Police Deny Wrongdoing in Death of Alabama Man, Dispute Family's Account
Attorneys for the family said a police officer kneeled on Reeder's neck and compared what happened to Reeder with what happened to George Floyd in 2020–an incident that captured the country's attention and renewed scrutiny of police practices. Reeder was white; Floyd was Black. In autopsies, the term homicide has a medical definition that is different from a criminal one. In a medical context, homicide means that a death is caused at the hands of another person but does not necessarily mean someone is criminally guilty.
Both the police department and Reeder's wife, Sandra Lee Reeder, agree that police officers were dispatched to a local highway just after 5 a.m. on Aug. 6, 2024, after multiple 911 complaints of a man behaving erratically and running into traffic. 'Reeder continued to run in the road shouting when officers approached him, ignoring multiple commands to comply,' the city statement said. Officers then shocked Reeder with a Taser, saying he posed a danger to himself and others. 'After officers handcuffed him, Mr. Reeder continued to struggle and resist for almost two minutes,' the statement read. Officers used their arms to restrain Reeder, it said, but 'no knee was placed in the back of his neck and no excessive force was used.' The statement emphasized that Reeder had a history of hypertensive heart disease, which the coroner said contributed to his death. The statement underscored the portion of the autopsy that said the blunt force injuries alone would not account for Mr. Reeder's death. It also said that the Alabama Law Enforcement Agency, the state agency tasked with investigating the incident, found no wrongdoing and that the Jefferson County District Attorney didn't see evidence sufficient for criminal charges against the officers involved.
Reeder's wife, Sandra Lee Reeder, offered an account Monday that was starkly different. She and her attorney say they saw body camera footage of the incident on July 18 after almost a year of asking the city and police department for more information on Reeder's death. 'The video showed no attempt from the Irondale police officers to talk Phillip down,' Reeder's wife said at a news conference. She said that her husband was unarmed and was suffering from a mental health crisis. Sandra Lee Reeder said an officer put a knee on Reeder's neck for approximately three minutes after he was shocked with the Taser. She said her husband can be heard saying 'I can't breathe' three times while he was restrained. The body camera footage has not been released publicly because of an Alabama law that governs release of police recordings. The law says an agency may choose to not disclose a recording to the public if it would affect an active law enforcement investigation but does not require an agency to provide a reason for denying a request. Reeder's family attorney, Roderick Van Daniel, has urged authorities to release the bodycam video to the public.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Al Arabiya
14 hours ago
- Al Arabiya
South Korea's ex-leader Yoon lay on floor of cell and refused to be questioned: Prosecutor
South Korea's ousted President Yoon Suk Yeol, who is in detention while on trial and facing various criminal probes, lay on the floor of his cell on Friday and refused to leave it for questioning, a spokesperson for a special prosecutor said. Yoon was removed from office in April by the Constitutional Court over his botched attempt last year to declare martial law and is now being investigated by a special prosecution team formed under new President Lee Jae Myung. Prosecutors investigating influence-peddling allegations connected to Yoon and his wife had tried to get him to comply with an arrest warrant and attend questioning voluntarily, a spokesperson for the special prosecution said. 'But the suspect stubbornly refused to do so, while lying on the ground, not dressed in a prison uniform,' Oh Jung-hee told a news briefing. She said investigators would try again to bring him in, even if they had to use force. Yoon was dressed only in his undershirt and underwear when prosecutors came to his cell, the Yonhap News Agency reported, citing the special prosecution. Yu Jeong-hwa, one of Yoon's lawyers, told Reuters that bringing up what he was wearing in a small space where the temperature was close to 40 degrees Celsius (104°F) was a public insult to his dignity and showed how the state was violating inmates' human rights. The former president was put back in a solitary cell at the Seoul Detention Center in July, as prosecutors investigating his short-lived declaration of martial law in December sought additional charges against him. Yoon is already on trial for insurrection, a charge which is punishable by death or life imprisonment. He also faces a string of other investigations led by special prosecutors including one into scandals surrounding his wife, former First Lady Kim Keon Hee, where the couple allegedly exerted inappropriate influence over elections. Yoon has denied any wrongdoing and his lawyers have accused prosecutors of conducting a politically-motivated witch hunt. The former president has repeatedly rejected requests by prosecutors to appear for questioning, citing health issues. His lawyers said on Thursday that he was unwell due to preexisting conditions, including a condition that meant there was a risk of him losing his eyesight. In a reference to Yoon's position as a former top prosecutor, Oh, the spokesperson for the special prosecution, said the case was being closely scrutinized by the public. 'The suspect has consistently highlighted the importance of laws, principles, fairness and common sense and through this case people are watching if the law applies equally to everyone,' Oh said. Separately, investigators requested that Yoon's wife Kim, who has also denied any wrongdoing, attend questioning on August 6. Kim's lawyers have said she would cooperate with the investigation.
Arab News
a day ago
- Arab News
Mourners honor the NYPD officer Didarul Islam, who was killed in Manhattan skyscraper attack
NEW YORK: Mourners packed a New York mosque on Thursday to honor a Bangladesh-born police officer who embraced the job of protecting his adopted city and gave his life for it when a gunman opened fire in an office building this week. Officer Didarul Islam 'did believe in the American dream, not as something handed down but as something built with your own hands,' Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch told Islam's family and friends as his fellow officers lined up rows deep outside the Bronx house of worship. Dignitaries and members of the New York's thriving Bangladeshi community also paid tribute to the fallen officer during a memorial that emphasized the importance he placed on his family, background and service to the city. A married father of two with a third child on the way, the 36-year-old was working a New York Police Department-approved private security detail, in uniform, when he and three other people were killed Monday at the Manhattan skyscraper that houses the NFL's headquarters and other corporate offices. 'To our family, he was our world. To the city, he was a proud NYPD officer who served with compassion and integrity. He lived to help others,' Islam's widow said in a statement that a relative read on her behalf at the service at the Parkchester Jame Masjid mosque. With officers stationed on surrounding rooftops for security, fire trucks used their ladders to hold a huge American flag over a nearby street. A flatbed truck carried a digital billboard showing photos of Islam and a commemorative message from his union. White House sends condolences After coming to the United States, Islam began building a career in the nation's largest police force. He described policing as 'a blanket of the community, there to provide comfort and care,' the police commissioner said. Islam served as a school safety agent before becoming a patrol officer less than four years ago, and was promoted posthumously Thursday to detective. 'He could have gone into any other occupation he wanted, but he wanted to put on that uniform, and he wanted to protect fellow New Yorkers. And he wanted to let us know that he believed in what this city and what this country stood for,' Mayor Eric Adams, a Democrat, told the gathering. 'That's the greatest symbol of what we know we are as a country.' In Washington, White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt began her daily briefing by expressing President Donald Trump's condolences to Islam's family, saying he 'made the ultimate sacrifice in defense of his fellow New Yorkers.' A 'humble, steady, and reliable' officer Like others who spoke, Imam Zakir Ahmed highlighted the officer's immigrant background and Muslim faith. But said Islam 'lived at a time when people like him are too often feared, vilified and made to feel like outsiders.' 'It's time for New York and America to give back — to see us, to hear us, to protect our dignity, the way Officer Islam protected yours,' Ahmed said. The eldest of several siblings, Islam supported his parents in Bangladesh, as well as his wife and two young sons in the Bronx, the imam said. The police commissioner said Islam worked a long day at a parade Sunday, then picked up private security hours Monday at the office building. Deputy Inspector Muhammad Ashraf, the commander of the busy Bronx precinct where Islam worked, said he was a 'humble, steady and reliable' officer. 'He knew what it meant to protect the place that gave him a new beginning, and in return, he gave everything back,' Ashraf said at Thursday's service. After the service, the streets filled with people, mostly men, kneeling in prayer. Some Muslim officers took part, as colleagues stood in formation behind them and looked on. Later, officers saluted as Islam's casket, draped in US and NYPD flags, was brought to a hearse for burial at a cemetery in Totowa, New Jersey. Another victim, real estate firm worker Julia Hyman, 27, was mourned at an emotional service Wednesday at a Manhattan synagogue. Funeral arrangements for the two others killed, security guard Aland Etienne and investment firm executive Wesley LePatner, have not been made public. Governor praises officer for saving lives Police identified the gunman as Shane Tamura, a 27-year old former high school football player who most recently worked in a Las Vegas casino's surveillance department. Authorities say he believed he had a brain disease linked to contact sports and accused the NFL of hiding the dangers of playing football. On Thursday, police said they found more than 800 rounds of ammunition in Tamura's car and had recovered 47 shell casings in the building's lobby and the office floor where Hyman was killed. Police said Tamura had a history of mental illness, but they haven't elaborated other than to say they found psychiatric medication prescribed to him at his residence in Las Vegas. Officials said he was heading for the NFL's office but took the wrong elevator and went by mistake to another floor. The gunfire seriously injured an NFL employee in the lobby. Islam 'saved lives. He was out front,' Gov. Kathy Hochul, a Democrat, said at Thursday's service. 'Others may be alive today because he was the barrier.'
Arab News
a day ago
- Arab News
Mourners honor the NYPD officer killed in the attack at the NFL headquarters building
NEW YORK: Mourners packed a New York mosque on Thursday to honor a Bangladesh-born police officer who embraced the job of protecting his adopted city and gave his life for it when a gunman opened fire in an office building this week. Officer Didarul Islam 'did believe in the American dream, not as something handed down but as something built with your own hands,' Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch told Islam's family and friends as his fellow officers lined up rows deep outside the Bronx house of worship. Dignitaries and members of the New York's thriving Bangladeshi community also paid tribute to the fallen officer during a memorial that emphasized the importance he placed on his family, background and service to the city. A married father of two with a third child on the way, the 36-year-old was working a New York Police Department-approved private security detail, in uniform, when he and three other people were killed Monday at the Manhattan skyscraper that houses the NFL's headquarters and other corporate offices. 'To our family, he was our world. To the city, he was a proud NYPD officer who served with compassion and integrity. He lived to help others,' Islam's widow said in a statement that a relative read on her behalf at the service at the Parkchester Jame Masjid mosque. With officers stationed on surrounding rooftops for security, fire trucks used their ladders to hold a huge American flag over a nearby street. A flatbed truck carried a digital billboard showing photos of Islam and a commemorative message from his union. White House sends condolences After coming to the United States, Islam began building a career in the nation's largest police force. He described policing as 'a blanket of the community, there to provide comfort and care,' the police commissioner said. Islam served as a school safety agent before becoming a patrol officer less than four years ago, and was promoted posthumously Thursday to detective. 'He could have gone into any other occupation he wanted, but he wanted to put on that uniform, and he wanted to protect fellow New Yorkers. And he wanted to let us know that he believed in what this city and what this country stood for,' Mayor Eric Adams, a Democrat, told the gathering. 'That's the greatest symbol of what we know we are as a country.' In Washington, White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt began her daily briefing by expressing President Donald Trump's condolences to Islam's family, saying he 'made the ultimate sacrifice in defense of his fellow New Yorkers.' A 'humble, steady, and reliable' officer Like others who spoke, Imam Zakir Ahmed highlighted the officer's immigrant background and Muslim faith. But said Islam 'lived at a time when people like him are too often feared, vilified and made to feel like outsiders.' 'It's time for New York and America to give back — to see us, to hear us, to protect our dignity, the way Officer Islam protected yours,' Ahmed said. The eldest of several siblings, Islam supported his parents in Bangladesh, as well as his wife and two young sons in the Bronx, the imam said. The police commissioner said Islam worked a long day at a parade Sunday, then picked up private security hours Monday at the office building. Deputy Inspector Muhammad Ashraf, the commander of the busy Bronx precinct where Islam worked, said he was a 'humble, steady and reliable' officer. 'He knew what it meant to protect the place that gave him a new beginning, and in return, he gave everything back,' Ashraf said at Thursday's service. After the service, the streets filled with people, mostly men, kneeling in prayer. Some Muslim officers took part, as colleagues stood in formation behind them and looked on. Later, officers saluted as Islam's casket, draped in US and NYPD flags, was brought to a hearse for burial at a cemetery in Totowa, New Jersey. Another victim, real estate firm worker Julia Hyman, 27, was mourned at an emotional service Wednesday at a Manhattan synagogue. Funeral arrangements for the two others killed, security guard Aland Etienne and investment firm executive Wesley LePatner, have not been made public. Governor praises officer for saving lives Police identified the gunman as Shane Tamura, a 27-year old former high school football player who most recently worked in a Las Vegas casino's surveillance department. Authorities say he believed he had a brain disease linked to contact sports and accused the NFL of hiding the dangers of playing football. On Thursday, police said they found more than 800 rounds of ammunition in Tamura's car and had recovered 47 shell casings in the building's lobby and the office floor where Hyman was killed. Police said Tamura had a history of mental illness, but they haven't elaborated other than to say they found psychiatric medication prescribed to him at his residence in Las Vegas. Officials said he was heading for the NFL's office but took the wrong elevator and went by mistake to another floor. The gunfire seriously injured an NFL employee in the lobby. Islam 'saved lives. He was out front,' Gov. Kathy Hochul, a Democrat, said at Thursday's service. 'Others may be alive today because he was the barrier.'
