English voters face ‘democratic deficit' without devolved parliament
Unlike Northern Ireland, Scotland and Wales, where some decisions are taken by lawmakers in Stormont, Holyrood and Cardiff Bay, England does not have a devolved national assembly.
Mr Rosindell told MPs that after the devolution process in the late 1990s, 'for the first time in centuries, the unifying lynchpin of these islands – the crown in Parliament – seemed to have been wrenched out of place'.Speaking in a debate about English Affairs, the Conservative MP later added: 'What must in any case be acknowledged is that England, the most populous region with the biggest economy, is the only home nation not to have her own devolved parliament.
'This has created a democratic deficit in which the proud people of England, such as those in my constituency of Romford, Essex, are left with a rich cultural heritage, as I've outlined earlier, and without a fully developed but rather diminished democratic voice.'
Father of the House Sir Edward Leigh, the Conservative MP for Gainsborough, urged Mr Rosindell to 'please spare us another parliament'.
The Romford MP replied that he was a 'very strong supporter of this Parliament and of this United Kingdom', added he 'would have most certainly not voted to break up our United Kingdom in the way that we have done', and said he would 'love to see' the London Assembly abolished in the capital.
Liberal Democrat Scotland spokeswoman Christine Jardine intervened and said: 'What we did was devolve some of the power closer to the people so that they felt more represented, not in an attempt to break up the country, but – as a member of the party who was instrumental with the Labour Party in achieving it – so that we held the country together but gave people the feeling of being closer to where decisions were made.'
Mr Rosindell replied that he thought 'all members of Parliament should be equal and elected representatives should be equal, but if you make different types of elected representation at different levels, it obviously means that English MPs have a different role than Scottish MPs, because they have Members of the Scottish Parliament in Scotland, which have another role'.
Labour MP Adam Jogee, who opened the debate, had earlier said: 'We must work to ensure that people across England, and indeed all those across the United Kingdom, continue to feel pride in our flag and in our communities, and feel hope for the future and respect for our past.'
The Newcastle-under-Lyme MP added that 'any talk about love for flag and country must be matched by an investment in the people who make them what they are – investment in our national health service, in our education and employment support services, in our arts and culture, and in our villages, towns and cities'.
Communities minister Rushanara Ali said St George's day was an opportunity to 'fight against the forces of division' that present the English identity as 'an exclusive identity, that is a white only identity'.
Mr Rosindell intervened and asked: 'Would the Government consider St George's Day to become a public holiday in England?'
Ms Ali replied that she could not 'respond with a positive answer right now'.
She added: 'We must inspire the next generation to carry forward the best of England through education, opportunity and the belief that no matter who you are or where you come from, you belong and you can help shape this country's future.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mirror
15 minutes ago
- Daily Mirror
Painted St George's Cross on mini-roundabouts sparks debate among residents
The roundabouts were painted as the council took down flags attached to lampposts Residents have taken a flag row to the streets by painting the St George's Cross on a handful of mini roundabouts across one major UK city. People in Birmingham hit out after the Birmingham City Council announced English flags hoisted from lampposts would be removed. The Union Jack and St George's Cross had been put on display in the Weoley Castle and Northfield neighbourhoods of the city. Local residents said that they were doing this out of a sense of patriotism. However, the city council removed the flags and made a safety appeal to residents who were considering putting the flags on lampposts and other street furniture. Locals put up the Union Jack and St George's flags as part of an online movement called Operation Raise the Colours. Council chiefs ordered the flags to be taken down due to safety concerns. They said the "unauthorised items" are "dangerous" and could potentially harm motorists and pedestrians. Following the announcement, several mini roundabouts in Kings Heath and Yardley Wood have been painted, and there are reports of more being painted in other areas. The Union Jack and St George's Cross have also appeared on lampposts in the Weoley Castle and Northfield areas of the city, according to SWNS. The council said it had removed around 200 flags while upgrading streetlights to energy-efficient LED lighting. West Midlands Police said it had not yet received any complaints of criminal damage. However, the police force said it would investigate any reports of criminal damage made by the local authority or a member of the public. Residents from the areas have expressed mixed views on the transformed traffic islands. One woman in Kings Heath said: "It is nothing more than sheer, wanton vandalism. There is nothing patriotic about having a spray can and damaging a roundabout. The council can't afford to fix the potholes, let alone repaint mini islands idiots have defaced." Resident Ian Anderson, 40, said: "I certainly don't agree with vandalising roads or roundabouts, after all flags are just flags and can be taken down. However, there is a real sense that people who are proud to be British are being made to feel ashamed of their patriotism. I don't see anything wrong with flags on lampposts, it reminds me of when the World Cup or Olympics is on." Speaking to the BBC, another local said it was "not patriotic", adding: "It just feels like an excuse for xenophobia. There are better ways to show pride - ways that are inclusive and respectful, not resorting to vandalism." Several residents from the Weoley Castle and Northfield neighbourhoods in Birmingham shared with BBC Radio WM their approval of the flags being displayed. One woman said: "It's patriotic, so I think it's wonderful. It symbolises us, doesn't it, Great Britain?" Another woman said: "I believe they're fantastic, [they] bring joy to people's faces. They're harmless, just fluttering in the breeze, representing England, which is where we are, of course."
The Guardian
15 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Empty corridors and a quiet hum: if there were fireworks at Albanese's economic roundtable, they were well hidden
'What's on your agenda this week?' 'Hanging out for three days while we wait.' So went a conversation overheard in Parliament House, between two people from organisations represented at the government's economic reform roundtable, just before the three-day meeting kicked off. Rome wasn't built in a day, and Australia's economy won't be fixed in three days (although with productivity gains, who knows how we could have supercharged the Roman construction sector). Government sources were quick to stress the 'constructive' atmosphere in the room; in a rosy five-line statement after the first day's activities, an upbeat Jim Chalmers described the vibe as 'outstanding', 'promising', 'productive', 'constructive' and 'consensus building' – proving, if nothing else, productivity is high among his media team. But those of us stuck outside the cabinet room – that is, everyone but the 30-odd participants – were left waiting and wondering what the economic inner circle were discussing. Parliament House wasn't exactly abuzz – more a quiet hum as staffers of interest groups drifted the halls like tumbleweed, trying to fill in time between sessions. Aussies cafe, usually the spot to see and be seen in Parliament, lay near-empty. Journalists skulked around the ministerial wing, trying to learn any scraps from inside; while shadow treasurer Ted O'Brien, the Coalition's sole invitee, bustled out during the lunch break, appearing to take a phone call but perhaps just hoping to avoid questions. Nationals senator Matt Canavan, taking advantage of an unexpected lull in the middle of the day, set up a real-life version of the 'change my mind' meme on the front lawn of the building, spruiking his own pirate version of a roundtable on Tuesday. A special media space set up for press conferences lay mostly empty, barely used beyond quick stand-ups from one business group and one union secretary, where each criticised the other over an ACTU push for employers to pay a levy to train workers. Industry leader Innes Willox reportedly called that idea a 'crock of shit'. ACTU assistant Secretary Liam O'Brien said these weren't 'new tensions', but said the summit was helping thorny issues get 'surfaced in a productive way.' In public comments, at least, participants played nice, saying compromises were being found. But on the outside, like waiting for chimney smoke from the papal conclave, we were left to interpret the smallest signals emanating from the cabinet room. Phones and smart watches had to be surrendered at the cabinet room door, the tech devices of the nation's key policy minds left stranded in little plastic boxes. Sadly the large 'no mobile phones' sign didn't include a warning to switch them to silent, leaving one smart watch to ring deafeningly during Chalmers' opening address and spotlight moment, prompting a mad scramble from the staffers in the lobby. We managed to nip inside the cabinet room as Anthony Albanese and Chalmers made their opening addresses to the roundtable (it was an oval table), to check out the seating plan. Flanking the PM were treasury secretary Jenny Wilkinson, and Chalmers (on Albanese's left this time, not his right-hand man). Sitting directly opposite, Productivity Commission chief Danielle Wood, former treasury secretary Ken Henry, and Commonwealth Bank boss Matt Comyn. Sitting on the far rounded edge of the cabinet table, as far from Albanese as would be possible, was Ted O'Brien. Albanese said he didn't expect participants to agree on every issue. With unions, business groups, environment leaders and politicians in one room, it's probably hard to agree on the coffee order, let alone the future economic direction of the country. But in the spirit of consensus (a word you're hearing a lot this week, alongside 'constructive') the PM invited all the roundtable members to drinks at the Lodge on Wednesday night. It will follow a key economic summit of another kind on Monday night at the PM's house. Chalmers, in business-casual mode, in a quarter-zip jacket meeting Albanese… and his dog, Toto. 'I'm delighted at how specific people's ideas have been and how constructively participants have worked together,' Chalmers said after day one, praising participants for having 'risen to the occasion' with 'a lot of consensus building'. But with business groups and unions expecting a key confrontation on AI and regulation on day two, let's check back tomorrow to see if the smoke signals are quite as positive.
The National
44 minutes ago
- The National
Reform UK hiring staff in London to write Holyrood manifesto
The party is hiring more staff in Westminster to look at Scotland-specific policy ahead of next year's election. Reform UK are expected to pick up a number of seats in May, with some polls suggesting the party could even come in second place. Reform UK leader Nigel Farage As reported by the Daily Record, one of the job listings advertised by the party in London is a "Scotland policy advisor". The blurb for the role reads: "Play your part in shaping Scotland's future. Join Britain's fastest-growing political movement. READ MORE: Crown Office cancels court dates for Scottish activists on terror charges 'Reform UK is seeking a proactive, passionate, and detail-oriented Policy Advisor to lead on policy development for Scotland. "You'll help shape bold, evidence-led proposals that will form the backbone of our manifesto for the 2026 Scottish Parliament elections, and support our wider policy direction across the UK. "This is a unique opportunity to work at the heart of a dynamic political movement committed to common-sense reform, national pride, and real change.' According to the job advert, the post will be based in "Westminster, England". There is a second advert for a policy advisor role which involves coming up with policy proposals for the "devolved manifestos", which is also based in "Westminster, England". A press officer job is based in Glasgow which the listing states involves championing the party's 'common-sense policies' on immigration and law and order. Political parties in Scotland have said the listings come as "no surprise", with the SNP arguing that Reform UK know "nothing about what's good for Scotland". SNP MSP Kenneth Gibson said: "Decisions for Scotland are best made in Scotland - with the SNP, that's guaranteed. 'Nigel Farage knows nothing about what's good for Scotland. His politics couldn't be more out of touch with the people of Scotland's priorities and values. 'By thinking that policy for Scotland can be dictated from hundreds of miles away in London, Farage is making all the same mistakes that all the other Westminster-based parties have made for decades." READ MORE: Anger as Edinburgh Fringe venue admits to censoring artist's work Gibson added: 'It is only with the full powers of independence that Scotland can finally be free from being told what to do by politicians in London with little understanding of Scotland's needs, values and priorities.' Scottish Greens co-leader Patrick Harvie said: "The last thing Scotland needs is more London-based policy makers who think they know better than everyone who actually lives here. Farage doesn't want to create jobs here in Scotland; instead, he wants to throw our country under the bus to benefit his wealthy friends. Scottish Greens co-leader Patrick Harvie 'This comes as no surprise, given the disastrous impact his climate denialism would have on the Scottish economy. 'The Scottish Greens are building a strong future for Scotland, with secure jobs based in Scottish communities, and a vision for that that could not be more different from the racist and hateful agenda of Reform.' READ MORE: Police Scotland refuse to reveal number of pro-Palestine activists arrested And Scottish Labour deputy leader Jackie Baillie said: ""It is no great surprise that a party that does not care about Scotland will be dictating their Holyrood manifesto from London. "Despite pretending to be a man of the people, Nigel Farage took a private jet when he visited here ahead of the Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse by-election, which his party went on to lose. "Farage is nothing more than a chancer who thinks he can take the Scottish public for mugs.'
