Verdict is in on MLB's ABS challenge system: 52% overturned in spring training
Verdict is in on MLB's ABS challenge system: 52% overturned in spring training
Show Caption
Hide Caption
MLB players and managers have mixed feelings around robot umpires in Spring Training
Bob Nightengale and Gabe Lacques share feedback from players and managers regarding robot umpires in this year's Spring Training.
Sports Seriously
In the spring training battle of pitchers, catchers and batters vs. borderline strike calls from umpires, the players prevailed – but just barely.
Major League Baseball's tryout of a challenge system utilizing automatic ball-strike technology resulted in 52.2% of calls getting overturned, according to data furnished by the league.
The Hawk-Eye technology that fuels the ABS zone was available in 13 ballparks and for 288 Cactus and Grapefruit league games played this spring, resulting in an average of 4.1 challenges per game. The challenge system was largely lauded by players, managers and fans, perhaps most notably because the impact on game play was minimal.
The feedback was reflected in the data: Delays caused by challenges averaged 13.8 seconds, the time it takes for a batter, pitcher or catcher to indicate the challenge, the home plate umpire to signal to the press box that a review was requested, and then for the ABS verdict to be displayed both on a stadium video board and for viewers at home.
Consequently, time of game increased slightly, from 2 hours, 35 minutes in 2023 and 2024 to 2:38 this spring; however, an increase in runs scored and on base percentage (from .331 in '24 to .340 this year) makes that increase even more statistically insignificant.
Teams were granted two challenges a game and retained a challenge if it was successful. The grievances were virtually even among hitters (2.1 challenges per game) and pitchers and catchers (2.0).
Yet it's catchers who were most successful. Batters were correct on 50% of challenges and the defense on 54.4%. Within that, reviews initiated by catchers were overturned 56% of the time compared to 41% for pitchers, perhaps attributable to the catcher's best seat in the house.
And overall, the numbers closely mirrored a full season – or 740 games – worth of data at Class AAA in 2024. The minor leaguers challenged a few less calls per game (3.9 to 4.1) and were a little less successful (50.6% to 52.2%) than big leaguers this spring.
The challenge system will not be used in major league games this season, but there is a strong chance it will be implemented for the 2026 season.
The USA TODAY app gets you to the heart of the news — fast. Download for award-winning coverage, crosswords, audio storytelling, the eNewspaper and more.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
San Francisco Chronicle
12 minutes ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
Brothers bring boxing back to Fenway after 70 years and hope to revitalize the sport in Boston
For the first time in nearly 70 years, boxing is returning to Boston's famed Fenway Park. The 11-fight card is the culmination of years of effort by twin brothers and longtime public schoolteachers who grew up in Watertown and want to revitalize boxing in the city that was home to some of the greatest athletes in the sport's history. It's also symbolic of a shift back to the roots of the oldest ballpark in Major League Baseball, to when it wasn't just used for Red Sox games but for other sports and political events. 'Most people's experience there is solely related to baseball,' said Richard Johnson, Fenway expert and curator at The Sports Museum in Boston. 'But the fact is that this year, you can see an event that'll be very similar to what your grandparents saw.' Promoters Mark and Matt Nolan want 'Fight Night at Fenway,' scheduled for Saturday, to be both a time capsule and time machine, taking spectators back to boxing's glory days and what the sport can be for the city in the future. The Nolans got their license to organize fights last year with the goal of bringing boxing back to Boston. After Fenway, 'That's mission accomplished,' Matt Nolan said. 'It's not just like our dream, it's everybody's dream — every boxer on planet Earth,' he said. 'Just the idea that some kid can fight his way to Fenway Park. It's like hitting the lottery. You can't you can't beat it. There's nothing comparable.' A rich history Boston has played a long and impressive role in American boxing history and the development of the sport itself, said Johnson, author of 'Field of Our Fathers, An Illustrated History of Fenway Park.' The city was home to 'Boston's Strong Boy,' John L. Sullivan, born in 1858 to Irish immigrant parents and widely considered America's first sports superstar. The first heavyweight champion of the world, he was as famous as Muhammad Ali was in his time. Sam Langford, a Black Canadian-born boxer, moved to Boston as a teenager but was blocked from competing in the world championships by racist policies and is considered one of the greatest non-champions in boxing. Other boxing stars with Boston connections include Marvin Hagler and Rocky Marciano of nearby Brockton. 'The Boston Bomber' Tony DeMarco, whose statue raises his fists at passersby in Boston's North End, was the last fighter to win in the ring at Fenway in 1956. For a time after it was built, Fenway Park was the only outdoor venue with a significant seating capacity in Boston, making it a destination for all kinds of events, including boxing starting in 1920. After new owners took over in 2002, the park became a venue for concerts and sporting events like hockey, snowboarding, Irish football and curling. 'Back in the day, it was sort of the Swiss Army knife of sports facilities in Boston. And it's returned to that — a little bit of everything. So, returning boxing to the park is just a nod to the past,' Johnson said. Other venues can feel 'more corporate and sterile,' but Fenway is living history, said Johnson, who calls it the 'largest open-air museum in New England.' A different pitch Mark Nolan said it's not for lack of trying that no one has hosted a boxing fight at Fenway in almost 70 years. But many promoters couldn't make a pitch that landed with ballpark management. The Nolans, who teach full time and own a boxing gym in Waltham where people can train regardless of their ability to pay, were different. After success hosting events at other venues, Mark Nolan said Fenway Sports Group connected to their 'everyman' appeal and decided to give them a shot. The brothers fell in love with boxing while accompanying their father, a boat captain, to the gym as kids. When they expanded from coaching amateur boxers to professionals five years ago, they were dismayed by what they found: shows full of uneven fights set up to make the promoters as much money as possible, with established amateurs fighting people who 'have no right putting gloves on in any capacity whatsoever' in venues like high school gymnasiums. Fighters weren't being paid fairly and contracts weren't transparent. They came up with a simple business plan: pick good venues, pay fighters well and only host matches in Boston proper. They said a lot of promoters sell fighters, but they're focused on selling fights fans want to see. 'They're making sure that every fight is well-matched,' said Thomas 'The Kid' O'Toole, a fighter from rural Galway, Ireland, who has lived in Boston for the past two years, 'Nobody wants to see someone go in and just knock their opponent out right away and beat them up for four, six, eight rounds. They want to see a competitive fight.' O'Toole went professional in 2021 and is undefeated with 13 fights. He said his fight against St. Louis-born Vaughn 'Da Animal' Alexander at Fenway will be 'the biggest test of his career.' Massachusetts-born Lexi 'Lil Savage' Bolduc will compete in her fourth professional fight. She faces Sarah Couillard in a rematch after coming out on the losing end of a majority draw at the Royale. 'Fighting at Fenway, I think adds a little bit of pressure because I'm local, I grew up in Mass and idolized a lot of players as I was growing up. ... But at the same time, I'm trying to use it just as a huge opportunity and really soak in the moment,' she said. 'Pressure makes diamonds. 'To be able to kind of stand on that same ground of some of the most accomplished athletes, it's really remarkable,' she said.
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Letters to Sports: Dodgers must figure out their injured pitcher problem
Injured Dodgers pitcher Tyler Glasnow throws in the outfield at Dodger Stadium before a game against the New York Mets on June 4. (Gina Ferazzi/Los Angeles Times) The Dodgers now have 15 pitchers on the injured list. This team, with all of its talent, is going nowhere without frontline pitching. Andrew Friedman realized this when he emptied Fort Knox during the offseason. But, like previous seasons, they are dropping like flies, with shoulder and forearm issues. Other MLB teams don't seem to have these issues, at least not to this degree. Advertisement At what point do we begin to look at the training staff, starting with pitching coach Mark Prior? What is it that he's asking (and teaching) these guys to do with their arms, to get that extra 'something' out of them? Too often that extra something becomes nothing at all. Rodger Howard Westlake Village The underperforming, injury-plagued — and very well-paid — Dodger pitching staff illustrates the true financial advantage of big-market teams willing and able to spend. Yes, the Dodgers can afford to sign and pay frontline players, but, just as important, they can also afford to set aside or simply eat the contracts of those expensive players if they become hurt or ineffective, and replace them with additional highly (over)paid players. It's almost a lock that, if their staff isn't healthier and more reliable come August, the Dodgers will probably trade for pitching help and take on even more salary. Small-market teams such as the Reds, Guardians and Pirates can't sign many top-tier players in the first place, let alone replace them if they don't pan out. John Merryman Redondo Beach Instead of spending hundreds of millions on pitchers to sit on the injury list for the majority of every year, I recommend the Dodgers instead allocate those funds to put nine All-Star offensive players in the lineup. Then just do what the team always winds up doing anyway — rely on inexpensive, lower-tier and journeyman pitchers for the season. Advertisement Jerry Leibowitz Culver City Time to say goodbye It's about time that the Dodgers separate from Clayton Kershaw. Yes he has been with them forever, and was very good. But that was then, not now. The Dodgers separated from Chris Taylor, and Austin Barnes, long-term team members, now it's time to do the same with Kershaw. Deborah R. Ishida Beverly Hills Dear Clayton, It's time to say goodbye. Injuries have taken their toll. Don't ruin what has been a first-ballot Hall of Fame career by performing at a level that is a shadow of yourself. It's been a great run, but you are hurting the team. Announce that you're leaving so the fans can give you the send-off you deserve. Please don't hang around and make us watch you continue to pad the worst stats of your career. Advertisement Geno Apicella Placentia At 37 and having pitched more than 3,000 innings, there's no doubt Clayton Kershaw still has the smarts if not the scintillating fastball of days gone by to help the Dodgers race toward another World Series appearance. Manager Dave Roberts says he trusts him to keep taking the mound, and so do I. Like the headline reads, 'History says don't count out Kershaw.' Marty Zweben Palos Verdes Estates Max retention While we all lament and understand the need to move on from fan favorites, thank goodness the Dodgers resisted the urge to go the youth route with Max Muncy. And it's not his glasses. Have you seen his swing of late? Probably not — it's too fast for the naked eye. Advertisement Robert Gary Westlake Village Too much Ohtani praise? Look, I get it. Ohtani is great. Amazing. Remarkable. Fill-in-the-blank with any superlative. But it seems like every week Dylan Hernández writes the exact same column, praising Ohtani for his greatness and saying how important he is to the Dodgers. And it was the same when he was on the Angels. Everyone knows that. I'd like to see Dylan mix it up with his critique and commentary a bit more. Greg Wagner Huntington Beach It looks like "Plaschkeitis" has spread to another LAT sportswriter. In his report of the Dodgers' 18-2 win over the Yankees, Jack Harris writes, "It was a statement, a reminder and a warning all wrapped into one." It was also just one game, and 24 hours later, the Dodgers lost to the Yankees. Advertisement Try to hold it down fellas; you're giving everybody whiplash. Ralph Martinez Arcadia Don't run from rivalry An easier path to the playoffs is no reason to cancel the most storied intersectional rivalry in sports. If USC cannot defeat Notre Dame, USC does not belong in the playoffs. Recruit and coach a team to beat them. Don't look for a way to claim success by running away from them. Jay McConnell Los Angeles USC football coach Lincoln Riley makes excuses why his team can't or won't play Notre Dame. I think the truth is he's scared to play Notre Dame because he feels overmatched. USC lost to Notre Dame in 2023 and 2024, and Riley can't handle another loss. Advertisement Neil Snow Manhattan Beach Verdict on Bauer There are two subjects I hope never to read about again in The Times' Sports section: 1. The 2017 Houston Astros.* 2. Trevor Bauer. Jim Lawson Santa Barbara Night terrors Got an unused night light? Send it to Mookie Betts. Mike Eberts Los Feliz The Los Angeles Times welcomes expressions of all views. Letters should be brief and become the property of The Times. They may be edited and republished in any format. Each must include a valid mailing address and telephone number. Pseudonyms will not be used. Email: sports@ Get the best, most interesting and strangest stories of the day from the L.A. sports scene and beyond from our newsletter The Sports Report. This story originally appeared in Los Angeles Times.
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Spencer Torkelson supports Tarik Skubal with home run in Detroit Tigers' 3-1 win over Cubs
Tarik Skubal clapped to acknowledge the fans. A sellout crowd of 40,132 cheered for him. "Skub," they chanted. The reigning American League Cy Young winner dominated for the Detroit Tigers on Friday, June 6, leading them to a 3-1 win over the Chicago Cubs in the opener of a three-game series at Comerica Park. He lost his scoreless streak at 21 innings in the sixth inning and fell short of completing the eighth inning, but he put the Tigers in a position to win. Advertisement And so they did, for the 42nd time this season. Celebrate the Tigers with our new commemorative book! Detroit Tigers first baseman Spencer Torkelson (20) celebrates batting a solo home run against Chicago Cubs during the sixth inning at Comerica Park in Detroit on Friday, June 6, 2025. ROSTER MOVES: Detroit Tigers call up Jahmai Jones; Andy Ibáñez optioned to Triple-A Toledo The Tigers (42-23) were saved by right fielder Kerry Carpenter with two outs in the top of the eighth inning, when Seiya Suzuki hit a fly ball off right-handed reliever Will Vest — who had just replaced Skubal — that kept carrying toward the wall. Carpenter made a leaping catch to keep the Tigers ahead, 2-1. The Cubs have a 39-24 record, dropping just behind the New York Mets in the National League. In the bottom of the eighth, Jahami Jones — called up from Triple-A Toledo for his Tigers debut — came off the bench to pinch-hit for Carpenter against left-handed reliever Génesis Cabrera. On the first pitch he saw, Jones crushed a curveball for a solo home run to left-center field. Advertisement The Jones homer made it 3-1. The Tigers took a 2-1 lead in the sixth inning, thanks to Spencer Torkelson's 15th home run in 62 games. Torkelson fell behind 0-2 in the count, but he refused to chase three consecutive down-and-away curveballs, working a 3-2 count. On the sixth pitch, he hit a 97 mph fastball from right-hander Ben Brown to left-center field for a solo home run. [ MUST LISTEN: Make "Days of Roar" your go-to Detroit Tigers podcast, available anywhere you listen to podcasts (Apple, Spotify) ] Key hits from Gleyber Torres, Kyle Tucker The Tigers and Cubs traded runs in the fifth and sixth innings, respectively. Advertisement In the bottom of the fifth, Gleyber Torres hit an RBI single off Brown. He delivered the third two-out single in a row to put the Tigers ahead, 1-0: Javier Báez and Parker Meadows set the table, then Torres cashed in. With that single, Torres increased his on-base percentage to .378 through 222 plate appearances, ranking 22nd among qualified MLB players — ahead of superstars such as Bryce Harper, Juan Soto, Trea Turner and Francisco Lindor. In the sixth, the Cubs tied the game, 1-1. Kyle Tucker hit an RBI double off Skubal's slider in a 3-1 count with one out in the sixth inning. It was the first run allowed by Skubal since the sixth inning May 20 against the St. Louis Cardinals, snapping a 21-inning scoreless streak. Advertisement The 21 scoreless innings in a row matched Skubal's career high. For the Cubs, Brown allowed two runs on seven hits and one walk with seven strikeouts across seven innings, throwing 92 pitches. He entered with a 5.72 ERA — and lowered that mark to 5.37 in his 13th game (11th start) against the Tigers. Brown primarily threw fastballs and curveballs. Big break in fifth inning The Tigers benefitted from a big break in the fifth inning. The Cubs should've had runners on second base with no outs, but Pete Crow-Armstrong was thrown out on the bases. He rounded third base on Dansby Swanson's double to left field, then jammed on the breaks and retreated. Advertisement The Tigers caught him easily on his way back. It seemed like a mistake from Cubs third base coach Quintin Berry, who waved Crow-Armstrong around third base before suddenly throwing up the stop sign way too late. Berry, now 40, played 94 games for the Tigers in 2012, stealing 21 bases in 21 attempts. He also hit .258 with 10 doubles, three triples and two home runs, helping the Tigers reach the World Series, where they lost to the San Francisco Giants. Contact Evan Petzold at epetzold@ or follow him @EvanPetzold. Listen to our weekly Tigers show "Days of Roar" every Monday afternoon on Apple, Spotify or wherever you listen to podcasts. And catch all of our podcasts and daily voice briefing at Advertisement Order your copy of 'Roar of 125: The Epic History of the Detroit Tigers!' by the Free Press at This article originally appeared on Detroit Free Press: Detroit Tigers take first matchup of MLB's best with 3-1 win over Cubs
