With the touch of a finger, a Neanderthal may have made art
Researchers in Spain say they have found evidence that Neanderthals were capable of creating art — challenging the idea that art began with the modern humans who succeeded them.
The canvas was a quartz-rich granite pebble that was excavated from a rock shelter in central Spain in 2022, in a layer dating back between 42,000 and 43,000 years. Measuring more than 8 inches long, the pebble has curves and indentations that make it resemble a human face.
In the middle of its surface is a single red dot, right where a nose would be, researchers said in a study published Saturday in the journal Archaeological and Anthropological Sciences, adding that it appeared to be a non-utilitarian object rather than a tool.
'From the outset we could tell it was peculiar,' said David Álvarez-Alonso, lead author of the paper.
Analysis showed that the red dot consisted of ochre, a natural earth pigment. The next step was to determine how it got there.
While not visible to the naked eye, the red dot was confirmed by Spanish forensic police to be a fingerprint, leaving 'no doubt' that it was applied to the stone intentionally by a finger dipped in ochre, Álvarez-Alonso said in an email on Tuesday.
The researchers postulate that the Neanderthal, who based on the fingerprint was possibly an adult male, perceived the pebble as resembling a face — a psychological phenomenon known as pareidolia — and was inspired to complete the depiction, creating 'one of the oldest known abstractions of a human face in the prehistoric record.'
'It would be a clear act of symbolization — apparently very simple, yet meaningful,' Álvarez-Alonso said.
The discovery is 'doubly exceptional' since it's the 'most complete' Neanderthal fingerprint identified to date, apart from a partial one previously found in Germany, the researchers said.
Neanderthals, a distinct species that went extinct around 40,000 years ago, lived alongside early modern humans in Europe, Asia and the Middle East for at least part of their existence. Characterized by a large nose and relatively short and stocky bodies, the species is very closely related to humans, or Homo sapiens.
The remains of Neanderthals do not show clear evidence of lower intelligence than modern humans, some scientists have argued.
The stone is 'one of a small but growing number of discoveries that point to the existence of symbolic behavior among Neanderthals,' Álvarez-Alonso said.
However, it's 'clearly an isolated object, with no known parallels' that can be used for comparison, he added.
'We should not try to draw direct analogies between the Neanderthal and sapiens worlds,' Álvarez-Alonso said, as Neanderthals did not create a visual symbolic system as complex and diverse as the one developed by Homo sapiens.
'This pebble doesn't solve the mystery, but it offers one more clue suggesting the presence of a complex mind — one capable of producing symbols,' he said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
2 days ago
- Scottish Sun
Archaeologists discover 3,000-year-old LOST CITY featuring ‘remarkable' pyramids and canals
Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) AN ANCIENT Mayan city has been discovered by archaeologists in northern Guatemala, offering fresh insights into the historic civilisation. The nearly 3,000-year-old remains include remarkable pyramids and monuments that appear to be "sculpted with unique iconography". Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 6 Two anthropomorphic sculptures of human form or appearance that 'represent an ancestral couple' Credit: AFP 6 The archaeological site of the pre-Columbian Maya civilization in Tikal National Park, Guatemala Credit: Alamy 6 Temple I in the main plaza of Maya Archaeological Site of Tikal, Tikal National Park Credit: Getty 6 The city is likely to have been "one of the most ancient and important ceremonial centres" of Mayan civilisation Credit: AFP This ancient city, named Los Abuelos - the Spanish for "The Grandparents" - once stood around 21km from the significant archaeological site of Uaxactún, Guatemala's culture ministry said on Thursday. Los Abuelos gets its name from two human-like sculptures of an "ancestral couple" found there. These figures "could be linked to ancient ritual practices of ancestor worship", the ministry added. The city is likely to have been "one of the most ancient and important ceremonial centres" of Mayan civilisation. Monuments unearthed at the site have been dated to the Middle Preclassic period of 800-500 BC, while the city itself "presents remarkable architectural planning". The city covers an area of around six square miles and is found in Guatemala's northern Petén department. Researchers also found a 108 foot high pyramid nearby that had Preclassic murals and "a unique canal system". "Archaeological investigations have included the active participation of Guatemalan and international professionals, with the support of the Comenius University in Bratislava, Slovakia," a ministry spokesperson said. "This joint effort has allowed significant advancements in the exploration, conservation, and dissemination of the Mayan legacy." Three sites - Los Abuelos, Petnal and Cambraya - were unearthed through the country's ongoing Uaxactún Regional Archaeological Project. Rediscovering the Lost Maya City of Ocomtún (1) "These sites form a previously unknown urban triangle," a ministry spokesperson added. "These findings allow us to rethink the understanding of the ceremonial and socio-political organisation of pre-Hispanic Peten." Mayan civilisation rose around 2000 BC and reached its peak between 400 and 900 AD. It spanned across present-day southern Mexico and Guatemala, along with some parts of Belize, El Salvador and Honduras. The amazing new discovery comes after a 1,000-year-old altar from Mexico's ancient Teotihuacán culture was unearthed in April. It was painted with a mural of red, yellow, and blue - which are colours associated with that culture. This find was seen as suggesting evidence of possible contact between the two cultures. 6 The Pyramid at Calakmul, Mexico Credit: Getty
The Herald Scotland
3 days ago
- The Herald Scotland
Pebble with finger print suggests Neanderthal may have created art
The quartz-rich granite pebble included indentations resembling a face, its nose a Rudolph-like red dot visible at center. Significantly, the spot didn't appear to be random, instead bearing evidence indicating it was the product of someone's imagination. "The ocher dot does not appear as a shapeless addition or a mere stain," wrote lead author David Alvarez-Alonso of Madrid's Complutense University. "Rather, it contains a fingerprint that implies the pigment has been applied specifically with the tip of a finger soaked in pigment." The authors consider the artifact a nonutilitarian visual symbol - in other words, not a tool but an altered or marked object with possible symbolic significance. While its age makes it impossible to draw any definitive conclusions, they wrote, the stone could "represent one of the oldest known abstractions of a human face in the prehistoric record." ????Hemos resuelto un caso de 43.000 anos de antiguedad Se trata de la????huella dactilar mas antigua del mundo y nuestra Policia Cientifica ha logrado el hito de su identificacion por procedimientos no invasivos de teledeteccion junto a la @unicomplutense Ha sido fundamental el... — Policia Nacional (@policia) May 27, 2025 "The fact that the pebble was selected because of its appearance and then marked with ocher shows that there was a human mind capable of symbolizing, imagining, idealizing and projecting his or her thoughts on an object," they wrote. An expanding Neanderthal portfolio This isn't the first time a Neanderthal fingerprint has been pinpointed, the authors noted. A partial one, likely made by a thumb, was found on resin discovered in Germany in 1963. However, the discovery offers yet another dab of evidence suggesting that Neanderthals made art. In 2018, The Guardian reported archaeological findings in Spain indicating that Neanderthals used red ocher to produce shapes and symbols on cave walls 65,000 years ago. The species flourished from roughly 350,000 to 40,000 years ago, and studies indicate they and modern humans may have gone their separate ways as long as 800,000 years ago. Increasing evidence has indicated that Neanderthals were more advanced than once thought. In 2020, a paper published in the journal Science said evidence found in a coastal cave in Portugal suggested Neanderthals were skilled fishermen who regularly consumed seafood as part of their diet. Until then, only humans (Homo sapiens) had been thought to look to the sea as a food source. Meanwhile, the discovery of 176,000-year-old structures deep within a French cave hinted at Neanderthals' ability to use fire and work in groups. A 2016 article in Nature described strange, circular edifices constructed in an interior space 360 yards removed from daylight; the formations were made from uniform stalagmites, many of them cut to size. With the earliest known human-built structures 40,000 years old, the cave formations not only predate such activity by Homo sapiens but also show Neanderthal utilization of deep caves began much earlier as well. According to the study, the earliest indications of modern humans using deep caves are less than 42,000 years old.
Sky News
5 days ago
- Sky News
Neanderthals may have made art just like modern humans, say researchers
Neanderthals may have made art just like modern humans do, researchers in Spain have said. The findings, published in the Archaeological and Anthropological Sciences journal, challenge existing assumptions that art began with homo sapiens. Researchers said a pebble excavated from central Spain in 2022 seemed to have been made to look like a face by having a painted dot where a nose would be – suggesting it may be an early artwork. "It has gradually been determined that the origin of symbolic behaviour and apparently also of art was not exclusive to modern humans but can also be attributed to Neanderthals," the researchers said. "From the outset, we could tell it was peculiar," David Alvarez-Alonso, lead author on the paper, told Sky News' US partner NBC News. The pebble dates back between 42,000 and 43,000 years and was found in the San Lazaro rock shelter in modern-day Segovia. It was thought to have been deliberately brought to the shelter and found in a space where humans lived. The red dot was confirmed by Spain 's forensic police to be a fingerprint, offering another level to the discovery, as it is one of the most complete Neanderthal fingerprints identified to date. "This pebble could thus represent one of the oldest known abstractions of a human face in the prehistoric record," the researchers said. They added: "The pebble was selected because of its appearance and then marked with ochre [showing] that there was a human mind capable of symbolising, imagining, idealising and projecting his or her thoughts on an object... in creating art." Neanderthals were a distinct species of early humans that went extinct around 40,000 years ago but lived alongside modern humans in Europe, Asia and the Middle East.
