Court continues to hear closing arguments in Lai case
The prosecution has spent two days laying out its final arguments in the national security trial. Photo: RTHK
Prosecutors have alleged that former media tycoon Jimmy Lai "deliberately painted a false picture' of central and SAR authorities to push for foreign sanctions, as they wrapped up their evidence against the Apple Daily founder.
The prosecution's closing speech continued for a second day on Tuesday, arguing that the defendant had indirectly requested punitive actions following the implementation of the National Security Law in 2020.
Prosecutor Anthony Chau said Lai tried to 'create a false impression' about the mainland and Hong Kong so external elements could punish the central and SAR governments.
While the former media boss 'did not overtly call or request' for such actions following the security law's promulgation, Chau said, Lai's remarks were 'naturally and reasonably' persuading foreign countries to impose sanctions, blockades or hostile activity.
The court heard the Apple Daily founder had leveraged 'international attention' to advance his own agenda following the law's implementation.
'He's aware of the international attention to his acts and conducts, and he continued to make use of this media to arouse international attention to achieve his own purpose,' Chau said.
One of three judges, Alex Lee, queried whether this was a form of hearsay, as Lai was said to have heard about the attention he was receiving from other people.
Judge Esther Toh said regardless of whether this 'international attention' was based in fact, this spoke to the defendant's thinking. The prosecution agreed, adding that it also relied on other evidence to prove its case.
Chau also said articles published by the now-defunct newspaper failed to offer 'rational criticisms' of the government or provide solutions to remedy the situation, dismissing the defence's contention that such publications were 'critical opinions'.
Judge Toh questioned if suggesting solutions is necessary when giving critical opinions. In response, Chau said commentaries that focus on providing remedies would not have seditious intent.
Lai had denied conspiracy charges relating to colluding with foreign forces and publishing seditious material.
The prosecution is expected to continue its closing arguments on Wednesday.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South China Morning Post
2 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
Even his biggest fans in Japan are turning against Taiwan's William Lai
Western cheerleaders of Taiwanese leader William Lai Ching-te love his constant poking of Beijing in the eye. People from the Asia-Pacific, though, are less cheery about the incessant and often pointless provocations. Japanese media pundits have been among the biggest fans of the leadership of the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP), even before Lai entered office. It's not a good sign when even they are turning against him . That's not hard to understand. If there was to be a shooting war over Taiwan, it would affect Japan a lot more than faraway Europe and North America. Yomiuri Shimbun, Japan's largest daily, has denounced the latest recall vote – which failed to oust a single Beijing-friendly Kuomintang (KMT) lawmaker – as an undemocratic attempt to 'eliminate opposition parties' which make up the majority in the island's legislature. Sankei Shimbun, a conservative newspaper, compared Lai with the disgraced Chen Shui-bian, the island's first DPP president who was mired in corruption scandals. His time in office worsened polarisation at home and antagonism with Beijing. Sound familiar? Thanks to high tariffs and borderline blackmail on forced investments in the United States, even Japan and South Korea, actual allies of Washington with long-standing formal treaties, are waking up to how unreliable and even threatening Washington has become. But Lai, who faces the same economic coercion from the US, prefers to double down on provoking Beijing. He now talks about the 'purity' of Taiwan, presumably as opposed to the impure mainland, the kind of racial language fitting for a proto-fascist.
South China Morning Post
2 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
Hong Kong court challenges Jimmy Lai's rights claims in national security trial
Two Hong Kong judges hearing Jimmy Lai Chee-ying's national security trial have expressed reservations about the defence characterising the former media boss's alleged endeavours to trigger Western sanctions and foster hatred towards authorities as a legitimate exercise of fundamental rights. The 77-year-old Apple Daily tabloid founder's legal team on Wednesday started presenting its closing arguments at West Kowloon Court after the prosecution made their final remarks in his case of conspiracies to print seditious publications and collude with foreign forces. Senior counsel Robert Pang Yiu-hung opened his speech by hitting out at what he saw as prosecutors' attempt to 'denigrate' human rights and dismiss it as 'an alien concept'. 'You can't force someone to think in one way or another,' the lawyer said. 'Nor is it wrong to hope that the government would change its policies, whether through its own internal review or through suggestion or even pressure, whether from inside Hong Kong or out.' Madam Justice Esther Toh Lye-ping, one of three presiding High Court judges, said the charges were not as simple as that.
RTHK
6 hours ago
- RTHK
Couple arrested again over govt water scandal
Couple arrested again over govt water scandal Tommy Kwok, head of customs' trade descriptions investigation bureau, says the couple are suspected of violating the Trade Descriptions Ordinance. Photo: RTHK A couple caught up in a scandal involving bottled water supplied to government offices have been arrested for a second time, as customs officers look into whether they lied about where the water came from. A 61-year-old company director and his 57-year-old shareholder wife were first arrested by the police on Sunday on suspicion of fraud. The man later appeared in court accused of providing officials with false documents to win the HK$52 million water contract. His wife was not charged by police and was released on bail. Now customs officers have arrested the pair again, this time on suspicion of violating the Trade Descriptions Ordinance. 'Our investigation revealed that the bottled water provided to the Government Logistics Services Department by the supplier involved [allegedly] contained false manufacturer information," said Tommy Kwok, head of customs' trade descriptions investigation bureau. It's thought the water sold to the government came from a plant in Zhangmutou, Dongguan, rather than the mainland supplier it was claimed to have been sourced from. Kwok said officers would be going to Zhangmutou as part of their investigation. The government has since terminated the water contract, with Secretary for Financial Services and the Treasury Christopher Hui conceding there had been "problems and inadequacies" in the tendering process.
