The Irish Times view on the Clodagh Hawe case: real questions for State and society
Clodagh Hawe and her three sons were murdered in 2016 in Castlerahan, Co Cavan by Alan Hawe, Clodagh's husband and the boys' father, who subsequently took his own life. The story as recounted in the book raises troubling questions about coercive control, victims' rights and social attitudes to familial murder-suicide.
A Serious Crime Review report into the initial investigation into the murder was finally completed by the Garda in 2023. The 800-page document has not been published but its findings and recommendations are 'incorporated into senior investigative training'. This seems inadequate.
In Garda briefings on the report to Clodagh Hawe's family, as described in Deadly Silence, they acknowledge flaws in the investigation's handling of CCTV evidence and the manner in which key witness testimonies were collected. Digital evidence was also missed.
READ MORE
Just as unsatisfactory is the State's failure to address the long-standing legal loophole surrounding inheritance rights in cases of familial killings. That became a matter of public debate following the killing of Celine Cawley by her husband Eamonn Lillis in Dublin 2008. Legislation proposing changes to the law was published in 2017, but was never progressed.
Irish society has also been slow to recognise the ways in which coercive control can be exercised, sometimes invisibly, in a family or relationship. The welcome introduction of legislation in 2019 criminalising such behaviour has hopefully raised awareness.
Murder-suicides, with all their attendant trauma, pose a particular challenge for the communities in which they occur as well as for law enforcement. Public reaction may seek to frame the crime in a way that diminishes the responsibility of the perpetrator. That was the experience of Jacqueline Connolly and her mother as they struggled to understand what had really happened to Clodagh and her sons. In their account, there is a lacuna in how the State deals with cases of this sort when there is no living person to prosecute for a crime.
None of the questions raised by this appalling tragedy would have come to light had it not been for the perseverance of Jacqueline Connolly. While her commitment and determination are to be admired, her search for the truth should never have been made so difficult.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTÉ News
20 minutes ago
- RTÉ News
Minors behind many attacks on Indian citizens
The Minister for Justice has said that many of the recent attacks on members of the Indian community appear to have been carried out by young people which, he said, poses a particular challenge within the criminal justice system. Jim O'Callaghan was speaking after he met with representatives of the Ireland India Council and the Federation of Indian Communities in Ireland, to discuss the recent attacks. The attacks have prompted the Indian Embassy to issue a warning to its citizens living and working in Ireland. Mr O'Callaghan said that what he found most concerning about the attacks was that the majority appeared to have been carried out by young people. "Regrettably, it appears to be the case that very many of the offenses appear to be perpetrated by persons under the age of 18 and that does pose a particular challenge for us within the criminal justice system, to ensure that individuals who are under 18, who commit criminal offenses are brought before our courts, and that they do, in fact, face a sanction," he said. He said he had been informed that Garda Juvenile Liaison Officers were engaging with the respective communities and youth groups on the matter. The minister added that he had been engaging extensively with Garda Commissioner Drew Harris about the matter and that action had been taken to support the Indian community. Minister O'Callaghan said that Senior Investigating Officers had been assigned to investigate all reported incidents, and that he hoped to see progress on those investigations soon. "Any attack against innocent members of the public such as those suffered by members of the Indian community are totally unacceptable and will not be tolerated," he stated. "Attacks on individuals because of their inherent characteristics including race are abhorrent to the values of our republic and are condemned by any right-thinking people." The Minister pointed out that laws had recently been amended by the Criminal Justice (Hate Offences) Act 2024 to ensure any attack motivated by hate will, on conviction, result in increased sentencing parameters for the sentencing judge, adding that "there are severe consequences for the perpetrators of these attacks". More: President Higgins condemns 'despicable' attacks on Indian community
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Damning findings of report on Garda roads policing ‘heartbreaking' for victims' families, campaigners say
Road safety campaigners and other groups have expressed concern about the 'heartbreaking' findings revealed in a report into Garda roads policing publishing on Thursday. The Crowe report, an independent review of the Garda Roads Policing Unit set up to assess the unit's effectiveness and integrity, found some gardaí were 'unproductive' and unconcerned with the quality of their performance . Susan Gray of the road safety campaign group Parc said the Garda whistleblower whose information led to the commissioning of the review 'must be praised'. She added it was 'heartbreaking reading for bereaved families like us who have suffered the loss of a loved one in a road-traffic collision'. READ MORE 'Much blame has to also be laid at the feet of the superintendents, chief superintendents and assistant commissioner in charge of roads policing who apparently were unaware of this,' Ms Gray said. The vice president of the Irish Road Victims Association, Leo Lieghio, said 'a small number of gardaí don't think that people's lives are worth doing their jobs or they think it's not important enough'. He told RTÉ radio's News at One: 'They need to realise that every single life lost on the roads is big and that's what we've always been saying.' 'The enforcement has to be out there and at the moment there isn't the enforcement." The Policing and Community Safety Authority said it was 'deeply concerned' by the report, which it has already discussed with Garda Commissioner Drew Harris. The authority said while the report focused on roads policing, its 'wider concern' related to 'the absence of any effective performance management within An Garda Síochána'. 'For an organisation of approximately 18,000 to have no means of effectively managing poor performance is shocking and needs immediate action,' it said. Chairwoman Elaine Byrne said the vast majority of gardaí perform their duties to a very high standard. 'However, as this report shows, some have a blatant disregard for the job and its functions. 'We are seriously concerned that there seemed to be a fear from some managers of managing performance.' Minister for Social Protection Dara Calleary described the results of the Crowe report as 'very serious', but he added it was important to emphasise it was a 'minority' of gardaí involved. [ Garda roads policing numbers hit historic low of 618 Opens in new window ] Mr Calleary said new regulations introduced in April 'will strengthen the whole area of discipline'. In a statement, the Garda Representative Association (GRA) accused Commissioner Harris and Ms Byrne of showing 'utter contempt and disregard' for the integrity of all members of the Roads Policing Unit. It said they did this 'by making comments that questioned the professionalism of the entire unit when drip leaking certain lines before the Crowe report was published, which gave an unfair slant to the entire findings'. The GRA said the report 'simply reflects' concerns the GRA has been raising for years including fewer gardaí in the unit, a lack of training, resources and equipment, as well as mismanagement. Sinn Féin spokesman on Justice, Matt Carthy, said that the findings of the Crowe report on roads policing were 'deeply concerning.' He proposed that the Oireachtas Justice Committee urgently discuss the report with the incoming Garda Commissioner Justin Kelly and Minister for Justice Jim O'Callaghan.
The Irish Sun
2 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Bombshell reports shows some ‘unproductive' gardai on road duties ‘unconcerned with doing effective job' amid fury
BAD BOYS Bombshell reports shows some 'unproductive' gardai on road duties 'unconcerned with doing effective job' amid fury SOME gardai tasked with road policing duties are 'unproductive' and 'unconcerned with doing an effective and professional job', a damning report found. The independent review of Roads Policing found that while a majority of Garda members involved in the work were productive and professional, there were major issues with poor productivity and behaviour among a 'noticeable' minority. 2 Garda Commissioner Drew Harris said the report makes for 'stark reading' Credit: Garrett White/PA Wire The Crowe Report said members who were 'disinterested' in the job were able to 'get away with such behaviour' to the 'frustration' of their colleagues, supervisors and managers. Advertisement The review by consultancy firm Crowe was commissioned by the Garda amid an increased focus on road safety in Ireland in recent years. The Government recently introduced new speed laws, and Garda Commissioner Drew Harris has mandated that frontline gardaí dedicate 30 minutes of road policing duties per shift. The review assessed the effectiveness of the Garda's Roads Policing Units (RPUs). Its findings are based on visits to RPUs within six Garda divisions in Ireland. In response, outgoing Garda Commissioner Drew Harris said the report makes for 'stark reading'. Advertisement Harris said that the findings of the report were 'shocking and disturbing, particularly given the importance of this work in saving lives and preventing life-altering injures". He added: 'While they found the majority of roads policing gardai were professional, dedicated and productive, they also met a significant cohort of officers who are disinterested, have a poor work ethic and deliberately ignored offences. 'Any members of An Garda Siochana – either Garda or supervisor – failing to perform their duties is a breach of trust with the public who depend on us to keep them safe.' AGSI President Declan Higgins said: 'The Crowe Report is a hard-hitting wake-up call for An Garda Siochana, but will Garda management see the wood from the trees? Advertisement 'In pursuing strategic transformation, An Garda Siochana under Commissioner Harris' leadership, has lost focus on the realities of on-the-ground operational policing. Fatal crashes on Irish roads continue to remain a problem as warning issued 'The Crowe report shows that the Garda Roads Policing Units have a solid, effective core which is deserving of support and praise. 'However, it also highlights that there is a small minority that are demotivated and clearly demoralised. 'DEMORALISATION' 'This demoralisation within An Garda Siochana has been ignored by Garda management and overseeing agencies for far too long.' Sinn Fein's Matt Carthy described the findings as 'deeply disturbing' and added: 'It is something that has to be addressed and can only be done so when the Minister for Justice gets to grip with the recruitment retention crisis in An Garda Siochana, which saw a net increase of a mere seven members in the first five months of 2025 Advertisement 'We cannot accept anything less than the highest level of professionalism from An Garda Siochana in terms of the policing of our roads.'
