Poll: OIA request for stadium event costs refused
The Star requested under the Local Government Official Information and Meetings Act (LGOIMA) all reports, documents and correspondence in regards to the split of costs for stadium events between Venues Ōtautahi and event clients.
The Star also asked for all written material related to contracts between ratepayer-subsidised Venues Ōtautahi and event clients.
Ratepayers are funding the stadium to the tune of $453m. It is scheduled to open in April.
The LGOIMA request came after Venues Ōtautahi refused to answer questions in May.
Venues Ōtautahi chief executive Caroline Harvie-Teare said the information is 'commercially sensitive.'
The Star editor in chief Barry Clarke said ratepayers had a right to know what arrangements had been made, given ratepayers may fund ongoing operational costs when the stadium is up and running, which appears to still be a grey area.
"It's all about transparency. Ratepayers are effectively shareholders in the running of the city – the stadium included,' he said.
The Star has laid a complaint with the Ombudsman about the refusal to provide the information.
Venues Ōtautahi receives grants from the city council to run operations alongside revenue from ticketed events at its venues.
The company operates key public venues on behalf of the city council, such as the Christchurch Town Hall, Wolfbrook Arena, Apollo Projects Stadium, and the new stadium.
The agency received $3.2 million from ratepayers in operational funding for all its venues in the past financial year.
New Zealand Taxpayers' Union head of policy and legislative affairs James Ross said Venues Ōtautahi must be transparent with ratepayers about the split of event costs.
"Ratepayers have a right to know how their funds are being spent.'
He says "commercial sensitivity" is often used as an excuse for refusing official information requests.
"When ratepayer money is involved, transparency must come first.
'What sensitivities are being breached by simply sharing the cost-splitting model?'
Harvie-Teare previously said event clients will pay a venue hire charge to hold events at the stadium.
'Event costs vary per event and per venue based on the type of event, the specific requirements of the event and the crowd size.
'The split of costs between the venue and the client also varies from event to event,' she said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
3 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Radich stands by letter to government
Despite community backlash and being opposed to writing it, Dunedin Mayor Jules Radich is standing by his letter to the government seeking sanctions against Israel. Critics said Mr Radich's letter — sent to Prime Minister Christopher Luxon and Foreign Affairs Minister Winston Peters on July 2 asking them to back Green Party co-leader Chloe Swarbrick's Unlawful Occupation of Palestine Sanctions Bill — was embarrassing, a cop-out and read like a "word salad". "The whole tone of your letter pretty much reads like you were forced to write it at gunpoint," one email to the mayor read. Others said the tone of the letter was appropriate given backing the Bill was "none of local government's business". Mr Radich said the letter accurately reflected how the council arrived at the decision to send it following the lodgement of a "divisive" motion. Dunedin city councillors narrowly passed a motion at June's community services committee meeting to support the Bill and chairwoman Marie Laufiso's casting vote was required to break a 7-7 tie. Mr Radich, who voted against the motion, was directed to write to Mr Luxon and Mr Peters asking government MPs to back the Bill. In his letter, he also detailed the vote's outcome and said the situation in the Middle East was of great concern to many Dunedin residents. "There are also many who do not think that international relations are the business of local government," he wrote. Correspondence released to the Otago Daily Times under the Local Government Official Information and Meetings Act showed Mr Radich's letter was not welcomed by those who supported the Bill. In the week from July 2, Mr Radich received communications from seven people criticising him and his letter. One person said Mr Radich should recall and rewrite it with "some degree of pride" in his position and should accept it with grace when a decision went against him. One email said Mr Radich had intentionally misconstrued a council decision. "You have chosen to throw your toys out of the cot, rather than to uphold collective responsibility," another said. He also received three emails in support of his letter, from those who felt the decision to back the Bill was "none of local government's business". Between July 4 and 14, Mr Radich and councillors received 2284 impersonal emails from "concerned American and global citizens", urging them not to support the motion to support the Greens' Bill. Council chief information officer Graeme Riley said it was not uncommon for councillors to receive bulk emails when considering "contentious" issues. Mr Radich said he stood by the letter, saying it was "an accurate description of what happened". "Trying to divide our council and our community by asking the government to support an opposition party Bill, I think is ... inappropriate and it's just looking to create further division in the community." He had not received a response from Mr Luxon or Mr Peters.
Otago Daily Times
03-08-2025
- Otago Daily Times
What is the city council spending on?
Construction of One New Zealand Stadium at Te Kaha accounts for $92m of this year's Annual Plan budget. PHOTO:CCC About $1.6 billion will be spent on Christchurch City Council's Annual Plan this financial where it is going. Significant amendments to the draft Annual Plan were made by city councillors, with funding going to unexpected projects. The Air Force Museum of New Zealand will now receive $5 million towards its $16m extension project. The new wing will house the museum's C-130H Hercules and P-3K2 Orion. Another amendment is a pause in the Christ Church Cathedral reinstatement levy after the project was put on hold. The cathedral levy cost ratepayers $6.52 annually and was planned to last at least another three years. Other notable spending greenlighted through amendments include more chlorine-free water taps like those at Burnside Park and Rawhiti Domain. The taps will be installed with $900,000 allocated to the programme over three years from July next year. This will be enough to install at least two stations a year and potentially more if Government water regulations are relaxed as has been speculated. University students are winners of the budget with discounted prices for city council pools. A student ID will reduce prices to $4.90 from $6.70, in line with gold and community services cards. The reduced prices will start in July next year. Altogether, amendments added 0.04% to the rates increase. Rates have gone up by 6.6% on average to help pay for the $1.6 billion budgeted to cover the cost of running Christchurch. There will be $871 million in operational spending on day-to-day services and $648m in capital spending, including $95.5m for One New Zealand Stadium. Debt repayment will cost $81m. The city council will borrow about $366m to meet a budget shortfall with the goal of returning to surplus in 2028. Total debt will reach $2.8b after this year's Annual Plan. Mayor Phil Mauger says the Annual Plan strikes a 'difficult but necessary' balance between maintaining spending on services and keeping rates manageable. 'Across New Zealand, both organisations and households are grappling with challenging economic conditions and rising living costs, and our council is not immune to these pressures.' The rates increase will be 6.6% overall, including commercial properties, and 6.49% for the average household. This compares to a 9.52% average increase in the 2024/25 Annual Plan approved last year. Mauger points to 1.75% of this budget's rates increase going towards the One New Zealand Stadium build. 'If you take that out of the equation, the overall increase is below 5%,' he said. 'We will build on the foundation set this year – ensuring that Christchurch is well-positioned to face whatever lies ahead.' Several notable projects already had funding allocated in the draft Annual Plan ahead of the final budget. They include $20.3m for the continued Ōmōkihi South Library and Service Centre rebuild, expected to open end of next year. Flood protection and control infrastructure get $20m, which will help improve service and meet increasing demand. There is $19.6m for the activated sludge reactor at the Bromley waste plant, which aims to reduce greenhouse emissions and odour. Ongoing construction of the Ōtākaro-Avon River Corridor City to Sea shared pathway will cost $9.7m. It is due to open end of next year. The Akaroa Wharf will get $6.8m for its continuing upgrade, expected to finish in 2027. City council-funded community housing will receive $5.2m for any needed improvements. The Eastman Sutherland and Hoon Hay Wetlands will get $4.5m to improve stormwater capacity and reduce flooding. There is $3.5m for the Botanic Garden's Cunningham House, or main greenhouse, for an ongoing upgrade expected to finish next year. City council-owned companies and private organisations continue to receive significant grants from the city council. The funding includes Canterbury Museum getting $9m to continue its redevelopment and $4m going to city council-owned Venues Ōtautahi for any upgrades to major venues such as the Town Hall or Wolfbrook Arena. The city council-owned economic development agency ChristchurchNZ will receive $966,000. There is a $618,000 fund which major events hosts can request grants from. Some other well-known organisations receiving grants are Orana Wildlife Park ($260,000), The Arts Centre ($250,000) and the Watch This Space Street Art Programme ($250,000). City council income Rates cover about half of city council income with borrowing about a quarter. The rest mostly comes from fees to access city council services, and facilities and dividends from investments, particularly the city council's owned strategic assets such as Lyttelton Port Company and Christchurch International Airport. Rates: 52% $837m Borrowing: 25% $366m Fees, charges and operational subsidies: 12% $197m Dividends and interest from investments (including council-owned companies): 6% 102m Capital contributions, grants and subsidies: 3% $51m Development contributions: 2% $24m City council spending
NZ Herald
28-07-2025
- NZ Herald
Wellington City Councillors more complained about than elected officials in other main centres
The council confirmed the complaints relate to city councillors, not community board members. Wellington City Councillors meeting at their chambers on The Terrace. Photo / Mark Mitchell. The council said complaints are handled with 'strict confidentiality, ensuring that employees feel supported and empowered to raise concerns without fear of disclosure'. Further requests for more detail on the complaints, including the names of the councillors involved, was denied by the council because of privacy. While different authorities record complaints in different ways, Wellington councillors received twice as many complaints as their Christchurch counterparts, the council with the second highest number. None of the three complaints raised by council officials about elected members at Christchurch City Council this term was escalated further. Christchurch City Councillors meeting at their premises on Hereford St. Photo / George Heard 'All three of these complaints never made it past notification, with staff choosing not to continue with the formal complaint process before they could be formally investigated and the claims substantiated.' Christchurch City Council would not provide any detail on the nature of the complaints. Auckland Council recorded two official complaints initiated by staff, both against local board members. A complaint was laid against Rodney Local Board member Geoff Upson by an Auckland Transport staff member regarding alleged offensive comments made about staff online. The council said it was resolved through mediation and no breach of the council's code of conduct was recorded. Auckland Council. Photo / Newstalk ZB Matt Winiata, a Manurewa Local Board member also faced a complaint by a parks staff member regarding alleged 'offensive comments in correspondence to staff', Auckland Council said. 'One aspect of the complaint was upheld and determined to be a non-material breach of the Code.' Other elements were not upheld as Winiata had already apologised. 'The Conduct Commissioner's recommendation was directed to the Chief Executive and staff, and no further action was required from the member', the council said. Why is Wellington City Council the worst? Tensions at Wellington City Council reached boiling point last year during a controversial debate on the proposed sale of its 34% share in Wellington airport. Traditional party voting blocs were broken and the council ultimately voted against a sale – upending the Long Term Plan (LTP). The Long Term Plan process also saw tensions rise between councillors and staff, with some around the council table questioning the quality of advice supplied by officers. Former Local Government Minister Simeon Brown intervened with the appointment of Crown observer Lindsay McKenzie. Mayor Tory Whanau said the process had brought out the worst behaviour of council members. Since his appointment, McKenzie has noted tensions in the relationships between councillors and staff. Lindsay McKenzie. Photo / Supplied. In his first report in December last year McKenzie said some elected members were concerned about the quality and timeliness of information they received ahead of making decisions. He said a few were concerned about biases in officers' reports and advice. McKenzie noted the way the council provided information to elected members was 'as thorough as one could expect'. He said his own appointment as a Crown observer had 'moderated' much of the conduct that has called the council into question. Mayor Tory Whanau also said at the time McKenzie's presence had helped her colleagues work more collaboratively. Mayor Tory Whanau at a Wellington City Council meeting. Photo / Mark Mitchell. Responding to the fact her council has recorded the most complaints, Whanau acknowledged she had seen instances of poor conduct from councillors. 'There is no doubt that the conduct by some councillors this term has not been what Wellingtonians would expect. Both to each other and staff', Whanau said. Whanau would not say whether she was the subject of any staff complaints. Reports of anti-social behaviour towards the council's frontline staff increased by a reported 323% in the past five years, rising from around 400 reports each year pre-covid to almost 1000 annually, the council announced in May. Ethan Manera is a New Zealand Herald journalist based in Wellington. He joined NZME in 2023 as a broadcast journalist with Newstalk ZB and is interested in local issues, politics, and property in the capital. Ethan can be emailed at
