minister Gillian Martin ample opportunity to rebut his claims in a pointed letter. Sixty-six per cent of Scotland's water bodies are of good ecological status compared to 16 per cent in England and 29 per cent in Wales. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Whilst there is always more that can be done and Scottish ministers are right to focus on areas for which they have responsibility, Scottish water is improving with 87 per cent assessed as 'clean or good', up from 82 per cent in 2014. There is always work to be done in Scotland, and in fairness Scottish ministers have the benefit of being answerable to the public rather than shareholders, but nonetheless the intervention was 'courageous' by the British minister. £78bn in shareholder dividends A recent report by the UK Environment Agency showed serious pollution incidents in England were up 60 per cent compared to the previous year with 'consistently poor performance from all nine water and sewage companies' in England. The Environment Agency put this down to 'persistent underinvestment in new infrastructure, poor asset maintenance and reduced resilience due to the impacts of climate'. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The Secretary of State even conceded on Sky News this week that most of the £104 billion investment needed in the water industry in England would have to be paid back by bill payers. What's more, since privatisation by the Tories in the 1990s, water companies have paid out £78bn in dividends and millions in bonuses to water company bosses, a system that a Labour minister was now seeking to defend. One might say that the UK Government has found itself up a rather polluted creek without a paddle. No wonder so few voices are calling for Scottish water to be privatised given the unfolding disaster south of the Border. Bill payers in Scotland gain from successive devolved administrations managing water better. Since 2010 for instance, average charges to Scottish customers have reduced by over 10 per cent with average prices significantly lower than in England and Wales. Given all of this you might have expected the Secretary of State to be more focused on keeping to past Labour commitments that might help voters down south. In the 2020 Labour leadership race, one of Keir Starmer's ten key pledges was to 'support common ownership of rail, mail, energy and water'. That commitment appears to have been one of many dropped by Labour in office. Scottish Labour's favourite tactic Labour finds itself politically rudderless in stormy waters, pun absolutely intended. No wonder, the party has won power and doesn't know what to do with it. The Secretary of State was left gasping, a fish out of water. When he was interviewed, unable to defend his own record, he did what Labour MPs are getting rather good at, talk about something else entirely. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad It's a favoured tactic of Scottish Labour MPs to talk about anything but their own Westminster government. At the most recent Scotland Office question time, supposed to be Scotland's voice in the UK Government, only my Dundee colleague Chris Law and I seemed to be bothered to ask about issues pertinent to the UK Government. Labour MP after Labour MP stood up to talk about the Scottish Government, telling us something of who is setting the policy agenda – and it isn't this Labour administration. The lack of Labour MPs' curiosity about the work of their own government and the Secretary of State's brazen deflection tells us of a Westminster government and UK ruling party without much of a political compass, holed below the water line by their own lack of purpose. My experience of speaking to voters tells me that people want to know what you are for, rather than what you are against. Even where voters disagree with you, and plenty do, they respect parties who are clear on their beliefs. Things could always be better and Scottish ministers should continue to keep up their work to ensure that Scottish water is cheaper, less polluted and more sustainable than elsewhere. The same goes the other way, and given the state of England's waters maybe, just maybe, Labour ministers could do with focusing on areas over which they have responsibility. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Water is a precious commodity, and it has rightly grabbed a bit of attention this week. It's certainly more deserving than this week's early silly season but we shouldn't let that wander into September. Time for some serious politics about a serious resource – time for Labour ministers to focus on the day job?

Trump warns 'there'll be no Europe left' before immediately hitting golf course
Trump warns 'there'll be no Europe left' before immediately hitting golf course

Metro

time32 minutes ago

  • Metro

Trump warns 'there'll be no Europe left' before immediately hitting golf course

Donald Trump is following up his dire warnings about the future of Europe by cracking on with the real business of his trip to Scotland: a few rounds of golf. The US President landed at Prestwick Airport in Ayrshire yesterday evening for his first UK visit since returning to the White House in January. It took only a few minutes after stepping off Air Force One for Trump to begin predicting doom for the West due to immigration. He told reporters: 'On immigration, you better get your act together. You're not going to have Europe anymore, you've got to get your act together.' The President claimed nobody had entered the US last month before describing the situation faced by Europe as a 'horrible invasion'. His British mini-break will begin with a day of golf at his Turnberry course on the Ayrshire coast. Craig Munro breaks down Westminster chaos into easy to follow insight, walking you through what the latest policies mean to you. Sent every Wednesday. Sign up here. More serious discussions with leaders including Prime Minister Keir Starmer, Scottish First Minister John Swinney and European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen will come on Sunday and Monday. Police in Scotland are bracing for a major operation as protesters begin to gather at a number of spots Trump is expected to visit on his brief tour. The presidential motorcade, containing more than two dozen vehicles, passed a small protest on its way into Turnberry yesterday evening but demonstrations are expected to swell today. To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video Later, the entourage will travel east across Scotland to Aberdeen and another of Trump's links courses near Balmedie, on the coast north of the city. Scottish Secretary Ian Murray, who met the President at Prestwick just after he arrived at around 8.30pm yesterday, said Trump's first words after stepping off the plane were: 'It's great to be here, I always love standing on the soil of Scotland.' Murray added: 'I said, 'I hope you're looking forward to a bit of downtime with some golf this weekend', and he said, 'Yes'. 'And I said, 'Well, we've whipped up a bit of a wind for you to make it a bit more competitive', and he went, 'I'm looking forward to it'.' Trump is expected to meet with von der Leyen tomorrow in an effort to thrash out a trade deal between the EU and the US. More Trending The EU has been one of the biggest targets of the tariff campaign from the White House since dramatic new trade measures were announced at the beginning of April. Starmer is understood to be travelling to Scotland on Monday for a meeting with the President, where the finer details of the UK's trade deal with the US are likely to be discussed. Speaking at Prestwick yesterday, Trump said: 'I like your Prime Minister, he's slightly more liberal than I am – as you probably heard – but he's a good man. He got a trade deal done.' He also suggested the meeting would be taking place this evening, which is not believed to be accurate. Get in touch with our news team by emailing us at webnews@ For more stories like this, check our news page. MORE: New arrest in cold case of mum killed 30 years ago walking home from shops MORE: Trump says 'I'll give you a list' of Epstein associates and 'I'm allowed' to pardon Maxwell MORE: Donald Trump's Scotland visit branded 'cynical circus' by his nemesis in land battle

Donald Trump: ‘It's great to be in Scotland'
Donald Trump: ‘It's great to be in Scotland'

STV News

timean hour ago

  • STV News

Donald Trump: ‘It's great to be in Scotland'

US President Donald Trump arrived in Scotland on Friday night for a five-day private visit The president was met by Scottish Secretary Ian Murray as he disembarked The visit is expected to include meetings with PM Sir Keir Starmer and FM John Swinney Trump will split his time between his golf resorts at Turnberry and Menie Police Scotland has launched a major security operation, with road closures and extended shifts for officers across Ayrshire and Aberdeenshire Demonstrations are expected in Aberdeen, Edinburgh, and near Trump's golf courses The visit comes amid renewed scrutiny over Trump's past ties to Jeffrey Epstein, fuelling conspiracy theories in far-right circles Trump said he would meet Starmer on Friday night to 'do a little celebrating' and discuss the US-UK trade deal He also confirmed he would meet with the Scottish First Minister who he said was 'a good man' US President Donald Trump has arrived in Scotland to begin a five-day visit. The visit is officially private, rather than presidential, but Trump is expected to meet with Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer and First Minister John Swinney while he's in Scotland. Air Force One – the presidential aeroplane – was in the air for approximately seven hours before touching down at Prestwick Airport at around 8.30pm on Friday. The US president was greeted by Scottish Secretary Ian Murray as he walked off Air Force One at Prestwick. After disembarking from the aircraft, the president told reporters that it was 'great to be in Scotland.' He left Prestwick Airport in his motorcade at about 8.50pm on Friday, bound for his golf course at Turnberry on the west coast of Scotland, south of Ayr. Mr Trump spent around five minutes speaking to journalists before leaving in his armoured car known as The Beast. European countries need to 'get your act together' on migration, and 'stop the windmills', Donald Trump said as he arrived in Scotland. Asked by reporters at Prestwick Airport for his advice to European leaders on reducing immigration, the US president said: 'I say two things to Europe: Stop the windmills. You're ruining your countries. I really mean it, it's so sad. 'You fly over and you see these windmills all over the place, ruining your beautiful fields and valleys and killing your birds, and if they're stuck in the ocean, ruining your oceans. 'Stop the windmills, and also, I mean, there's a couple of things I could say, but on immigration, you'd better get your act together or you're not going to have Europe anymore.' Donald Trump also praised Sir Keir Starmer as 'a good man' and confirmed they will be meeting on Saturday. Speaking to reporters as he arrived in Scotland, the US president said: 'I like your Prime Minister, he's slightly more liberal than I am – as you probably heard – but he's a good man. He got a trade deal done. 'You know, they've been working on this deal for 12 years, he got it done – that's a good deal, it's a good deal for the UK.' Mr Trump added: 'I'll be seeing him tomorrow, I guess tomorrow evening'. @stvnews Plane spotters anticipate arrival of Air Force One. #stvnews #scotland #donaldtrump ♬ original sound – STV News Crowds gathered at the perimeter of Prestwick Airport to catch a glimpse of Air Force One on Friday evening, and there was a major police presence around the airport. Standing on the White House lawn before boarding Air Force One, Trump said he would be meeting with Prime Minister Keir Starmer on Friday night after he lands in Scotland. 'We're also going to do a little celebrating together because we get along very well', he said. 'The UK has been trying to make a deal with us for like 12 years and hasn't been able to do it, and we got it done. [Starmer] is doing a very good job, he's a good Prime Minister, and a good guy. We're going to meet at Turnberry and Aberdeen.' The President also confirmed that he would be meeting with Swinney during the visit. Trump said he had a 'lot of love' for Scotland, and called the Scottish leader a 'good man'. 'I look forward to meeting him,' Trump said. On Thursday, Murray said the UK will extend a 'warm welcome' to the President. It comes as Trump seeks to downplay his previous connections with the paedophile Jeffrey Epstein. The Epstein case feeds into far-right conspiracy theories about child abuse rings formed of members of the global elite, propagated by some of the President's closest allies. Tight security measures are in place ahead of the visit, including road closures and restrictions in and around Turnberry, Maidens, and Prestwick Airport. A deer was euthanised on Friday morning after it was knocked down by a police vehicle at Donald Trump's golf course in Aberdeenshire ahead of the US President's arrival. New Arc Wildlife Rescue said it was called to Trump International Golf Links at around 5.30am on Friday. Due to the animal's injuries, it had to be euthanised at the scene. Trump's visit is also set to spark protests across the country over the weekend. STV News The Stop Trump Coalition is organising events in Aberdeen city centre and outside the US consulate in Edinburgh on Saturday – similar gatherings during Trump's visit to Scotland in 2018 attracted thousands of demonstrators. Protests are also expected around Trump's golf courses at Turnberry and Menie. First Minister John Swinney has urged protesters to express their views 'peacefully and lawfully'. European Commission president Ursula von der Leyen will meet US President Donald Trump in Scotland on Sunday. Ms von der Leyen made the announcement on X, saying: 'Following a good call with @POTUS, we have agreed to meet in Scotland on Sunday to discuss transatlantic trade relations, and how we can keep them strong.' Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store