logo
Kenny MacAskill: SNP losing by-election was unforgiveable

Kenny MacAskill: SNP losing by-election was unforgiveable

The National2 days ago

The town's name is seared in Scotland's soul from Winnie Ewing's victory there in the UK Parliament by-election in 1967. I was a child then but was aware of its seismic effect on not just Scottish politics but Scottish society.
Many stalwarts told me how a movement viewed as marginal and romantic came alive with that triumph. Scottish politics was changed irrevocably, with independence becoming a possibility, not just a dream.
More recently, when I was justice secretary, I worked with Christina McKelvie, an assiduous and popular MSP, as she sought to address knife crime in her community.
READ MORE: SNP candidate calls out Tory rival for being in 'lockstep with failed ideology'
The seat's loss a bitter blow to the efforts of those stalwarts and countless others.
Alba stood aside, calling on supporters to 'max the Yes vote'. Just what the Scottish Greens think they achieved by standing is for them to explain, with their total of votes barely greater than the very small Labour majority.
Unionists are now crowing and the impact will be felt by the wider independence movement. It's a tragedy which will require work and change to come back from.
It wasn't the fault of the SNP candidate any more than success can be attributed to her spectacularly poor Labour opponent. The polish of New Labour was forsaken, with Davy Russell a throwback to Labour candidates from days of yore when the party reigned across huge swathes of Scotland, its dead hand lying across the land.
Under Alex Salmond's leadership, that Tammany Hall power was broken and Scotland was transformed for the better. We cannot allow those dark days to return.
Remember that this was also a defeat for what little remains of the Labour left and those who still think Scotland can be transformed within the Union.
Last week's result will be taken as an endorsement of Starmerism, legitimation of the austerity agenda and Labour's attacks on the poor and vulnerable. Those who have bravely spoken out will be hounded and party loyalists empowered.
Responsibility for the defeat rests with the SNP leadership for both its lamentable by-election strategy, and its actions and failings over recent years. Circumstances had changed from last year and were favourable for SNP.
The tidal clamour for change last July, which saw myself and my Alba colleague swept out of the UK Parliament along with numerous SNP MPs, had well and truly ebbed. Starmer's Labour were and are deeply unpopular. At the same
time independence was polling well above 50% and even higher when the spectre of Farage and Reform was posed. All good, you'd think, for pushing the case for independence.
READ MORE: SNP must turn support for independence into 'real political action', says Swinney
That was what, after all, was done by Winnie Ewing all those years ago and decades before we even had our Parliament restored. She gave a vision of the land Scotland could be, contrasting it with the country it was, as pits and shipyards started to close and emigration continued.
But independence wasn't mentioned by the SNP. It was the policy notable only for its absence in literature, on the doorsteps and in debate.
Yet it was the unique selling point for the SNP.
It was the one thing that carved them out from their principal opponents, Labour and Reform, and, even more than that, was backed by well over half of voters. That failure's not just inexplicable but unforgiveable.
Instead, a strategy of 'stop Reform' was pushed. Just what was that meant to express other than avoiding having to answer for failings in their Scottish Government administration is hard to fathom.
In politics, saying what you're for is always better than arguing what you're against. It motivates those who share your beliefs and can even earn respect or at least legitimation from opponents.
Besides, Reform are not going to take power in Scotland – but only independence can ensure they are not foisted on us by being in the Union. The SNP leadership treated independence supporters in Hamilton with the same arrogance and disdain that they've treated the wider movement over recent years.
A simple assumption that they'd have to vote for them and the backing of others could safely be pursued.
Do what 'yer telt' and 'wheesht for indy'. But, as in 2017, where there's neither motivation nor articulation of independence, many simply stayed at home. The SNP did not lose support to Reform in Hamilton, instead they saw independence supporters say: 'What's the point of voting?'
That compounded growing contempt for their failings in office and their lack of vision for the country. An obsession with gender and identity when what is wanted is an improvement in public services, whether health or housing, jobs or justice. Focusing on individual rights rather than the collective good at a time when communities are struggling.
There has to be a coming together of the independence movement but that requires a recognition by SNP that they are only a part, albeit a major part, of it.
The growing gap between support for independence and support for SNP tells a story and a bit of humility would go a long way. It also means that Holyrood 2026 has to be a plebiscite election and that to 'Max the Yes', it has to be vote Alba on the list.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Wales: Online abuse of politicians ‘getting worse'
Wales: Online abuse of politicians ‘getting worse'

Leader Live

time12 minutes ago

  • Leader Live

Wales: Online abuse of politicians ‘getting worse'

Plaid Cymru's Adam Price, the first out-gay man in his party to be elected to national office, warned prejudices based on sex, race and sexual orientation have been reinvigorated. He told the Senedd: 'It is getting worse by the day, and it really represents an existential crisis for our democracy and our society.' Mr Price said: 'For our democracy to be effective, it has to be diverse. Diversity trumps ability. It's a piece of evidence in social science.' The former Plaid Cymru leader called for a focus on representation of trans women and men, a community 'under siege', to ensure their voices are heard in the Senedd. Mr Price highlighted harmful comments below news stories involving him in recent weeks. 'That certainly won't deter me and I hope it won't deter anyone else,' he said. 'But we've got to do something about it collectively, haven't we?' Labour's Hannah Blythyn expressed concerns that Wales could go backwards in terms of equality of representation at the next Senedd election in less than 12 months. She warned that online abuse, misogyny and homophobia are rife across society. Ms Blythyn told Senedd members: 'I very much made an active decision when I had the opportunity to stand in this legislature because of the make-up – that there were more women here, that it was more representative.' She emphasised that diversity not only changes the face of politics but its focus too, saying: 'It makes what we do and the policies that we produce so much better because we are experts by our own life experiences.' Jane Hutt, Wales' social justice secretary, acknowledged the rise of abuse, harassment and intimidation towards politicians, candidates and campaigners. During a statement on June 10, she told the Senedd: 'This is a significant barrier to participation in politics, particularly for people from under-represented groups.' She outlined voluntary diversity and inclusion guidance for political parties which aims to ensure democratic bodies are truly representative of all the people of Wales. Ms Hutt said safety costs will be exempt from spending limits for Welsh elections, in line with calls from the Jo Cox Foundation which was set up after the Labour MP's murder in 2016. TOP STORIES TODAY She added that Welsh ministers are working with regulator Ofcom, which has new enforcement powers, around the misuse and abuse of online media. Altaf Hussain, the Kashmir-born Conservative who represents South Wales West, warned guidance on equal representation risks crossing a dangerous line. The former surgeon said: 'Equality of access cannot come just by bureaucratic diktats or targets that treat individuals not as nuanced, valued voices but boxes to tick. 'This removes merit, choice and, frankly, voters' rights deciding who is best representing them. Let's not replace one form of exclusion with another altogether; the truest diversity only flourishes where and when freedom leads.' Plaid Cymru's Sioned Williams said progress on underrepresentation of women in politics has slowed and, in some parts of democracy, has gone into reverse. She pointed out that the number of female leaders in councils has halved to only 9%. Ms Williams warned the voluntary guidance was published 'far too late' and represented a 'poor reflection' of shelved plans to introduce gender quotas to ensure equal representation. 'Wales belongs to everyone,' she said. 'Everyone must have a voice in our nation's future.'

SNP plotters should think twice before moving against John Swinney
SNP plotters should think twice before moving against John Swinney

Spectator

time14 minutes ago

  • Spectator

SNP plotters should think twice before moving against John Swinney

For those who feel Scottish politics has become a little dull of late, fear not: a rebel faction within the SNP is plotting to make things very interesting again. Today's Glasgow Herald brings the news of a secret summit of top SNP insiders at which plans to remove incumbent party leader (and Holyrood first minister) John Swinney were discussed. The paper says 25 'senior' figures gathered on Monday to consider the boss's future after the SNP's surprise defeat in last week's by-election in Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse, a seat they had held uninterrupted since 2011. The conspirators are reportedly frustrated by Swinney's moderation on domestic policy and his failure to ramp up efforts to take Scotland out of the United Kingdom. They are said to be giving Swinney two weeks to present a new independence strategy or face a leadership challenge before the year is out.

Douglas Ross convenes Education Committee from Caribbean
Douglas Ross convenes Education Committee from Caribbean

STV News

time19 minutes ago

  • STV News

Douglas Ross convenes Education Committee from Caribbean

Douglas Ross faced calls to leave a Holyrood committee after convening it from the Caribbean, with one MSP branding the situation 'farcical'. The former Scottish Conservative leader video-called into the Education Committee on Wednesday from Turks and Caicos, where it was about 4am at the time. He is in the region as part of a Commonwealth Parliamentary Association seminar following a nomination by Scottish Parliament members of the association. Ross, who arrived in the archipelago on Monday and will return on Thursday, had said beforehand he would still attend the committee. MSPs were grilling Education Secretary Jenny Gilruth, children's minister Natalie Don-Innes, and higher and further education minister Graeme Dey. Willie Rennie, a member of the committee, raised concerns about Ross chairing the meeting in Edinburgh from abroad. He said: 'It is wholly inappropriate and unprofessional for Douglas Ross to even attempt to chair the Education Committee 4,000 miles away in the Caribbean. 'This is especially the case when questioning the three ministers for education on issues such as temporary contracts for teachers, school violence, the University of Dundee, the future of colleges, The Promise, additional support needs and so much more. 'These issues deserve a convener who is in the room rather than attempting to conduct affairs in the middle of the night in the Turks and Caicos islands. 'Everyone in education in Scotland deserves better than this.' PA Media Scottish Liberal Democrat MSP Willie Rennie called for Douglas Ross to leave the Education Committee (Fraser Bremner/Scottish Daily Mail/PA) The Liberal Democrat MSP had raised a point of order during the committee, adding he had also raised concerns before the meeting began. During the session, Rennie said his appearance from the Caribbean 'doesn't make you look good and it doesn't make this committee look good'. He had asked Ross to hand over his duties on Wednesday to the vice-convener. Ross said he was happy to hear concerns and allow deputy convener Jackie Dunbar to convene the committee. Following a brief suspension, Dunbar said the rules for conveners did not distinguish between a virtual or physical appearance at the committee, and Ross convened the rest of the meeting. PA Media SNP MSP George Adam described Douglas Ross's appearance at the committee as a 'farcical' (Scottish Parliament/PA) SNP MSP George Adam told Ross at the committee: 'I would just like to say a few words with regards to the situation of you convening this from a tropical island on the other side of the world. 'I am, for the record, not happy. I find this meeting farcical, the fact that you could even think you could do that online from the other side of the world. 'To be fair, it's the best behaved you've been in the past couple of weeks so perhaps being online suits you and not actually meeting people in person is maybe not your best way forward. 'The aggressive manner and the lack of respect you've shown to people who have come to the committee in the past have actually made this Parliament look bad. 'I want to put that on the record because we have tried on numerous occasions to talk to you, take you aside and ask you to do the right thing, but you continue with your continued behaviour and quite frankly I think it makes you look small and pathetic.' Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store