PM shoulders blame for welfare fiasco and says No 10 ‘didn't get process right'
Looking to repair some of the damage done by Labour's 11th hour climbdown on the central plank of its welfare changes, Starmer said the government would reflect on its mistakes.
'We didn't get the process right. Labour MPs are absolutely vested in this,' Starmer told the BBC's podcast Political Thinking with Nick Robinson. 'It matters to them to get things like this right, and we didn't get that process right.'
He added: 'We didn't engage in the way that we should have done.'
Starmer said he took responsibility for the chapter and repeated his support for his besieged chancellor after recriminations over the government's U-turn appeared to have left Rachel Reeves in tears at prime minister's questions in the Commons on Wednesday. He said Reeves would be in post for the next election and 'many years after'.
An already under-pressure Reeves has been criticised for her political misjudgment in trying to force through cuts in the face of deep backbench unhappiness. As a result of the U-turn, she now has to fill a £5bn shortfall in planned public savings with tax rises or cuts elsewhere.
Starmer said Reeves's tears in the Commons were 'nothing to do with politics' and she would be chancellor for a 'very long time to come'.
The prime minister denied suggestions the chancellor was upset by the fallout over the government's welfare bill and insisted he and his chancellor remained 'in lockstep'.
He said: 'That's absolutely wrong, it's got nothing to do with politics, nothing to do with what's happened this week. It was a personal matter for her. I'm not going to intrude on her privacy by talking to you about that. It is a personal matter.'
He insisted that the £5bn gap in public finances would not result in an increase in income tax, national insurance or VAT for working people. 'That was a manifesto commitment,' he said. 'The one thing we didn't do in the last budget was we didn't breach that manifesto commitment. We're not going to breach that manifesto.'
Acknowledging a 'tough' few days, Starmer said his party would 'come through it stronger'.
'I'm not going to pretend the last few days have been easy, they've been tough. I'm the sort of person that then wants to reflect on that, to ask myself what do we need to ensure we don't get into a situation like that again, and we will go through that process,' he said. 'But I also know what we will do and that's we will come through it stronger.'
On Thursday, the health secretary, Wes Streeting, said people showing kindness to Reeves 'is really appreciated', and told BBC Breakfast she was 'here to stay as our chancellor'. He added that Reeeves was 'tough', had the 'courage, strength and judgment' to make tough decisions in the interests of the country and would 'bounce back'.
The bill passed its second reading with a majority of 75 on Tuesday, after a climbdown from the government in which it shelved plans for deep cuts to personal independence payments (Pip). But the fierce row exposed tensions between No 10 and Labour backbenchers and created a huge headache for Reeves.
Ministers said there would be long-lasting implications for the government's spending priorities after it was forced to abandon the central plank of its welfare changes to prevent a damaging defeat by rebel MPs. The chaos briefly caused turmoil in financial markets, but by Thursday, Starmer's insistence that he would stand by his chancellor appeared to have calmed the waters, with overnight rates back to were they were at PMQs, and seemingly unmoved by the U-turn.
Asked by Robinson if he had 'lost the dressing room' and the support of his own MPs, Starmer replied: 'Absolutely not'.
'As soon as we go through the long list of things that we've achieved this year, the Labour dressing room, the PLP, is proud as hell of what we've done,' he said. 'Their frustration, my frustration, is that sometimes the other stuff, welfare, being an example, can obscure us being able to get that out there.'
Starmer said the government was 'only just starting', adding: 'This, in a sense, is the toughest year.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
16 minutes ago
- BBC News
Consultation opens for Northamptonshire temporary housing plans
A council has asked people living in a county to share their thoughts on plans to build new temporary accommodation. West Northamptonshire Council said it was preparing planning applications for temporary housing on two sites in Northampton. The plots near Edgar Mobbs Way, near Sixfields, and Birds Hill Walk, in Weston Favell, could create 108 temporary homes, the authority said. Charlie Hastie, Reform UK councillor and cabinet member for housing on the council, said: "This proposal allows us to create temporary accommodation which is better suited to people's needs and saves taxpayers' money." The authority said it has faced significant challenges in finding and funding short-term accommodation for people in West Northamptonshire. In June, the cabinet at the council voted in favour of bringing the management of social housing in-house after a number of "failings" with a property management were was the first major decision by the Reform UK-led council after the party took control of the authority in the local elections in May. Small communities The new proposal would see one and two-bedroom units which could help people while reducing costs, the authority said the new units would "create two small communities" as a starting point for "people to get back on their feet". One of the sites, Edgar Mobbs Way near Sixfields, is planned to have 14 one-bedroom and 56 two-bedroom homes. The other site, which is off Birds Hill Walk in Weston Favell, would see 38 two-bedroom sites are owned by the council who said the units would be stacked to create two floors to make use of the space. Each location would have a community hub building, laundry facilities, cycle and refuse story and a play area, alongside a site office for council support staff and out-of-hours security as added: "Nobody ever wants to find themselves and their family homeless, and if they do, they want the reassurance that someone can help solve the immediate worry of needing a roof over their head."They will have integrated local amenities, though the units can be moved elsewhere at any time, should the need arise."People in the nearby area were invited to look at the plans by the council before they were submitted. The exhibitions were set to take place on 9 July between 15:30 BST and 20:00 at Weston Favell parish Hall in Booth Lane South, and on 16 July between the same times at 1897 Suite at Sixfields Stadium. Follow Northamptonshire news on BBC Sounds, Facebook, Instagram and X.
The National
17 minutes ago
- The National
MPs' 'hypocrisy' blasted as Suffragettes celebrated while Palestine Action banned
Female MPs posed for a photograph in Westminster Hall on Wednesday bearing sashes with the colours of the Women's Social and Political Union, a group which used militant tactics including bombing Westminster Abbey in their quest to win votes for women. The photograph featured top politicians including Home Secretary Yvette Cooper, Deputy Speaker Caroline Noakes, and Home Office Minister Angela Eagle. It came on the same day that Palestine Action was proscribed under the Terrorism Act for their campaign to put pressure on the UK Government and private companies for complicity in Israel's genocide in Gaza. Independent MP Zarah Sultana (below), currently suspended from Labour, posted the picture to social media, saying it was 'Parliament in a nutshell'. (Image: PA) She added: 'Yesterday MPs, including Yvette Cooper, celebrated the suffragette legacy of civil disobedience that won women the right to vote. Only to then vote to designate non-violent direct action group Palestine Action as terrorists. "Westminster is broken.' MPs voted to ban Palestine Action by 385 votes to 26, with the Greens, Independent Alliance MPs, and nine Labour MPs voting against. The SNP and the LibDems abstained. READ MORE: Rachel Reeves breaks silence on tears in the House of Commons It means that it will become a criminal offence to express support for or be a member of Palestine Action, carrying a prison sentence of up to 14 years in jail. Wearing clothing which expresses support of the group, such as T-shirts with the group's branding, can result in a six-month prison sentence and/or a fine of up to £5000. Others called out MPs for expressing their support for the Suffragettes, who were persecuted in their own time for their campaign to win votes for women. Green co-leader Carla Denyer (above) said: 'Today women MPs wore Suffragette sashes to celebrate Votes for Women – won by civil disobedience and celebrated in Parliament's gift shop. 'And yet now the government is asking us to vote to proscribe Palestine Action – a modern civil disobedience group – as terrorists.' Novara Media editor Aaron Bastani added: 'The Suffragettes literally blew up David Lloyd George's house, as it was under construction, in Surrey. 'The same politicians now celebrating that think you should get six months in prison for wearing a Palestine Action t-shirt.'
Telegraph
18 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Investors can't trust Labour, warns UK bond giant
Investors can no longer trust Labour after its multiple about-turns, bond giant Legal & General (L&G) has warned. Sonja Laud, the chief investment officer at L&G, said the decision to abandon key benefit reforms and reverse course on winter fuel payments had destroyed faith in the Government's economic plans. L&G is one of Britain's biggest investors, managing £1.1 trillion of assets. It is one of the biggest buyers of UK government debt. Ms Laud said: '[Markets] can't trust that what's been put forward will be put in place. You will see the adverse reaction. It was quite a big one yesterday.' It follows a dramatic day in which Rachel Reeves's tears in the House of Commons triggered a fall in the pound and a jump in borrowing costs. Investors were concerned that the Chancellor could be on the brink of leaving Downing Street, sparking fears that her fiscal rules could be abandoned. However, borrowing costs had been rising even before the Chancellor wept after Sir Keir Starmer gutted his welfare reforms on Tuesday night to avoid an embarrassing defeat on the legislation. The about-turn has blown a £5bn hole in Ms Reeves's budget. Ms Laud said: 'The changes we have seen ever since the first announcements from the Labour Party - and the intended changes they wanted to put forward - have subsequently been either watered down or changed. 'That's what the bond market does not like. The reaction in the gilt market yesterday [shows] that there clearly is an unwillingness to accept that lack of clarity.' 'Flashback to days of Liz Truss' She added that traders were still nervous after Liz Truss's mini-Budget. She said: 'There's heightened sensitivity in the UK because of what happened in 2022, where you had unfunded fiscal promises.' Ms Laud's comments come as Sir Keir and Ms Reeves scramble to repair the damage done this week. The Chancellor made a surprise appearance alongside the Prime Minister at an event on Thursday, at which she insisted she remained committed to her fiscal rules. The Prime Minister also said Ms Reeves would remain Chancellor 'for many years to come'. Borrowing costs dipped in response but remain higher than where they were just days ago. David Roberts, at Nedgroup Investments, said the bond market turmoil was a 'flashback to the days of Liz Truss'. 'Having been elected on a mandate to sort out public finances, to rein in benefit spending, it appears many in the [Labour] party have decided to return to their traditional tax and spend ideology,' he said. 'Failure to push through welfare reform whilst adhering to fiscal rules seems to leave the Government with little option other than to raise taxes.' Morgan Stanley warned that the struggling Chancellor could be as much as £30bn in the red against her fiscal rules ahead of the autumn Budget. With limited room to borrow or cut spending, 'tax hikes look most likely,' the bank said. Sir Keir's failure to grasp the nettle of welfare reform means Britain will spend £1.5bn a week on health and disability benefits for working-age adults by the end of the decade. The bill is on course to balloon to £75.7bn by 2029-30, up by one quarter from £60.4bn this year. It puts the cost of this portion of the welfare state on a par with the defence budget.
