'Another way to get back NRC': Rajya Sabha MP Kapil Sibal on revision of electoral rolls in Bihar
Kapil Sibal
on Saturday while addressing the issue of
Special Intensive Revision
(SIR) exercise in Bihar said that it is "another way to get back
NRC
" and alleged that the government wants to impose "authoritarian" rule in the country.
Sibal further alleged a "partnership" between the
Election Commission of India
and the BJP, claiming that in Maharashtra, the votes were increased, whereas in Bihar, they will decrease.
"It is being said that this exercise is a pilot project; It is another way to get back NRC...They want to impose
majoritarian rule
in India..They don't want anyone else to come to power in India. In Maharashtra, they increased the number of votes, and here they are reducing them. It is my allegation that there is a partnership between the Election Commission and them (BJP)", Kapil Sibal told ANI.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Villas Prices In Dubai Might Be More Affordable Than You Think
Villas In Dubai | Search Ads
Get Quote
Undo
The Supreme Court on Thursday allowed the Election Commission to continue with its exercise of conducting a Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls in poll-bound Bihar.
A bench of Justices Sudhanshu Dhulia and Joymalya Bagchi did not stay the SIR process but asked the ECI to consider allowing Aadhaar, ration cards, and electoral photo identity cards as admissible documents to prove voter identity during the SIR of electoral rolls being undertaken in Bihar.
Live Events
"We are of the prima facie opinion that in the interest of justice, the Election Commission will also include documents like Aadhaar, Ration Card, Voter ID card, etc.. It is for the ECI to decide whether it wants to accept the documents or not, and if it does not, then provide reasons for its decision, which shall be sufficient to satisfy the petitioners. Meanwhile, petitioners are not pressing for an interim stay," the bench stated in its order.
In its order, the top court noted that the timeline for the process is very short since elections in Bihar are due in November.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
United News of India
an hour ago
- United News of India
Cong welcomes SC order on SIR, accuses BJP of spreading disinformation, distorting facts
New Delhi, July 12 (UNI) In an effort to counter what it called as "disinformation and distortion" by the BJP regarding the Supreme Court order on the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls in Bihar, the Congress today said it was satisfied with the ruling, noting that the court had directed the Election Commission of India (ECI) to accept the Aadhaar card, voter card and ration card as valid proof of identity. Moreover, the party clarified that it "never pressed" for the stay of the SIR. Addressing a press conference at the AICC headquarters here, senior party leader Abhishek Manu Singhvi said that the court had validated the Aadhar card, voter identity card and ration card as the proof of identity which roughly covers 90 percent of the people who could be affected by the SIR condition of producing citizenship proof. He claimed that the exercise could well disenfranchise about two crore voters out of around 4.9 crore voters registered after the year 2003, as they were being asked to furnish citizenship proof. He said it was beyond the jurisdiction of the Election Commission of India to verify the citizenship of people. Stating that since 2003 when the last special revision was done, ten elections have been held, he asked, "what was the hurry to carry out another revision just before the Bihar elections, which are just a few months away". He said the previous revision in 2003 was done one year before the Parliamentary elections and about two years before the Assembly elections. The senior Congress leader maintained that this "exercise of the ECI will mainly affect the marginalised, poor, disadvantaged and the minority voters". He said that, most of the labour class during the months of July and August remains away in different parts of the country for paddy sowing. Then, he added, there is an imminent threat of floods. He said, it will be practically impossible for these sections of people to produce the proof of residence like birth certificates of their parents in such a short span of time. Asserting that the Aadhaar card is an important proof of identity, he said, 'India lives on Aadhaar, from rations to rail, but for elections, it's suddenly a fairy tale? You amended the law to embrace Aadhaar, then kicked it out from the main bazaar". UNI RBE GNK 2004
New Indian Express
an hour ago
- New Indian Express
Not interested in direct elections anymore: Union Minister Jual Oram
SAMBALPUR: Veteran BJP leader and Union Tribal Affairs Minister Jual Oram on Saturday announced he would no longer contest direct elections. The younger generation, he said, should be given more opportunities in Odisha's political landscape. Interacting with the media following his visit to the Rozgar Mela in Sambalpur, Oram said he may be chosen as Governor or nominated to Rajya Sabha but will not take part in direct elections anymore. "I have contested elections 10 times during my career - eight times as MP and twice as MLA. I am not willing to contest direct elections anymore," he said. However, he clarified that he is not considering formal retirement from politics. "I may be sent to the Rajya Sabha or appointed as a Governor by the party. In any case, I will continue serving my party," he added.
New Indian Express
an hour ago
- New Indian Express
Fields of despair: Why Maharashtra farmers are paying the ultimate price
Every three hours between January 1 and March 31 this year, a farmer in Maharashtra ended his/her life, with 767 suicides recorded in just 90 days, according to data tabled in the state legislative assembly on July 1. This alarming rate — averaging eight deaths daily — is not a one-off data point. Last year, the government admitted on the floor of the assembly that farmers died by suicide at a similar rate since the last 56 months. It reflects a deepening agrarian crisis that has defied solution in Maharashtra, particularly the Vidarbha and Marathwada regions, for over two decades. Despite tall political promises, including by the BJP's 2014 pledge to eradicate farmer suicides, the trend persists, driven by a toxic mix of economic distress, environmental challenges and policy failures. The case of Kailash Arjun Nagare, a 2020 Young Farmer Award recipient, who took his life in March 2025, citing government inaction on irrigation demands, is one indicator of the mounting despair in the farming community. Why is it business as usual when farmer suicides are showing no signs of dropping in Vidarbha and Marathwada? Scale of the crisis Over the past 24 years, the Amravati revenue division in Vidarbha alone recorded 21,219 farmer suicides, including 5,395 in Amravati district, 6,211 in Yavatmal, 4,442 in Buldhana, 3,123 in Akola, and 2,048 in Washim. In January this year, 80 suicides were reported across these districts, with Yavatmal recording the highest at 34. In Marathwada's Hingoli district, 24 suicides occurred in the same three-month period. Vidarbha is represented by BJP heavyweights in the state assembly and Parliament — Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis and Union minister Nitin Gadkari. They are achievers in various domains but sadly haven't been able to push the envelope on the agrarian crisis. Historical data from the National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB) and other reports show 37,142 farmer suicides in Maharashtra from 2015 to 2024: 4,291 in 2015, 3,058 in 2016, 3,701 in 2017, 3,594 in 2018, 3,927 in 2019, 4,006 in 2020, 4,064 in 2021, 4,268 in 2022, 2,851 in 2023, and 2,635 in 2024. NCRB's 2022 data shows that 11,290 people in the farming sector (5,207 farmers/ cultivators and 6,083 agricultural labourers) across the country died by suicide, accounting for 6.6% of total suicides (1,70,924) in India. More males than females chose to take the extreme step. Of the 5,207 farmer/cultivator suicides, 4,999 were male and 208 female. And of the 6,083 agricultural labourers who killed themselves, 5,472 were male and 611 female. States and UTs that reported zero suicides in the farming sector included West Bengal, Bihar, Odisha, Uttarakhand, Goa, Mizoram, Tripura, Chandigarh, Delhi, Lakshadweep and Puducherry. As for Maharashtra, 2,708 farmers/cultivators—2,448 landowners and 260 cultivators of leased land—died by suicide in 2022. It constituted over 50% of the national figure of 5,207 in the same category. And over one-fourth of the national suicide toll of agricultural labourers (1,560) came from Maharashtra. These are staggering figures by any comparison. As Congress leader Rahul Gandhi put it, while tagging this newspaper's report, "Think about it... in just 3 months, 767 farmers committed suicide in Maharashtra. Is this just a statistic? No. These are 767 destroyed homes. 767 families that will never be able to recover.' He went on to score political points, claiming the government easily waives loans of the rich but not the poor, drawing a caustic rebuttal from the BJP, which reminded him of the 'sins committed by the NCP-Congress government during its tenure in Maharashtra.' Amid all the political sparring, the key question as to why a spate of welfare measures undertaken by the state and Central governments, including putting money in their pockets, haven't been able to give farmers the confidence to face the vagaries of life, remains unanswered. Root causes: A complex web The farmer suicide crisis stems from a combination of economic distress, environmental challenges, and social pressures, worsened by policy gaps. Economic distress and debt: Crushing debt is the primary driver, fueled by rising input costs and inadequate crop prices. Farmer leader and expert Vijay Jawandhia told this newspaper that the input cost for seeds, fertilizers, pesticides, and diesel have surged, while crops end up being sold below the Minimum Support Price (MSP). For example, in 2024, soybeans were sold at Rs3,800–4,000 per quintal against an MSP of Rs4,892, cotton at Rs5,000–6,000 against Rs7,550, and tur dal at Rs6,000–6,500 against Rs7,500. One report estimates that Maharashtra's soybean farmers lost Rs8,500 crore in 2024 due to sub-MSP sales. The 18% GST on agricultural inputs further erodes margins. Rahul Gandhi in his swipe pointed out that while both governments provide at total of Rs12,000 annually (Rs6,000 each from the central and state governments under the Pradhan Mantri Kisan Samman Nidhi) to the farmers, input taxes for cultivation more than suck the dole out of their pockets. Environmental challenges: Vidarbha and Marathwada, where cotton, soybeans, and pulses dominate, have only 10–12% irrigation coverage, compared to 60% in western Maharashtra's sugarcane belt. Farmers rely on erratic monsoons, worsened by climate extremes—droughts, unseasonal rains and hailstorms. Groundwater depletion forces farmers to drill borewells up to 1,000 feet, escalating costs. In 2015, reservoirs like Manjara had zero live storage. Similar shortages persist elsewhere. Kailash Arjun Nagare's suicide in March 2025, after a 10-day hunger strike for irrigation water from the Khadakpurna reservoir, highlights the desperation caused by water scarcity. Declining yields and market volatility: Crop yields have plummeted, particularly for cotton. Sanjay Patil, a farmer from Dhule, told this newspaper that cotton yields have dipped from 10-12 quintals per acre to 2-3 quintals, with prices falling from Rs10,000-12,000 to Rs5,000-6,000 per quintal. Social and psychological pressures: Rising costs for education, healthcare, and daily needs outpace farmers' stagnant incomes, creating a stark income-expense gap. Jawandhia notes that unlike government employees, who receive inflation-linked dearness allowances and salary hikes, farmers lack such protections. Financial strain, coupled with limited access to mental health services, fuels depression. The suicide of Sachin and Jyoti Jadhav, a farmer couple from Parbhani in April 2025, which orphaned their two daughters, indicates the urgent need to address mental health issues on a war footing. Government response In the Constitutional scheme of things, agriculture is a state subject, but many important decisions in the sector are taken by the Central government, said Jawandhia. 'I raised this issue before MS Swaminathan when he was chairman of the National Commission of Farmers. He laughed and agreed to recommend to the Central government to put agriculture in the Concurrent list. However, the proposal is yet to be accepted at the policy level,' he added. Be that as it may, governments have a stock response to troubling questions on farmer suicides. Sample this in the Rajya Sabha to an unstarred question on May 4 this year: 'Agriculture being a State Subject, the State Governments provide relief. However, Government of India supports the efforts of States through appropriate policy measures, budgetary allocation and various schemes/ programmes. The various schemes/ programmes of the Government of India are meant for the welfare of farmers by increasing production, remunerative returns and income support to farmers. The Government has substantially enhanced the budget allocation of Department of Agriculture & Farmers Welfare (DA&FW) from `21,933.50 crore BE during 2013-14 to `1,22,528.77 crore BE during 2024-25.' The minister goes on to list 28 major schemes to enhance the overall income of farmers. For their part, states put out data on the assistance given to the next of kin of the eligible victims. But empirical evidence of the measures turning the tide of suicides is hard to come by. Welfare measures and issues Compensation: Rs1 lakh for families of deceased farmers, but only 376 of 767 suicide cases between January-March 2025 were approved, with Rs295 lakh sought by eight districts and only Rs18 lakh disbursed MSP: Limited procurement through 562 centres fails to prevent sub-MSP sales Financial support: Rs12,000 annual aid (Rs6,000 each from the Central and state governments under the PM Kisan Samman Nidhi) offset by GST and rising input cost Counselling: Psychological support sessions aim to deter suicides but lack scale Sugarcane-centric: Deputy Chief Minister Ajit Pawar proposed a law to protect sugarcane farmers. Cotton farmers, predominant in Vidarbha, feel neglected due to the political influence of sugarcane cooperatives. Jawandhia criticises the focus on sugarcane, noting that cotton farmers are treated like 'orphans' in Vidarbha. Voices from the ground Farmers and activists highlight the systemic neglect that has led to the crisis. Sanjay Patil switched from cotton to lemon orchards due to unsustainable losses. Ajit Nawale of Kisan Sabha contrasted India's policies with the US and European subsidies, accusing the government of favouring traders. He said the Union government gives `6,000 to poor and needy farmers under the Kisan Samman Scheme, but in the garb of 18% GST on chemicals, fertilizers and pesticides, squeezes out more money from the farmers than the subsidies it provides. 'My appeal to farmers is to get united and fight against the government and its policies,' he suggested. As for Jawandhia, he said, "The Thackeray cousins came together on the issue of Marathi language and opposed the imposition of Hindi in Maharashtra, but why are no politicians coming together for the cause of the state's farmers?" Going forward Addressing the crisis of farm suicides requires structural reforms: MSP regime: Enforcing MSP as a legal right could ensure fair prices, said Jawandia. Besides, no crop should be sold below MSP Irrigation infrastructure: Expanding irrigation in Vidarbha and Marathwada, potentially through projects like Khadakpurna dam, is critical. Lack of irrigation facilities has claimed scores of lives of farmers, with Nagare's suicide one among them Mental health support: Scaling up counseling could address psychological distress Nagare's suicide note demanded action; the Jadhavs' deaths orphaned their daughters. Until debt, water scarcity, and market volatility are addressed, Maharashtra's farms will remain a graveyard for its farmers.
