NA panel to probe Rs300bn sugar windfall
The multi-party panel, led by PTI's Atif Khan, is scheduled to meet Monday (today) to probe what it calls the 'hidden beneficiaries' behind the sugar price spiral. The inquiry will look into years of cyclical price hikes, export-import swings, and the role of government deregulation.
The push for accountability follows testimony from the Auditor General of Pakistan at a Public Accounts Committee meeting, confirming that sugar mill owners had benefitted massively from price fluctuations and export-friendly policies. Critics in parliament have gone further, branding the sugar industry a 'mafia' with disproportionate influence over policy.
Tax on windfall profits of sugar millers being mulled
Federal Minister for National Food Security and Research, Rana Tanveer Hussain, recently announced full deregulation of the sector — removing government control over prices, procurement, and supply. But while he vowed to act against hoarders and named certain mill owners on the Exit Control List (ECL), retail prices have continued to soar beyond agreed limits.
A July 15, 2025 agreement between the government and Pakistan Sugar Mills Association (PSMA) fixed the maximum ex-mill price at Rs 165/kg, allowing a monthly increase of Rs 2 until mid-October. Insiders say the Rs 2 increase was based on a 25% interest rate that has since dropped to 11%, making the agreed carrying cost — and thus the price escalation — unjustified.
Ministries of Finance and Commerce reportedly resisted sugar exports over price concerns, but some mill groups withheld stock until export approvals to capitalise on higher global prices — reportedly Rs 30-40/kg more than domestic rates — while avoiding sales tax on exports.
The government is now preparing to import 100,000 tons of sugar via the Trading Corporation of Pakistan by October to ease shortages. This follows a broken assurance from PSMA that prices would not exceed Rs 140/kg.
Atif Khan's panel is now weighing a windfall tax similar to that imposed on banks, aiming to capture part of the extraordinary profits made by millers and channel them towards subsidising sugar for consumers. The move could mark the first serious fiscal pushback against a sector long accused of manipulating both the market and policy to its advantage.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
5 hours ago
- Express Tribune
PSX extends bullish momentum as week opens
The Pakistan Stock Exchange (PSX) opened the week on a positive note on Monday, with the benchmark KSE-100 index rising 1,274.79 points, or 0.88%, current index at 146,657.58 during intra-day trading. The index touched an intra-day high of 146,762.78 and a low of 145,258.49, compared with the previous close of 145,382.79. Market volume was recorded at 244,438,330 shares, with a total value of Rs 25.23 billion. The market remains open. Earlier, PSX wrapped up the week on a bullish note, with the benchmark KSE-100 index breaching the 145,000 mark amid strong institutional buying, handsome corporate earnings and improved macroeconomic sentiment. Gains were further bolstered by record remittances for July, a sharp jump in textile exports and optimism about government reforms, including a major reduction in circular debt and an ambitious privatisation road map. On a day-on-day basis, the PSX started the week by breaching the 142,000 level, another all-time high, with a rise of 1,018 points as Oil and Gas Development Company (OGDC) received its first term finance certificate (TFC) payment of Rs7.7 billion, signalling strong financial health. On Tuesday, the market extended gains as the KSE-100 index ended at 143,037, up 985 points. Investor confidence was supported by robust inflows and a nine-year low fiscal deficit of 5.38% for FY25. The record-breaking rally continued the next day as well, where the index broke another key psychological level of 145,000, reflecting a surge of 2,051 points. However, the bourse took a breather on Thursday, closing at 145,647, up a modest 559 points, as Pakistan recorded a trade deficit of $2.8 billion in July. The PSX ended the week by consolidating around 145k on Friday, with the index standing at 145,383, down 264 points. Investors displayed caution, reacting to recent macroeconomic developments by shifting focus across sectors and booking profits selectively.
Business Recorder
12 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Federal govt and provinces: Senate body seeks ‘out of box' fix for NHP dispute
ISLAMABAD: The Senate Standing Committee on Power headed by Senator Mohsin Aziz is scheduled to meet on Monday (today) to find out an 'out of box' solution on the dispute on Net Hydel Profit (NHP) between Federal Government and provinces, particularly Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. The Water and Power Development Authority (WAPDA) has reportedly distanced itself from the proposal of out of box solution of current controversy on NHP. Minister for Planning, Development and Special Initiative, Ahsan Iqbal is also heading a committee on this issue. Ministry of Energy (Power Division) is represented by the CEO of CPPA-G and the MD of PPMC The Committee has convened five meetings attended by the representatives of all four Provinces, the Ministry of Energy (Power Division), the Finance Division. Further update on the finalisation may be shared by the Ministry of IPC. KP formulates strategy aimed at recovering NHP dues According to WAPDA, the Council of Common Interests (CCI) based on Article 161(2) of the Constitution determines the sale rate at Bus Bar of hydel power stations. However, calculating NHP has been tricky due to conflicting claims and interpretations of the Kazi Committee Methodology. Various attempts have been made to resolve this, including ad-hoc payments and arbitration, but a long-term solution remains unresolved. After power sector restructuring and becoming NEPRA licencee, WAPDA paid Rs. 6 billion annually to the Govt, of KP as NHP until FY 2014-15, which was later uncapped at Rs 1.10 per kWh by NEPRA in FY 2015-16, following GoKP's request for settlement of all previous NHP arrears by making payments of Rs.70 billion in four installment and notification of uncapped NHP rate of Rs 1.10/kWh-an MoU was signed between Govt of Pakistan and Govt. of KP on February 25, 2016. The MoU was also approved by CCI on February 29, 2016 and later the settlement of Govt of Punjab's claims of Rs.82.71 billion and payment of regular NHP at uncapped rate was also agreed and approved by CCI on December 16, 2016. Despite paying NHP at the uncapped rate that was further enhanced by NEPRA from Rs.1.10/kWh to Rs.1.155/kWh in FY 2017-18 and CCI's overriding of its earlier decision of Jan 1991 regarding KCM through approving the said MoU, the GoKP again raised the issue in CCI and asked for payment of NHP as per KCM. WAPDA argues that considering Deputy Chairman, Planning Commission's report (suggesting WAPDA's replacement with CPPA-G for NHP obligations), ECC's decision of January 24, 2019 (Power Division to lead efforts to secure financing for NHP payments to provinces) and Finance Minister's remarks during 49th CCI meeting (Finance Division is working on clearing NHP outstanding dues of KPK and Punjab, and in future CPPA-G will directly pay NHP to provinces), the Power Division and CPPA-G are in better position to propose an out of box solution for NHP payment . WAPDA doesn't profit from selling power at hydel stations, as NHP is a pass through item and makes the NHP payment to provinces as per government guidelines and regulations. WAPDA's outstanding recovery from CPPA-G against power sales invoices has sharply increased due to delayed payments, hindering WAPDA's ability to make timely NHP payments to provinces, despite regular billing at NEPRA-determined rates. Currently, WAPDA has to pay NHP of Rs.49.565 billion to GoKP and Rs. 114.584 billion (including Rs. 13.617 billion as NHP arrears) to GoPb. WAPDA maintains that Power Division and CPPA-G are in better position to propose an out of box solution for NHP payment. Power Division (Power Planning & Monitoring Company): PPMC has offered the following comments: (i) Article 161(2) of Pakistan's 1973 Constitution requires that net profits from hydroelectric power generation be paid to the province where the power station is located, calculated by deducting operating expenses from bus bar revenue, and explicitly excludes Net Hydel Profit (NHP) as a pass-through cost to electricity consumers ;(ii) KCM calculates NHP by aggregating power generation income, but this approach, formulated in 1985-86 was based on a unified and unbundled WAPDA being the sole power producer and distributor. Now, Pakistan's energy landscape has changed significantly including WAPDA's unbundling, emergence of IPPS, and shifts in the power mix wherein hydro power contributes 27% (approx.) ;(iii) NHP payments should be made through the federal budget or covered by WAPDA's profits from hydropower sales, rather than consumers; (iv) commenting on GoKP's proposal, PPMC is of the view that the transfer of hydropower plants to provinces is governed by the Power Generation policies of 1995 and 2015 that is applicable to BOOT-based IPP projects developed within a province by private sponsors. The WAPDA Act lacks provisions for transferring hydropower plants constructed under its mandate to the provinces, and its projects are primarily financed through PSDP, donor loans, and internal funds, after accounting for NHP; (v) NHP payment through ESCROW account, does not align with the legal and regulatory framework and the constitutional scheme. Regarding wheeling of power from PEDO and wheeling charges determination, B2B electricity supply through wheeling arrangements will be integrated into IGCEP and TSEP under the CTBCM Directive No. 7. NEPRA's periodical regime, determined water usage charges should be reviewed based on the mechanism applied in various countries. Government of Sindh: The Provincial Government submitted proposal regarding transferring Hydro Electric Stations to the respective provinces in lieu of NHP requires clarification as presently no hydro power station is managed in IPPs mode. It further stated that the hydro-electric power generation is a bi-product of 'Water Reservoir Projects (Dams)'. While framing any such proposal, the basic purpose of construction of these reservoirs be considered and IRSA be included in the committee. Govt of Sindh further contended that transfer of Hydro Electric Stations to provinces requires careful consideration of the primary purpose of water reservoir projects. To ensure a comprehensive approach, it is suggested to include representatives from IRSA, Finance Division, and Economic Affairs Division in the committee to provide technical, financial, and economic expertise. Govt of Sindh has reiterated its earlier stance on NHP, reflected in the minutes of 49th CCI meeting which is as follows; 'Chief Minister, Punjab endorsed views of DCPC and asked for early payment of Rs. 58 billion dues of NHP owned to Punjab. The Chief Minister, Sindh, endorsed the NHP claim of Chief Ministers of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Punjab being constitutional. He, however, did not support increase in tariff and its passing on to consumers. He said that since profit was utilized by WAPDA it should now be accounted for'. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Express Tribune
13 hours ago
- Express Tribune
PTI 'apologises' for Bajwa's extension
Listen to article The Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) admitted on Sunday that granting a service extension to former army chief Gen (retd) Qamar Javed Bajwa was a mistake, apologising to the nation over the decision and vowing never to be part of such practices again. The admission and apology came from PTI senior leader and former National Assembly speaker Asad Qaiser during a joint press conference of Tehreek Tahafuz Aain Pakistan (TTAP) leaders in Islamabad. "The decision about Bajwa's extension was wrong; I believe it was our historically incorrect decision," Qaiser said, responding to a question about the former COAS's extension. "We apologise to the whole nation [on this decision]," he added. "We will not be a part of any such decision in the future." TTAP chief and veteran politician Mahmood Khan Achakzai added that neither any civilian nor military official should be granted service extensions, arguing that appointments should be made solely on merit — the only principle, he said, essential for Pakistan's progress. In late 2019, Pakistan faced an unprecedented legal standoff over then — prime minister Imran Khan's decision to grant a three-year extension to Gen Bajwa, whose term was due to end on November 28. Just two days before his retirement date, the Supreme Court suspended the extension while hearing a petition challenging it — the first such case in the country's history. The government had justified the extension by citing regional security concerns, including India's revocation of Kashmir's autonomy and Pakistan's role in the US-Afghan peace process. Critics, however, viewed it as a political calculation to secure Khan's own tenure, given the army's perceived role in facilitating his rise to power. During his remarks, Qaiser not only criticised the incumbent governance model but also termed it "illegal, unconstitutional and undemocratic," claiming the country was under a "practical martial law" where decisions were made under institutional pressure rather than merit. The PTI stalwart said his party believed that cases of political prisoners, including party founder Imran Khan, should be heard on merit and without external influence, adding that live media coverage of trials would expose the reality of the proceedings. On the so-called 27th Constitutional Amendment, Qaiser said PTI would use every available forum — parliament, the courts, and public mobilisation — to resist it, adding that a lawyers' movement would also be initiated. He said the party would approach the legal fraternity to challenge any such move, begin consultations with the Islamabad Bar this month, engage with foreign diplomats, and hold seminars to highlight its concerns. Achakzai, speaking at the same press conference, stressed that the TTAP movement would avoid personal attacks and focus on constitutional protection, adding that political differences should not undermine democratic principles. He recalled visiting PML-N supremo Nawaz Sharif and his daughter Maryam Nawaz during their imprisonment in the past, noting that "party leaders would visit them in flocks and no one would object". Criticising Pakistan's political and governance decline, Achakzai warned that when public anger rises, even the most entrenched rulers can be removed. He called for a political agreement to ensure supremacy of the Constitution, judicial independence, establishment of a credible election commission, media freedom, and an end to harassment of journalists — saying all parties should sign such a document. Former PML-N leader and Sindh governor Muhammad Zubair also addressed the gathering, highlighting the country's deepening economic crisis. He cited record inflation — with weekly price increases touching 50 per cent and overall inflation hitting 38 per cent — saying such levels had never been seen before in Pakistan. Zubair said more than 110 million people had fallen below the poverty line, with overall unemployment at 22 per cent and youth unemployment at 30 per cent. He pointed to a sharp rise in public debt, noting that while PTI's tenure saw an increase of Rs19 trillion, the last three-and-a-half years had added Rs38 trillion more. Foreign investment, he said, was now at a 50-year low despite promises of major inflows. He noted a decline in GDP growth to an average of 1.62 per cent against a population growth rate of 2.6 per cent, alongside a 60 per cent fall in purchasing power over three years. Calling the state of education "shameful," he cited 27 million out-of-school children and malnutrition affecting 40 per cent of children. Public sector enterprises, he added, were incurring losses of Rs1 trillion, further straining national finances.
