National Health Insurance system will mean little if we don't offer the right kind of care
South Africa's healthcare system is
'Of 696 facilities evaluated in the Office of Health Standards Compliance's latest report, only five met 80% of the required performance standards, which include drug availability and proper infection control,' SAMRC writes.
Additionally, the healthcare system is facing an exodus of workers. Since July 2023,
Then there is the fact that in cases where South Africa can provide care in a strained system, it is not providing the right kinds of care. Non-communicable diseases (NCDs) — obesity, cardiovascular diseases, cancers and diabetes, for example — remain a major cause of death in the country: in 2010, they caused a similar number of deaths to
How we manage NCDs should be a focus of the NHI — but it requires a full recalibration of how we understand health.
But in the early 20th century, biomedicine came to the fore, and medical progress began to occur in research and disease management: cancer treatment, vaccines, antibiotics, organ transplants.
Medicine became a science, and the point of science is to eliminate subjectivity. This meant the mind and body were separated, and a person's emotions were seen to have nothing to do with a disease. But, in certain cases such as cases of NCDs and mental health issues, treating diseases as purely physical or purely mental has significant drawbacks.
NCDs are lifestyle diseases. By their very nature they are diseases that arise from the ways in which a person lives — physically, socially, psychologically and emotionally.
But at medical school, doctors are trained to find physical symptoms. When a patient comes in suffering from a chronic ailment — which may have arisen equally from whatever facet of their life, but is now representing itself physically — a doctor looks for and treats the physical issue.
The other aspects — the emotional, social and psychospiritual nature of humans — are not given as much attention. The physical problem — the shortness of breath, chest pain, lack of appetite, weakness, trouble sleeping — may be cured. But the sickness goes on. The patient does not become truly healthy.
South Africa is full of patients suffering in this way. On top of the huge burden of NCDs, the country has an estimated
In the public health system, these people have nowhere to go. Private mental healthcare is financially out of reach for most. It is something of a catch-22: the NHI might provide access to psychologists and psychiatrists, but there is a risk of overwhelming mental health professionals and contributing toward the exodus of medical workers.
Furthermore, having one professional treat only a person's mental health continues the problem of treating mind and body as separated from one another.
A patient's psychologist and physician might rarely be in contact with one another, if at all. They may treat a patient's symptoms using approaches that are in conflict with one another. This is what is meant when it is said that South Africa's healthcare system — even its private healthcare system — does not always provide the right kinds of care.
As South Africa's public healthcare system is overhauled, it is necessary that from the outset it is clear how patients suffering from NCDs and mental health issues will be treated. Medical schools may need to focus on training a new kind of doctor — one who can care for patients holistically: emotionally, physically, socially and beyond that, psychospiritually. Family physicians should be trained in this capacity. While they do learn to perform a three-stage assessment — physical, personal and contextual — they need to go even further and incorporate a person's psychology and spiritual state to treat patients with the utmost effectiveness.
No patient suffers in their mind or body alone; these elements are irrevocably connected, and must be treated in tandem with one another. If we treat just one, we treat only half of a human.
It is an overhaul that begins with a restructuring of our understanding of health itself. As the
Professor Shadrick Mazaza is a specialist family medicine physician and past national chairperson of the South African Academy of Family Physicians.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mail & Guardian
13 hours ago
- Mail & Guardian
The warning labels that could be coming for your crisps
Decrypting the nutritional label on your favourite packaged food products might get easier sometime soon. But that doesn't mean you're going to like what it's going to say. (UNSPLASH) 'It's sort of hidden.' That's how 30-year-old Elvina Moodley describes the nutritional labels on the back of packaged food products stacked on grocery store shelves. 'When you're there, you're already in a rush and don't have the time to look at the small print on the back to see how much sugar or salt is in an item.' Moodley, like many South Africans, says she's never really understood how nutritional tables — the per serving amounts of calories, But big, bold triangle warning labels on the front of packages could mean making healthy choices will be a lot easier. South Africa's draft food labelling It would work, says Edzani Mphaphuli, executive director of the childhood nutrition nonprofit 'You might not know why smoking causes cancer, but when you see the label, you start to think, 'Okay, this might not be good for me,'' she says. 'But [many people] don't know that sugar causes cancer or that obesity is related to cancer. We just think about it as, 'I'm big,' and it ends there. There isn't a clear link that is made around that and hypertension (high blood pressure) and diabetes, and all of the other chronic diseases.' Why labels are hard to read Many familiar foods — from noodles and breakfast cereals to Currently, food labels in South Africa Even when it does appear, it's often in small writing and uses terms and measurements that an ordinary shopper would not understand, says Makoma Bopape, a nutrition researcher and lecturer at the 'It tells you how much of certain nutrients you get in, say, 100ml or in a serving size. But if you don't have a nutritional science [background] it's hard to know what that means.' That's why some countries have started to These labels help shoppers compare products, but they can also confuse them. A UK government A Chile warning Not all front-of-pack labels are equal. Research shows that clear warning signs that simply say the food is 'high in' sugar, salt or saturated fats are Chile was the first country to The result? After the regulations were enacted, Chileans bought In 2021, Chilean researchers Yet obesity rates continued to In France, manufacturers use what's called South Africa will use a similar system to Chile, but the label will come in the shape of a triangle. The warnings will cover between 10% and 25% of the front of the package, will be black on a white background and will be located in the top right corner. They will have the words 'high in' and 'warning' in bold, uppercase letters, next to an exclamation mark and an icon to represent the nutrient. This will help make the warning easier for people who can't read or don't speak English to understand. Because each nutrient will have its own warning symbol, if a product is high in more than one nutrient — or has any artificial sweeteners at all — a single package could carry up to four warning icons. 'They just want to fill their tummies' Still, what people — and their children — eat isn't always up to them, says Mphaphuli. 'Some parents can only afford cheap food that fills up the family the quickest, which limits their choice in what they consume.' In Most of these households are located outside of the metropolitan areas, where healthy, 'If in your spaza shop one apple costs the same as a bottle of highly concentrated juice that can be shared across days, you're going to go for the cheaper thing.' When people don't have enough types of food to choose from, they 'People say, 'At the beginning of the month, when I still have money, I get worried and I pay attention to what I buy. But as the month goes by, I just buy whatever I can afford,'' explains Bopape. 'They just want to fill their tummies.' Clear labelling alone won't be enough to reduce unhealthy eating, says Bopape. Warning signs need to go hand in hand with other policies such as sugar taxes, restrictions on advertising and the selling of unhealthy foods in and around schools. Moodley wishes healthy foods were more reasonably priced. But the warning labels will at least 'help us know what we're getting ourselves into'. This story was produced by the . Sign up for the .
The Herald
17 hours ago
- The Herald
No discussions with ZHRC about Zimbabweans denied access to healthcare services: public protector
The public protector's office has clarified it has not received complaints lodged by the Zimbabwe Human Rights Commission (ZHRC) regarding the denial of Zimbabwean nationals' access to healthcare services in South Africa. There has been a growing trend of advocacy groups such as Operation Dudula blocking illegal foreigners from receiving medical care. The small fringe group has been protesting outside clinics and hospitals, checking patients' nationalities and turning away non-South Africans. In a recent interview with Newzroom Afrika, ZHRC chairperson Jessie Majome said she had a conversation with public protector Kholeka Gcaleka about how the two countries can resolve the issue. 'This is not a new conversation. In September 2024 Gcaleka hosted the ZHRC for a benchmarking and learning visit,' Majome said. 'During the visit we agreed we want to come together and devise ways to come up with lasting solutions to ensure all human beings enjoy their rights freely.' The public protector's office said it did host the ZHRC delegation last year and no discussions were held about Zimbabweans being denied access to healthcare services in South Africa. 'The visit covered several issues commonly shared between institutions with a similar mandate, including but not limited to best practices within the environment, corruption and challenges relating to service delivery in the two countries, among those being healthcare systems,' the public protector's office said. 'Consequently, and on the request of the ZHRC, on October 14 the public protector of South Africa shared documents with the ZHRC that would assist to strengthen the ZHRC's institutional capacity to investigate malfeasance in its own country. At no point did the discussions then, or recently, focus on the denial of Zimbabwean nationals' access to healthcare services in South Africa. 'We are therefore surprised by reports in the media about discussions, which purportedly occurred recently, and were centred around matters relating to Zimbabwean nationals being denied access to healthcare services in South Africa, neither do we have record of a complaint of that kind.' TimesLIVE
The Herald
20 hours ago
- The Herald
Why SA men may reject male birth control pill
Tshimane Joseph Baloyi, a professional nurse working at Netcare Unitas Hospital, said many men are not ready to talk openly about sexual health. 'Most men don't want to discuss contraception; their pride and ego don't allow them to open up. They still think contraception is only a woman's responsibility, because women give birth. If male pills were introduced in clinics, I don't think they'd accept them easily. They'd say it's a woman's thing,' he said. However, he said he would take the pill if it was safe and affordable. 'It would make my life easier. I wouldn't have to rely on my partner to get the morning-after pill. I'd be in control. It's not fair when people say only women should take responsibility. 'If I don't pull out on time, she might fall pregnant. I produce thousands of sperm [and] it only takes one, so why must it always be her responsibility?' Though all three interviewees believe male birth control could change the way society thinks about family planning, they agree that South Africa isn't there yet. There's no training, no rollout plan and most importantly, no public readiness. For male contraceptives to work, they say the government must invest in education, build trust and shift outdated cultural beliefs. Until then, the male pill may remain just an idea. TimesLIVE
