11 Actors Who Were Fired, Quit, Or Flat-Out Left Massively Popular TV Shows...And Then Came Back

Buzz Feed

20-02-2025

Just because a beloved actor leaves a hit TV show doesn't mean they're gone forever. Here are 11 famous celebs who eventually returned to shows they once starred on, and the reasons for their comebacks are both deeply personal and truly fascinating:
1. Natasha Rothwell on The White Lotus
Natasha starred in Season 1 of The White Lotus as Belinda, the spa manager in Hawaii. She didn't appear in Season 2, but she was the first cast member announced for the third season, which is set in Thailand. Natasha told the Hollywood Reporter last year that her return was series creator Mike White's idea. He'd reached out to her while finishing Season 2.
"I told him I'd follow him anywhere, and I meant it. I didn't know where the shoot or the storyline were, it was just a yes," she said.
Steve Carell starred in the first seven seasons of The Office, leaving the show ahead of Season 8 to pursue other career opportunities. He returned for a guest appearance in the series finale at the end of Season 9.
"It was time for other characters to step to the forefront and other storylines to be pursued. I think it was the right. The timing was right," he said on the Office Ladies podcast, hosted by his co-stars Jenna Fischer and Angela Kinsey. In a separate episode of the podcast, Jenna said, "Steve was reluctant" to return for the finale, noting he felt his character's story "had really ended." However, he was convinced to return by series creator Greg Daniels.
Christopher Abbott starred as Marnie (Allison Williams)'s college boyfriend, Charlie, in the first two seasons of Girls. He left the show because he couldn't relate to his character.
He returned for one episode in Season 5, where Charlie and Marnie run into each other and learn of the different directions their lives have taken. The idea for his return came from series creators Lena Dunham and Jenni Konner. "It attacked the idea of, in New York especially, after years, people change. People go through weird shifts. It was fun to poke fun at that," Chris told Vanity Fair in 2019 of his return.
Damon Wayans Jr. starred in the New Girl pilot but left the show before Season 1 aired because he was already committed to starring in another TV show, Happy Endings, which got picked up for a second season at ABC. When Happy Endings finished its three-season run, Damon returned to New Girl.
"There weren't as many rooms when they shot the pilot," Damond told the New York Times in 2013 of returning to New Girl. "It was weird not knowing where stuff was."
FOX / Via youtube.com
Patrick J. Adams starred in the first seven seasons of Suits but left to focus on his personal life. He appeared again in the show's ninth and final season.
"I was in a zone of living a pretty unexamined life, was pretty miserable, was pretty depressed, and I didn't have the tools to deal with that depression beyond just spending money and drinking too much, and not really knowing how to talk about it," Patrick said last of his departure while appearing on Jesse Tyler Ferguson's podcast. As for why he returned, he told Entertainment Tonight in 2019 that wanted to "do one last trip around the world."
6. Sarah Silverman on Saturday Night Live
Sarah Silverman starred on SNL for one season, from 1993 to 1994. Though she wasn't back for the next season, she returned to host an episode in 2014. She also participated in the show's 40th and 50th anniversaries. The latter occurred earlier this month.
"I don't think I was ahead of my time. I may have been, shortly after, when I kind of realized stuff, after I had failed that experience. I think coming out of that and going back into stand-up and just going back to square one was what really took me to where I was meant to be. But that experience was so important," Sarah told GQ in January of her year on the show.
7. Nina Dobrev on The Vampire Diaries
Nina Dobrev starred in the first six seasons of The Vampire Diaries before announcing she'd leave the show after her six-year contract expired. She went on to guest appear in the following and final two seasons, including the series finale.
"That was the plan from the get-go," she told Harper's Bazaar in 2017 of exiting after Season 6. "If anything, the fact that [leaving] terrified me drove me even more. I needed to feel that fear of 'Oh, my God, what if I never get a job again?' That just made me want to work five times as hard to make sure that didn't happen."
8. Robert Downey Jr. on Saturday Night Live
Robert Downey Jr. starred for one season on SNL from 1985 to 1986. A decade later, he returned to host in 1996.
"I learned so much in that year about what I wasn't. I was not somebody who was going to come up with a catchphrase. I was not somebody who was going to do impressions. I was somebody who was very ill-suited for rapid-fire sketch comedy," he said on Off Camera with Sam Jones in 2019.
9. Adam Sandler on Saturday Night Live
The comedian starred on SNL from 1990 to 1995 and became known for his parody songs and characters like Opera Man. However, he was fired alongside Chris Farley and several others in a cast overhaul, telling the Hollywood Reporter in 2022 that new people at the network didn't "like" either of them. There doesn't seem to be much bad blood as Adam has returned to the show several times, including as a host in 2019. He also appeared in the show's 25th, 40th, and 50th anniversaries.
In fact, during Sandler's host monologue in 2019, he directly addressed his firing live on air in a spoof song titled "I Was Fired."
10. T.R. Knight on Grey's Anatomy
T.R. Knight was part of the original Grey's Anatomy cast, starring in the first five seasons alongside Ellen Pompeo, Sandra Oh, Patrick Dempsey, and Katherine Heigl. After feeling his character's storyline had hit a wall, he exited the show. This also came following headline-making workplace struggles a few seasons prior. He returned for a guest appearance in a dream sequence in Season 17.
"[My husband and I] were talking about that idea of closure, and he was saying that sometimes closure's shutting a door, and sometimes it's revisiting a familiar room, and finding what brought you joy. And it just hit me," T.R. told Vanity Fair in 2020 of returning to the show.
11. Finally, Patrick Dempsey on Grey's Anatomy
Patrick was also an OG Grey's star and stuck around full-time through Season 11. In 2016, he told People he left the show because "there was a cost," including long hours and a major time commitment. "It had been long enough. It was time for me to move on with other things and other interests. I probably should have moved on a couple of years earlier. I stayed a bit longer than I should have," he said.
Which of these actors' exits and returns surprised you the most? And who would you add to this list? Let us know in the comments below!