Keir Starmer's approval among Scots at all-time low, STV News poll shows
This week marks one year in office for the first Labour PM in 14 years.
It comes as Starmer faces what could be the biggest rebellion by Labour MPs since he took over as leader.
The internal party split over welfare reforms has left Labour MPs in despair at the standard of political leadership from 10 Downing Street. STV News Satisfaction with leaders and opposition.
A new poll by Ipsos, in partnership with STV News, shows 64% of Scots are dissatisfied with Starmer's performance as Prime Minister.
Ipsos interviewed a representative sample of 1,066 adults between June 12 and June 18 – before the peak of the welfare cuts row and ahead of the Prime Minister's U-turn.
The Scottish Political Monitor reveals Starmer's approval ratings have 'fallen markedly' compared with a year ago, when his Labour Government won the 2024 general election in a landslide.
Only 22% of the Scottish public are satisfied with the way Starmer is doing his job, giving him a net-satisfaction rating of -42 in Scotland.
Among voters who supported Labour at the 2024 General Election, almost half (49%) say they are dissatisfied.
Starmer's ratings have also fallen behind Nigel Farage's. 24% say they are satisfied by the Reform UK leader's performance. Although he remains unpopular among the Scottish public, with 54% of Scots saying they are dissatisfied with him.
'These new results show how dramatically Scotland's political landscape has shifted compared with a year ago,' Emily Gray, managing director of Ipsos in Scotland, said.
'Reform UK have made significant strides in Scotland to become the third largest party in both Westminster and Holyrood voting intentions.
'While neither Nigel Farage nor Keir Starmer are popular amongst the Scottish public at present, Starmer's ratings have now fallen behind Farage's, far from the situation the Prime Minister would want as he marks his first anniversary in Downing Street this week.'
Reform UK is set to receive the third-largest share of the votes at the next Holyrood election, according to the poll.
While the SNP is currently leading on Scottish Parliament voting intentions, with 34% of voters saying they would vote for the party, 14% said they would vote for Nigel Farage's Reform.
The Scottish Political Monitor also reveals a change in fortunes for Labour, who are expected to lose seats but remain the second largest party at Holyrood with 23% of the vote.
'A key question for Labour is whether it will be able to win voter support back ahead of next May's Holyrood elections,' Ms Gray said.
'While the SNP will be pleased that the results show them leading on both Holyrood and Westminster voting intentions, there are also warning signs for the party.
'Their vote share still lags behind what the party achieved at the last Holyrood elections in 2021, and John Swinney's approval ratings are lower than they were a year ago.' STV News Which of the following do you see as the most important issues facing Scotland today?
Although a slight majority of Scots are in favour of independence, the latest poll suggests that it's not a major priority for voters, with it not appearing in the top ten most important issues facing the country.
Among those likely to vote either Yes or No in an immediate referendum, 52% say they would
vote Yes and 48% No.
However, the poll reveals that healthcare, the NHS, the cost of living, and public services all take precedence over independence for many voters.
Although it remains important for SNP voters.
50% of those who say they would use their constituency vote for the SNP mention it as a very important issue facing Scotland, compared to 24% of the public overall.
The NHS, the cost of living crisis, and issues with public services generally are seen by the public as the most important issues facing Scotland, according to the poll.
Respondents were asked to select subjects they considered to be the most important issues facing the country today.
The results were: Healthcare/NHS/hospitals (69%)
Inflation/rising cost of living (52%)
Public services generally (42%)
Lack of faith in politicians/political parties/system of government (41%)
Poverty/inequality (40%)
Education/schools (40%)
Economy/economic situation (37%)
Housing (37%)
Care for older and disabled people (36%)
Crime and anti-social behaviour/law and order (35%)
Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News
Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scotsman
35 minutes ago
- Scotsman
Disability benefit cuts: Sir Keir Starmer forced to make late concession in biggest Labour rebellion
Sir Keir Starmer was forced to abandon a key plank of his welfare reform agenda to get the legislation through its first Commons test. Sign up to our Politics newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... In a late climbdown as MPs prepared to vote, the UK government shelved plans last night to restrict eligibility for the personal independence payment (Pip), with any changes now only coming after a review of the benefit. The move will cause a headache for Chancellor Rachel Reeves, who has seen a forecast £4.8 billion saving from the welfare budget whittled away through a series of concessions, leaving her to seek extra money through spending cuts, tax hikes or borrowing to balance the books. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The decision to remove the Pip changes from the Universal Credit and Personal Independence Payment Bill was announced just 90 minutes before MPs voted. Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer delivers a speech during a reception for public sector workers, at 10 Downing Street, London. Picture: Carl Court/PA Wire The legislation cleared its first hurdle by 335 votes to 260 – a majority of just 75. Despite the late concession, there were 49 Labour rebels in what was the largest revolt so far of Sir Keir's premiership. Labour's Brian Leishman, the MP for Alloa and Grangemouth who was among the rebels, said ministers should still withdraw the Bill despite the legislation passing its second reading. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The Scottish MP had also voted in favour of a cross-party amendment that would have stopped the Bill before its second reading. Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer delivers a speech during a reception for public sector workers, at 10 Downing Street, London. Picture: Carl Court/PA Wire He said: 'Today was a prime example in how not to legislate. A shambolic afternoon with policy being made up off the cuff and on the notion of promises to come. 'The government should do the honourable and decent thing and withdraw this dreadful Bill.' Work and Pensions Secretary Liz Kendall insisted the Labour Party was '100 per cent' behind the Prime Minister, but acknowledged there were 'lessons to be learned' after the rebellion. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad She also appeared to express regret over the handling of the issue, saying: 'I wish we had got to this point in a different way.' The decision to remove key parts of the Bill is remarkable for a government with a working majority of 165 and after just under a year in office. This personal independence payments is devolved in Scotland as the adult disability benefit. But any cuts at UK-level would affect how much money the Scottish Government receives from the Treasury for the payments. Other Scottish Labour MPs who had opposed the original Bill had included Patricia Ferguson, Tracy Gilbert, Dr Scott Arthur, Kirsteen Sullivan, Richard Baker, Euan Stainbank, Lillian Jones, Elaine Stewart, Martin Rhodes and Irene Campbell. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Tory leader Kemi Badenoch accused ministers of 'utter capitulation' and said the legislation was now 'pointless'. She said: 'They should bin it, do their homework, and come back with something serious. Starmer cannot govern.' SNP Westminster leader Stephen Flynn said: "From start to finish, Labour's disability cuts Bill has been a shambles – and it defines their chaotic first year in office. "The cause of that chaos, and the blame for it, falls directly at the doors of Keir Starmer and Rachel Reeves. Tonight, the Labour Party owe an apology to disabled people. Their daily lives have been subjected to a cruel Westminster political game. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad "The final U-turn they deserve tonight is an apology from the Prime Minister and for this shambolic Bill to be scrapped. "The only option left for the Labour Party is to stop their attack on disabled people, remove the threat of a two-tier disability system and for them to finally scrap this bill." The government's concessions mean it will not make any savings as a result of its welfare reforms by 2029/30, but could in the longer term, think-tank Resolution Foundation said. The organisation's chief executive Ruth Curtice said: 'The government originally hoped to save £4.8bn from its welfare reforms in the crucial year of 29/30. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'The upshot of all the concessions this week is it will now not make any net savings in that year. The changes to universal credit are nonetheless important for recipients and their work incentives, and are expected to save money in the longer term.' Earlier, a Labour rebel attempt to halt the legislation was defeated by 179 votes. A total of 44 Labour MPs including two tellers backed the bid by rebel ringleader Rachael Maskell, who described the Bill as 'unravelling' and 'a complete farce'. A previous effort to kill the Bill had attracted more than 120 Labour supporters, but was dropped after the first partial U-turn on the legislation last week, which restricted the Pip changes to new claimants from November 2026. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad That date has now been abandoned in the latest climbdown, with any changes now only coming after disability minister Sir Stephen Timms' review of the Pip assessment process. Sir Stephen announced the climbdown in the middle of the debate on the legislation. He acknowledged 'concerns that the changes to Pip are coming ahead of the conclusions of the review of the assessment that I will be leading'. He said the government would now 'only make changes to Pip eligibility activities and descriptors following that review', which is due to conclude in the autumn of 2026. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The concession came after frantic behind-the-scenes negotiations in Westminster involving the Prime Minister, his Cabinet and wavering Labour MPs. Charlotte Gill, head of campaigns and public affairs at the MS Society, said: 'We thought last week's so-called concessions were last minute. But these panicked 11th hour changes still don't fix a rushed, poorly thought-out Bill.' But Jon Sparkes, chief executive of learning disability charity Mencap, said: 'The last-minute change relating to the review Sir Stephen Timms is leading sounds positive and we are pleased that the Government has listened.' He added: 'Disabled people should not have to pay to fix black holes in the public finances.' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The government's concessions have gutted the reforms, leaving only parts of the current Bill still on the table. Proposals to cut the health element of universal credit by almost 50 per cent for most new claimants from April 2026 remain in place, along with an above-inflation increase in the benefit's standard allowance.
The Herald Scotland
an hour ago
- The Herald Scotland
How Scottish MPs voted on Labour's welfare reform bill
It now moves to committee stage, where MPs will scrutinise and amend the legislation line by line. Scottish Labour MPs Irene Campbell, Tracy Gilbert, Brian Leishman, Euan Stainbank were among the 49 backbench rebels who voted against the legislation. Here is the full list of how Scottish MPs voted. Voted in favour Douglas Alexander (Labour) Zubir Ahmed, Dr (Labour) Richard Baker (Labour) Johanna Baxter (Labour) Torcuil Crichton (Labour) Scott Arthur, Dr (Labour) Gordon McKee (Labour) Martin McCluskey (Labour) Kirsty McNeill (Labour) Katrina Murray (Labour) Chris Kane (Labour) Lillian Jones (Labour) Chris Murray (Labour) Gregor Poynton (Labour) Patricia Ferguson (Labour) Frank McNally (Labour) Melanie Ward (Labour) Pamela Nash (Labour) Chris Murray (Labour) Elaine Stewart (Labour) Michael Shanks (Labour) Kenneth Stevenson (Labour) Graham Downie (Labour) Susan Murray (Labour) Joani Reid (Labour) Alan Gemmell (Labour) John Grady (Labour) Kirsteen Sullivan (Labour) Alison Taylor (Labour) Ian Murray (Labour) Martin Rhodes (Labour) Imogen Walker (Labour) Voted against Andrew Bowie (Conservative) Irene Campbell (Labour) Alistair Carmichael (Liberal Democrat) John Cooper (Conservative) Harriet Cross (Conservative) Dave Doogan (SNP) Stephen Flynn (SNP) Tracy Gilbert (Labour) Stephen Gethins (SNP) Maureen Burke (Labour) John Lamont (Conservative) Chris Law (SNP) Brian Leishman (SNP) Seamus Logan (SNP) Angus MacDonald (SNP) David Mundell (Conservative) Brendan O'Hara (SNP) Jamie Stone (Liberal Democrat) Euan Stainbank (Labour) Wendy Chamberlain (Liberal Democrat) Pete Wishart (SNP) Graham Leadbitter (SNP) Kirsty Blackman (SNP) Did not vote
Leader Live
an hour ago
- Leader Live
PM braced for revolt over welfare after defending his record of a year in power
Some 39 Labour MPs have indicated they will vote to halt an overhaul of the benefits system on Tuesday evening, though that number is far lower than the 83 needed to overturn the Prime Minister's working majority. However, more are expected to join them in what could be the largest revolt of Sir Keir's time in office. Ahead of the parliamentary showdown, the Prime Minister insisted at a meeting with his senior ministers that the Government could look back with a 'real sense of pride and achievement' as the July 5 anniversary of his first year in office nears. Ministers have given working people a 'chance to thrive, not just survive', Sir Keir also told the Cabinet meeting, according to a No 10 spokesman. Downing Street pointed to trade deals, economic growth, the extra long-term investment in the spending review, and a cut in NHS waiting lists among the Government's achievements one year on. The spokesman added: '(The Prime Minister) said the Government's work is all designed and focused on improving the lives of working people and giving them the chance to thrive, not just survive, and the Government should be proud of those achievements as a team.' Cabinet ministers, and even Sir Keir himself, were said to be involved in efforts to persuade Labour MPs not to join the rebels ahead of the crunch Commons debate. Ministers hope a partial U-turn on the benefit cuts, which will protect existing claimants of personal independence payments (Pip) and the health element of universal credit, will be enough to win over Labour rebels. As the second reading of the Universal Credit and Personal Independence Payment Bill began in the Commons, Work and Pensions Secretary Liz Kendall said reforms to the welfare system are needed to ensure its longevity. 'I do not believe that this is sustainable if we want a welfare state that protects people who most need our help for generations to come,' the senior minister said. She added: 'There is no responsibility in leaving our system of social security to continue as it is, and risk support for it becoming so frayed that it is no longer there to provide a safety net for those who can never work, and who most need our help and support.' To see off the threat of far greater rebellion by some 126 Labour MPs led by Treasury Committee chairwoman Dame Meg Hillier, the Government last week softened the impact of its changes to protect some 370,000 existing Pip claimants who had been set to lose out following reassessment. Ministers also committed to a review of the system, involving disabled people and led by disabilities minister Sir Stephen Timms, and unfreezing the higher universal credit rate for those already claiming the health-related element. As a result of the U-turn, the reforms are expected to save less than half the £5 billion the Government had expected from its initial proposals. In the Commons, Ms Kendall faced warnings the Timms review could be published after the reforms themselves are implemented. She insisted any changes to be made following the review will be done so 'as soon as is practically possible via primary or secondary legislation', though Downing Street would earlier not guarantee Sir Stephen's review would be completed by the time reforms are implemented. No 10 was also insistent that Government modelling, which predicts the welfare proposals will push 150,000 more people into poverty by 2030, was 'subject to uncertainty'. Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch said the Government's plans were 'driven not by principle but by panic'. Indicating that the Tories will not support the Government, Mrs Badenoch told the Commons: 'By 2030, on this Government's spending plans, we will hit £100 billion on health and disability benefits alone, that is more than what we spend on defence, and this should make everyone in this House stop and think, because this Bill does nothing to fix that problem, and that is why we cannot support it.' She described the Bill as a 'fudge', adding: 'A fundamental and serious programme to reform our welfare system is required, and this Bill is not it.' Rachael Maskell, the leading force of the rebellion which seeks to halt the Bill in its tracks on Tuesday night, urged MPs to join her in the voting lobbies. The York Central MP told the Commons: 'These Dickensian cuts belong to a different era and a different party. 'They are far from what this Labour Party is for, a party to protect the poor, as is my purpose, for I am my brother's keeper.' Ahead of the Commons debate, Ms Maskell indicated she believed 'many more' Labour MPs than the 39 who had signed her 'reasoned amendment' would join her in rebelling. The Liberal Democrats are also expected to back the rebel amendment, the party's work and pensions spokesman Steve Darling told the Commons. Ministers have been coy about whether rebel Labour MPs will face disciplinary action, with Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds telling broadcasters he was 'not aware' they would lose the party whip, but said 'those issues are for the chief whip'. Whatever people's views about the concessions, surely everyone can see the process here is ALL wrong? Third Reading in eight days? A timetable like that diminishes the role of MPs in getting this legislation right, shuts out disabled people and puts too many at risk. — Andy Burnham (@AndyBurnhamGM) July 1, 2025 Elsewhere, critic of the Bill Andy Burnham, the Labour Mayor of Greater Manchester, hit out at the parliamentary process it will undergo, claiming it was all wrong. On social media site X, he wrote: 'Third Reading in eight days? A timetable like that diminishes the role of MPs in getting this legislation right, shuts out disabled people and puts too many at risk.'
