North West Company accused of holding on to subsidy money in proposed class-action suit
The federal government started the Nutrition North program in 2011 to help residents in northern communities, where food prices can be significantly higher than in the south, access nutritious food. The subsidy is applied to a list of food items and hygiene products in 125 remote communities.
A statement of claim filed before the Court of King's Bench in Manitoba on Feb. 5 calls North West Company, a multinational Canadian grocery company based in Winnipeg, "outrageous" and "predatory" for not passing 100 per cent of the subsidy on to consumers, as it's supposed to.
North West Company's retail locations include 188 Northern stores and five NorthMart stores across northern Canada, according to its website.
"[North West Company]'s misconduct has caused — and will cause, if allowed to continue — a reduction in health and well-being outcomes for class members," the claim reads. It goes on to list a series of health problems related to poor nutrition, including obesity, cardiovascular disease and diabetes.
The lawsuit has not yet been certified by a judge, nor have the allegations been proven in court.
Red seedless grapes at a grocery store in Nain, N.L., shows an example of how the Nutrition North subsidy is displayed. The price tag shows that before the subsidy was applied, they would have cost $15.65. After the subsidy, they were $11.99. (Ariana Kelland/CBC)
Former Nunavut commissioner Nellie Kusugak, film producer and social advocate Malaya Qaunirq Chapman and artist and cultural educator Isabelle Chapadeau are the plaintiffs on the statement of claim.
The claim says because the full subsidy isn't being passed down to consumers, they've had to spend more money for healthy food — meaning they couldn't spend it on other things like housing, transportation and childcare.
North West Company declined to do an interview with CBC News about the proposed class-action lawsuit.
In a statement emailed to the Winnipeg Sun, a spokesperson for the company denied the allegations and said that it works with Nutrition North Canada and participates in third-party audits that ensure 100 per cent of the funds are passed on to consumers.
Tim Dickson, one of the lawyers representing the plaintiffs in the statement of claim, said the purpose of the proposed class action lawsuit is to get compensation for northerners and to put pressure on the federal government to improve the Nutrition North Program. (Daniel Ha)
The statement of claim cites a 2023 study that found overall only 67 per cent of the subsidy was being passed on to consumers. In communities where North West Company has a monopoly, the study found that just 53 per cent of the subsidy was passed on.
Tim Dickson of JFK Law in Vancouver is one of the lawyers representing the plaintiffs. He told CBC News the 2023 study uses data that isn't publicly available, but that through the court process North West Company would be required to provide information about how the subsidy works.
"To really litigate this claim, we will need expert evidence of economists based on a whole lot of data that the North West Company will have to disclose," he said.
Also at issue is how North West Company markets the subsidy. When you enter one of its stores, certain items have price tags indicating the price before and after the subsidy is applied.
Dickson said the allegation is that the original price is inflated, so that the price the consumer actually pays doesn't use up the entire subsidy.
The purpose of the proposed lawsuit is twofold, said Dickson. It aims to get compensation for Northerners and to put pressure on the federal government to improve the Nutrition North program.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hill
31 minutes ago
- The Hill
Air Canada reaches deal with flight attendant union to end strike as operations will slowly restart
TORONTO (AP) — Air Canada said it will gradually restart operations after reaching an agreement early on Tuesday with the union for 10,000 flight attendants to end a strike that disrupted the travel plans of hundreds of thousands of travelers. The agreement came after Canada's biggest airline and the union resumed talks late Monday for the first time since the strike began over the weekend, affecting about 130,000 travelers a day at the peak of the summer travel season. Air Canada said flights will start resuming at 4 p.m. ET. Flight attendants walked off the job early Saturday after turning down the airline's request to enter into government-directed arbitration, which allows a third-party mediator to decide the terms of a new contract. The union said the agreement will guarantee members pay for work performed while planes are on the ground, resolving one of the major issues that drove the strike. 'Unpaid work is over. We have reclaimed our voice and our power,' the union said in a statement. 'When our rights were taken away, we stood strong, we fought back — and we secured a tentative agreement that our members can vote on.' Chief executive Michael Rousseau said restarting a major carrier is a complex undertaking and said regular service may require seven to 10 days. Some flights will be canceled until the schedule is stabilized. 'Full restoration may require a week or more, so we ask for our customers' patience and understanding over the coming days,' Rousseau said in a statement. The two sides reached the deal with the help of a mediator early Tuesday morning. The airline said mediation discussions 'were begun on the basis that the union commit to have the airline's 10,000 flight attendants immediately return to work.' Air Canada declined to comment further on the agreement until the ratification process is complete. It noted a strike or lockout is not possible during this time. The carrier said it plans to complete about half Tuesday's scheduled flights, with a focus on international outbounds. The ramp-up will begin on Wednesday morning for mainline North American routes. Earlier, Air Canada said rolling cancellations would extend through Tuesday afternoon after the union defied a second return-to-work order. The Canada Industrial Relations Board had declared the strike illegal Monday and ordered the flight attendants back on the job. But the union said it would defy the directive. Union leaders also ignored a weekend order to submit to binding arbitration and end the strike by Sunday afternoon. The board is an independent administrative tribunal that interprets and applies Canada's labor laws. The government ordered the board to intervene. Labor leaders objected to the Canadian government's repeated use of a law that cuts off workers' right to strike and forces them into arbitration, a step the government took in recent years with workers at ports, railways and elsewhere. 'Your right to vote on your wages was preserved,' the union said in a post on its website. Air Canada operates around 700 flights per day. The airline estimated Monday that 500,000 customers would be affected by flight cancellations. Aviation analytics firm Cirium said that as of Monday afternoon, Air Canada had called off at least 1,219 domestic flights and 1,339 international flights since last Thursday, when the carrier began gradually suspending its operations ahead of the strike and lockout that began early Saturday. Toronto's Pearson International Airport, Canada's largest, said it will deploy additional staff to assist passengers and support startup operations. 'I am relieved that Air Canada and the Canadian Union of Public Employees have reached a tentative agreement early this morning,' Prime Minister Mark Carney said in a statement. 'It is my hope that this will ensure flight attendants are compensated fairly at all times, while ending disruption for hundreds of thousands of Canadian families, workers, and visitors to Canada.' Passengers whose flights are impacted will be eligible to request a full refund on the airline's website or mobile app, according to Air Canada.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Canadian universities are adopting AI tools, but concerns about the technology remain
Canadian universities are embracing generative artificial intelligence in their teaching plans as more students and instructors opt to use the rapidly evolving technology. Several large institutions, including McGill University, University of Toronto and York University, said they are adopting certain AI tools because they can enhance learning. Those include tested tools that help students summarize academic research or assist professors in course planning. The shift comes as post-secondary students' AI use continues to grow. A survey conducted in late 2024 by the online learning platform Studiosity found that 78 per cent of Canadian students used AI to study or complete their school work. The Pan-Canadian Report on Digital Learning also found that the number of educators who reported generative AI use in student learning activities was 41 per cent last year, up from 12 per cent in 2023. McGill University's associate provost, Christopher Buddle, said the school has integrated digital AI assistant Microsoft Copilot into its systems to help staff, students and faculty with their work. The tool can be used to make a first draft of a letter, summarize online content or to organize day-to-day tasks. "People use it for all kind of things and from what I understand it's being used effectively and used quite a lot by our university community," he said. Buddle said offering generative AI tools through the school's IT infrastructure ensures they are vetted properly to address privacy risks and ensure data protection. "We've not approached it through the idea of banning (AI) or saying 'no.' In fact, what we'd rather see and what we support instructors doing and students doing is effective use of generative AI in teaching and learning," he said. Buddle said the university has left it up to instructors to decide how much AI use they want to allow in their classes. "We don't tell instructors what to do or not to do. We provide them tools and give them the principles and let them make the best decisions for their course because it's so discipline specific," he said. Some professors, for example, have their students use generative AI to create a first draft of a written assignment and then the students evaluate the outcome, Buddle said. The school is launching an online module for students and instructors this fall to help them navigate and understand the benefits and risks of AI in education, he added. "Generative AI is pervasive. It's everywhere and it will remain that way going forward," Buddle said. University of Toronto professor Susan McCahan, who led the school's task force on AI, said the institution is integrating AI tools but it's also taking a balanced approached that allows instructors to explore the technology while critically thinking about its value in education. "We have a wide range of opinions on AI and the use of AI in classrooms and in teaching and in learning," she said. "And we want to support faculty who are interested in innovating and using it in their classes. We want to support faculty who find that it is not useful for them or for their students." McCahan said the university has used AI systems for years, including for auditing financial reports and helping students find mental health resources. More recently, the school also made Microsoft Copilot available to all faculty, students and staff. "They can use in any way they wish. And because it's within our system, you can do things like open a library article in the library, and ask Copilot to summarize it," she said. "It doesn't share that data back with Microsoft ... so you can put in more sensitive information into that." McCahan said the university has also made ChatGPT Edu licences available to students and staff who would like to use the tool with added security protection. The school has been experimenting with AI tutors and will expand that in the coming school year with Cogniti, an open-source system developed at the University of Sydney in Australia, she added. At York University, the goal is "to take a thoughtful and principled approach to this modern technology," deputy spokesperson Yanni Dagonas said. "Transparency works to demystify AI, helping our community better understand its impact and potential," Dagonas said. The university has created an online AI hub with a dedicated section for instructors, who are discouraged from using AI detection tools when evaluating students' work because many such tools are considered unreliable and raise concerns about data security and confidentiality. Despite the "huge uptake" in students' generative AI use, many professors are still worried about bias in AI models, ethical and privacy issues, as well as the technology's environmental impact, said Mohammed Estaiteyeh, an assistant professor of education at Brock University. "Students are kind of using (AI) to save time. They think it is more efficient for various reasons," he said. But when it comes to instructors, "it depends on your domain. It depends your technological expertise. It depends on your stance towards those technologies," he said. "Many instructors have concerns." Estaiteyeh said most Canadian universities are providing guidance to instructors on the use of AI in their classes but leaving much of it to their discretion. "For example, (at) Brock, we don't have very strict guidelines in terms of students can do this or that. It's up to the instructor to decide in relation to the course, in relation to the materials, if they want to allow it or not," he said. "We are still navigating the consequences, we're still not 100 per cent sure about the benefits and the risks. A blanket, a one-size-fits-all approach may not suit well." Estaiteyeh said instructors and students need AI training and resources on top of guidance to reduce the risk of relying too much on the technology. "If you offload all the skills to the AI tools then you're not really acquiring significant skills throughout your three- or four-year degree at the university," he said. "Those tools have been in place for around two years only. And it's too early for us to claim that students have already grasped or acquired the skills on how to use them." The Canadian Alliance of Student Associations said AI technologies must complement the learning experience and universities should discourage the use of AI for evaluations and screening of student work. The alliance said in a report released earlier this year that research has shown untested AI systems can introduce "bias and discriminatory practices" against certain student groups. "For instance, AI-powered plagiarism detection tools have been found to disproportionately misclassify the work of non-native English speakers as AI-generated or plagiarized," the report said. The alliance has been calling for "clear ethical and regulatory guidelines" governing the use of generative AI in post-secondary education. This report by The Canadian Press was first published Aug. 19, 2025. Maan Alhmidi, The Canadian Press Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
New Brunswick deficit forecast rises by almost 22 per cent to $668.7 million
FREDERICTON — The New Brunswick government is revising its budget deficit upward by almost 22 per cent, adding that "unstable trade conditions" and poor weather are casting a shadow over the province's finances. The province said its deficit is now projected to be $668.7 million for the 2025-26 fiscal year, up from the $549 million forecast in the March budget. Revenues are expected to be $59.6 million lower than forecast in the budget, and expenses are projected to be $60 million higher than the March estimate. The government estimates the province's GDP will grow by 0.9 per cent for the year — lower than the private sector forecast average of 1.2 per cent. Finance Minister René Legacy attributed the increase in spending to higher costs in health and long-term care, seniors, and child and youth welfare. 'We will not sacrifice investments in health and social development or addressing the very real affordability challenges New Brunswickers are facing in favour of only satisfying the bottom line,' he said. The U.S. tariffs imposed on some Canadian goods are negatively affecting the province's economic outlook, he said, adding that the effects are still unclear. "We're still very cautiously monitoring. We should have a better picture about the impact that tariffs and trade will have on our projections as we progress in the second and third quarters," he said. "Anecdotally, we certainly hear that … industry and companies are very cautious in investing and moving forward because they just don't know what to expect in the months to come." Legacy said the government is also keeping a close eye on how much weather events, such as wildfires, will cost the province. John Herron, natural resources minister, said Monday the wildfires have grounded the province's forestry sector to a halt. There are mills on the verge of running out of wood after the government banned forest harvesting amid extreme wildfire risk, he said. About 25 square kilometres of forested land have burned or are expected to burn so far. Giving a ballpark estimate, he said the amount of forest lost to fire represented about $10.5 million in direct and indirect taxes from the forestry industry and about $42.5 million in lumber revenue to sawmills. On Tuesday, Legacy told reporters the full impact of the wildfires will be known once they are put out. "At this moment, it's still within the boundaries of what we had budgeted." The government is also concerned about the drought-like conditions gripping Atlantic Canada. "God willing, we're not going to have more hurricanes or ice storms but the year is still very early." This report by The Canadian Press was first published Aug. 19, 2025. The Canadian Press Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
