'Loyalist paramilitary transitioning has failed' ex-watchdog says
The process aimed at disbanding loyalist paramilitary groups has failed, a former security watchdog has told BBC Northern Ireland's Spotlight programme.Lord Alderdice, the former Alliance Party leader who was a member of the Independent Monitoring Commission, said talks about loyalist transition should stop.He was responding to the arrest and conviction on firearms charges of Winston Irvine, who worked as an interlocutor with the Loyalist Communities Council (LCC), which represents mainstream loyalist groups.A senior LCC source told Spotlight that loyalist transition is on course to be concluded this autumn, with an announcement of the complete dismantling of all paramilitary structures.
Irvine, of Ballysillan Road in north Belfast, was a well-known community worker before being given a two and a half year sentence over guns and ammunition found in the boot of his car in 2022.The Public Prosecution Service (PPS) is appealing the sentence for being "unduly lenient".Irvine's conviction has returned attention to loyalist funding and paramilitary groups.Set up in 2015, the LCC says it represents a loyalist leadership committed to transition, the scaling back of criminality and ultimately disbandment.A source in the organisation told Spotlight that Winston Irvine has been instrumental in moving the mainstream Ulster Volunteer Force (UVF) away from criminality, and that a final push for loyalist transition is imminent.
Lord Alderdice spent seven years on the Independent Monitoring Commission, which was given access to secret intelligence to report on paramilitary activities, before it was wound up in 2011.He said the transition process is "not working". "A halt should be called, and you can't call a halt now sooner than today."There comes a point when you have to say no, this hasn't been delivered."It's not going to be delivered. And, actually, by continuing we are making it worse."Lord Alderdice told the programme he does not believe the loyalist paramilitaries are making a genuine effort to transition away from criminality."What I've seen is more talking about transition, and transformation, and no doubt with an invoice provided, for how much money is needed to be made available from public services in order to pay off these people."
Cathy McIlvenny's sister, Lorraine, was murdered by UDA members in 1987.She previously told Spotlight, in 2013, that she dealt with Winston Irvine when he arranged a punishment shooting of her nephew, Craig, in 2002.Cathy believes the sentence given to Irvine is not enough, and says loyalist paramilitaries will continue as long as funding is still available."They're just being given money to keep them quiet and make it look to the rest of the world now that the British government has solved the Northern Ireland problem."But, it hasn't. It's made it worse for the communities."In 2013 it was alleged to Spotlight that Winston Irvine was a UVF leader, something which he has denied as "preposterous".
No explanation was given in court as to why Irvine and his co-accused had the guns.Following the arrest, police discovered UVF paraphernalia in Irvine's home, and that of his co-accused Robin Workman.However, in sentencing, Judge Gordon Kerr KC concluded the movement of weapons had not been directly connected to terrorism.54-year-old, Workman, of Shore Road in Larne, was sentenced to five years - the minimum custodial sentence, which the PPS said it would not be appealing.The guns were found by covert police six weeks after a hoax bomb, which targeted a peace event in Belfast attended by then Irish Foreign Minister Simon Coveney in March 2022.Police said UVF involvement in the hoax attack was a primary line of inquiry.
Prior to his arrest and conviction, Winston Irvine spent more than a decade as a paid community worker.That role gave him access to high-level contacts and enhanced his credibility as a peace builder.The 49-year-old, who received a number of supportive character references during the case, provided a pre-prepared statement in which he claimed to be a "trusted interlocutor" in community relations and the peace process.However, his arrest sent shock waves through the British and Irish governments because of how they often rely on community workers to engage with loyalist communities.Following his arrest, Irvine was suspended from his role at the north Belfast community group Intercomm Ireland, in line with its internal disciplinary procedures.He left the organisation several months later.Intercomm said it was "difficult to convey the impact" the case had on its team who were "shocked, disappointed and felt let down" by Winston Irvine's actions.A statement added that "significant reorganisation (was) required to continue to deliver on our commitments to projects and fulfil obligations to funders and to the community".But Irvine continued to work on funded projects in unionist and loyalist areas while on bail for the weapons charges.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
35 minutes ago
- BBC News
South Shields rapist contributed to woman's suicide, judge says
A rapist whose attack on a friend contributed to her killing herself has been jailed for 10 Callaghan, 33, raped the woman at his home after inviting her round to use a hot tub in June 2022, Newcastle Crown Court woman killed herself eight weeks later with Judge Stephen Earl saying the rape was a factor in her of Mowbray Road, in South Shields, denied rape but was found guilty by jurors. Callaghan and the woman had known each other for years and been platonic friends, Judge Earl 12 June 2022, when his partner and child were away, Callaghan invited the woman to a hot-tub party, after which he raped her at his home, the court you have been affected by any issues raised in this report, help and advice is available on the BBC Action LineThe woman, who the BBC has chosen not to name, fled into the street and was helped by a "good samaritan" who called 999, the judge said. Death was 'tragic' She gave an interview to police but killed herself in August 2022, the court was told, with notes she had left referencing the rape and the trauma caused by court heard the "very complex" and vulnerable woman had significant mental health problems and an alcohol addiction, and had been released from hospital only hours before Callaghan had raped Earl said he could not say Callaghan "caused" her death but the rape had been a "substantial element" in her thinking over the "last few weeks" of her said Callaghan's actions had been a "significant point towards the end of her life" ,which she "found unable to deal with".The woman's death was "tragic" and she had so much to live for, the judge said, adding her family were devastated. 'Attacked her character' During the trial, Callaghan sought to make out the woman had been "throwing" herself at him, but the judge said jurors "did not countenance that was the truth".Judge Earl said the evidence against Callaghan, which included the woman's interview with police, was "clear and compelling", while accounts given by the rapist were "inconsistent".He also said Callaghan made attacks on the woman's character during the trial "knowing she could not respond".After the six-day trial, jurors took one hour and 10 minutes to unanimously convict Callaghan of rape. Prosecutors had also sought an order that would have required Callaghan to tell any women he planned to have a relationship with or work with in his role as a fitness instructor in the future of his rape Judge Earl said that was neither "necessary" nor "proportionate" and such an order would be the start of a "rocky road" of court orders. Follow BBC North East on X, Facebook, Nextdoor and Instagram.
Telegraph
36 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Countries refusing to take back illegal migrants could be stripped of visas
Countries refusing to take back migrants who arrive illegally in the UK could be stripped of visas under new plans being scrutinised by Sir Keir Starmer. The Prime Minister said he was looking at taking a more 'transactional' approach to returns agreements and how to treat nations that refuse to sign one with the UK. Sir Keir brought up the idea with fellow world leaders at the G7 summit in Kananaskis, Canada, as he pressed European counterparts to do more to tackle the small boats crisis. The number of people arriving in the UK on small boats across the Channel so far this year is around 40 per cent higher than it was last year. The crossings have piled pressure on the Government to go further to tackle the problem, with concern seen to be contributing to the surging popularity of Nigel Farage's Reform UK. The UK has returns agreements with countries including Albania, India, Pakistan, Vietnam, Iraq, Nigeria, Bangladesh, Georgia, Somalia, Serbia, and Algeria. Each is different – but broadly, they include a commitment to take back citizens who have no right to stay in the UK, such as failed asylum seekers and foreign criminals. Speaking to reporters at the summit, Sir Keir said he had raised the idea of linking returns agreements to visas in a round table discussion on Monday. He said he had 'made clear that we are looking at issues like a smarter use of our visas', saying that included 'looking at whether we should tie our visas to the work that the countries we're dealing with are doing on preventative measures and on returns agreements '. The Prime Minister said: 'We are looking at what we can do on returns agreements. We have done a number of bilateral returns agreements. 'So the question is, again, whether it is possible to go a bit beyond that, including looking at this question of visas now and whether we can't be a bit smarter with the use of our visas in relation to countries that don't have a returns agreement with us'. Asked whether that meant countries that refused to sign returns agreements being stripped of visas, he said: 'Yeah – it would be much more sort of transactional, if you like. 'Now we're looking into it, but certainly I think there are areas like that that we should look more closely at.' Sir Keir also had discussions with the leaders of France, Italy and Germany about where they could cooperate more deeply to tackle the small boats crisis. His talks with Emmanuel Macron, the French president, included discussing 'innovative ways' to tackle the flow of boats, according to a Downing Street spokesman. There is a UK-France summit next month, at which it seems likely that a new package of measures could be announced to counter the crisis. The Downing Street readout of the Starmer-Macron bilateral meeting made mention of the 'deteriorating situation in the Channel', an apparent reference to the high number of crossings this year. Asked whether that amounted to an admission of failure on small boats in his first months in office, Sir Keir said: 'Look, there's a serious situation in relation to the Channel crossings and, as I've said on a number of occasions, nobody should be making that crossing. It is a serious challenge that requires serious responses to it.' Sir Keir said his conversations with Giorgia Meloni, the Italian prime minister, focused on what could be done 'upstream' – an area in which Ms Meloni has had 'some success in reducing her own numbers', the Prime Minister added. He also talked to Friedrich Merz, the German chancellor, attending his first G7 summit, about the problem of how some of the boats used for crossings often are moved through Germany.
The Sun
36 minutes ago
- The Sun
Globetrotting fake landlord who swindled desperate tenants out of £200k to fund lavish lifestyle is jailed
A GLOBETROTTING fake landlord who swindled desperate tenants out of £200,000 to fund his lavish lifestyle has been jailed. Samy Daim, 28, advertised luxury properties he did not own, collected substantial deposits from his victims and then disappeared. 4 The former estate agent targeted 11 prospective tenants in total - including teen students - to the tune of £213,180. He then splurged the cash on luxury holidays around the world, which he bragged about on social media. Daim has now been jailed for four years and four months after he admitted admitted 11 counts of fraud by false representation. Inner London Crown Court was told Daim carried out the fraud between 2023 and 2024. He would book Airbnbs to advertise on Rightmove and Zoopla before getting a woman to show the victims around the property. Daim then asked for a year's rent upfront along with a 25 percent deposit before pocketing the cash. He even used his own flat in London for the scam - even though his own landlord was trying to boot him out for not paying rent. The fraudster shared a string of photos on social media while spending his ill-gotten gains. This included a picture of him feeding an elephant in Thailand and posing next to an infinity pool on an expensive trip to propose to his girlfriend. Daim also posed on a Jeep beside the beach at Key West in Florida. His scheming came to an end when he was arrested while attempting to get on a plane to Thailand at Heathrow. The amount he stole from his victims ranged from between £10,730 and £19,800 - totalling £204,180. Some of the victims, who were as young as 18, managed to reclaim the money through their banks. But one of the prospective tenants was an international student who never got his money back. Judge Silas Reid told Daim: "All of the victims suffered considerable detrimental impact and the amount of money was significant. "Two of the victims suffered serious detrimental effects, one of them his wife was pregnant and they were left in a situation almost unable to afford food, and of course they still needed to secure accommodation. "One was recently bereaved which meant your actions had an even greater impact. "One victim suffered their hair falling out, disrupted sleep and one lost his job and had nowhere to live." 4 4
