Time for re-election, or for a re-evaluation?
His worship, Winnipeg Mayor Scott Gillingham, has committed to seeking another term in office. One of his top priorities is the completion of the upgrade for the North End Water Pollution Control Centre (NEWPCC), which is crucial if Winnipeg wants to increase housing stock.
The plant is 88 years old and has reached capacity, so there is a sense of urgency. Getting this monkey off of city hall's back will entail the benevolence of the province and federal government who ironically have charged the city for last February's gigantic sewage spill at the Abinojii bridge. Concurrently, all three levels of government are also in court fighting a $4.8-billion lawsuit by 11 First Nation communities over its role in the pollution of Lake Winnipeg.
Winnipeg's sewer infrastructure is an absolute mess and, if elected, the mayor will be spending his next term stickhandling around lawsuits, environmental arraignments and the implementation of a woefully inadequate sewer master plan.
MIKAELA MACKENZIE / FREE PRESS FILES
Winnipeg Mayor Scott Gillingham plans to run for re-election to finish a series of major projects.
During his first term, he was obliged to raise taxes substantially to accommodate infrastructure that had been neglected for decades. His campaign promise of a 3.5 per cent increase soon became 5.95 per cent, and in addition, increases in garbage and sewer rates were levied.
As a result, the average sample home will see a tax hike of close to $400/year. We're playing catch up for all those years of tax breaks and are now facing the real costs of flushing toilets and picking up garbage, which will continue to rise.
Homeowners should expect to pay for city amenities especially since their properties are increasing in value by leaps and bounds. The real costs of essential services must also be shared with any new or infill construction, Winnipeg is experiencing an infill housing boom thanks to a federal housing initiative which puts pressure on communities still dependent on combined sewers.
According to the city's master plan it may take until 2095 to get even close to significantly reducing releases. Citizens are fed up with the pollution of our rivers and lakes and it will take some innovative strategies to overcome what has reached epic proportions in cost overruns and lengthy deferrals. There are two major elephants sitting in the council chambers — an outdated sewage treatment plant and sewers that combine household waste with storm drain flows.
With very few exceptions, government contracts far exceed their estimated costs and it is with some relief that a consultant has been hired by city hall to review the treatment plant project in search of efficiencies.
In 2015 the estimated cost for revamping the NEWPCC was $795 million, it has now ballooned to $3 billion. This review will cost $180,000 but hopefully will meet Mynarski Coun. Ross Eadie's expectations that upgrades will come in under budget, but we shouldn't be holding our breath.
There are very few companies willing to take on such a massive undertaking, so awarding the contract under the consultant's fiscal constraints by mid-September may be unrealistic, kicking the project further down the road.
Although Winnipeg homeowners are being called upon to pay the piper, the city must also ensure that a levy on new developments include realistic costs for city services. Gillingham has an obligation to ensure projects are brought on in a timely and cost-efficient manner.
Council must also recognize that status quo for sewer infrastructure planning is not robust enough to deal with the anomalies of climate change. The department of waste and water will have to revise the master plan for combined sewers slated for review by the province in 2030. In order to make changes to the plan's timeline, Gillingham will be required to arrive cap in hand at the doors of both federal and provincial ministers to desperately procure infrastructure capital.
Seeking re-election, the mayor would be wise to summon his departments to review their own efficiencies and accountability and make them public, especially since he is asking for such substantial increases in taxes. It is virtually impossible to interview representatives from the waste and water department or get a full account of what went wrong when 230 million litres of sewage was spilled in to the Red River 17 months ago.
Wednesdays
A weekly dispatch from the head of the Free Press newsroom.
Transparency would make the tax bill a little easier pill to swallow.
The mayor needs to get ahead of these chronic problems at city hall. His promise from last year to avoid diluted sewage from going into the river rings hollow. His belief that the city is doing as much as it can doesn't seem to be reducing the billions of litres of raw sewage entering our rivers each year.
Contrary to the Gillingham's belief, there's much more to be done to clean our rivers.
Is this the mayor to see it through?
Dave Taylor has drawn attention to the pollution of rivers in Manitoba for several decades and is a regular contributor to the Free Press. Visit his blog at wpgsewage.wordpress.com.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
11 hours ago
- CBC
York Factory First Nation 'essentially stranded' after low water levels ground ferry: grand chief
Indigenous leaders in Manitoba want an all-season road for a northern Manitoba First Nation that's been "essentially stranded" after low water levels left its ferry grounded for more than two weeks. York Factory First Nation Chief Darryl Wastesicoot said his community of about 300 is located between two Manitoba Hydro dams, and that the Crown corporation controls the water levels on the lake. Unprecedented low water levels this year have left his community "basically stuck," Wastesicoot said. York Factory, about 900 kilometres north of Winnipeg, declared a state of emergency earlier this week, because the ferry has been inoperable for more than two weeks. "It's not the first year that's been like this and it continues to happen, so we are looking for solutions here with Manitoba Hydro, but we're falling on deaf ears," he said. At a news conference on Tuesday, Wastesicoot and several other First Nations chiefs and grand chiefs demanded that the federal and provincial governments fast track an all-season road for York Factory. Assembly of Manitoba Chiefs Grand Chief Kyra Wilson said the issue boils down to Manitoba Hydro's control of water levels within First Nations communities, leaving places like York Factory "essentially stranded." "What we're seeing right now is dams surrounding our First Nations communities, and they're controlling the flow through and the water levels, and it's negatively impacting our First Nations communities," she said at the news conference. However, Infrastructure Minister Lisa Naylor said ongoing drought conditions are to blame for the unusually low water levels that left York Factory's ferry inoperable. The province is watching the water levels and precipitation to determine when the ferry can resume service, she said. "In the meantime, we are working closely with York Factory First Nation and the federal government to ensure that families have access to the essential supplies and resources they need," she said in a statement to CBC News on Monday. Manitoba Hydro spokesperson Peter Chura said the low water levels that docked the ferry are not because of operations at the nearby Keeyask Generating Station. He also blamed drought, saying both the Churchill River and Lake Winnipeg basins are much drier than normal. "As a result, water levels and flows are low on lakes and rivers throughout Manitoba," he said in a statement. Chura also said there are "open lines of communication" between Manitoba Hydro and York Factory. 'Can't afford to wait' Wastesicoot said the ferry is a critical part of York Factory's survival because winter roads are "not reliable anymore." "We used to get three months out of it, but now we're lucky to get 30 days," he said. Manitoba's current wildfire season has also threatened the ferry's viability, preventing the ferry from docking a few times already this year, Wastesicoot said. "Sometimes the planes couldn't land because of the smoke," he said. "It would be devastating if we couldn't get out." Two external studies recently commissioned by York Factory found that a 60-kilometre, all-season road for the community would cost around $150 million, Wastesicoot said. York Factory would ideally like to return to its traditional lands, he said. The First Nation was forced to relocate to its current location in 1957. But such a return would be costly, with an estimated $5 billion price tag, according to Wastesicoot. "I don't think that's going to happen anytime soon." Wastesicoot has spoken with Naylor and Premier Wab Kinew about the situation, and while both promised to meet with the chief, he said York Factory can't wait for that to happen any longer. He expects the ferry to be out of commission until September at the latest. "We can't afford to wait to meet with the officials who have the power to do something about it," he said.
Winnipeg Free Press
a day ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
A start — but only a small start
Opinion The Kinew government has taken its first concrete steps toward addressing one of the most visible and heartbreaking manifestations of poverty in Manitoba: the growing number of people living in encampments. So far, 59 people have been moved from tent encampments into either social housing or private market rentals — a modest but significant start. But with an estimated 700 Manitobans living in encampments, the road ahead is long and fraught with challenges. The reality is this: there simply isn't enough social housing available to meet the current need. The province's social housing stock has eroded over the years due to aging infrastructure, lack of maintenance and chronic underfunding. MIKAELA MACKENZIE / FREE PRESS FILES Tents by the river on Waterfront Drive on May 22. New social housing builds have not kept pace with the demand and the waitlist for Manitoba Housing units continues to grow. That shortage leaves vulnerable people — many of whom are dealing with addiction, mental illness, trauma or all of the above — with no viable alternative but to pitch tents near riverbanks, in alleyways, or in downtown parks. This is not just a housing crisis. It's a poverty crisis, a mental health crisis, an addictions crisis and, ultimately, a policy crisis that stems from decades of neglect and underinvestment by multiple levels of government. Premier Wab Kinew's government has shown a willingness to take this issue seriously — something that was often lacking in previous administrations. Announcements of funding for transitional housing, wraparound supports and partnerships with community organizations are welcome. However, even the most well-intentioned policies cannot fix this problem overnight. The public needs to understand this will take time. Moving 700 people into stable housing is not just a matter of finding empty units and handing out keys. Many people who live in encampments are dealing with deeply rooted issues — untreated trauma, mental illness and addiction. For many, traditional housing won't work unless it comes with long-term supports, including mental health counselling, harm-reduction services and case management. Some may require transitional or supportive housing before they can live independently. That's why the Housing First model — which prioritizes stable housing as a foundation for recovery — has proven effective in other jurisdictions. But to succeed, Housing First requires an actual supply of housing. And Manitoba does not have it. This is where the Kinew government faces a steep uphill climb. It must urgently increase the supply of affordable and supportive housing, not just to help those in encampments today but to prevent others from ending up there tomorrow. That means investing in new social housing, refurbishing old stock, and incentivizing private-market affordable rentals. Weekday Mornings A quick glance at the news for the upcoming day. But more housing alone won't be enough. If the upstream causes of homelessness aren't addressed — the poverty that drives people to the streets, the addictions that destroy lives and the mental health crises that go untreated — then encampments will remain a tragic fixture in Manitoba's urban landscape. Governments must also expand mental health services, increase funding for addiction treatment and harm reduction, and overhaul income supports that currently leave many Manitobans living below the poverty line. Minimum wage, disability supports and social assistance rates must be brought in line with the real cost of living. Without those reforms, efforts to reduce homelessness will be little more than a Band-Aid over a much deeper wound. The Kinew government has been in office less than two years and no one should expect it to undo decades of systemic neglect in a matter of months. But progress, however incremental, must be sustained. Getting 59 people into housing is an important first step. But it must be followed by hundreds more. The time for short-term fixes has passed. What's needed now is a comprehensive, patient and compassionate approach — one that understands that housing is a human right.
Winnipeg Free Press
a day ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Time for re-election, or for a re-evaluation?
Opinion His worship, Winnipeg Mayor Scott Gillingham, has committed to seeking another term in office. One of his top priorities is the completion of the upgrade for the North End Water Pollution Control Centre (NEWPCC), which is crucial if Winnipeg wants to increase housing stock. The plant is 88 years old and has reached capacity, so there is a sense of urgency. Getting this monkey off of city hall's back will entail the benevolence of the province and federal government who ironically have charged the city for last February's gigantic sewage spill at the Abinojii bridge. Concurrently, all three levels of government are also in court fighting a $4.8-billion lawsuit by 11 First Nation communities over its role in the pollution of Lake Winnipeg. Winnipeg's sewer infrastructure is an absolute mess and, if elected, the mayor will be spending his next term stickhandling around lawsuits, environmental arraignments and the implementation of a woefully inadequate sewer master plan. MIKAELA MACKENZIE / FREE PRESS FILES Winnipeg Mayor Scott Gillingham plans to run for re-election to finish a series of major projects. During his first term, he was obliged to raise taxes substantially to accommodate infrastructure that had been neglected for decades. His campaign promise of a 3.5 per cent increase soon became 5.95 per cent, and in addition, increases in garbage and sewer rates were levied. As a result, the average sample home will see a tax hike of close to $400/year. We're playing catch up for all those years of tax breaks and are now facing the real costs of flushing toilets and picking up garbage, which will continue to rise. Homeowners should expect to pay for city amenities especially since their properties are increasing in value by leaps and bounds. The real costs of essential services must also be shared with any new or infill construction, Winnipeg is experiencing an infill housing boom thanks to a federal housing initiative which puts pressure on communities still dependent on combined sewers. According to the city's master plan it may take until 2095 to get even close to significantly reducing releases. Citizens are fed up with the pollution of our rivers and lakes and it will take some innovative strategies to overcome what has reached epic proportions in cost overruns and lengthy deferrals. There are two major elephants sitting in the council chambers — an outdated sewage treatment plant and sewers that combine household waste with storm drain flows. With very few exceptions, government contracts far exceed their estimated costs and it is with some relief that a consultant has been hired by city hall to review the treatment plant project in search of efficiencies. In 2015 the estimated cost for revamping the NEWPCC was $795 million, it has now ballooned to $3 billion. This review will cost $180,000 but hopefully will meet Mynarski Coun. Ross Eadie's expectations that upgrades will come in under budget, but we shouldn't be holding our breath. There are very few companies willing to take on such a massive undertaking, so awarding the contract under the consultant's fiscal constraints by mid-September may be unrealistic, kicking the project further down the road. Although Winnipeg homeowners are being called upon to pay the piper, the city must also ensure that a levy on new developments include realistic costs for city services. Gillingham has an obligation to ensure projects are brought on in a timely and cost-efficient manner. Council must also recognize that status quo for sewer infrastructure planning is not robust enough to deal with the anomalies of climate change. The department of waste and water will have to revise the master plan for combined sewers slated for review by the province in 2030. In order to make changes to the plan's timeline, Gillingham will be required to arrive cap in hand at the doors of both federal and provincial ministers to desperately procure infrastructure capital. Seeking re-election, the mayor would be wise to summon his departments to review their own efficiencies and accountability and make them public, especially since he is asking for such substantial increases in taxes. It is virtually impossible to interview representatives from the waste and water department or get a full account of what went wrong when 230 million litres of sewage was spilled in to the Red River 17 months ago. Wednesdays A weekly dispatch from the head of the Free Press newsroom. Transparency would make the tax bill a little easier pill to swallow. The mayor needs to get ahead of these chronic problems at city hall. His promise from last year to avoid diluted sewage from going into the river rings hollow. His belief that the city is doing as much as it can doesn't seem to be reducing the billions of litres of raw sewage entering our rivers each year. Contrary to the Gillingham's belief, there's much more to be done to clean our rivers. Is this the mayor to see it through? Dave Taylor has drawn attention to the pollution of rivers in Manitoba for several decades and is a regular contributor to the Free Press. Visit his blog at
