logo
Edinburgh man released from Israeli prison after six months

Edinburgh man released from Israeli prison after six months

The National04-05-2025
Mohammad el Sharif, who works for Edinburgh Firefly International, was among detainees from the Gaza Strip freed last week and has been ­reunited with his wife, Alaa, and their three little boys.
Firefly International director Jane Salmonson said that while it was a 'huge relief' he was safe, he had ­appeared to have aged 'years' during his detention.
El Sharif was the director of a child mental health clinic in Gaza which was bombed after the region's ­invasion by Israel in response to the Hamas attack on October 7, 2023.
READ MORE: John Swinney urged to put 'country before party' and join Independence Summit
Despite being displaced several times, he had managed to keep ­contact with Firefly staff until he was picked up by the Israel Defence Force (IDF) on November 27 last year while trying to move his young family to a 'safer' part of the stricken region.
Along with other residents, they were walking westwards from Gaza City when soldiers stopped them at a checkpoint, separated the women and children on one side of the road, put the men on the other, then took all the men away.
Salmonson said the news he had been released was 'wonderful'.
'Mohammad appears from his ­photo to have aged years during ­almost six months of detention, but we at Firefly are all so pleased and ­relieved that he is free – that is all that matters just now,' she said.
'Team Firefly International are ­enjoying a moment of huge relief, feeling better than we have felt since Mohammad's arrest and detention without charge, last November. Not knowing if someone is alive or dead has been very hard for us in Scotland and will have been far worse for his family in Gaza.
'Please continue to keep us in your sights, as the carnage continues in Gaza, now compounded by ­starvation.'
In an Associated Press video of the release, el Sharif said his freedom was a 'new date of birth' for him because he had found his family safe and alive.
'While I was in captivity I thought I would not find any of my family members and relatives,' he said.
However he added that his 'great joy' was incomplete because of the detainees still being held in Israeli prisons.
'The captives gave us a message that everyone must work to release them peacefully and they all want to live in security, safety and peace,' he said.
Salmonson added: 'His message of peace is a very strong one, especially bearing in mind what he has suffered in almost six months of detention kept incommunicado from his family.'
Along with the release of el ­Sharif, the Palestine Red Crescent ­Society (PRCS) confirmed the release of ­paramedic Asaad al-Nasasra, who was detained on March 23 this year while performing humanitarian ­duties during the Israeli massacre of medical teams in the Tel Sultan area of Rafah. The massacre resulted in the deaths of eight members of PRCS ambulance staff.
The number of people detained from Gaza acknowledged by the ­Israeli prison system now stands at 1747, not including those held in ­military camps.
A recent report issued by the ­Palestinian Commission of ­Detainees and Ex-Detainees Affairs and the ­Palestinian Prisoner's Society (PPS) revealed severe conditions endured by Palestinian detainees in Israeli jails.
The report noted that in the 19 months since the ongoing genocide, the conditions of detention have not improved and have in fact worsened in many cases.
At one point el Sharif was being held in the notorious Sde Teiman prison which has been condemned internationally for alleged torture and gang rape of detainees, including children and health workers.
READ MORE: 'Football ban makes me feel sick': Transgender player hits out at SFA rules change
Prisoner testimonies of ­widespread human rights violations have been corroborated by Israeli whistleblowers and an investigation by CNN. Leaked CCTV footage has shown one gang rape of a Palestinian by Israeli soldiers.
Gazans who have been detained since the 2023 Hamas-led attack on Israel have been classed as ­'unlawful combatants' and kept as suspects even if there is no evidence of any ­involvement with Hamas.
Some have died and others have had limbs amputated as a result of ­injuries sustained from being ­shackled, according to reports.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Trump administration sanctions ICC officials in new ‘flagrant attack'
Trump administration sanctions ICC officials in new ‘flagrant attack'

The National

time2 hours ago

  • The National

Trump administration sanctions ICC officials in new ‘flagrant attack'

The sanctions were immediately denounced by the ICC as a 'flagrant attack against the independence of an impartial judicial institution' and 'an affront against the Court's states parties, the rules-based international order and, above all, millions of innocent victims across the world'. The United Nations also gave its full support. READ MORE: Scottish police station evacuated after 'possible bomb' handed in by member of public 'We firmly believe that the ICC is a key pillar of international criminal justice, and we respect their work,' UN spokesperson, Stéphane Dujarric, said. 'The decision imposes severe impediments on the functioning of the office of the prosecutor in respect for all the situations that are currently before the court.' In November, the Hague-based court issued arrest warrants for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and former defence secretary Yoav Gallant for alleged war crimes and crimes against humanity. The sanctions on four ICC officials, including two judges and two prosecutors, comes after the US has already imposed penalties on the ICC's former chief prosecutor, Karim Khan, who stepped aside in May pending an investigation into allegations of sexual misconduct – as well as four other judges. The new penalties target ICC judges Kimberly Prost of Canada and Nicolas Guillou of France and prosecutors Nazhat Shameem Khan of Fiji and Mame Mandiaye Niang of Senegal. 'These individuals are foreign persons who directly engaged in efforts by the international criminal court to investigate, arrest, detain or prosecute nationals of the United States or Israel, without the consent of either nation,' US secretary of state, Marco Rubio said. He added that the administration would continue 'to take whatever actions we deem necessary to protect our troops, our sovereignty and our allies from the ICC's illegitimate and baseless actions'.

Israel risks rewarding Hamas's kidnapping
Israel risks rewarding Hamas's kidnapping

Spectator

time5 hours ago

  • Spectator

Israel risks rewarding Hamas's kidnapping

What weapon is stronger than F-16s, drones, targeted strikes, disciplined and war-hardened ground troops, and even nuclear weapons? Hostages. Despite its formidable armed forces and weapons capabilities, in the long and bitter struggle between Israel and its enemies, no tool of war has proven more effective in bending the will of the Jewish state than the abduction of its own citizens. Missiles can be intercepted, tanks can be destroyed, but a single captive Israeli can paralyse decision-making at the highest levels of government, as we are seeing today. From the earliest wars, prisoner exchanges followed the conventions of armed conflict. After 1948 and again in 1967, soldiers were exchanged for soldiers in relatively balanced numbers. But over time, the symmetry vanished. In 1983, Israel released some 4,700 Palestinian and Lebanese prisoners for just six Israeli soldiers. The Jibril Agreement of 1985 deepened the trend: 1,150 prisoners, including many convicted of bloody attacks, were freed in exchange for three Israelis. Each successive deal confirmed to armed groups that hostages could yield not parity but jackpots. By the time of Gilad Shalit's release in 2011, the ratio had become grotesque: 1,027 Palestinian prisoners for one Israeli soldier. For Hamas, the lesson was unmistakeable: kidnapping was more valuable than missiles, more effective than rockets, more devastating to Israel's strategic posture than any other weapon in its arsenal. That lesson holds today. The current ceasefire proposal, dressed up in humanitarian language, risks institutionalising hostage-taking as the ultimate deterrent against Israel. If the Israeli military withdraws to the Gaza perimeter – as proposed – and allows a massive influx of aid that Hamas will seize and weaponise, then infiltration attempts and kidnappings will increase. In fact, it has already started. Today, in Khan Yunis, 15 terrorists stormed an outpost of the Israeli army's Kfir Brigade with gunfire and anti-tank missiles, even managing to breach the fortified position. Three soldiers were wounded, one of them severely. The attackers were eliminated by ground troops and IAF strikes, but the incident is a chilling preview of what will follow should Hamas be given breathing space to regroup. If they can kidnap soldiers right now, Hamas' hand will be immeasurably strengthened if Israel retreats. As I have written many times over the years, if a single captive can yield the release of thousands, then why should Hamas or other Islamic state and non-state actors not pursue this tactic relentlessly? The price of capitulation is not an end to the ongoing hostage tragedy, but its perpetuation long into the future. Accepting the ceasefire under these conditions simply affirms the enemy's tried and tested techniques which they have honed to perfection over decades. They use brutality to seize hostages, then torture and starve them, drawing an inevitably severe military response, which in turn is followed by the predictable international outrage as they drip feed the media curated images of suffering. Add to this the unavoidable internal Israeli chaos which comes as emotions are inflamed and passions are ignited. Thousands of powerless civilians pour onto the streets to protest, effectively lending their manpower to Hamas despite their utter hatred of the terrorists. In turn this bolsters the media and international pressure on Israel, and soon enough the entire nation itself is held hostage. Live to fight another day and simply repeat as needed. Why would Hamas change a winning formula? The ethical cost of making a deal now is grave. To send soldiers to conquer ground at enormous sacrifice, once, twice, three and even four times, only to abandon it under international pressure, is to treat fighters as expendable. But just as Israel treats every hostage life as irreplaceable, it has an unusually reverent attitude to every soldiers of its citizens army, too. And Israel's army and society are exhausted after nearly two years of war. There comes a point where the reservoir of manpower is too depleted to sustain another round. Iran's leaders are surely watching. Why spend billions on rebuilding clandestine centrifuges when the abduction of a handful of Israelis could provide a shield stronger than concrete and steel? A regime that learns this lesson will act on it, and Israel will face not only Hamas's blackmail but also the Islamic republic of Iran's. The tragedy of hostage warfare is that it pierces Israel's moral core: the sacred duty to bring its people home. Yet that duty cannot be honoured by surrendering to a logic that only guarantees more captives, deaths and wars. Hamas has learnt this lesson well. Its Pavlovian reflex to every hostage crisis is to kidnap again, knowing that the more it takes, the more it will be rewarded by the world and even by Israel itself. Israel, by contrast, has not broken that cycle. The lives of today's hostages are indeed immeasurably precious, but who can say they are worth more than the lives of those who will be seized tomorrow if this sick transactional relationship continues? It can only end by defeating those who have turned human beings into bargaining chips. Anything less may feel compassionate, but end up a perilous and risky act of capitulation.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store