In Calgary courts: Preliminary inquiry begins for pair charged with murdering Rocky View County worker believed to have offered assistance
More from Calgary courts
Article content
Article content
The hearing to determine if two men will stand trial for the murder of a Rocky View County employee believed to have stopped to offer help got underway Monday.
Article content
Article content
Elijah Blake Strawberry and Arthur Wayne Penner are charged with second-degree murder in connection with the shooting death last Aug. 6 of Colin John Hough.
Article content
Article content
They're also charged with attempted murder in the shooting of Matthew Andres in the same incident.
Article content
Before Crown prosecutors Photini Papadatou and Ryan Ziegler called the first of their witnesses, defence lawyers Rebecca Snukal (For Strawberry) and Alexandra Seaman (for Penner) were granted a publication ban on the evidence in the case by Justice Karim Jivraj.
Article content
At Papadatou's request, the Calgary Court of Justice also informed several members of the deceased's family viewing proceedings via Webex that the publication ban also prohibited them from publicly disseminating information about the evidence.
Article content
Hough was shot on a rural road near Conrich, east of Calgary, when it's believed he pulled over to offer assistance in connection with a burning truck.
Article content
Article content
Andres, who was working for FortisAlberta Inc., survived being shot.
Article content
Papadatou and Ziegler are expected to call up to 13 witnesses over the course of the preliminary inquiry, which is scheduled to last four days.
Article content
Penner, 36, was arrested by the RCMP's major crimes unit with the assistance of Edmonton police six days after the fatal shooting of Hough.
Article content
He was initially charged with first-degree murder, but that allegation was later downgraded by the prosecution.
Article content
Strawberry, 28, was picked up more than a month after Hough's killing. Mounties arrested him Sept. 13, at a residence on O'Chiese First Nation near Rocky Mountain House in Central Alberta.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Montreal Gazette
5 hours ago
- Montreal Gazette
McGill Ghetto murder trial: ‘I was dealing with all sorts of evil'
By François Pelletier, the man on trial for the murder of 24-year-old Romane Bonnier, ran out of time Friday before he could tell the jury hearing his case about the day of the brutal slaying in the McGill Ghetto more than three years ago. Friday was Pelletier's third day on the witness stand in a first-degree murder trial at the Montreal courthouse, where the 39-year-old is acting as his own lawyer. His testimony has been confusing, full of unfinished thoughts and asides on pop culture references he appears to be fixated on. When he brought up Brave New World, the book by Aldous Huxley, yet again late Friday afternoon, Superior Court Justice François Dadour abruptly called it a day. The judge noted he had asked the jury to stay an extra 45 minutes with the hope Pelletier would reach the end of his testimony in principle before the weekend. Instead, Pelletier is expected to testify on Monday about Oct. 19, 2021, the day he stabbed Bonnier 26 times in front of several stunned witnesses. He will then be cross-examined by either prosecutor Louis Bouthillier or prosecutor Marianna Ferraro. The Crown's theory of the case is earlier in 2021, Pelletier met Bonnier after she placed an ad seeking a roommate to share the apartment she was already living in, and they had a brief relationship after he moved in. It did not end well and, on Oct. 19, 2021, he killed the woman who dreamed of being an actor on Broadway. The jury has heard evidence Bonnier put a quick end to the relationship and, on Sept. 1, 2021, Pelletier moved out of the apartment as had already been planned. On Friday, Pelletier said September was difficult for him as he rented a room to start, but he couldn't take the noise there and ended up moving in with a friend on Oct. 1. 'In late September, I'm still trying to figure (the breakup) out,' he said, adding he was having nightmares in which he killed Bonnier. 'I was dealing with all sorts of evil. 'Towards the end, I was trying to tell (Bonnier) that I was not well.' Pelletier said Bonnier ignored many text messages he sent to her and she asked him to 'stop harassing her' after he met her mother and asked her to tell Bonnier to read his messages. 'She finally did agree to give me a last 30 minutes in her presence. I was like, that sounds like a fair deal, right,' Pelletier told the jury. 'We actually did meet, on Oct. 11, (2021) on McGill (University's) campus. At that point, I was in a rather rough shape, but I showed up. I had been requesting this meeting and I was getting it. At that point, I was deeply immersed into this different interpretation of things. I had been cooking in it for weeks now.' Pelletier said he and Bonnier sat on a bench for the conversation and it was clear 'Romane had moved on.' 'She was not just like a girl to me, she was like my twin flame,' he said. 'I was thinking about her all the time.' Before he described the meeting at the university campus, he told the jury about a scene from the movie Dude, Where's My Car?, a goofball comedy starring actor Ashton Kutcher. Pelletier said he compared his inability to communicate with Bonnier, through text messages, to a scene in the movie where 'these two idiots' are unable to understand each other. 'So there we were. I didn't get any of my answers, no explanation,' Pelletier said. 'I was not expecting Romane to tell me what I wanted to hear or anything specific. I just wanted her to tell me ... I don't know exactly what I wanted her to tell me. 'I chose not to ask her at all (about their relationship). We talked about a bunch of stuff. Essentially, it was just back and forth and then I went away from there.' Pelletier said before they parted ways that day he gave Bonnier a hug. 'It was like hugging a corpse, really,' he said. 'I was in bad shape already and that (hug) was bad.' Pelletier added the last words Bonnier told him before she walked away was: 'Have fun.'
Toronto Sun
7 hours ago
- Toronto Sun
MANDEL: Is accused serial killer now fit to stand trial?
A forensic psychiatrist testified Sabrina Kauldhar has 'no psychotic symptoms to impact her being meaningfully present at her trial' Get the latest from Michele Mandel straight to your inbox Sabrina Kauldhar was arrested Thursday, Oct. 3, 2024, in the Burlington area. She has been charged with murder in connection with separate slayings in Toronto, Hamilton and Niagara Falls. Photo by Handout / Niagara Regional Police The woman accused of the shocking murders of three people over three days last fall has improved after receiving medication for her schizophrenia – and she could finally be scheduled to stand trial for murder. This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. THIS CONTENT IS RESERVED FOR SUBSCRIBERS ONLY Subscribe now to read the latest news in your city and across Canada. Unlimited online access to articles from across Canada with one account. Get exclusive access to the Toronto Sun ePaper, an electronic replica of the print edition that you can share, download and comment on. Enjoy insights and behind-the-scenes analysis from our award-winning journalists. Support local journalists and the next generation of journalists. Daily puzzles including the New York Times Crossword. SUBSCRIBE TO UNLOCK MORE ARTICLES Subscribe now to read the latest news in your city and across Canada. Unlimited online access to articles from across Canada with one account. Get exclusive access to the Toronto Sun ePaper, an electronic replica of the print edition that you can share, download and comment on. Enjoy insights and behind-the-scenes analysis from our award-winning journalists. Support local journalists and the next generation of journalists. Daily puzzles including the New York Times Crossword. REGISTER / SIGN IN TO UNLOCK MORE ARTICLES Create an account or sign in to continue with your reading experience. Access articles from across Canada with one account. Share your thoughts and join the conversation in the comments. Enjoy additional articles per month. Get email updates from your favourite authors. THIS ARTICLE IS FREE TO READ REGISTER TO UNLOCK. Create an account or sign in to continue with your reading experience. Access articles from across Canada with one account Share your thoughts and join the conversation in the comments Enjoy additional articles per month Get email updates from your favourite authors Don't have an account? Create Account But the lawyer for Sabrina Kauldhar insists she still doesn't understand the charges against her. It's clear she understands this much – a mental hospital is certainly much nicer that jail. Kauldhar begged the Crown psychiatrist to send her back for treatment rather than returning her to prison where she claimed she's not safe. Often standing to pace in the small prisoner's box, Kauldhar wore a lime green sweatshirt and black head scarf as lawyers and a judge in the downtown mental health court discussed her future on Friday. Kauldhar was arrested in October 2024 and charged with one count of first-degree murder and two counts of second-degree murder involving three slayings that took place over three consecutive days in Toronto, Niagara Falls and Hamilton. Your noon-hour look at what's happening in Toronto and beyond. By signing up you consent to receive the above newsletter from Postmedia Network Inc. Please try again This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. In March, an Ontario court ruled the unresponsive accused killer was unfit to stand trial and ordered her to undergo 60 days of psychiatric treatment. Released from CAMH and returned to prison on May 30, she was now back in court for her second fitness hearing and this time, Crown attorney Joanne Capozzi argued that she's improved enough to go to trial. Dr. Amina Ali told Justice Russell Silverstein that Kauldhar has been diagnosed with schizophrenia and schizoaffective disorder in the past and was hospitalized as recently as February 2022 at Credit Valley hospital. While under the treatment order at CAMH, she was given two anti-psychotic medications and is no longer showing any outward symptoms of her mental illness – she isn't hearing voices or having delusions or hallucinations. This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. Read More The forensic psychiatrist testified that where Kauldhar used to remain mute, she now engages with staff members, especially when she wants something. During her stay, Ali said, she assaulted a patient and a worker but was released after 15 days of seclusion after she responded to a staff question and said she didn't want to hurt anyone. At their meeting just before the hearing Friday, Ali said Kauldhar recognized her and responded to her questions at first. This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. 'And then she stated that 'I need to come back to treatment. Can you say I'm unfit? I can't be at jail. I feel unsafe. Will you tell them?'' Ali said Kauldhar knew her charges were 'homicide' and she had a choice to plead guilty or not guilty. When the psychiatrist tried to ask more, she said Kauldhar announced the conversation was over. 'I think at this point, she is choosing not to engage in some questions that are part of this process,' Ali said. 'There are no psychotic symptoms to impact her being meaningfully present at her trial.' Defence lawyer Rick Frank said Kauldhar doesn't have 'a reality-based understanding' that she faces three separate murder charges in three different jurisdictions and as recently as that morning, she either didn't answer questions or her speech was unintelligible. This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. 'Ms. Kauldhar cannot be meaningfully present and cannot meaningfully participate,' Frank insisted. Sabrina Kauldhar is accused of killing three people on three consecutive days in Toronto, Hamilton and Niagara Falls. Photo by Handout / Niagara Regional Police The judge pushed back, saying the psychiatrist has found she's improved and is able to understand what she's facing. 'I'm telling Your Honour … I'm not able to get meaningful instructions,' the lawyer said. Silverstein suggested that according to the psychiatrist, his difficult client is making a conscious choice not to answer certain questions. And Kauldhar may be as wily as a fox. 'I think implicit in the doctor's evidence is that Ms. Kauldhar is angling to be found unfit so as to be taken out of jail and put in hospital, which is where she'd rather be,' the judge said. 'It demonstrates some sophisticated, purposeful behaviour on her part.' This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. The killing spree allegedly began Oct. 1, when Toronto Police were called to a basement apartment in the Junction and found the body of Kauldhar's roommate, 66-year-old Trinh Thi Vu. Police believe the next two victims were strangers to their alleged killer: Chef Lance Cunningham, 47, had gone to walk his dogs at a Niagara Falls park before picking his daughter up from school when he was killed. The following day, Mario Bilich, a 77-year-old retired teacher, was slain in the Hamilton parking lot of his Sicilian social club. Kauldhar is charged with first-degree murder in Bilich's death and second-degree murder in the Toronto and Niagara investigations. Will she stand trial? The judge has reserved his decision to next week. mmandel@ Olympics NHL Toronto & GTA Columnists Editorial Cartoons
Calgary Herald
8 hours ago
- Calgary Herald
Double murder suspect has charges stayed in historical Calgary homicides
Historical murder charges against a Calgary man arrested more than 18 months ago in connection with a 1994 double murder have been dropped by the Crown. Article content A letter from Edmonton Chief Crown prosecutor Sarah Langley was filed in Calgary Court of King's Bench on Friday staying two first-degree murder charges against Stuart Douglas MacGregor. Article content Article content MacGregor, also known as Surridge, was arrested in November 2023, and had been in custody since despite three attempts by his lawyers, Rebecca Snukal and Michael Bates, to have him released on bail. Article content Article content 'Pursuant to section 579 of the Criminal Code you are hereby directed by counsel instructed by the Attorney General for that purpose to make an entry on the record that the proceedings against the above named accused on the above named charges are stayed,' Langley's letter to the clerk of the court said. Article content 'If you have any questions or concerns, please do not hesitate to contact our office.' Article content MacGregor's arrest came just days before a second suspect, Leonard Brian Cochrane, was convicted on the same two charges in connection with the July 11, 1994, fatal shootings of Barry Buchart and Trevor Deakins in their Radisson Heights home. Article content Article content Cochrane was linked to the scene by police using investigative genetic genealogy, which compares individuals in known DNA databases and to material found at the scene to narrow the list of suspects to relatives with similar genetic markers. Article content Article content When MacGregor was charged police said they used the same technology to lead them to a second suspect. Article content In Cochrane's trial, he testified he had gone to the victims' residence to buy drugs from Buchart after meeting him a short time earlier at a nearby convenience store where the drug dealer asked if he wanted to purchase some narcotics. Article content After agreeing to purchase an ounce of marijuana and having gone home to pick up some cash to pay for it, Cochrane said he found himself inside the basement suite in the early morning hours when two balaclava-clad intruders stormed in. Article content Cochrane said he was bloodied during a struggle with one of the intruders leading to his blood being found at the scene, but Justice Keith Yamauchi dismissed his claim noting the drops of blood of the offender's found at the scene were inconsistent with his claim he was bleeding heavily.
