Should teen sex be a crime? Indian woman lawyer mounts challenge
Like many countries, India has struggled to set its age of sexual consent. Unlike the US, where it varies by state, India enforces a uniform age nationwide.India's legal age for having sex is also much higher than most European countries, or places like UK and Canada, where it is 16.It was 10 years when India's criminal code was enacted in 1860 and was increased to 16 in 1940 when the code was amended.Pocso introduced the next major change, pushing the "age of consent" to 18 years in 2012. A year later, India's criminal laws were amended to reflect this change and the country's new criminal code, introduced in 2024, has adhered to this revised age.Why is consensual teen sex a crime in India?But over the past decade or so, many child rights activists and even courts have taken a critical view of the country's legal age to have sex and have called for it to be lowered to 16 years. They say the law criminalises consensual teen relationships and is often misused by adults to control or block relationships - especially those of girls.Sex remains a taboo topic in the country even though studies have shown that millions of Indian teenagers are sexually active."As a society, we're also divided along caste, class and religious lines, which makes the [age of consent] law even more susceptible to misuse," says Sharmila Raje, co-founder of Foundation for Child Protection-Muskaan, a non-profit working to prevent child sexual abuse for over two decades.
In 2022, the Karnataka High court directed India's Law Commission - an executive panel that advices the government on legal reform - to rethink the age of consent under Pocso, "so as to take into consideration the ground realities".It noted several cases where girls over 16 fell in love, eloped, and had sex, only for the boy to be charged with rape and abduction under Pocso and criminal law.In its report the following year, the Law Commission ruled out lowering the age of consent, but recommended "guided judicial discretion" during sentencing in cases involving "tacit approval" from children aged 16 to 18 years, meaning where the relationship has been consensual.Though this is yet to be implemented, courts across the country have been using this principle to allow for appeals, grant bail, make acquittals and even quash cases after taking into consideration the facts of the case and the victim's testimony. Many child rights activists, including Ms Raje, urge this provision be codified to standardise enforcement; left as a suggestion, courts may ignore it.In April, the Madras High Court overturned the acquittal in a case where the 17-year-old victim was in a relationship with the 23-year-old accused and the two eloped after the victim's parents arranged her marriage to another man. The accused was sentenced to 10 years imprisonment."The court adopted a literal interpretation of the Pocso Act," Shruthi Ramakrishnan, a researcher at Enfold Proactive Health Trust - a child rights charity - noted in her column in The Indian Express newspaper, calling it a "grave miscarriage of justice".
Ms Jaising argues that judicial discretion at sentencing isn't enough, as the accused still faces lengthy investigations and trials.India's judicial system is infamously slow with millions of cases pending across all court levels. A research paper by India Child Protection Fund found that as of January 2023, nearly 250,000 Pocso cases were pending in special courts set up to try these cases."The process is the punishment for many," Ms Jaising notes. "A case-by-case approach leaving it to the discretion of judges is also not the best solution as it can result in uneven results and does not take into account the possibility of bias," she adds.She urges the court to add a "close-in-age exception" for consensual sex between 16- and 18-year-olds in Pocso and related laws. This "close-in-age exception" would prevent consensual acts between peers in that age group from being treated as crimes.Lawyer and child rights activist Bhuwan Ribhu warns that a blanket exception could be misused in cases of kidnapping, trafficking, and child marriage. He advocates judicial discretion paired with a justice system overhaul."We need faster processes so that cases are disposed off in a time-bound manner. We also need better rehabilitation facilities and compensation for victims," he says.Enakshi Ganguly, co-founder of HAQ: Centre for Child Rights, however, agrees with Ms Jaising. "We can't shy away from making changes because we're afraid of the law being misused," she says, adding that Ms Jaising's argument is not new as over the years, many activists and experts have made similar recommendations."Laws need to keep pace with changes in society if they are to remain effective and relevant," she says.Follow BBC News India on Instagram, YouTube, Twitter and Facebook.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ITV News
an hour ago
- ITV News
India rejects UK parliament report on transnational repression
India has launched a blistering counterattack against a UK parliamentary report that accused it of waging 'transnational repression' on British soil and misusing global policing tools like INTERPOL to silence political dissidents. In a strongly worded statement on India's foreign ministry denounced the allegations as 'baseless,' 'politically motivated,' and 'drawn from dubious and discredited sources.' 'The deliberate reliance on unverified inputs from proscribed entities with a long record of anti-India hostility calls into question the credibility and objectivity of the entire report,' said MEA spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal, dismissing the claims as an orchestrated smear. The rare diplomatic rebuke was triggered by the release of a hard-hitting report titled 'Transnational Repression in the UK' on July 30 by the UK Parliament's Joint Committee on Human Rights — a powerful cross-party body comprising lawmakers from both the House of Commons and House of Lords. The report accuses multiple foreign governments of targeting exiled dissidents, activists, and journalists who have sought refuge in the UK, creating what it describes as a 'chilling effect' on diaspora communities. India was named among 12 countries, including China, Russia, Iran, and Saudi Arabia, allegedly involved in such practices. While the report reserves its sharpest criticism for what it terms the 'three most flagrant perpetrators' — China, Russia, and Iran — India's inclusion, particularly the accusation of abusing INTERPOL's Red Notice mechanism for political ends, has sparked sharp pushback from New Delhi. The committee's findings draw heavily from evidence submitted by UK-based Sikh advocacy groups, including the Sikh Federation (UK) and Sikhs for Justice. These groups allege that Indian authorities have sought to weaponise international policing tools to harass and intimidate diaspora voices, especially those supporting the Khalistan separatist movement — a claim India has long dismissed as misinformation propagated by extremist elements. While the report has reignited debate within Britain over how to protect residents from foreign interference, India's sharp reaction signals a potential diplomatic flashpoint — particularly amid already sensitive ties following the killing of Sikh separatist Hardeep Singh Nijjar in Canada last year, which also raised questions around cross-border intelligence operations. As both countries navigate a delicate relationship shaped by strategic partnerships and domestic political pressures, the fallout from this latest allegation is likely to echo beyond Westminster and Raisina Hill.
BBC News
2 hours ago
- BBC News
Jersey trawling and dredging area limited from September 2026
More than one fifth of the island's territorial waters will be designated as marine protected areas and off limits to trawling and dredging from September 2026, the government has politicians voted unanimously for the Marine Spatial Plan in October, which included a pledge to increase the area of protected waters from 6.5% to 23%.Marine protected areas prohibit mobile gear fishing, which includes trawling and dredging, to stop damage to habitats and government said it will work with licensed fishermen in Jersey and France to support adjustment to the new rules. A timeline for implementing the plan released by the infrastructure and environment committee also shows part of Les Sauvages reef will be off limits to all fishing. Only commercially licensed vessels will be prohibited from fishing in the protected netting, rod and line fishing and all recreational activities are unaffected by the changes. An additional 4% of territorial waters are being researched and could be added to the protected marine areas by 2030, the committee said. "This will be a seismic shift for marine management in Jersey waters, significantly changing the face of fishing," it said."The Economic Impact Assessment will assist in understanding the livelihood impact of these changes and government will work with licensed fishermen in Jersey and France to support adjustment to the new rules."
Daily Mirror
2 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Woman murdered by ex made THIRTEEN chilling calls to police but no-one came to help
After Janbaz Tarin stabbed his ex Raneem Oudeh and her mother Khaola Saleem to death in 2018, Khaola's sister Nour Norris campaigned for a new law to ensure no other domestic abuse victim would be failed by the police again It was a murder which shocked Britain - when a domestic abuse victim, who had already made nine desperate calls to the police, was murdered by her violent ex while begging for help again - for the fifth time that night. Janbaz Tarin, 21, stabbed Raneem Oudeh, 22, to death, and brutally killed her mother, Khaola Saleem, 49, too. To add to their families' pain, police had to apologise after an inquest found their errors 'materially contributed' to the women's deaths. Many at the time might have rolled their eyes at another police force pledging that 'lessons will be learnt'. But today, standing in the West Midlands 999 control room where Raheem's last ever call was taken, we are seeing those promises put into action. It comes after The Mirror's Justice for Our Daughters campaign launched to highlight awareness of domestic violence. I am here with Nour Norris, Raneem's aunt and Khaola's sister, who ever since their deaths has fought to ensure no other women crying out to the police for help are failed again. Desperate Raneem had made four 999 calls before the police finally phoned her back - and heard she and her mother being murdered while on the line. Tarin was jailed for life. Over the past six years, grieving Nour has not only shed light on the gross inadequacies of an organisation that should be protecting victims, but has also successfully campaigned for positive change. Raneem's Law - a groundbreaking domestic violence specialist police response that is now in action at the Birmingham operations hub base of the UK's second largest force. Seeing firsthand the results of her campaigning, Nour, 46, says: 'Being here brings out so many mixed emotions in me. 'The mistakes that took my sister and niece's lives were made in this room. But other women are now getting the support they deserve. So much has changed since Raneem called this centre. Knowing that brings happiness to my sadness.' Backed and supported by Minister for Safeguarding and Violence against Women and Girls, Jess Phillips, the Government announced last year it would fund Raneem's Law in targeted police forces. Raneem's Law is live in the West Midlands, Northamptonshire, Bedfordshire, Northumberland, and Humberside. Domestic abuse specialists in these 999 control rooms advise on risk assessments and work with officers on the ground, to ensure that victims get a fast response when needed and are referred to support services as quickly as possible. Mother and daughter Khaola and Raneem, were both killed in the frenzied knife attack outside Khaola's home in Solihull on August 27, 2018. In the weeks leading up to the murders, Tarin repeatedly harassed and made death threats to Raneem, and she made desperate pleas to the police for help, but none were answered. Her blood-curdling screams can be heard on the recording of that fateful final call. On The Mirror 's visit, there are 90 call handlers taking 999 and 101 calls from across the West Midlands. As information screens across the room show, 5- 6000 calls are handled daily. Up to 200 of these calls are domestic violence-related and Raneem's Law strives to give each of these calls a specialist response. For 'preventing violence against women and girls' in delivering Raneem's Law, Nour was made an OBE in the King's Birthday Honours List. The mum of five is now also a 2025 Pride of Britain award nominee. Nour introduces me to Vulnerability Desk Lead Mair Mason who is leading the West Midlands' implementation of Raneem's Law which began in March this year. Call handlers assisted by domestic violence charities now have 'professional curiosity in identifying risks,' she says. The Vulnerability desk which previously only focused on mental health-related calls. acts as 'quality control' for domestic abuse calls. On the desk today is call handler Tara Hobley, now a specially trained Domestic Abuse Liaison Officer. Next to Tara is an advisor from Coventry Haven Women's Aid. The charity works on a rota basis with Birmingham and Solhull Women's Aid as independent advisors. The Women's Aid advocate and Tara scroll through incoming logs - looking for any marked domestic violence, so they can listen in and ensure all appropriate risk assessments are done. Tara explains, 'When we come across a DV call on the log, we will dial into those calls, and make the contact handler aware that we are listening in. 'We are there to provide advice if needed and will also assist with risk identification and making sure that everything that we need—any orders, specifically non-molestation orders and stalking protection orders—is identified and included in the log. 'So when officers attend, they've got access to the information to make an informed decision in the best interest of the victim.' Mair adds, 'Every effort is made to filter such calls to the Vulnerable Desk so they can be picked up easily on the log, with information to call back if necessary and a clear record of times that person has called.' As Tara shows me on her computer screen, there is also a mapping system so police can see, even if someone calls through from a different number, what other instances have happened in that area: 'So even if we can't make a link through the telephone number, there are other ways that we can see, oh, maybe this is related to that call.' In Raneem's case, one of the most shocking failures was there was no record of her previous calls. Nour says: 'The whole system in place was not fit for purpose. None of Raneem's calls were linked. Every time it was counted as a new call. There was no record, no follow up. 'She had made four 999 calls before the police finally called her back - and heard her being murdered.' The recording of that fateful final police call was heard at the 2022 inquest. It found that mistakes by West Midlands Police 'materially contributed' to the tragedy. Police had responded to 10 domestic abuse incidents linked to Tarin. Five officers were disciplined over failings. Raneem had fled to the UK from war torn Syria in 2014 and found herself in a new hell - in a violent marriage. After getting a restraining order against Tarin, Raneem had moved back into her mum's Solihull house, where her younger sister also lived. Nour who lives in Solihull close to her sister's home, says: ' Raheem had called the police several times because he was breaking the order and harassing her, but he was never arrested or cautioned. That emboldened him. He realised he could get away with it—she told me, he told her, 'They listen to me, so why are they going to believe you?' The night they died, they had visited Nour. She recalls: 'I had a horrible feeling something would happen. I made lots of food because I wanted them to stay with me.' Raneem and Khaola returned home, and later Nour received a devastating call: ' My other niece who was 14 at the time, witnessed the attacks and called me. When I got there, Khaola was already gone, but Raneem was in the ambulance and the paramedics were trying to revive her. I was taken inside the house, but the ambulance was not moving. I realised then that Raneem was dead.' She adds: 'There were dozens of police cars outside when they died. But why couldn't they bring just one police car when they were alive? One police officer could have saved them.' In a matter of months, the difference in the police approach is like 'day and night,' says Mair: 'There have been so many positive changes with regard to police culture and working practice since March. 'It's been so beneficial for us to be working with domestic violence charities at the early stage,' says Mair. Women's Aid has worked with police on incidents previously, but never before Raneem's Law, had such pioneering early intervention access. Mair explains: 'A call that came through a couple of weeks ago - we could see from the log that the partner was now in custody and the victim was known to the charity. 'She had been struggling to find a time to call them previously because she lived with her abuser, but now we could safely call that person to get some safeguarding in place. 'Also, our collective knowledge, within the contact centre, wasn't where it could be with regards to non fatal strangulation. There were so many risks that we were not aware of previously. We've learned a lot in the past six months. 'For example, in another 999 call where the woman was being harassed by her ex-partner, he had also strangled her a few days prior, leaving injuries. Live-time advice from the charity was provided to the Call Handler to advise the caller to seek urgent medical attention.' Women's Aid advises domestic abuse survivors to seek urgent medical attention following pressure to the neck area is essential, 'whether they have any detectable injuries or not, and it is a key indicator of a potential domestic homicide.' Although brought in as a pilot scheme, West Midlands Police say they are committed to securing its long-term status. 'I know the Home Office has been looking at how everything is going across the different forces, and I have a meeting with them next week, but it 's our full intention that even should the Home Office pilot come to an end, we will still continue this work and make it permanent,' says Mair. Since the attack, Nour who backs The Mirror's Justice For Our Daughters Campaign, retrained as a psychotherapist. She also leads domestic abuse training workshops through the organisation SecureLife. She says:'The system wasn't fair to Raneem and Khaola, but through them, other people will not suffer the same way - and that wlll save lives. They have left a powerful legacy.' Although never proven, there were 'question marks' over how much ethnicity played a part in the botched handling of Raneem's case. Nour adds: ' At the inquest, we saw mainly that it was failings of handling domestic abuse cases coming through. 'But those question marks should no longer exist because of Raneem's Law - everyone is now accountable for what they do, everyone has to follow through and do their duty- to protect victims. My dream is to see Raneem's Law embedded in every 999 control room in the country.'
