Child homelessness a ‘national shame', TDs and Senators told
Child homelessness is a 'national shame' and those affected cannot be given their childhoods back, TDs and Senators have been told.
The remarks were made by Nuala Ward, the director of investigations at the office of the Ombudsman for Children during an appearance at the Oireachtas Housing Committee on Tuesday.
The committee met to examine the challenges to tackling homelessness
Of the 15,580 homeless people living in emergency accommodation in April, 4,775 were children.
READ MORE
A statement submitted to the committee by Ombudsman for Children Dr Niall Muldoon said children have 'borne the biggest brunt' of the homelessness crisis.
Mr Muldoon said: 'The impact of homelessness and unstable living conditions on children is catastrophic' and it 'affects every aspect of their lives; education, wellbeing, self-development'.
During the meeting, Social Democrats TD Rory Hearne asked the representatives of the Ombudsman's office if they 'see a future requirement for a redress scheme for children who've been through homelessness, given that the State is failing to protect them'.
Ms Ward described the situation as 'a national shame', adding that 'we have children in this country growing up, not just for a few months, but growing up in B&Bs and hotels and we're paying State money to private providers for this type of accommodation that is having a devastating impact on children.'
She described them sitting in bathrooms trying to be quiet while their mother is putting a sibling to bed.
'We've got children who are devastated because their pet dog or their hamster is not allowed in family hubs,' she said. 'They've had to leave them behind with granny or leaving behind with the auntie. Can you imagine that?'
She said the most important point heard repeatedly from children related to growing up in poverty.
Ms Ward said: 'I'm not sure if anybody here has grown up in any state of poverty, or can remember being deeply ashamed of not having something or being known that you're poor ... that there's something different to you from your peers.
'That shame doesn't leave you and that's what we're doing to children.
'So should there be a Redress Scheme? Can you give children back their childhoods? No, we can't. So that would be what our view would be on this.'
Sinn Féin TD Eoin Ó Broin later said it was 'hard not to feel utterly depressed' at 'yet another housing committee meeting having the same conversation'. He said the number of children in emergency accommodation has increased by 442 per cent in a decade.
'I know numbers don't convey, Nuala, the points that you made. I understand that completely,' he said. 'But thousands upon thousands upon thousands of children have been forced into long-term stays in emergency accommodation during that period.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
8 hours ago
- Irish Times
Child homelessness a ‘national shame', TDs and Senators told
Child homelessness is a 'national shame' and those affected cannot be given their childhoods back, TDs and Senators have been told. The remarks were made by Nuala Ward, the director of investigations at the office of the Ombudsman for Children during an appearance at the Oireachtas Housing Committee on Tuesday. The committee met to examine the challenges to tackling homelessness Of the 15,580 homeless people living in emergency accommodation in April, 4,775 were children. READ MORE A statement submitted to the committee by Ombudsman for Children Dr Niall Muldoon said children have 'borne the biggest brunt' of the homelessness crisis. Mr Muldoon said: 'The impact of homelessness and unstable living conditions on children is catastrophic' and it 'affects every aspect of their lives; education, wellbeing, self-development'. During the meeting, Social Democrats TD Rory Hearne asked the representatives of the Ombudsman's office if they 'see a future requirement for a redress scheme for children who've been through homelessness, given that the State is failing to protect them'. Ms Ward described the situation as 'a national shame', adding that 'we have children in this country growing up, not just for a few months, but growing up in B&Bs and hotels and we're paying State money to private providers for this type of accommodation that is having a devastating impact on children.' She described them sitting in bathrooms trying to be quiet while their mother is putting a sibling to bed. 'We've got children who are devastated because their pet dog or their hamster is not allowed in family hubs,' she said. 'They've had to leave them behind with granny or leaving behind with the auntie. Can you imagine that?' She said the most important point heard repeatedly from children related to growing up in poverty. Ms Ward said: 'I'm not sure if anybody here has grown up in any state of poverty, or can remember being deeply ashamed of not having something or being known that you're poor ... that there's something different to you from your peers. 'That shame doesn't leave you and that's what we're doing to children. 'So should there be a Redress Scheme? Can you give children back their childhoods? No, we can't. So that would be what our view would be on this.' Sinn Féin TD Eoin Ó Broin later said it was 'hard not to feel utterly depressed' at 'yet another housing committee meeting having the same conversation'. He said the number of children in emergency accommodation has increased by 442 per cent in a decade. 'I know numbers don't convey, Nuala, the points that you made. I understand that completely,' he said. 'But thousands upon thousands upon thousands of children have been forced into long-term stays in emergency accommodation during that period.'
Irish Times
8 hours ago
- Irish Times
Mother settles legal action over birth of baby girl on hospital floor at Rotunda Hospital in Dublin
A woman whose baby was born head first on to the floor of the Rotunda Hospital in Dublin as she was moved between beds has settled a High Court action. LesleyAnn Flynn broke down in court on Tuesday as she told how she pleaded for help to get on the hospital bed as she was in advanced labour when her daughter Mabel was born on to the floor. 'I was pushing. I told them I couldn't get on the bed. I said: 'Please, please help.' I knew the baby was coming. I then felt the pressure just leave me and the baby was on the floor,' she told Ms Justice Leonie Reynolds. The court heard that a letter expressing deepest regret had been sent to Ms Flynn and her partner Ronan Keaskin earlier this month from the Master of the Rotunda Hospital in relation to the incident in 2018. READ MORE Opening the case, Roughan Banim SC, for Ms Flynn, said it was 'a terrifying and frightening experience' for the mother 'who felt she was not listened to and her baby daughter should not have been born on the floor, but she was'. Counsel said Ms Flynn's daughter Mabel was now six years of age and has met all her milestones. He said liability was admitted in the case but causation was at issue. A mother of three, Ms Flynn (40), of Baldoyle, Dublin had sued the Rotunda Hospital, Parnell Square, Dublin for nervous shock over the circumstances of her daughter's birth in the early hours of December 27th, 2018. It was claimed there had been a failure to anticipate the delivery of the baby and a failure to take any reasonable care for the health and welfare of the mother and of her unborn child during the course of the labour. In evidence, Ms Flynn said she was on a bed and had contractions when a midwife came with a wheelchair to move her to another delivery room. She said she could not sit on the wheelchair and was half sitting and half standing as she was moved. When they reached the delivery suite, she said she was told to get on the bed, but she said she couldn't because she was pushing. After her baby was born on to sheets on the ground, Ms Flynn said she was in complete and utter shock and there was silence in the room. She said after she was discharged home she kept playing what happened over and over in her head. She said she was worried about her daughter, but it was some comfort to her that she met all her milestones. The hospital's barrister, Eileen Barrington SC, representing the Rotunda with Rory White BL, put it to Ms Flynn that hospital records show the baby girl was crying regularly within a minute of birth. Ms Flynn replied that when her baby was born, she was not crying. On Tuesday afternoon, after a brief recess and talks between the parties, Ms Justice Reynolds was told the case had been settled and could be struck out.
Irish Times
10 hours ago
- Irish Times
More than 1m Irish people exposed to harmful transport noise, report finds
More than 1.1 million Irish people are exposed to high levels of transport noise that exceed thresholds set under EU reporting rules and which harm health, a five-year review of noise pollution across Europe has found. The environmental noise in Europe 2025 report from the European Environment Agency (EEA) concludes 1.14 million Irish people were exposed to unsafe noise levels, with just over 1 million related to road traffic, 92,700 related to rail and 13,400 related to airport flights. The figures from 2021-2022 are likely to be an underestimate, according to noise experts. More than 20 per cent of Europeans – 110 million people – are exposed to high levels of transport noise, says the report published on Tuesday. It calls for stronger action at EU and national levels to address the problem. READ MORE Progress in decreasing exposure to harmful levels of noise has been slow, the EEA says. Long-term exposure to transport noise is linked to a wide range of negative impacts on health including cardiovascular diseases, mental illness, diabetes and premature death. The report says children and adolescents are particularly vulnerable to noise effects. Based on new research, noise exposure in children contributes to reading impairment, behavioural problems and obesity. Dr Eoin King, a noise specialist based at the University of Galway, said the level of noise exposure being experienced by more than one million Irish people is at a level that both the EU and World Health Organisation would consider damaging to health. Given when data was compiled and how the report is put together using 'noise maps' and targeted at large cities and extremely busy roads, levels were likely to be 'an underprediction'. This was especially in relation to aviation and Dublin Airport in particular, he said. [ 'We're blasted out of it': Living under Dublin Airport's flight paths Opens in new window ] The noise map for Dublin Airport was 'not up to par', he said, because flight paths were incorrect while the noise was averaged out over a longer time period rather than a measure of intermittent noise associated with flights. 'This doesn't capture the true impact on people,' Dr King said. He hoped more progressive noise indicators would be used at the airport. 'Noise policy in Ireland is nowhere near where it should be,' he added. This had been recognised by the EPA and in a study by UCD and the ESRI, which found noise was more impactful on the Irish population than air quality. Dr King said there was a lack of public awareness of the health implications and 'little political will to do something about noise'. [ Dublin Airport has not addressed effects of noise on people living near flight paths, warns sleep expert Opens in new window ] There was no legal noise limit in Ireland, while the EU was hesitant about applying a European noise limit 'because countries like Ireland are so far behind. So all it can do is guide policy'. Local authorities were required to produce noise action plans but for most, this was a box-ticking exercise and the problem came down to a lack of expertise, he said. Residents living near Dublin Airport welcomed the report as it 'spells out the real cost to the public of noise pollution'. The St Margaret's The Ward group said it highlights in stark terms the impacts on health and wellbeing of people living close to airports. In April, the group published its own independent report on the health impacts of noise pollution which placed the costs at €800 million annually . The EEA report concludes aircraft noise affects about 2.6 million people (day, evening and night) across Europe. Group spokesman Liam O'Gradaigh said: 'Our own report in April spelled out just what local residents have had to endure through exposure to noise pollution. Now that we have an international watchdog such as the EEA pointing out the real costs across Europe, maybe politicians, policymakers and those driving completely unsustainable growth at Dublin Airport might sit up and pay attention before it is too late.' Mr O'Gradaigh said the report probably underestimates current aviation impacts as data used stems from the period of the Covid pandemic when aircraft movements plummeted.
