The Irish Times view on the Clodagh Hawe case: real questions for State and society
Many readers will have been moved by the testimony of Jacqueline Connolly, whose memoir, Deadly Silence, has been published this week. The book details the experience of losing her brother and husband to suicide, experiences that most people would find difficult to imagine bearing. It is also a clear-eyed account of the circumstances and aftermath of the murder of her sister Clodagh and three nephews, Liam, Niall and Ryan
Clodagh Hawe and her three sons were murdered in 2016 in Castlerahan, Co Cavan by Alan Hawe, Clodagh's husband and the boys' father, who subsequently took his own life. The story as recounted in the book raises troubling questions about coercive control, victims' rights and social attitudes to familial murder-suicide.
A Serious Crime Review report into the initial investigation into the murder was finally completed by the Garda in 2023. The 800-page document has not been published but its findings and recommendations are 'incorporated into senior investigative training'. This seems inadequate.
In Garda briefings on the report to Clodagh Hawe's family, as described in Deadly Silence, they acknowledge flaws in the investigation's handling of CCTV evidence and the manner in which key witness testimonies were collected. Digital evidence was also missed.
READ MORE
Just as unsatisfactory is the State's failure to address the long-standing legal loophole surrounding inheritance rights in cases of familial killings. That became a matter of public debate following the killing of Celine Cawley by her husband Eamonn Lillis in Dublin 2008. Legislation proposing changes to the law was published in 2017, but was never progressed.
Irish society has also been slow to recognise the ways in which coercive control can be exercised, sometimes invisibly, in a family or relationship. The welcome introduction of legislation in 2019 criminalising such behaviour has hopefully raised awareness.
Murder-suicides, with all their attendant trauma, pose a particular challenge for the communities in which they occur as well as for law enforcement. Public reaction may seek to frame the crime in a way that diminishes the responsibility of the perpetrator. That was the experience of Jacqueline Connolly and her mother as they struggled to understand what had really happened to Clodagh and her sons. In their account, there is a lacuna in how the State deals with cases of this sort when there is no living person to prosecute for a crime.
None of the questions raised by this appalling tragedy would have come to light had it not been for the perseverance of Jacqueline Connolly. While her commitment and determination are to be admired, her search for the truth should never have been made so difficult.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTÉ News
an hour ago
- RTÉ News
'Preferable if we had a cadaver dog', says justice minister amid concerns over Satchwell case
Minister for Justice Jim O'Callaghan has said he raised concerns with the Garda Commissioner about how long it took to uncover the body of Tina Satchwell, who was murdered by her husband, and that it would be "preferable" if gardaí had a cadaver dog. Richard Satchwell was sentenced to life in prison for the murder of his wife in their home in Cork in 2017. It took more than six and a half years before gardaí discovered Ms Satchwell had never left their home at Grattan Street in Youghal. Speaking on RTÉ's This Week, Minister O'Callaghan commended the gardaí for their investigation but he said it took a considerable period of time for her body to be uncovered. Adding that he is expecting a report on this, he said: "There are very devious people out there. There are very devious murderers who go to a very great length to hide their crimes. That was the case with Richard Satchwell and it's also the case for the person responsible for the murder of Mike Gaine, who hasn't yet been apprehended." He said he would have preferred that the body of Tina Satchwell was discovered sooner. "That wasn't done and I will get a report on that, but justice has been done in her case." Asked whether a cadaver dog should have been used, he said probably this should have been the case. He said there was only one trained dog on the island of Ireland, used by the PSNI. Asked if the lack of a cadaver dog was hampering garda investigations, he said he did not believe this was the case, but added: "It obviously would be preferable if we had a cadaver dog." He said the animals only had a limited work life of around three years and had to go through a difficult training process. Asked if this would be included in the funding for the Garda Dog Unit, he said it was up to the Commissioner how this money would be spent. He said he hoped the person responsible for Michael Gaine's murder would be brought to justice and he said the gardaí were conducting a thorough inquiry and had a good reputation for bringing murderers to justice. Last month, gardaí investigating the disappearance and death of 56-year-old sheep farmer Michael Gaine from Kenmare in Co Kerry said human tissue found on his farm had been identified as his remains. Mr Gaine, also known as Mike, went missing from his farm on 20 March. On Friday, . He said he accepted that, "in hindsight", it may seem "very obvious" where Ms Satchwell's remains were located. A report on the investigation will be furnished to Mr O'Callaghan and the Policing and Community Safety Authority, according to the commissioner.
Irish Times
10 hours ago
- Irish Times
‘The country is going to the dogs': How agitators exploited the Carlow shooting
The shooting in Carlow last Sunday was shocking, but what followed online was depressingly familiar. As soon as word emerged of an incident at the Fairgreen Shopping Centre, far-right agitators surfaced online, like moths to a flame, spouting confident falsehoods before any facts were known. How could they know the details so quickly? They couldn't, but that didn't deter them. Offline, figures from the same ideological milieu travelled to the town to use the backdrop of the shooting as an opportunity to rant about immigration, the Government or the media – again, a well-established playbook that by now is both predictable and exhausting. And all details that had little to nothing to do with the incident itself. Just one hour after the incident in Carlow, Derek Blighe, formerly the president of the minor far-right Ireland First political party, posting on X, claimed – without evidence, because there was none – that 'apparently 7 people including a child have been shot'. This post has been viewed just shy of 400,000 times on the platform, but at the time of writing includes no note by X stating that it is false. Philip Dwyer, once associated with Ireland First, travelled to Carlow and livestreamed himself shouting at members of the fire brigade outside the shopping centre for not furnishing him with details about the supposed number of casualties. He then returned to a familiar topic. 'The country is going to the dogs. Everyday there's something going on … crime, mental health … migrant crime. I'm looking around me here in Carlow … good God. The diversity … the non-Irish people,' he said. READ MORE Back online, British far-right agitator Tommy Robinson posted on X that there were 'multiple reports of a suspected terror attack in Carlow, Ireland … gunman shot dead by Gardaí'. Another viral post, viewed over 200,000 times on X. Journalists, gardaí and emergency responders at the scene were berated for not releasing details about the incident fast enough. And when they did release details, they were admonished when those details didn't match the narrative circulating on social media. Carlow has quickly become another case study in how false and misleading information pollutes our online information environment, and why our democratic institutions must better equip themselves to counter this challenge. By now, we have a good grasp of the facts. Shortly after 6.15pm last Sunday, a man entered the Fairgreen Shopping Centre and fired a number of shots into the air. In the ensuing panic, a young girl suffered a minor leg injury when fleeing the scene. Outside the shopping centre, the man used his firearm again and died from a self-inflicted gunshot wound. No one else was shot and gardaí did not discharge their firearms. Evan Fitzgerald, from Kiltegan, Co Wicklow, walked through the Fairgreen Shopping Centre in Carlow firing a shotgun into the air The gunman was later named as Evan Fitzgerald, from Kiltegan, Co Wicklow, a 22-year-old who appeared in court last month on charges related to offences associated with purchasing firearms on the dark web last year. This was established through media reporting and garda statements, four of which were released by Monday lunchtime. In the second of those statements , gardaí confirmed the ethnicity and nationality – white Irish – of the man who died at the scene. In their fourth statement, they shared detailed information about the incident. Media reports described him as 'vulnerable'. [ Man dead after shots fired in Carlow shopping centre, Army bomb disposal team called to scene Opens in new window ] The practice of gardaí sharing such specific information regarding a suspect and an unfolding situation is unprecedented. It signals the force's attempts to combat the spread of harmful misinformation before it has potentially deadly consequences. We don't have to look too far back to recall how online misinformation and hate can fuel offline violence in the space of a few hours. Rioting broke out across the UK last summer after the Southport stabbing when anti-migrant and anti-Muslim narratives helped instigate violence, while closer to home, we all remember the Dublin riots of November 2023. More recently, police in Merseyside acted similarly in the aftermath of the car ramming incident at the Liverpool FC parade . Blighe, Dwyer and Robinson have a track record of portraying their respective countries as places of lawlessness, neglected by authorities and riven by (typically migrant) crime. They opportunistically jump on any purported incident they believe – usually incorrectly – reinforces this sentiment and, in the words of Steve Bannon, accordingly 'flood the zone with shit' online. It is, at its heart, part of a wider nativist, populist strategy employed internationally by the far right to appeal to the public for political support, monetised subscriptions and broader cultural influence. While evidence was still being gathered, none of these figures could have been aware of what had transpired. Yet they – and many others – worked swiftly to fill an information vacuum that develops after such incidents while gardaí, local services and the media work to establish the facts. It is no coincidence that the three operate 'blue tick' accounts on X. The platform offers financial rewards for creating viral, sensationalist content, with few repercussions when that content later turns out to be wrong. These posts are then weaponised by far-right figures for their own ideological agendas, and sometimes used to exploit tragic cases such as this one. [ Carlow shooting: Taoiseach criticises spreading of misinformation and 'blatant lies' online Opens in new window ] There is an ongoing conflict between old and new media systems here. The slower, methodical practices of police and media in reporting on such incidents is rarely a match for the rapid sharing of content online that includes serious and potentially harmful claims with no factual basis. All of this signals how fundamentally broken our online information ecosystem has become. This is best encapsulated in the tiring trope that is typically found in online spaces after reports of an incident like the Carlow shooting emerge: repeated cries that the gardaí or mainstream media are deliberately not releasing information about an incident. Delay is interpreted as deceit and fact checking becomes censorship. This week, Taoiseach Micheál Martin said this kind of misinformation can result in a lot of 'public disquiet' and needs to be addressed. 'There is a family in mourning right now. The level of misinformation on Sunday was quite shocking, and we can't just ignore that and say: 'Well, we don't have to do anything about that.'' This wasn't a question of freedom of speech, he said. 'I wouldn't overstate the impact on clamping down on blatant lies online as a sort of incursion or an undermining of freedom of speech.' The Carlow shooting has quickly become another reminder that unless we address these imbalances – between old and new media, the power of social media and the need to stop misinformation – trust in our core democratic principles and institutions will continue to erode. Ciarán O'Connor is a researcher and journalist who focuses on extremism and technology
Irish Times
10 hours ago
- Irish Times
Woman tells court husband has abused her ‘many times in his sleep'
A woman who alleged that her husband of more than a decade has become increasingly abusive to the point of abusing her while he was sleeping has been granted an interim barring order against him. The woman told Dublin District Family Court she has been attacked by her husband 'many times in his sleep' further claiming that, on several occasions, she has woken to find him sexually assaulting her. She told Judge Gerard Furlong that her husband was also 'extremely abusive and controlling when he's not asleep,' saying he does not want her to work, and does not want her 'going out with anybody or seeing my family'. Her husband left their family home for several months and, after returning, his behaviour in his sleep was 'way worse' and happens every night, he said. READ MORE 'He tells me regularly that I'm mad, mental, unhinged and said that I should kill myself, that my children would be better off without me,' she said in a sworn statement. On one recent occasion, she said her husband followed her 'everywhere' including to shops, making comments about her throughout, adding that he 'humiliates' her in front of their children. She said one of her children, who is currently completing their State exams, is in a 'desperate state' and that the atmosphere in the house is 'unbearable'. the judge granted the interim barring order until a full hearing later this month, saying he did not believe a protection order would be sufficient, given the evidence heard. 'In those circumstances, I'd be asking the gardaí to remove him from the house and he's not to come back,' he said. The woman, who broke down once the interim barring order was granted, thanked him, saying the length of the order 'will be enough time to get the exams out of the way'. In a separate case, a woman who claimed her former partner had lost thousands due to gambling was granted a protection order after an alleged recent rape. The woman originally from eastern Europe, told Judge Furlong their relationship had been 'abusive from the start' but had worsened in recent months due to fights regarding his gambling addiction. 'He's lost thousands of euro,' she said, further claiming that he recently lost his entire wages shortly after being paid, first losing €200 through online gambling before losing a further €800 in city centre casinos days later. 'When he came home, he had 54c in his bank account and no money to pay the rent,' she said, adding that the gambling 'was destroying' their lives. The woman told the judge that, last week, her former partner 'became aggressive and he raped me'. She said following the incident, she tried to call gardaí but he 'shouted and commanded me to go back to bed', adding that he subsequently took her phone and placed it on his side of the bed for the night. She said she believed the rape was 'revenge' for refusing to give him money, and for arguments and her repeated refusals to have sex with him. She said after attending the Rotunda Hospital and reporting the rape to gardaí, she was brought to a women's refuge centre where she has stayed since. She fears seeing her former partner, who has called her mother in an attempt to locate her since, the woman added. The judge said the option of a barring order was available to her, which would result in him having to leave their apartment, though the woman said she could not afford to pay €1,300 in rent. He granted an interim protection order 'with no hesitation' until her case returned to the court.
