As a senior police officer I saw first hand how the war on drugs fails
Even we in the police have our own: Keeping People Safe. It's etched on the sides of patrol cars and echoed in briefings. Some vehicles even boast a slightly tweaked version – Keeping Communities Safe – as if that changes the reality on the ground. But is it true? Or is it just another sound bite crafted by comms departments and PR consultants?
READ MORE: Is Westminster stopping Scotland from tackling the drugs death crisis?
A new report lays bare a disturbing truth, one with particular weight here in Scotland. It reveals a cruel irony – when police successfully disrupt drug supply chains, more people die.
Seizing heroin, dismantling county lines operations, jailing mid-level dealers – these are still branded as 'wins.' But the aftermath tells a darker story. Users, cut off from familiar sources, turn to the streets, to the unknown, to the dangerous. And they die.
In communities such as Glasgow and Dundee, and throughout parts of the Highlands and islands, drug-related deaths have reached catastrophic levels.
Scotland has one of the highest drug death rates in Europe. That isn't just a grim statistic, it's a national shame. It's a stain on our conscience. Or should be.
We must confront an uncomfortable reality: We're not keeping people safe. We're sending a fire engine to douse the flames while pouring petrol on the blaze.
When we ramp up the so-called War on Drugs, the market doesn't vanish. It mutates. Violence erupts. Turf wars escalate.
Vulnerable users are forced to navigate a shifting and deadly underground economy, one increasingly filled with synthetic poisons and unpredictable cutting agents. Dealers adapt faster than we can react, flooding communities with ever more lethal products. And while we chase headlines, people die in alleyways, closes, public toilets. Families bury their loved ones and grieve in silence, again and again. This isn't what we signed up for. Most officers don't join the force to feed a policy that kills the very people we're sworn to protect.
We sign up to serve. To stand between harm and the public. But the system now demands we play a part in something broken, a relentless cycle of raids, seizures, and arrests that achieves nothing except body counts.
IF we truly mean Keeping People Safe, we need to ask: safe from what? From drugs? From crime? From grief? Right now, they're not safe from any of it.
The solution doesn't lie in tougher sentences or bigger hauls. We've tried that. It failed. The answer lies in a public health approach, rooted not in punishment but in compassion, evidence and common sense.
We need to expand safe consumption spaces, such as the long-delayed but now operational pilot in Glasgow. We must flood the streets not with raids but with naloxone. We must back recovery services with real resources, not lip service. And, above all, we must end the criminalisation of addiction. Addiction is an illness, not a moral failing. You can't arrest your way out of a health crisis.
We stand at a crossroads. One road continues this tired, tragic pantomime of punishment and PR. The other leads to reform. To regulation. To treating drug use for what it really is – a complex public health issue requiring bold, grown-up decisions.
READ MORE: The illegal drugs trade affects the lives of everyone
We have the power to choose. We can continue with the same course – more slogans, more bodies, more shame. Or we can change direction and begin to save lives.
If Keeping People Safe is more than a motto, if it's a promise, then it's time to prove it.
Simon McLean is a former serious crime and drugs squad officer who infiltrated crime gangs nationwide. He is a spokesperson for LEAP (Scotland) and co-host of the true crime podcast Crime Time Inc with former deputy chief constable Tom Wood. Both are published authors and outspoken advocates for evidence-based drug policy reform
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Metro
12 hours ago
- Metro
US hitwoman who dressed in niqab for botched assassination guilty of murder plot
An American woman who wore a niqab disguise and tried to shoot a stranger dead in the street only for the gun to jam is facing a life sentence. Aimee Betro, 45, was flown to the UK from Wisconsin by Mohammed Aslam, 59, and Mohammed Nabil Nazir, 31, who orchestrated the murder plot to settle a 'vendetta' with a rival family in Birmingham in September 2019. The city's crown court heard the father and son wanted 'revenge' against Aslat Mahumad after they were beaten up at his clothing boutique a year earlier. Betro donned the disguise and lay in wait outside Mr Mahumad's home on September 7 before approaching his son Sikander Ali, with CCTV showing her raising her arm and pulling the trigger at point-blank range. Fortunately, Mr Ali managed to flee when the gun jammed and jurors heard Betro returned hours later and fired three shots into the family home, which was empty at the time. It took jurors 21 hours to convict Betro of conspiracy to murder, possessing a self-loading pistol with intent to cause fear of violence, and a charge of illegally importing ammunition. Betro, who work a purple T-shirt and with her hair in space buns, stared towards the jury bench as the verdicts were returned. She was found guilty by majority 11-1 verdicts on the conspiracy to murder and firearm charges, and by a unanimous verdict on the ammunition charge. Nazir and Aslam were jailed at the same court in November last year for their part in the plot, with the younger man given 32 years and his dad 10. Betro flew back to the US days after the bungled assassination attempt and was later extradited to the UK. She was found guilty of conspiracy to murder, possessing a self-loading pistol and a charge of fraudulently evading the prohibition on importing ammunition today. The court was told she was involved in another of Nazir's plots when she sent three parcels of gun parts and ammunition to the UK a month later. They were addressed to a man named Faris Quayum, who Nazir was hoping to frame by tipping police off to the delivery. Prosecutor Tom Walkling KC told jurors: 'The prosecution say that the evidence in this case is compelling and strong. 'Aimee Betro was the would-be assassin on September7, 2019. 'She was the shooter on Measham Grove in the early hours of the next day, and she was the person who furthered another of Nazir's vendettas when she sent ammunition to the UK in October 2019.' Betro denied any involvement in the failed hit, telling the court she flew to the UK to celebrate her birthday and go to a boat party. She also maintained that a woman described as having an American accent and being small and fat, who bought a BMW linked to the plot, was not her. Betro suggested it must have been 'another American woman' who sounded like her, used her phone and had almost identical trainers on. More Trending The fact she happened to be around the corner from the shooting minutes later was 'all just a terrible coincidence', she added. Cross-examining Betro, Mr Walkling said: 'So there must be, on your case, another American woman in Birmingham at the same time as you, who knew Mr Nazir, who sounded similar to you, who used the cheap phone that you bought, who called (a taxi firm) on your own telephone, and who wore at the very least the same sort of Converse trainers you had.' Betro answered: 'Yes.' She will be sentenced later. Get in touch with our news team by emailing us at webnews@ For more stories like this, check our news page. MORE: Man and woman arrested after one-year-old girl dies after suffering 'serious injuries' MORE: British granddad who 'tried to drown daughter-in-law in pool' pleads to be freed MORE: Three people killed after man 'in an Hawaiian shirt' opens fire outside Target store in Austin, Texas
Scottish Sun
12 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
US hitwoman in burka disguise GUILTY of plotting to murder Birmingham shop owner in botched assassination bid
Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) A US hitwoman who disguised herself in a burka to murder a shop owner in a botched assassination plot is facing jail. Aimee Betro was hired by Mohammed Nazir, 30, and Mohammed Aslam, 56, to kill the head of a rival family. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 10 Aimee Betro was captured firing the weapon in the failed assassination attempt 10 The wannabe hitwoman disguised herself in a burka Credit: PA 10 She has now been convicted over the plot Credit: Social media The 44-year-old travelled to Birmingham, West Midlands, and disguised herself under a burka to carry out the contract hit. But when she pointed the gun at Sikander Ali's head and pulled the trigger, the weapon jammed and the target was able to flee. Undeterred, she later went to Sikander's home and fired three shots before flying back to America. Betro has now been convicted over the botched bid following a trial at Birmingham Crown Court. Nazir and Aslam were previously jailed for a total of 42 years after they were found guilty of conspiracy to murder. The pair hatched the plot following a fight at a boutique clothing store in 2018. Both Nazir and Aslam harboured a grudge against Aslat Mahumad and his family after they came off worse in the scuffle. Hell-bent on revenge, they enlisted the help of the hitwoman - flying her over from the US so she could execute him or a loved one. CCTV showed Betro lying in wait outside the shop owner's family home in a Mercedes she had bought earlier that day. Around 45 minutes later, Aslat's son Sikander arrived home - with Betro leaving her car with her face covered. She was seen firing the gun at point-blank range before it jammed during the September 2019 attack. Sikander then escaped by reversing his SUV out of the road, clipping the car door of the BMW and damaging it so badly it would no longer close. After the failed shooting, Betro messaged Aslat asking him where he was hiding. She added: "Stop playing hide and seek, you are lucky it jammed." Betro later returned to the scene in a taxi and fired three shots through the windows of Aslat's home. The damaged Mercedes was later found dumped, with cops finding a black glove with Betro's DNA on it. Meanwhile, Betro fled to Manchester Airport and was back in the US the following day. A global hunt was launched for Betro, who had taken selfies before the shooting, and she was arrested in Armenia. She denied conspiracy to murder, possession of a firearm with intent to cause fear or violence and smuggling of ammunition into the UK. Betro will be sentenced at a later date. 10 Betro flew in from the US to carry out the botched hit 10 She was seen checking into a Birmingham hotel Credit: PA 10 She travelled to her intended victim's home and blasted it three times Credit: SWNS 10 Thankfully no one was at home at the time Credit: SWNS 10 Mohammed Nazir was found guilty of conspiracy to murder last year Credit: PA 10 He and his dad wanted 'revenge' on Aslat Mahumad Credit: PA
The Guardian
12 hours ago
- The Guardian
Trump will ignore crime reduction data for the political value of a show of force
'They fought back against law enforcement last night, and they're not going to be fighting back long,' Donald Trump said of young people on a 'rampage through city streets' at his press conference this morning. 'See, they fight back until you knock the hell out of them, because it's the only language they understand.' Lay this comment against a series of executive orders about law enforcement and civil rights that the president has issued over the last seven months, and one consequence of the federalization of police in Washington DC becomes evident: Trump will ignore measured effectiveness in reducing crime for the political value of a show of force. 'There is no public safety emergency warranting the deployment of the national guard on DC streets or the federalization of the city's police force,' said Ryan Downer, legal director of the Washington Lawyers Committee for Civil Rights and Urban Affairs, a Washington DC-based civil rights group that has litigated police brutality cases. Noting a sharp decrease in violent crime – reaching a 30-year low this year – Downer said that federalizing control of the district 'is an invitation for abuse. When you try to solve a problem of criminal behavior with overpolicing and harsher penalties … you see increases in police violence and police harassment. It's a call at the highest levels for police lawlessness.' Downer said his group would be vigilantly looking for stories to share about police abuses over the term of federal control of the district's police. But accountability under these conditions is complicated. Police officers almost anywhere else in the US are constrained both by state and federal law. If a local cop in New York or Los Angeles brutalizes someone in the course of an arrest, they can be arrested by either state or local police, and accountable to a state court and a prosecutor elected by local voters. Uniquely in the US, a serious felony in Washington DC is prosecuted not by the elected attorney general for the district, but by a federal prosecutor appointed by the president – Jeanne Pirro, TV judge turned US attorney for the District of Columbia. And a crime prosecuted in that federal court can be pardoned by the president, as we saw with the convictions of rioters from the January 6 insurrection. 'This is ultimately a problem of DC not having statehood,' said Monica Hopkins, executive director of the ACLU of Washington DC. The city council passes laws covering the district and the mayor controls the police force, but the president can declare an emergency that gives him control for 30 days, she said. 'He is acting under a pretextual emergency and extending the sort of blatant abuse of power over DC in a way that he could not do in any other jurisdiction as of right now.' Local organizations said they view Trump's declaration as yet another reason to call for statehood. 'Statehood is the only path to real accountability and local control. Without it, the current administration will continue to treat us as powerless and deploy power over us,' said Clinique Chapman, CEO of the DC Justice Lab. 'This latest overreach mirrors nationwide efforts to disempower Black-led cities, elected officials and prosecutors, while leaving federal agencies, unaccountable to our residents, in control of our justice system.' Violent crime is higher in Washington DC than the national average. But it is not among the most violent large cities in the United States today, and the number of incidents have been falling in Washington DC for about two years. Trump cited figures during the press conference from 2023, while ignoring precipitous drops in most categories of violent crime since. Violent crime overall was at a 30-year low on the day Trump took office this January. Decrying local leaders who 'demonize' and 'handcuff' aggressive police, Trump issued an executive order in April, Strengthening And Unleashing America's Law Enforcement To Pursue Criminals And Protect Innocent Citizens, calling for the federal government to withdraw its support for consent decrees and other federal oversight on civil rights and police brutality and for city to 'unleash high-impact local police forces'. Then he went on to test out the experiment in California. Over the objections of California governor Gavin Newsom, Trump called in nearly 5,000 national guard troops and to guard federal property in Los Angeles, a move facing a three-day hearing today for Newsom's federal court challenge. But Trump has also called in the national guard in Washington DC in the past. Troops were present during protests against police brutality in the summer of 2020. US park police dispersed hundreds of demonstrators in Lafayette Park in front of the White House during the protests using chemical irritants, rubber bullets, smoke bombs, flash grenades and a baton charge. The federal government settled an ACLU lawsuit over the dispersal of peaceful protesters at Lafayette Park in 2022, agreeing to policy changes that restrict park police from arbitrarily withdrawing demonstration permits, allowing protesters to leave safely and to identify themselves clearly, and modifying Secret Service policy to make clear that uses of force and dispersals are not normally justified by the unlawful conduct of some individuals in a crowd. At the press conference on Monday, Trump seemed to ignore that completely and talked about the conduct of protesters writ large as justification for police violence. 'They're standing and they're screaming at them an inch away from their face, and then they start spitting in their face,' Trump said. 'And I said: 'You tell them you spit and we hit,' and they can hit real hard … People are spitting in their face, and they're not allowed to do anything, but now they are allowed to do whatever the hell they want.' The downward trend in violence in Washington is consistent with what's being reported in other large cities across the country, according to statistical tracking by the Council on Criminal Justice. But that may not matter if the president is ignoring data in favor of ideology and bluster. 'He made some pretty bold statements that I think should concern everyone in the country at that press conference,' Hopkins said. 'DC is being done now, but he is looking at other cities, right? He just can move more swiftly with DC.'
