Madani slammed for EV perks to rich, burden on poor
THE Madani government's push for electric vehicles (EVs) was initially praised, as EVs are seen as better for the environment than fuel-powered cars.
However, the high prices of EVs have made them unaffordable for most Malaysians — especially since almost 35% of formal workers earn less than RM2,000 a month.
Under current policies, EVs are exempt from import and excise duties until the end of this year. This has triggered criticism on social media.
Some users on X pointed out that while EV buyers — often the wealthy — get to enjoy tax-free benefits, regular Malaysians who buy fuel-run cars must still pay high taxes.
One user said that someone buying a locally made car like the Proton Saga would still pay around RM15,000 in excise and sales taxes. Many Malaysians need a car just to go to work, especially in a car-dependent country like Malaysia.
Meanwhile, luxury EVs like the Porsche Taycan — which costs RM675,000 — are completely tax-free.
When a low-income M'sian buys a Proton Saga, he pays RM15,375 in excise & sales tax.
But when a rich man buys an EV Porsche Taycan, he pays zero — saving over RM600,000.
Tesla Model 3 saves RM225k.
BYD Dolphin saves RM120k.
Well done, Madani. Reward the rich, tax the poor.
— khalid karim STEMKITA (@khalidkarim) June 6, 2025
To put things into perspective, that car costs nearly as much as the median house price in the Klang Valley, which is around RM745,000.
Another user pointed out that even if Malaysians pay less income tax than in some countries, they still end up paying a lot of 'indirect' taxes on daily goods and services.
Malaysia's income tax may be lower than many countries but we pay a lot more indirect taxes
— 1negara (@1negara1) June 7, 2025
Many Malaysians online feel that the current EV policy seems to benefit the rich while leaving the poor behind.
There's growing frustration over why Malaysia has set an RM100,000 minimum price for EVs — especially since brands like BYD offer much cheaper EVs in places like Thailand and China. This price gap has raised concerns about fairness and accessibility in Malaysia's EV market. — June 7, 2025
Main photo credit: Shutterstock
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Focus Malaysia
8 hours ago
- Focus Malaysia
Madani slammed for EV perks to rich, burden on poor
THE Madani government's push for electric vehicles (EVs) was initially praised, as EVs are seen as better for the environment than fuel-powered cars. However, the high prices of EVs have made them unaffordable for most Malaysians — especially since almost 35% of formal workers earn less than RM2,000 a month. Under current policies, EVs are exempt from import and excise duties until the end of this year. This has triggered criticism on social media. Some users on X pointed out that while EV buyers — often the wealthy — get to enjoy tax-free benefits, regular Malaysians who buy fuel-run cars must still pay high taxes. One user said that someone buying a locally made car like the Proton Saga would still pay around RM15,000 in excise and sales taxes. Many Malaysians need a car just to go to work, especially in a car-dependent country like Malaysia. Meanwhile, luxury EVs like the Porsche Taycan — which costs RM675,000 — are completely tax-free. When a low-income M'sian buys a Proton Saga, he pays RM15,375 in excise & sales tax. But when a rich man buys an EV Porsche Taycan, he pays zero — saving over RM600,000. Tesla Model 3 saves RM225k. BYD Dolphin saves RM120k. Well done, Madani. Reward the rich, tax the poor. — khalid karim STEMKITA (@khalidkarim) June 6, 2025 To put things into perspective, that car costs nearly as much as the median house price in the Klang Valley, which is around RM745,000. Another user pointed out that even if Malaysians pay less income tax than in some countries, they still end up paying a lot of 'indirect' taxes on daily goods and services. Malaysia's income tax may be lower than many countries but we pay a lot more indirect taxes — 1negara (@1negara1) June 7, 2025 Many Malaysians online feel that the current EV policy seems to benefit the rich while leaving the poor behind. There's growing frustration over why Malaysia has set an RM100,000 minimum price for EVs — especially since brands like BYD offer much cheaper EVs in places like Thailand and China. This price gap has raised concerns about fairness and accessibility in Malaysia's EV market. — June 7, 2025 Main photo credit: Shutterstock
The Star
10 hours ago
- The Star
Govt's data collection directive sparks privacy concerns, says Dr Wee
PETALING JAYA: The government's efforts to collate detailed records of phone calls and internet usage from telecommunications firms are a violation of the people's right to their personal data, said Datuk Dr Wee Ka Siong. He also said there is no need to have such detailed information for facilitating policymaking in the information, communications and technology (ICT) sector, and the tourism sector, as clarified by the Malaysian Communications and Multimedia Commission (MCMC). 'This is not a question of whether we trust in the current government or not. The question is, why does the government want to collect such detailed information on its citizens? 'Today, we say it's to study tourism statistics. We don't know what it'll be for tomorrow. 'You want to calculate tourists? You want to calculate active broadband users? You don't need the people's personal data. Aggregate data is enough,' Dr Wee said in a posting on his Facebook page on Saturday (June 7). It was previously reported that, according to industry sources, the government in April had ordered telcos in Malaysia to hand over detailed records of phone calls and internet logs for the first three months of this year, supposedly for the government's 'Mobile Phone Data' project. The records demanded purportedly include information about call logs, IP call records, location, latitude and longitude. It was also reported that if the telcos failed to comply, it would be considered an offence under the Communications and Multimedia Act, carrying a penalty of RM20,000 fine or six months' jail. MCMC has since explained that this move is to support evidence-based policymaking in two key sectors, i.e. the ICT and tourism sectors. The commission also stressed that the data will be anonymised before it is submitted to them and that no individual subscriber can be identified through the data collected. 'In both cases, no individual subscriber can be identified through the data collected,' MCMC said. However, Dr Wee said anonymising the data is not enough to maintain the privacy of the users, especially in an increasingly connected world. 'If you're collecting data on who we call, how long we talk, our Internet IP, and our location, including latitude and longitude - with such consistent location data showing the exact time and day, anyone with access to this data can easily match it back to our identities. 'Our identities can be uncovered very easily,' he said. On top of that, he added, there is also data from the mobile app MySejahtera, e-wallets, CCTVs, Touch n' Go and bank records which can be cross-checked to identify someone. MCMC had also previously said they engaged extensively with all telcos over the past two years on the safe handover of the data, but Dr Wee questioned the need to threaten the telcos if this is true. 'If it is true that this is all safe and it has all been agreed upon for two years, why is there a need to threaten the telcos?' Ultimately, he said, this is not about politics but about the rights of the people. 'Our personal data is not the right of any government, whether today, tomorrow or those to come. 'When the government starts collecting such detailed data, that has already crossed the line. 'The Malaysian people must raise this issue. Our data is not a plaything.'
Sinar Daily
12 hours ago
- Sinar Daily
'Abe Pajerolife' explores Peninsular Malaysia in old car
Using a 1999 Mitsubishi Pajero he purchased for RM5,000 in 2020, Muhammad Harith Ghazali, 32, gradually modified the SUV during the pandemic into a "mobile home', complete with a sleeping area, kitchen, storage space and even a shower. 07 Jun 2025 12:01pm Better known as Abe Pajerolife among his TikTok followers, Muhammad Harith said the idea for his road trip emerged during the Movement Control Order period when his desire to explore the outside world grew stronger, but financial constraints pushed him to think creatively. - Photo source: Muhammad Harith via Bernama KUALA LUMPUR - A vehicle that is over 20 years old may be considered unworthy for long trips but for a young man from Kota Bharu, Kelantan, it became a loyal companion throughout his 26-day solo journey around Peninsular Malaysia in October last year. Using a 1999 Mitsubishi Pajero he purchased for RM5,000 in 2020, Muhammad Harith Ghazali, 32, gradually modified the sport utility vehicle (SUV) during the pandemic into a "mobile home', complete with a sleeping area, kitchen, storage space and even a shower. Better known as Abe Pajerolife among his TikTok followers, Muhammad Harith said the idea for his road trip emerged during the Movement Control Order period when his desire to explore the outside world grew stronger, but financial constraints pushed him to think creatively. - Photo source: Muhammad Harith via Bernama Better known as Abe Pajerolife among his TikTok followers, Muhammad Harith said the idea for his road trip emerged during the Movement Control Order period when his desire to explore the outside world grew stronger, but financial constraints pushed him to think creatively. "I've always loved travelling, so I needed a way to do it without spending a lot. At the same time, I wanted to break away from my daily routine and explore new things,' he told Bernama. He said the vehicle modifications were done over four years, inspired by YouTube content from travellers abroad who converted their vehicles into mobile homes. Muhammad Harith said he had spent nearly RM40,000 to fully equip his Pajero for long-distance travel. The sum included repainting, engine repairs and interior modifications to ensure his mobile home functioned properly. "Only after that did I feel confident enough to travel around the entire Peninsular Malaysia. I started (my journey) in Perlis and made my way south to Johor, which was my last destination before returning to Kelantan,' he said, adding his vehicle did not encounter any major issue. Although the vehicle is fitted with a gas stove and basic amenities, the Universiti Malaysia Sarawak graduate said he preferred dining at local eateries as a way to experience the food and culture of each state. "I love eating local food because it helps me understand the culture. Every state has its own unique flavours,' he added. Besides discovering new places, Muhammad Harith viewed his trip around the peninsula as an opportunity for self-reflection, using the alone time to better understand his strengths and weaknesses. Better known as Abe Pajerolife among his TikTok followers, Muhammad Harith said the idea for his road trip emerged during the Movement Control Order period when his desire to explore the outside world grew stronger, but financial constraints pushed him to think creatively. - Photo source: Muhammad Harith via Bernama His entire journey cost around RM4,000, covering fuel, food, daily expenses and campsite fees. Sharing more about the experience, Muhammad Harith, who is self-employed, said one of the biggest challenges of being 'Abe Pajerolife' was making sure he arrived at each destination before 6 pm, as he is not comfortable driving at night. "Driving alone makes one feel drowsy easily. Since I had experienced microsleep previously, I didn't want to take any risk (during the trip). So, I would set off after dawn and aim to arrive (at my destination for the day) by evening,' he said. An avid camper, especially around Malaysia's east coast area, Muhammad Harith said during his journey, he also faced other challenges such as running out of electricity - leaving him to sleep in the heat - as well as contending with eerie disturbances in remote areas. For those considering similar expeditions, he offers this advice: "Start by building strong mental resilience because journeys like these are anything but easy, especially when you're doing it alone.' - BERNAMA More Like This
