Explainer: NZ Rugby's financial loss and what it means
The All Blacks after their win over Ireland, 2024.
Photo:
Billy Stickland/Photosport
Analysis
: New Zealand Rugby (NZR) has posted its financial results and instead of an appropriate all black, it's in the red. A $19.5 million loss has been announced and while it's obviously not ideal, there's a bit more to it than presuming it's been spent on magic beans and that the last one out of NZR headquarters in Wellington shouldn't forget to shut off the lights.
NZR posted a loss of $47m for 2022, then an $8.9m loss for 2023. So it's not uncharted territory but not the course they want to be heading in either.
NZR CEO Mark Robinson.
Photo:
Martin Hunter/ActionPress
The $19.5m is a lot of money but it drops significantly when the strategic commercial spend is taken out. It's estimated that accounts for around $11m, with the rest being 'non-operational losses' due to the downturn in the US dollar affecting the value of NZR's hedge instrument holdings. Because of the
early contract termination and non-payment by INEOS
, the hedges have been deemed to be ineffective.
Andy Ellis , George Bower, Elma Smit , James McOnie, NZR+ presenters in Toulouse, France.
Photo:
Lynne Cameron/ActionPress
That $11m has more or less gone on
NZR+ and content creation
, as part of a $38m investment over a four-year period. NZR+ is the direct to consumer content service, which offers access to both original content and match highlights. It has been seen as being a bit of a bust so far with a less than anticipated sign-up rate (despite being free) and subsequent pivot to distributing on YouTube and other social platforms, as well as New Zealand Rugby Commercial Limited (NZRC) boss
Craig Fenton leaving
after just over a year in the role.
That's all fair criticism but NZR basically has to get into this space if it wants to be relevant in new markets as a global sports brand - it just needs to figure out the best way to make it work. Whether detractors like it or not, major US teams, Premier League clubs and others have been running the same model for almost three decades and even local grassroots teams are producing their own content now. It's fair to say that the feeling that NZR is a part-production company is only going to grow, rather than diminish.
Serevi, left, who along with former All Blacks Ma'a Nonu were guests at the launch announcement in San Diego.
Photo:
Waisale Serevi
This is where NZR can claim a good kind of record, because income is at $285m. That's its highest ever and is reflective of last season being a full domestic schedule for the All Blacks, including a very successful 'home' test match staged in San Diego against Fiji. Positive revenue-sharing agreements with the JRFU and RFU meant decent money was made on tests against Japan and England, with the San Diego financial model set to be repeated for this year's test against Ireland at Soldier Field in Chicago.
England winger Immanuel Feyi-Waboso celebrates a try against the All Blacks at Twickenham.
Photo:
Photosport
Despite the $19.5m loss, NZR's reserves have only taken a $500,000 dent down to $174.5m. For what it's worth, it can boast the highest reserves of any major union*, with over $55m more than England.
The RFU infamously announced an
$88m loss
on last season, despite being the largest revenue generator by far (due to its ownership if the 82,000 capacity Twickenham Stadium). So this is where it gets difficult to compare unions' financial performance to one another. Another example is Rugby South Africa turning a modest profit, however in its post-Covid existence it virtually runs only the world champion Springboks, with a large percentage of them employed offshore to play their club rugby.
The closest to home comparison is Rugby Australia, which has just reported a
$39.6m loss
last year. Of that, $10m was integrating the Brumbies and Waratahs under its management and more than $5m on the voluntary administration and exit of the Melbourne Rebels - again, a series of events that would never impact NZR.
New Zealand Rugby has secured a new sponsorship deal with Toyota.
Photo:
supplied
This is where things are going quite nicely for NZR. Even though INEOS walked out, the swift resolution has seen it carry on as if nothing really happened.
NZR announced this week that
Toyota have come on board
a brand partner. That's not only well ahead of schedule - some forecasts were that an announcement on a replacement for INEOS wouldn't be till next year - but further legitimises the All Blacks as a blue chip given that Toyota is a global brand with exceptional market share and history in New Zealand. It is widely expected NZR will go back to the table when Altrad's front of jersey sponsorship deal ends in 2028 with the ability to demand an even higher amount than the $120m they signed on for in 2022.
Photo:
Andrew Cornaga/www.photosport.nz
You'd hope not, but it's not like this is some sort of death knell to the national game. Player numbers still remain high at 157,000, also rugby's broadcast deal and viewership is by far the highest of any sport in the country. There are legitimate concerns about crowd sizes for everything below test level, despite the overall Super Rugby Pacific attendance being up on last season. However, All Black test matches remain an extremely bankable drawcard. Fixtures in Dunedin and Hamilton against a supposed weakened French team have already sold out, while September's clashes against the Springboks and Wallabies at Eden Park will fill the country's largest stadium twice in a matter of weeks.
Those won't bring in anywhere near the sort of gate receipts that somewhere like Twickenham can command, so expect more American and Japanese 'home' tests regularly. The big question is around the commercial strategy and when it can start to recoup the investment that's being ploughed into it.
*This data set excludes France, whose exact financial details are very difficult to pin down. However, given that the FFR just announced it had
https://www.nzherald.co.nz/sport/rugby/rugby-world-cup/french-rugby-faces-57m-loss-from-world-cup-2023-watchdog-reports/XI25L23XVFC3HBGUPOPTV66KYI/ lost almost $60 million]
due to "major failures" in its hosting of the last World Cup, it is safe to presume that NZR would still be on top of this column anyway.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
New east stand at Taranaki's stadium reflects region's identity
WEEKEND NEWS An aerial shot of the stadium's East Stand. Photo: Supplied/Clelands Construction The iconic view of Taranaki Maunga reflected in the Pouākai Tarns and the flow of rivers from the mountain to the sea provided the inspiration for the design of the new East Stand at Stadium Taranaki (formerly Yarrow Stadium) . Ngāti Te Whiti hapu led the design narrative, providing an identity for the stand which has been rebuilt. The $80 million redevelopment of the New Plymouth stadium came about after two covered stands were declared earthquake prone. Kerehama Waru Te Pū worked on the narrative for five years, collaborating with hapū members who passed on their knowledge of the area to shape the design with a focus on how the stadium could bring the community together. New Plymouth-born Waru Te Pū, a graphic designer who works as a freelance artist and cultural monitor, said developing the concept through to the completion of the project had been a collaborative effort involving hapū members, Boon architects, contractors, stadium owners Taranaki Regional Council and its operators New Plymouth District Council. Kerehama Waru Te Pū at the stadium. Photo: Supplied/Taranaki Regional Council "We started by looking at the location and the history of the area and what it was used for. "Sketches by Frederick Carrington showed the area was a tributary swamp catchment of the Huatoki Stream and that link to water and the environment became the main focus. "This was reinforced by working with Damon Ritai at the hapū and hearing about the history of the Huatoki and the Poukaka Pa and Maratahu Pa, and a brief history of the environment. "Referencing back to that focus on water, the main design on the East Stand is of Taranaki Maunga on the building and the reflection is on the concourse, reflecting the view of the Maunga from the tarn. That's the inspiration for the design." Waru Te Pū said each point in the design represented the different maunga tipua (different peaks) with the reds in the lower section representing the Pouākai Range and other peaks. The whites represent snow, blues were water melted by the sun (the yellows), reinforcing the connection with water as it moved from the Maunga to the moana. "There are also connections to harakeke (flax) or weaving which was a highly prized thing in Taranaki and that's part of the history and environment we've focused on." The design narrative continued inside with windows and doors repeating the patterns on the outside of the buildings, while rivers on the walls of level one have been directly sketched from Carrington's original drawings of waterways in the area. "I hope that someday this design narrative can extend to other parts of the stadium," Waru Te Pū said. Ngāti Te Whiti chairman Shelton Healey it had been a privilege for Ngāti Te Whiti to help shape the design and identity of the new East Stand. "It's a reflection of our whenua, our waters and our stories. "We see this as a modern expression of our history and look forward to our narrative continuing to flow through future developments not only at the stadium, but throughout Ngāmotu New Plymouth." TRC chair Craig Williamson said Ngāti Te Whiti and Waru Te Pū had helped to give the East Stand a strong identity. "The completed East Stand is an outstanding facility for the people of Taranaki and the vital contribution Ngāti Te Whiti has made has absolutely enhanced the completed stadium. "Using the view of the Maunga reflected in the Pouākai Tarns was an inspired choice and really makes the stand unique to our region and our amazing environment. "We're extremely grateful to Ngāti Te Whiti for their continued support and we believe working together on this project has strengthened our ties with the hapū." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
5 hours ago
- RNZ News
Taranaki economy takes hit in latest quarterly report
Photo: David Hancock Taranaki's latest quarterly economic report card makes challenging reading with the region's economy contracting 3.1 percent compared to the 1.1 percent drop nation-wide. The region's employment figures have also dropped 1.8 percent and consumer spending has fallen 1.9 percent. On the positive side, there is a 31 percent increase in the region's dairy payout to $1.8b this season and a 13 percent jump in property sales and a 23 percent increase in the number of building consents issued. The Informetrics Quarterly Economic Monitor report was commissioned by the regional development agency Te Puna Umanga Venture Taranaki. Director of Strategic and Sector Partnerships, Anne Probert, said the report provided a clear, objective snapshot - presenting both the strengths and the challenges shaping the region's economic landscape. "This report is something we specifically commission for Taranaki because it's vital that our region has access to independent, timely data. It's about being informed, realistic, and proactive about the trajectory of the region." Probert said the figures reflected broader pressures felt across Aotearoa, as cautious spending patterns continue to influence business and household behaviour. Taranaki was also experiencing more localised impacts. "We're at the pointy end of the accelerated decline in gas production, and that's flowing through many of our industry sectors, particularly engineering and specialist supply chains, adding a further dimension to our economic situation, said Probert However, amid these pressures, the region's primary sector was showing significant strength. The dairy payout for Taranaki was forecast to reach $1.8b this season, a 31 percent increase from last year, thanks to rising global commodity prices and a lower exchange rate boosting export returns. "This is a much-needed boost for our rural communities, who have been contending with the impacts of drought and other challenges," Probert said. "Given the critical role that farming plays across our entire economy, from the farm gate to support services, manufacturing, logistics and retail, this upturn has flow-on benefits for the whole region." Adding further momentum to the sector, Fonterra had announced significant investments in Taranaki, including the electrification of its Whareroa plant and the development of new cool store facilities demonstrating long-term confidence in the region's agri-food future. The economic report also highlighted early signs of a turnaround in the housing market. House sales were up 13.2 percent over the year in the region, and the number of residential building consents has jumped nearly 23 percent. Probert said while house prices had remained steady, the increase in sales and listings points to renewed interest, driven in part by the region's lifestyle appeal and comparative affordability. Venture Taranaki chief executive Kelvin Wright said it was clear the region faced challengers, but that there were also positive signs of momentum. "The report highlights the importance of having the regional economic development strategy in place, Tapuae Roa, to ensure we're making the most of our region's strengths and capitalising on emerging opportunities." Taranaki's Economic Snapshot over the year to March 2025: Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
7 hours ago
- RNZ News
Facial recognition technology supported by big name retailers
Large retailers support having facial recognition technology in their stores. Photo: RNZ The heads of a dozen of the largest retailers and telcos in the country have come out in strong support of using facial recognition technology in their stores. This follows the Privacy Commissioner giving what he called a "cautious tick" to a trial in New World and Pak'nSave supermarkets. "The undersigned major New Zealand retailers strongly support the use of fair and accurate technology to protect our workers and customers," said a statement at industry group Retail NZ's website . Without saying when they might start using it, they stated they would work now to develop "best practice". "We recognise that technology must be used in a fair and accurate way." The letter was signed by the heads of Briscoes and Rebel Sport, Bunnings and Mitre 10, Michael Hill Jewellers, Farmers and The Warehouse, the two Foodstuffs supermarket groups in the two islands as well as rival Woolworths, and telcos One NZ and Spark. Privacy Commissioner Michael Webster had said his report was "not a green light for more general use of FRT" (facial recognition technology). "However, we recognise the importance of the issue for many businesses." The trial let other businesses ask themselves the right questions about whether to use FRT and in what ways to protect privacy, Webster said. There were significant caveats. "While the percentage of misidentifications may be small, rolling FRT out at scale would mean that large numbers of people would be misidentified." Foodstuffs North Island's own research suggested 900 shoppers a year could be misidentified in its stores alone. The commissioner suggested raising the algorithm accuracy from 90 percent to 92.5 percent, among other measures. A Māori Reference Panel set up at the end of 2024 told the commissioner it opposed FRT's use in supermarkets. This was "given the vital role of supermarkets in providing access to food, the current supermarket duopoly which means there are limited alternative options for people who are barred from entry, and the concern that the whole population of Aotearoa will be subjected to surveillance in supermarkets in order to reduce instances of harmful behaviour by a small minority of customers". Retail NZ's Carolyn Young said for someone to be on the watchlist, they had to have offended and/or been abusive and/or aggressive in store and trespassed. If someone was trespassed from a retail environment, they currently are not able to return to that store for two years. "What we know in retail is that recidivous offending is very high - between 35-50 percent (depending on the sector) of offending is done by recidivous offending. "So we know that even though someone has been trespassed, they continue to come back into store," Young said. "FRT will enable stores to identify these individuals as they enter store to ensure that the store is safe for staff and customers. "FRT does not enable customers to be monitored. It takes an image of people as they enter the store and if they are not on the watchlist, then they are deleted immediately. "FRT does not provide ongoing monitoring throughout the store, just one photo/image as someone enters." Facial recognition technology does not monitor shoppers. Photo: 123RF The big-store signatories said they acknowledged the commissioner's oversight, and Foodstuffs for leading the way with its trial. "The use of FRT in the right settings with the right controls will provide positive benefits and outcomes for customers, retailers and workers, while not impeding on the privacy of New Zealanders. "The vast majority of customers will be able to go about their business as usual and will in fact be safer in those stores where FRT is used," the Retail NZ statement said. Webster also stressed it would be "highly desirable" to do training of the FRT algorithms on New Zealanders' faces, by consent, to cut down the risk of bias and inaccuracy. Very limited such testing by the Department of Internal Affairs last year found the imported tech it is currently using was accurate. Many multiple FRT systems are on offer that return different rates of accuracy in independent tests by the US-based benchmarking agency. In Australia, Bunnings had been in a legal fight with a watchdog that asserted its facial recognition there impinged on people's privacy. Reports of the tech being used at supermarkets in an isolated way in New Zealand date back to at least 2018. Researchers foresaw the tech spread in 2021. "Private sector use of FRT-enabled surveillance is likely to increase, particularly in the retail sector, especially as these services come 'baked-in' to vendor offerings," their landmark report for police said. That contributed to police deciding not to use FRT on live camera feeds , a constraint they say they have stuck with till now. In Britain, the tech's spread, for example in airports and shopping centres, prompted the government's biometrics ethics group in 2021 to recommend oversight by an independent ethics group including of collaborative FRT use between retail and police. Young said Britain was a long way ahead of New Zealand in terms of the implementation of FRT and had used CCTV actively in the community for many years. Here, the Office of the Privacy Commissioner (OPC) would carry out the role of oversight, she said. "It may be in the future that there is a need for another regulatory body to do this work, but while we are in our infancy of implementation and the OPC has been very clear about how it is to be rolled out, we believe that the parameters for implementation are very clear." The Privacy Commissioner's report does not contain a similar recommendation. It mentioned Foodstuffs auditing how it compiled watchlists of people for the camera-software to look out for, but not that this should be independent. The signed Retail NZ statement did not mention independent overview. Australia's privacy regulator signalled in March it would be proactive in regulating biometric information . Biometrics include face, fingerprint and iris - unique identifiers of who a person is. The Office of the Australian Information Commissioner - it had taken on Bunnings, which was appealing - put this in a wider frame: "Our research told us that more than a quarter of Australians feel that facial recognition technology is one of the biggest privacy risks faced today, and only three percent of Australians think it's fair and reasonable for retailers to require their biometric information when accessing their services". "Thinking about what the law permits, but also what the community would expect" was critical. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
