
Westminster urged to increase ScotGov borrowing limits by MPs
A committee of MPs has told the UK Government to look at increasing the Scottish Government 's capital borrowing limits.
But in a report from the Scottish Affairs Committee at Westminster on the fiscal arrangements north of the border, MPs pushed for the limits to be increased.
The report said: 'At present, the Scottish Government's limited borrowing powers constrain its ability to manage fiscal shocks, as it is only able to borrow for resource purposes to cover forecast errors.
'Capital borrowing limits are currently linked to, and grow in line with, inflation, which may not necessarily be the highest metric of growth.'
It added: 'We agree with the Secretary of State that borrowing limits should be linked to the measure which offers the Scottish Government the highest level of flexibility but, crucially, we note that which metric delivers this remains undetermined.
'The UK Government should therefore publish a transparent analysis of what borrowing limits would look like based on the different metrics advised in the evidence for this inquiry.
'At the next fiscal framework review, we encourage the UK Government to consider reforming the Scottish Government's capital borrowing powers, by automatically coupling borrowing to the metric which offers the highest limit.'
Read More
The report comes at the end of an inquiry by the committee which sought to gauge the effectiveness of the Barnett Formula – the measure which dictates the level of funding the UK Government sends to Scotland every year.
The MPs found the measure was 'fit for purpose', although it is 'imperfect'.
The committee also rejected calls for the formula to shift and provide funding to Scotland based on need.
Scotland, the report said, already receives more funding per head than any other country in the UK and a change in the framework could see funding cut.
In written evidence to the committee, Scottish Finance Secretary Shona Robison reiterated the Scottish Government's support for full fiscal autonomy – an arrangement which would see powers over tax and spending devolved.
But the committee dismissed such a move as not being a 'realistic prospect'.
'Fundamental questions remain about how full fiscal autonomy would work in practice, and whether it would be operable within the constraints of the UK's current devolution settlement,' the report said.
'Practicality aside, we do not believe that a compelling case has been made that such a change would automatically result in Scotland receiving a higher level of funding.'
Ms Robison declined an invitation to appear before the committee, leading the MPs to say 'do not see how we can consider this a serious proposition, and we remain to be convinced that this proposal is desirable in principle, let alone workable in practice'.
Responding to the report, Ms Robison said: 'This report rightly recognises that Scotland's finances remain largely dictated by the UK Government's spending decisions, irrespective of the impact on Scottish public services.
'That has meant Scotland has been left with a shortfall of £400 million to pay for the Chancellor's national insurance increase, and saw Scotland short-changed by more than a billion pounds over the next three years at the recent spending review.
'The decisions we have taken to ask higher earners to pay a little bit more – while most income tax payers pay less than in the rest of the UK – mean that we can support vital public services and provide free tuition, prescriptions and the Scottish child payment to help tackle child poverty.'
Scottish Secretary Ian Murray said: 'The spending review provided the Scottish Government with an extra £9.1 billion, giving them a record settlement.
'People will expect that to deliver better outcomes for Scots – lower NHS waiting lists and better attainment in our schools.
'Spending per head in Scotland is around 20% higher than the rest of the UK thanks to the Barnett formula. This report confirms that it appears to be the position of the Scottish Government to scrap that formula that delivers higher funding – they should explain why they want less money for public services in Scotland.
'Their plans for full fiscal autonomy would mean a £12 billion cut in public spending for Scotland.'
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

Scotsman
a minute ago
- Scotsman
New homes released at East Lothian's Longniddry Village
Five-star Scottish housebuilder Cruden Homes has released more homes for sale at its multi-award-winning Longniddry Village development in East Lothian with prices from £290,000. From gorgeous Georgian town houses to jaw-dropping penthouses, converted campervans to bargain boltholes. Take a peek at the finest homes across the UK. Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... The latest release is across five plots, namely three two-bedroom apartments, available to move in from November and two four-bedroom properties which will be complete by early 2026. To further entice buyers, Cruden is offering a limited-time package of huge savings on the apartments with £5,000 cashback and a further £5,000 options voucher to make a new house at Longniddry a dream home. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Longniddry Village takes inspiration from the characterful architecture and appeal of quaint East Lothian villages and towns. Its local vernacular and carefully considered landscape design seamlessly extends into the existing vibrant village community. Longniddry Village development in East Lothian The traditionally inspired architecture includes period-style features such as sash windows, chimneys and high ceilings. Meanwhile, the interior accommodation is spacious and airy, complete with high-quality fixtures and fittings that include designer German kitchens with integrated Siemens appliances, built-in wardrobes, stylish bathrooms and fibre broadband. When complete, the development will include several features for residents to enjoy, including a play park, sports pitch, restored mill pond and wildflower meadow. New owners will also benefit from the neighbouring steadings restoration, which will be a hub for several amenities including an independent coffee outlet, a luxury convenience store and salon. Hazel Davies, Sales and Marketing Director of Cruden Homes, said:'It's great to extend the new home options available to discerning buyers at our Longniddry Village development, whether they're taking their first step on the property ladder or looking for more space to grow. The added incentives for our range of apartments make now the perfect time to move. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad


Scotsman
a minute ago
- Scotsman
Burness Paull: ‘Refined' three-year strategy paying off as law firm's turnover tops £93 million
'We are already seeing the benefits of the new strategy through a strong start to the current financial year' – Peter Lawson, chairman Sign up to our Scotsman Money newsletter, covering all you need to know to help manage your money. Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Scottish legal heavyweight Burness Paull said it was already seeing the benefits of a 'refined' three-year growth strategy as it reported annual turnover of more than £93 million. Chairman Peter Lawson hailed a 'solid year of trading' at the firm, which saw growth across all key practice areas. The financial year to the end of March 2025 also witnessed a change of leadership at the firm that saw Mark Ellis assume the role of managing partner midway through the period. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Turnover for the year amounted to £93.5m and overall profit was £35.9m as the firm made investments in support of a new three-year strategic growth plan and 'to ensure clients receive the highest quality advice amid ongoing economic uncertainty'. Those figures compare with turnover of £60.1m and profit of £24.3m for the prior, shortened eight-month period after the firm decided to change its year-end following tax reporting reforms and to 'align with market norms'. Peter Lawson is the chairman of law firm Burness Paull which has 700 people, including 95 partners, serving clients from its offices in Aberdeen, Edinburgh and Glasgow. Burness Paull has 700 people, including 95 partners, serving clients from its operations in Aberdeen, Edinburgh and Glasgow. Lawson said: 'A solid year of trading saw growth across all key practice areas, with our corporate M&A, energy, banking and funds, disputes, employment, cyber, and restructuring and insolvency teams performing particularly well. 'When Mark took over as managing partner, we initiated the most rigorous business planning exercise we have ever undertaken as a firm. The result was a refined three-year strategy beginning the 2025/26 financial year that, combined with the investments we have made in our people and infrastructure, offers us a clear roadmap for sustainable, profitable growth over the long term. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'We are already seeing the benefits of the new strategy through a strong start to the current financial year, which has seen us win instructions from across Scotland, the UK and internationally.' He added: 'It remains a dynamic business environment characterised by increased levels of investor confidence and transactional activity due to falling interest rates, paired with caution around cost pressures and volatility in global trade policy.' Notable client mandates for the year included advising i3 Energy on its takeover by Gran Tierra Energy in a deal valued at £174m, Springfield Properties in relation to its partnership with Barratt to deliver a new village settlement of 3,000 homes at Durieshill on the outskirts of Stirling, and the Scottish Football Association on the sale of UK and international broadcasting rights. Earlier this month, larger peer Brodies said it had racked up its 15th consecutive year of growth, triggering a 5 per cent bonus for hundreds of staff. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The firm's latest results revealed that total revenues rose to £126.7m for the year ending April 30, 2025 - an increase of some 11 per cent from £114.3m the previous year. Operating profit also grew, reaching in excess of £50m, up from £49.2m, with profit per equity partner recorded at £885,296.

The National
25 minutes ago
- The National
Labour minister grilled over Gaza in tense BBC interview
Peter Kyle, the Secretary of State for Science, Innovation and Technology, was quizzed on the mid-recess cabinet meeting that has been called to discuss Gaza and Palestinian statehood on Tuesday's edition of Good Morning Scotland. Kyle said Keir Starmer had been 'intensely moved and disturbed' by images coming from the enclave but defended the continued sale of arms to Israel. READ MORE: LIVE: Donald Trump meets John Swinney on final day of Scotland trip The presenter challenged the timing of the UK Government's reaction, asking why it had taken Starmer so long to be moved given how long the Palestinian genocide has been going on for. Kyle pushed back firmly, saying Starmer has been 'deeply, deeply moved and disturbed by what he has seen,' insisting the Prime Minister had already taken 'incredible action' by working with international partners by recognising the International Criminal Court and sanctioning figures, including members of Benjamin Netanyahu's government and individuals in the West Bank. However, the presenter referenced earlier comments from the SNP's Stephen Gethins, who pointed out the UK Government continues to supply arms to Israel – including parts of F-35 fighter jets. Kyle squirmed as he responded, insisting arms sales were 'under constant review' and claiming that 'British law is applied equally to all areas and all territories'. READ MORE: John Swinney to call for 'immediate' constitutional convention on independence The presenter suggested Labour's pledge to recognise Palestinian statehood – which Starmer continues to drag his heels on despite growing pressure from his own MPs – was nothing more than an 'empty gesture'. Kyle retorted: 'I'm saying nothing of the sort … what we are trying to do is deliver a statehood that has meaning.' Asked repeatedly when Labour would fulfil the commitment, Kyle refused to provide a timeframe, saying: 'What you're asking me to do is to release the contents of a meeting that hasn't happened yet.'