
‘Housewife puts heart, soul, sweat for family': MACT recognises homemaker's contribution, awards `20L in compensation ruling
Observing that a housewife puts her 'heart, soul and sweat to serve her family… 24 hours a day and seven days a week', the Motor Accident Claim Tribunal (MACT) of Chandigarh has has awarded Rs 20.06 lakh to a deceased woman's family.
The tribunal, presided by Dr Harpreet Kaur, was hearing a plea filed by Gurbachan Singh (husband of the deceased), two minor children, and Harbans Kaur and Baljit Singh (parents of the deceased). The plea sought compensation of Rs 35 lakh, on account of death of Sukhwinder Kaur, 32, in a motor vehicular accident.
According to the plea, on March 28, 2019, Sukhwinder, along with her husband, was going on foot to village Bahadurgarh after paying obeisance in Sheetla Meta temple situated at Sundra village. At about 7 pm, when they reached the area of Nimbua village, Sushil Kumar, who was riding a motorcycle, came from behind at a high speed and hit Sukhwinder, the plea said. As a result, she fell down on the road and suffered multiple injuries including head injury, due to which she died.
According to the complainant, Sukhwinder was a housewife, and the petitioners are entitled to receive the compensation of Rs 35 lakh on account of 'love, care, affection and multifarious services' given by the deceased woman to the claimants.
The driver of the motorcycle, Sushil Kumar, failed to appear before court, despite being issued notice, therefore was proceeded against ex parte in 2021. Upon notice, the insurance company — United India Insurance Company Limited appeared — through its counsel filed a written statement, in which it raised preliminary objections regarding maintainability, and while denying all the material averments having bearing on the amount of compensation, prayed for the dismissal of the claim petition.
The tribunal, in view of the recitals of the FIR, the postmortem report, and testimony of Gurbachan Singh (an eye witness to the accident), said that it 'stands amply established that the accident had taken place, due to rash and negligent driving of offending vehicle which was being driven by Kumar, and the same resulted into death of Sukhwinder'.
On the income of the deceased, the tribunal noted that it is claimed by the claimant that at the time of her death, the victim woman was a housewife and rendering multifarious services including household services to the claimants.
'No doubt, all these services can be performed by a maid servant. However, it would not be fair to equate the services of a wife with that of a maid as the former puts her heart, soul and sweat to serve her family and that too 24 hours a day and seven days a week. Therefore, the claimants are entitled to adequate compensation in lieu of the loss of gratuitous services rendered by the deceased,' the tribunal held.
It also cited a matter decided by the Punjab and Haryana High Court in 2014, in which the court had fixed the notional income of the deceased housewife as Rs 9,000 per month, while observing that housewife is something more than a 'mere skilled worker and it would be unreasonable to underestimate the contribution of her as housewife'.
Keeping the notional annual income of the deceased as Rs 9,000 and further adding other expenses, the tribunal ordered the insurance company to pay Rs 20.06 lakh to the claimants of the deceased. However, it clarified that though the insurance company has a right to recover the claim amount from the owner-insured and the driver of the motorcycle (Raj Kumar and Sushil Kumar).
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Time of India
14 minutes ago
- Time of India
Bank fraud case: Court rejects plea of accused to take part in trial without bail
Kanpur: Special Judge Companies Act Azad Singh on Tuesday rejected the plea of two accused who sought permission to appear and participate in the trial of Rs 7,820 crore bank fraud case without seeking bail. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now The judicial official not only dismissed their application but also ordered that a date be fixed every week in the case. June 17 has been fixed as the next date of hearing. The accused applicants, Sunil Verma and Anoop Kumar Verma, had submitted an application before the court to allow their participation in the trial. Kaushal Kishore Sharma, special prosecutor for the case, strongly opposed the plea, stating that without obtaining bail they can not be allowed to participate in the proceedings. The Companies Act contains special provisions regarding bail, which override those in the Cr PC. Consequently, the judicial official dismissed the application and fixed June 17 as the next date of hearing. Sharma stated that the Serious Fraud Investigation Office had lodged a complaint against 69 accused on behalf of several banks in bank fraud amounting to Rs 7,820 crore. Some name and famed persons of the city were also implicated in the case while as many as 20 accused were residing abroad and their files had been separated from the main case. Sharma mentioned that the court had already issued a non-bailable warrant against the accused, Satish Chandra Gupta, who is living abroad. The two accused Sunil Verma and Anoop Kumar Badhera had approached the apex court, where an order was passed that no coercive action should be taken against them, although their application is still pending. On Monday last, they moved an application before the court, which was dismissed. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now One of the accused, Vikram Kothari, has died, while others such as Rahul Kothari, builder Vishwanath Gupta, industrialist Suyash Desari and others have obtained bail orders in their favour from the apex court. The special prosecutor added that both accused have also applied for permission to travel abroad, and the court has reserved its order on that prayer. Speaking with TOI, the special prosecutor stated that the accused had formed a company for mercantile trading. They acquired a letter of credit from a bank, claiming that the company would purchase rice from one country and sell it in another. However, they used the funds for personal gains and only displayed sales and purchases on paper. The corporate ministry detected the nexus and ordered the Serious Fraud Investigation Office to lodge a complaint in the Companies Act court in 2020. Kanpur has the Companies Act court, which is the only one in Uttar Pradesh.


Time of India
14 minutes ago
- Time of India
42-year-old man commits suicide in Sajeti
Kanpur: A 42-year-old man took his own life by hanging in the Sajeti area on Monday, following alleged harassment from the police and his in-laws. The family claimed that after his wife filed a complaint, the station in-charge physically assaulted him and extracted Rs 15,000 from the family through the forced sale of their harvest before his release. The man ended his life after returning home. The local MLA visited the site and demanded strict action against the accused police officials. Subsequently, DCP (South) Deependra Nath Chowdhary suspended the sub-inspector and constable, while ordering serious charges against them along with the deceased's wife and father-in-law. Jeetu Nishad from Kotra village in the Sajeti police station area was employed in the private sector in Surat, Gujarat. He lived with his wife Suman and their three daughters. Having stayed in the village for approximately three months, Jeetu recently had a disagreement with his wife, who subsequently moved to her parents' house in Birbal Akbarpur. According to Jeetu's father, Ramesh, a few days ago, when Jeetu visited his in-laws to bring back his family, he faced physical and verbal abuse. Upon police notification, Jeetu endured mistreatment at the Kotra village police post on Sunday. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Free Chess. No Ads. Just Fun Play Classic Chess Install Now Undo The police then demanded Rs 15,000 for his release, which was arranged by selling wheat. Dejected over this, Jeetu returned home the same day and ended his life in his room. After Jeetu's father informed MLA Saroj Kureel about the incident and sought action against the police and in-laws, the DCP South visited Kotra village late at night. He suspended SI Gaurav Sahooliya and head constable Ravi. DCP said, "A case was registered at Sajeti police station against the accused officers, Jeetu's father-in-law Ram Kishore, and his wife Suman under serious charges. Further investigations are on. "


Time of India
14 minutes ago
- Time of India
Four held in Cachar with Rs 45cr drugs
Silchar: Police seized drugs valued at approximately Rs 45 crore and arrested four individuals in Cachar district. The recovery was announced by CM Himanta Biswa Sarma on 'X' handle on Monday evening, reports BB Goswami. The CM said during two successful anti-narcotics operations, Cachar police confiscated 1.5 lakh Yaba tablets valued at Rs 45 crore. The operations were reportedly carried out based on credible intelligence, leading to the arrest of four suspects involved in the drug trade. While the CM highlighted the success of the operation and reaffirmed Assam's commitment to combating drug abuse, Cachar police is yet to release an official statement. Silchar: Police seized drugs valued at approximately Rs 45 crore and arrested four individuals in Cachar district. The recovery was announced by CM Himanta Biswa Sarma on 'X' handle on Monday evening, reports BB Goswami. The CM said during two successful anti-narcotics operations, Cachar police confiscated 1.5 lakh Yaba tablets valued at Rs 45 crore. The operations were reportedly carried out based on credible intelligence, leading to the arrest of four suspects involved in the drug trade. While the CM highlighted the success of the operation and reaffirmed Assam's commitment to combating drug abuse, Cachar police is yet to release an official statement.