logo
Dáil votes by 86 to 64 to abolish juries in defamation cases

Dáil votes by 86 to 64 to abolish juries in defamation cases

Irish Times30-04-2025
Juries in High Court defamation actions are set to be abolished after the Dáil voted by 86 to 64 for their removal.
Minister for Justice Jim O'Callaghan had opposed the move as a Government backbencher, when the Defamation (Amendment) Bill was introduced last year.
At the time he described the measure as 'short-sighted' and 'not fully thought out'. But the Minister told TDs that being in a political party 'requires compromise'.
He said there has been a general election since he made those remarks, the legislation is part of the programme for government and he is bound by that as a member of Cabinet.
READ MORE
The Dáil was debating the legislation, which aims to reform the State's defamation laws, including relating to online trolling, and to reduce legal costs for parties involved.
The Bill also introduces protection against Strategic Lawsuits Against Public Participation (Slapps), which are seen as a threat to press freedom and are usually taken against individual journalists.
Independent TD Catherine Connolly had called on the Minister to show 'moral courage and leadership' by opposing the abolition of juries.
'I wouldn't like to be sitting in your position and having to eat my words. I don't think you should eat your words. I think you should be proud of them,' she said.
There has been a belief among media defendants that without juries, monetary award values will reduce and defamation cases would not last as long. Previously, Mr O'Callaghan's assessment was that this would not be the case, she said.
She quoted his remarks: 'If we abolish juries, I can guarantee [to] the House that we will develop a whole body of jurisprudence that will result in cases being repeatedly appealed to the Court of Appeal and probably the Supreme Court.' It is seldom the case that jury decisions are appealed, he had added.
Ms Connolly said to abolish juries 'is nothing less than a bowing to vested interests'.
Sinn Féin justice spokesman Matt Carthy said his party opposes the abolition of juries as a matter of principle and would oppose the entire Bill on this basis. He added that 'it would leave Ireland as a complete outlier in common law jurisdictions globally'.
The Law Society and Bar Council have pointed to the importance of members of the public determining issues relating to damage to reputation and freedom of expression, and he sees this as 'eminently sensible'.
Social Democrats justice spokesman Gary Gannon said juries play an important role to ensure fairness, particularly when 'powerful entities' are involved. He added that there is no evidence jury actions are more costly.
Labour TD Marie Sherlock said the legislation is now out of date. She said legal fees in defamation cases are higher than in any other civil action and the legislation should change that practice.
She proposed an amendment that would mean juries have a role in determining questions of fact but no role in the assessment of damages.
Mr O'Callaghan said it would be inappropriate and would divide functions between the jury and the judge. The amendment was rejected by 86 to 64 votes.
The Minister said one of the consequences of being in a political party 'is the need and necessity for compromise'.
There had been a general election, and Fianna Fáil put forward a manifesto that he supported, which included the passage of the Defamation Bill.
Mr O'Callaghan added it was 'not a question of morality but a recognition of the compromise that is required if one becomes a minister in government and if one signs up to a programme for government that contains a principle that was in conflict with what I had said previously'.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

The Irish Times view on climate policy: Government must avoid backsliding
The Irish Times view on climate policy: Government must avoid backsliding

Irish Times

timean hour ago

  • Irish Times

The Irish Times view on climate policy: Government must avoid backsliding

Methane arising from agriculture and the fossil fuel industry is a notorious greenhouse gas, contributing significantly to global warming. While it breaks down relatively quickly in the atmosphere – unlike carbon dioxide – it is a serious threat to climate stabilisation. The quicker it is reduced, the more global average temperatures can be cut. Much can be done to reduce methane releases in oil and gas production, but it is much more challenging in agriculture. Livestock exporting countries like Ireland and New Zealand are supporting a new approach to classifying methane which is gaining political traction. This is based around achieving national 'temperature neutrality', also known as 'no additional warming'. The Government has yet to take a formal position on the concept. Significantly it got the backing of the Climate Change Advisory Council, its key advisory body. It chose to interpret Ireland's legally-binding climate neutrality obligations in terms of temperature neutrality – rather than the more onerous target of 'net zero emissions'. An international study , published in the Environmental Research Letters journal this week, has questioned this approach. It says that it 'grandfathers high emissions from wealthy, livestock-exporting nations', shifts the burden of cutting emissions to others, and limits space for lower-income countries to grow food systems. The approach fails on food security grounds, with trade data showing most exports serve high-income markets. This risks locking in inequality and misses 'a critical opportunity to reduce peak warming'. READ MORE The most concerning finding was highlighted by lead researcher Dr Colm Duffy of the University of Galway: 'If every country adopted a temperature neutrality target, we'd seriously jeopardise the Paris agreement's goal of limiting warming to 1.5 degrees or even 2 degrees.' The Government is in a bind on this. How methane is regarded in policy terms has big implications for carbon budgets up to 2040, which must be signed off on soon. Climatologist Prof John Sweeney has argued that the shift, which reduces the required emissions reduction target, is not aligned with scientific recommendations and could hinder Ireland's ability to meet its climate goals. The study emphasises that governments must set targets that are internationally credible and farmers need to be supported within a national framework, rather than targeted for blame. The bottom line is that Ireland will not meet the global climate challenge by redefining climate targets. Ireland has yet to deliver an honest appraisal of what a genuinely climate-neutral, sustainable and resilient agricultural sector could look like in coming decades. Avoiding this issue would amount to backsliding on vital climate action.

'I'm leaving this country': Migrant workers call for immediate action in wake of attacks
'I'm leaving this country': Migrant workers call for immediate action in wake of attacks

The Journal

time2 hours ago

  • The Journal

'I'm leaving this country': Migrant workers call for immediate action in wake of attacks

MIGRANT WORKERS AND representatives from various organisations protested outside of the Department of the Taoiseach today, calling for immediate action from Government leaders in the wake of a spate of attacks against Indian people. Around 300 people turned out for the lunchtime protest, with some migrant workers telling The Journal that they plan to leave Ireland due to a rise in what one called 'subtle racism, and direct attacks'. The Indian Irish Society, the African Solidarity Centre Ireland and other organisations came together to deliver a letter to the Taoiseach Micheál Martin's office demanding immediate action in light of multiple assaults on Indian migrants that have been reported in the media in recent months. 'No one has taken responsibility. Due to the fear and anxiety caused by these incidents, one Indian cultural event has been cancelled,' the letter said, referencing the cancellation of the annual India Day celebration at Farmleigh House. They are asking for the attackers involved in these incidents to be prosecuted, for training for gardaí on how to handle racist attacks, and 'effective strategies against racism and hate crimes'. The Journal / YouTube One Indian tech worker, Abin, said that having lived and worked in Ireland for over two years, he now plans to leave within the next six months. 'It's the attacks and the fear, but it's also the subtle racism. I can work in other countries, I am just here to live abroad and get more experience for a while, just like Irish people who go to Australia in their twenties. 'Our demands as a community are very simple, we want to see gardaí deployed more in areas where there is a high incident rate of these racist attacks, including in areas like Tallaght. Many people are established here and it is not easy for them to leave, and they shouldn't have to,' Abin said. One Indian worker at the protest today held a sign that read 'I'm leaving this country'. Lassane Ouedraogo, the chair of the Africa Solidarity Centre Ireland, has been in Ireland for two decades. Today at the protest he said that he is also now planning to leave. Lassane told The Journal that he has been physically attacked over five times in Ireland, and that no one was ever persecuted in relation to the attacks. 'Each time you go to bed you are wondering what the next day will be like. You aren't sure that you will go to work safe and come back safe. If something happens, people are filming you, [there are] bystanders, the police take ages to come to your rescue. Advertisement 'Looking what happened on Sunday in Fairview with that man, his eyes were deeply cut,' Lassane said. The Journal / YouTube He added that his organisation and others have repeatedly called on the Government to strengthen legislation around hate crime and hate speech. Green Party Councillor Feljin Jose, who is a representative for Cabra-Glasnevin, said that bringing in stronger hate speech laws is one of the actions that the Government could have taken before now to protect the migrant communities of Ireland. The Journal / YouTube He also said that there has been a lack of action from senior government figures in response to the attacks against members of the Indian community. 'We've heard nothing from the Minister for Justice about it. I'm quite disappointed that he hasn't said anything at all. He's responsible for crime and safety laws, and he's said nothing.' He added that members of the Indian community are contacting him because they don't feel safe leaving the house anymore, and also that some are contacting him because they are worried for his safety as an Indian public representative. 'My parents are telling not to go out too late, not to get on the bus, it's sad actually,' Feljin said. 'Mates that I grew up with and went to school with are talking about leaving Ireland. These are people who have been in Ireland since they were 9 or ten-years-old. 'One of my friends is a healthcare assistant who cycles from appointment to appointment in Finglas, and he is being racially abused everyday. He wants to go and work in healthcare somewhere else.' Winifred, a Nigerian woman who has lived in Ireland for over two decades, who works in the Department of Foreign affairs, said that she went to the protest to show solidarity and speak out against the attacks that have been happening. 'On my break I have to go and protest. My colleagues don't hae to do that, but I don't feel safe anymore coming in and out of work,' she said. Tánaiste Simon Harris and Minister of State with responsibility for Migration, Colm Brophy met with members of the Indian community on Monday to discuss recent attacks on Indian citizens. Gardaí have said that the Garda diversity unit is working with the Federation of Indian Communities in Ireland to address present concerns and that the force 'would like to reassure those of an ethnic or minority background that we are here to keep you safe'. It's understood that the Justice Minister plans to meet with Indian community groups this week. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal

Budget supports for life sciences firms hit by US tariffs a 'priority', says finance minister
Budget supports for life sciences firms hit by US tariffs a 'priority', says finance minister

Irish Examiner

time4 hours ago

  • Irish Examiner

Budget supports for life sciences firms hit by US tariffs a 'priority', says finance minister

Supports for life sciences companies hit by US tariffs will be a "priority" in the Budget, the finance minister has said. While the final shape of a trading agreement between the US and EU remains to be seen, concern has been raised about the impact on the life sciences and medical device industries in even the case of a base rate 15% tariff. Speaking in Clonmel on Wednesday, Paschal Donohoe said that he would be examining the impact that the agreement between the EU and Ireland will have on the life science sector in Europe, and "what further measures we can take at national level to support a really important pillar of the economy of Ireland". He said the 15% tariffs that are in place "at least bring certainty regarding where we are, but will still bring cost". "And what we need to do, and are doing, is working with large employers in life science and elsewhere to look now at how we can support them and the jobs and investment that they have here in Ireland," said the minister. "We have expertise that we've built up over many, many decades of supporting the life science sector. I will continue to use that expertise to do all we can to protect jobs like we have here in Tipperary." He said those kinds of investments are replicated all over the length and breadth of Ireland "and it's a really important priority for me as we form the budget". Mr Donohoe once again reiterated that there will be no cost-of-living package in October's Budget, but said the Government is "very conscious that the cost of living continues to be a challenge for so many". Ticket prices Asked if he would be attending this weekend's Oasis concerts in Dublin, the minister said he is "more of a Blur fan", but indicated that he does not want to see the surge in pricing of Oasis tickets to become the norm. "This is something that the Competition and Consumer Protection Authority has already indicated that it wants to review because these tickets are really expensive. "They're really expensive because there is a demand for them. Oasis fans are willing to pay a lot of money to go and see them play. "But I wouldn't like this to be the future of live performances. Live performances are really, really important for fans. Lots of other gigs at the moment continue to be really affordable, and I'd like to see that as being the future."

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store