Selective Leaks, Missing Context: Global Pilots' Body Flags Gaps In Air India Crash Probe Report
The International Federation of Air Line Pilots' Associations (IFALPA), representing over 1,00,000 professional pilots worldwide, has issued a sharp critique of the preliminary crash report on the ill-fated Air India Flight 171, calling it incomplete, speculative, and lacking critical context.
In a formal statement, IFALPA said the report by India's Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB) 'raises more questions than it answers", particularly in its depiction of the cockpit sequence that preceded the June 12 crash. The federation warned against the premature assignment of blame, stating that key facts and technical details are still missing.
'The early release of selected information—particularly cockpit voice recordings—without a full investigative context risks misleading both the public and policymakers," the federation said. 'This approach not only undermines investigative integrity, it also casts unjust suspicion on crew members who can no longer speak for themselves."
The 15-page preliminary report confirms that both engines of the Boeing 787-8 Dreamliner lost power shortly after takeoff from Ahmedabad, following an abrupt shift of the fuel control switches from 'RUN" to 'CUTOFF". However, it does not conclude whether the action was mechanical, accidental, or deliberate.
IFALPA's primary concern lies in how the report presents these findings. The global pilots' body noted that no definitive mechanical faults were identified and no safety recommendations were made—a significant omission in their view, especially given the public speculation that has followed.
'In the absence of clear mechanical explanations, the vacuum is being filled with speculation," IFALPA warned. 'Investigations must remain focused on facts, not insinuation."
The pilots' group also voiced support for Indian pilot unions, including ALPA-India and the Indian Commercial Pilots' Association (ICPA), who have separately condemned the handling of the investigation and demanded transparency, including observer status for pilot representatives.
Call for Transparency and Patience
IFALPA called on the AAIB and Indian aviation authorities to adhere strictly to international standards under ICAO Annex 13, which outlines procedures for impartial accident investigation and stakeholder participation. The federation said this includes protecting sensitive data until it can be responsibly interpreted within the final report.
'We urge all stakeholders—including media outlets and public officials—to allow investigators the time and space needed to reach factual, technical conclusions. The rush to judgment benefits no one and disrespects the victims and their families."
As the investigation continues, IFALPA reaffirmed its commitment to supporting a professional and evidence-driven process, and to defending the integrity of pilots against premature criticism.
The final report on the AI171 crash is expected later this year.
The Pilot Association in India has also condemned the Air Accidents Investigation Branch (AAIB) for suggesting that the pilots of Flight AI-171 were responsible for cutting off the fuel to the engine.
Speaking exclusively to CNN-News18, Sam Thomas, head of the Pilot Association in India, called the report 'laughable" and questioned the timing of the report's release, the reasons for not asking GE and Boeing to carry out further checks on the engine and aircraft, the partial release of the cockpit conversation transcript, and the lack of a timestamp on when the cut-off switch was first activated.
He added: 'The report has led to more confusion than clarity. Using one line from the cockpit voice recorder to insinuate that the pilots cut out the fuel control switches is misleading. This action is actually part of a checklist if you lose both engines. When you put out such a report that says nothing definitive and insinuates something else, it becomes open to interpretation. A lot of people who have not even seen a picture of the airplane are commenting on it. Very irresponsible comments are being circulated, regarding the pilot's deliberate action to crash the plane, and it is making rounds in the western media."
view comments
Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
44 minutes ago
- Time of India
It's all about how you show your goodwill: When love feels like pressure to your child
Across Indian cities, particularly in families with children studying in private schools, a silent emotional drift is becoming more common. Parents, despite having the best of intentions, are finding themselves at odds with their children—especially their teenagers. The painful irony is this: these are not neglectful parents. They are loving, responsible adults doing everything 'right.' Yet their children are pulling away emotionally—retreating into silence, or often, into the online world. Let me share the story of one such family—a story from my practice that I carry with heaviness and hope. A 15-year-old boy, academically average and generally well-behaved, withdrawn from his mother. He didn't rebel or act out. He simply stopped talking. No conversations. No smiles. His door stayed closed, and his eyes remained glued to his screen. Though he was attending school and turning in work, emotionally, he had vanished. His mother, a single parent, was devastated. She had sacrificed everything to give him the best life—juggling work, finances, and parenting without a partner. 'I've done everything I could,' she told me during our first session, her voice breaking. 'Why won't he even look at me?' As we peeled back the layers of their relationship, it became clear that the problem wasn't a lack of love. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Cyprus investments might be cheaper than you think Investments Cyprus | search ads Get Info Undo In fact, it was an overflow of love—one that came wrapped in constant reminders, daily corrections, edifications and stories of personal sacrifice. Her intent was to guide and support. But to the boy, it all felt like pressure, criticism, and emotional suffocation. Every interaction seemed to whisper, "You're not doing enough—and look how much I do for you." This isn't a story of failure. It's a story of misunderstood love. From Pressure to Presence: A Mother's Journey We didn't focus on 'fixing' the boy. We worked with the mother on understanding how her care and concern could be expressed differently. Love, when it comes wrapped in instruction, worry, or disappointment, doesn't always land the way it's meant to. So, she stopped explaining her sacrifices. She paused the lectures. She began to practice what I call silent companionship. She would leave a plate of food quietly beside him while he played. She began saying things like, 'Hope you slept well' or 'It's chilly' – and keeping socks by his side, not expecting a response—just offering presence. She folded his clothes and left them on his chair. She held emotional space for him, even when he gave nothing in return. It wasn't easy. There were nights when she would call me in tears, whispering, 'Will he ever talk to me again?' And then, it happened. One morning, he walked into the kitchen and asked, 'I got bread for breakfast on the way.' One sentence. That's all. But it was everything. It meant he was beginning to feel safe again in her presence. The emotional door, once locked, had started to creak open. Image credits: Getty Images Why Love Needs a Softer Voice Many parents—especially mothers parenting alone—believe that working harder, guiding more strictly, and correcting more frequently is the path to raising good children. And often, it does lead to outward success. But in the process, emotional connection may erode. Children don't remember every instruction. But they do remember how they felt when they came home after failing a test, or being excluded by friends. They remember whether they were comforted or corrected. Our intent to help must be matched by our ability to connect. The Quiet Ways Goodwill Is Felt When a child begins to emotionally shut down, it's not always a sign of neglect. Sometimes, it's because love has started to feel like pressure—like a performance they're constantly failing to meet. In those moments, goodwill must be felt, not declared. And it's most deeply felt through quiet, consistent gestures that say: 'I care, without demanding anything in return.' Here are some powerful yet simple ways your goodwill can be seen—even when your child isn't ready to respond: A plate of food placed beside them while they game or study. (It says: 'I see you. You matter.') A glass of water or cup of chai at the right moment, without saying a word. (It says: 'You're cared for.') Folded clothes left neatly on their chair, with no reminders or remarks. (It says: 'I'm here to support, not scold.') A short message on a sticky note: 'Hope today feels better' or 'You've got this.' (It says: 'I'm still cheering for you.') Low-pressure check-ins like 'Want tea?' or 'Hope you slept okay,' that don't demand replies. (It says: 'Your comfort matters.') Sitting nearby with your own book or work, offering quiet presence. (It says: 'I'm available, without intruding.') Sending a meme, a reel, or a music link they might enjoy. (It says: 'I remember what makes you smile.') Fixing something they use—a charger, a zipper, a drawer. (It says: 'I care about your world.') Not filling the silence with lectures, but instead allowing quiet moments to be just that— quiet. (It says: 'I trust you. I'll wait.') These are not grand gestures. They don't demand eye contact or conversation. But theyoffer emotional oxygen. They quietly whisper: 'I'm not here to fix you. I'm here to love you—gently, steadily, and without condition.' What Can Parents Do Differently? If you're a parent feeling distanced from your child—especially a teen—pause. Reflect on how your love is being received, not just how it's being given. Here are small but powerful shifts you can make: Replace instruction with curiosity. Instead of 'You should...', try 'What do you think about...?' This invites conversation rather than resistance. Create low-pressure bonding moments. Chat about their music, their shows, their memes. Enter their world with interest, not judgment. Respect their opinions, even if you disagree. They're forming their own identities. Boundaries can coexist with freedom of thought. Just be there. Sit beside them while they scroll. Offer tea. Let silence be connection—not punishment. In our fast-paced, achievement-focused culture, parenting often becomes performative. We think that if we do more—work more, push more—our children will love us more. But sometimes, what they need is for us to do less and simply be present. And sometimes, that journey begins with just one quiet sentence—when your child before walking into the kitchen asks, 'Do you want anything ?' (Tatiana Arteyeva (Chopra) Counselling Psychologist)
Indian Express
6 hours ago
- Indian Express
Rare albino turtle spotted in freshwater lake in Vadodara; probably seen for the first time in Gujarat, says forest officer
The Social Forestry Department of Vadodara rescued a rare Albino Indian flapshell turtle (Lissemys punctata) from a freshwater lake at Chikhodra on Wednesday. The rare colour morph of a freshwater species, native to the Indian subcontinent, was handed over to the Vadodara Social Forestry Department, in what is probably the first case of rescuing this kind of a turtle in Gujarat. When the baby turtle was spotted in the lake in Chikhodra, it had excited onlookers queuing up to catch a glimpse, prompting rescuers to take it in safe custody and hand it over to the Social Forestry Department near Sayajibaug in the city. Range Forest Officer, Vadodara, Karansinh Rajput said, 'We received a call about this rare yellow turtle that climbed up on the bank from a freshwater lake at Chikhodra. Our rescue team reached the spot and brought the turtle to the centre. This is a rare species and probably seen for the first time in Gujarat. Now we will take guidance from the District Wildlife Warden for its conservation.' The albino turtle is named so due to its unique discolouration caused by a congenital genetic condition of a lacking pigment that is present in the turtles with the common dark green or brown shells.
Time of India
6 hours ago
- Time of India
Registered post ‘retires': Bygone postal era ends silently in bylanes
1 2 3 Bhopal:Among the first post-offices in city, the one at Jumerati was built at the end of the 19th century. If you were to visit this mundanely historical site today, you would have to first cross congested by-lanes where there are no cops to regulate traffic and only good samaritans in the area redirect the flow as vehicles drive on the wrong side. Even when you reach the Jumerati post-office, you might pass by and miss it. But when you do end up at the premises, a nearly deserted office with two employees would greet you. The reason: Postal services that once brought joy and a feeling of being seen by people or institutions, a letter of trust or your passport in a registered post, are fading away; assured and tangible acknowledgement being replaced by instant messages on mobiles and a cold distance in real time. The Indian govt has now decided to merge registered post with speedpost. The decline of physical spaces, letters and posts is evident from the state of the oldest post-office, which could've been a heritage site had things been more offline. The end of this era is pronounced more now with the iconic registered post and its physical acknowledgment increasingly becoming a thing of the past. And when it was announced a few days ago that registered post service will be merged with speedpost, the escalation went up a notch. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Substance Found in Pink Salt has Bariatric Effects on Women Over 50 Health & Family Click Here Undo Geeta Gupta, who was a postmaster 35 years ago at a post office in Datia district, and now lives in Bhopal, toldTOI, "The person sending the registered post received an acknowledgment, which is called AD, from the postman like a postcard, that their post has been delivered. I do not know how much of the practice is still adhered to by post offices now but at our time, the person got the AD without fail," While the hallmark of registered post was once reliability, security and accountability, the process of transitioning the speedpost to online servers in the last few days has ironically been marked by a bumpy start: People in the city stood in long and unending queues for the last few days, with some quarrelling with the staff, as the server fluctuated for hours on end. The situation improved a bit on Wednesdayn at TT Nagar post-office but people could be heard complaining about the server delaying their wait time at the post-office GPO near Gandhi Medical College. A staffer at the GPO said, wishing anonymity, "The timing for this server shift could've been chosen at a better time like April when there are no consumers at the post-office. In the Hindi-belt, the festival of Rakhi is celebrated more so that really created issues at the post-offices in Bhopal," And the registered post didn't only hold sentimental value as it is widely used for legal and official purposes, just ask any experienced lawyer in Bhopal, "I've been using registered post for 28 years now and it used to be a reliable way of presenting the acknowledgement of posts in court as it was also admissible, but for the last 10 years or so, the acknowledgements either do not arrive or the postman doesn't deliver them. This move to merge registered post with speedpost may help practically if there's a provision made to incorporate admissibility because registered post as it is wasn't working that well. Right now, we have to do rounds of the post-office to get confirmation from the postmaster while in an earlier era, acknowledgement from a registered post could be submitted in court directly." said CS Tiwari, a lawyer in Bhopal. Mayank Vijaywergiya, a financial consultant, also uses registered post, "There is uncertainty right now about how it'll be merged and how it'll work but the move could speedily send posts," he said. A local shopkeeper, wishing anonymity, said that registered post is cheaper than speedpost at times so he is concerned if higher costs would have to be paid now.
