Craig Breslow, Red Sox desire to rid themselves of Rafael Devers was greater than their will to win
To represent the right choice, Breslow needs to deploy the Duck Boats for a championship joyride during his tenure. Otherwise, the Sox committed another critical error in continuing a trend this decade of emphasizing the minds in baseball operations over the men in uniform.
Advertisement
Give Breslow credit, dealing Devers in the middle of a five-game winning streak and hours after his team authored the first sweep suffered by the first-place Yankees this season is an unflinchingly bold move. This trade is now Breslow's version of Reaganomics — an unyielding ideological stance forever knitted into his legacy. It will define his tenure.
Get Starting Point
A guide through the most important stories of the morning, delivered Monday through Friday.
Enter Email
Sign Up
'A lot of the moves he has made have been bold and decisive and rooted in what is in the best interests of the baseball team,' said Sox president and CEO Sam Kennedy, ownership's PR proxy.
Breslow believed so deeply in the culture-undercutting divisiveness created by Devers's refusal to play first base following a season-ending injury to Triston Casas on May 2 that he excised him from the clubhouse at the expense of this season and for a tepid return.
Advertisement
Despite what Breslow and Kennedy tried to sell in a Monday media session, this wasn't a baseball trade. It was a calculated dumping of Devers, both personality and paycheck. The Sox freed themselves of his insolence and pricy salary. The Giants assumed the rest of his salary this season and the remaining $254.5 million left on the 10-year, $313.5 million extension the Red Sox blithely handed him in 2023 to save face after the departures of Mookie Betts and Xander Bogaerts.
It's worse than the MLB version of the Mavericks jettisoning Luka Doncic (Luka and Raffy do sport similar physiques, no?) because
Two of the three pitchers the Sox acquired, Jordan Hicks and minor leaguer Jose Bello, profile best as relievers. All the chips are on lefthander Kyle Harrison, a highly-touted prospect who has yet to live up to the hype. Prospect James Tibbs is another left-handed hitting outfielder; the Sox need those like you need another streaming service subscription.
Players are people, and people are imperfect. Devers displayed warts that would make a dermatologist blanch, initially balking at moving off third base for Alex Bregman and extending to his standoffish stance with team personnel and the media.
Rafael Devers (right), speaking with assistant general manager Eddie Romero, made it clear that he saw himself as the Red Sox' third baseman, even after the team signed Alex Bregman.
Danielle Parhizkaran/Globe Staff
But the team was winning, and he was producing at DH. It's not his fault the thought leaders at Fenway didn't recognize that he's not a franchise frontman, a leader, or a winner. He's only a hitter.
Devers's recurring recalcitrance bothered ownership, led by John Henry (you know what else he owns), and Breslow,
Advertisement
It
'I do think that as we think about the identity, the culture, and the environment that is created by great teams, there was something amiss here,' said Breslow. 'It was something that we needed to act decisively to course-correct.'
The timing feels tone-deaf. Just when fans think they're turning the corner, the Sox throw it in reverse by telling Raffy to hit the road.
Whether you believe in Breslow or not, this trade simply doesn't jibe with
Suddenly, that line feels like British Prime Minister Neville Chamberlain pledging he has secured peace for our time. Trading your best hitter in June for pieces that don't improve your major league roster displays the antithesis of 'extreme urgency.'
Both Kennedy and Breslow worked assiduously — yet unconvincingly — to put that toothpaste back in the tube.
'I think it's important to point out that this is in no way signifying a waving of the white flag on 2025,' said Breslow. 'We are as committed as we were six months ago to putting a winning team on the field, to competing for the division, and to making a deep postseason run.'
We must call the yearly pledges of prioritizing contention what they are — the mendacity of hope, misleading messaging inconsistent with the club's actions.
While the Sox were preoccupied with the message Devers's defiance/aversion to sacrifice sent to the clubhouse, what's the message delivered by trading their best hitter during a winning streak to cultivate a culture suited to baseball baptizing prospects Roman Anthony, Marcelo Mayer, and Kristian Campbell?
Advertisement
Kids over wins.
Among the first teammates to congratulate Roman Anthony (right) on hitting his first career home run on Monday night was fellow rookie Marcelo Mayer.
John Froschauer/Associated Press
A disconcerting disconnect between baseball ops and the clubhouse remains. A former Sox pitcher, Breslow was supposed to bridge the gap that his predecessor, Chaim Bloom, couldn't. Instead, he managed to alienate the team's highest-paid player and last link to World Series success.
Bravo, Bres.
It's worth remembering Devers isn't the only intransigent party here. There's a fine line between intelligence and conviction vs. arrogance and obduracy.
To his credit, Breslow acknowledged, 'I need to own things that I could've done better.'
There's zero reason Breslow and the Sox couldn't have at least tried uber prospect Anthony at first base in Triple A. Also, the team hastily pulled the plug on using Campbell at first, right before he was slated to debut.
The only 'alignment' — a business-speak buzzword justifying the trade — Breslow foresaw for a roster problem he's responsible for was Devers sliding to first, knowing another position shift was anathema to Devers.
That pushed the detonator on this relationship implosion.
Breslow got the final word in his standoff with Devers, but the 2025 Red Sox and their fans got a raw deal.
Christopher L. Gasper is a Globe columnist. He can be reached at
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBS News
24 minutes ago
- CBS News
How have the Red Sox have won six straight? Pitching, pitching, and more pitching
Don't look now, but the Boston Red Sox have won six straight games. In the process, Boston has reintroduced itself to the American League Wild Card race. The Red Sox kept their streak going Monday night with a second straight 2-0 victory, this time over the Mariners in Seattle. Boston has now won nine of its last 11 games, and currently sit as the American League's third Wild Card team. The Red Sox are just half-a-game up on the Mariners and Minnesota Twins -- and a game ahead of both the Cleveland Guardians and Texas Rangers -- so the margin remains razor thin. But considering where the team was just a few weeks ago, sitting in a playoff spot is just as surprising as Sunday's shocking trade of Rafael Devers. Monday's win followed a similar script for the current Red Sox run: Stellar pitching and a few big swings. Lucas Giolito handled the first part by tossing six shut out innings and striking out 10 Mariners in his best start in a Boston uniform. Justin Wilson, Greg Weissert, and Aroldis Chapman all put up zeros out of the bullpen to preserve the win. Rookie Roman Anthony provided the winning run early with a solo home run in the top of the first -- his first career longball -- while Abraham Toro gave Boston a cushion in the top of the third with an RBI infield single. "There was a lot of energy today," Boston manager Alex Cora said after the win. "For the group, it's a tough day. Raffy, he's Raffy. He's not with us anymore. We've got a job, too. We have to continue. Today was a good day for us." The Red Sox are on their first six-game winning streak since July of 2023. They started the month 3.5 games back of the Twins for that final AL Wild Card spot, with the Blue Jays, Royals, Rays, and Rangers in between. Now Boston occupies that spot, and sit just 5.5 games back of the Yankees in the AL East. The Red Sox have sliced five games off that divisional deficit since beating the Yankees in New York on June 7. Is it sustainable? We'll see, especially considering the Red Sox have embarked on this streak in an unconventional way. All about Red Sox pitching The Boston pitching staff has been nothing short of incredible over the streak. Starters have gone at least six innings in each victory, and allowed no earned runs in four of those outings. Giolito hasn't allowed an earned run in two straight starts, while giving up just six hits and striking out 14 over his last 12 innings. How good is it going for Giolito at the moment? On Monday night, he surrendered three straight singles to the Mariners to load the bases in the bottom of the third. He struck out the next three batters swinging to escape the jam, including Cal Raleigh on three pitches to end the Seattle threat. The veteran's velocity was up Monday, with Giolito touching 96 mph on the radar gun and his fastball hovering around 93-94 mph for the night. On Sunday, Brayan Bello kept the Yankees off the board for seven innings in a 2-0 victory. Hunter Dobbins went six shutout innings Saturday against New York, after ace Garrett Crochet nearly went the distance before Aaron Judge took him deep in the top of the ninth. Before the Yankees were in town, Walker Buehler allowed three runs over seven innings in a 4-3 win over the Rays. The night prior, Giolito got this streak started with his six shutout innings against Tampa. During the streak, Red Sox starters have allowed just four earned runs over 40.1 innings. They've surrendered just 21 hits while striking out 41. The Boston bullpen has held up its end of the bargain too. Over the last six games, Red Sox relievers have allowed just three earned runs over 14.2 innings while striking out 18. All three of those runs came in Saturday's 4-3 win over the Yankees, with Luis Guerrero surrendering two and Weissert giving up one in the ninth. Red Sox bats doing just enough The Red Sox currently have the fifth-most runs in baseball with 355 over 74 games. But the offense hasn't really been lighting the world on fire during the current streak, outscoring opponents at just a 17-8 clip over the last six games. You read that correctly. The Red Sox have scored just 17 runs over the last six games, and have won them all. Boston has just 39 hits during the streak, but seven of them left the yard. Unfortunately, all seven of those homers were of the solo variety, with the Red Sox struggling to get runners on during the streak. When runners have been on base and in scoring position, the bats haven't done much. Boston is just 7-for-43 (a .162 average) with runners in scoring position the last six games. As great as the pitching has been, wins at such a clip can't be expected if the offense doesn't come through. Boston has a plus-24 run differential for the season, good for 11th-best in baseball, but the offense needs to be much better if the team wants to turn this streak into a sustained run of success. The Red Sox did this last season too. A scorching June gave the team hope, before they ultimately ran out of gas later in the summer. To avoid a repeat, the team needs to start playing complimentary baseball on a nightly basis. But wins are wins, and the Red Sox are stacking them up at a pivotal moment of the season. They've managed to claw their way back into the playoff picture, which didn't seem possible just a few weeks ago. "Winning solves everything," Giolito said Monday night. "No matter what's going on from the outside, no matter what people feel about what's going on, if we win baseball games, we put ourselves in a good position to continue to win more and more, that will take care of it."
Wall Street Journal
an hour ago
- Wall Street Journal
Shohei Ohtani Is Back to Doing What He Does Best: Everything
Shohei Ohtani, the man who might be the most talented player in baseball history, had been feeling antsy of late. It wasn't enough for him merely to be a World Series champion, the founding member of the 50/50 club, the reigning MVP and the best hitter in the National League this year. That's only Ohtani at half capacity.
New York Times
an hour ago
- New York Times
The unlikely power of Corbin Carroll, the diminutive Diamondback raking homers
PHOENIX — The ball left Corbin Carroll's bat with an exit velocity of 94.8 mph, more of a line drive than a towering fly ball. Sprinting out of the batter's box, head down, Carroll didn't think it was enough. The 24-year-old Arizona Diamondbacks outfielder thought he had clipped it. But the ball kept carrying at Chase Field, landing in the front row of the left-field bleachers, No. 20 on the season, putting Carroll on a 46-plus home run pace, not that such things matter in the middle of June, if at all. The most electric player in the — Arizona Diamondbacks (@Dbacks) June 14, 2025 In his third full season, Carroll's power isn't a secret. He's had it in some form since his high school days in Seattle, and it's transferred to baseball's highest level. But there's still something amazing about seeing someone listed 5-foot-10, 165 pounds, almost always the smallest guy on the field, muscling balls over the fence the opposite way. Pound-for-pound, Carroll might be baseball's top attraction. Advertisement We are conditioned to think of power hitters in a certain way. In 1968, the great Jim Murray of The Los Angeles Times put it like this: 'You all know what home run hitters look like — all those muscles. They might have a pot belly like Babe Ruth or legs that should have branches on them like Lou Gehrig. Some of them might look like the Washington Monument, others have biceps they might use to pull railroad cars or lift railroad wheels.' Carroll is different. As he rounded the bases last Friday night, he moved into fifth on this season's home run leaderboard. The four ahead of him — the New York Yankees' Aaron Judge, the Seattle Mariners' Cal Raleigh, the Los Angeles Dodgers' Shohei Ohtani and the Philadelphia Phillies' Kyle Schwarber — outweighed Carroll by an average of 74 pounds. (Diamondbacks teammate Eugenio Suárez has since also moved ahead of Carroll.) After the game, a 5-1 Arizona win, manager Torey Lovullo said that, unlike last season when Carroll got off to a slow start, Carroll isn't missing the pitch he's looking to square. He's looking to lift the ball. And of course: 'There's a ton of bat speed in there.' There are several ways to describe Carroll. Pitcher Ryne Nelson went with 'physical.' Assistant hitting coach Damion Easley called him a 'walking muscle.' Both lead to explosiveness, which is what makes Carroll unique. His signature play isn't the home run, but the triple. When Carroll belts a ball into the gap, before he has even rounded first, nearly everyone is thinking three bags. Entering Tuesday, his eight triples matched Boston's Jarren Duran for the major-league lead. (Over his first three full seasons, Seattle's Ichiro Suzuki, similar in size to Carroll, had 24 triples; Carroll has 32 and counting.) Rick Huegli saw this up close when he worked with Carroll at Lakeside School in Seattle. A former strength and conditioning coach at the University of Washington, Huegli said there are different ways to measure explosiveness, but one is with a standing vertical jump. During his high school days, Carroll leaped an impressive 36 inches. Advertisement Not much later, Huegli started telling folks Carroll might be among the five most impressive athletes he'd been around, high school or college. He compared him to a former Washington running back named Napoleon Kaufman, who played for the Huskies from 1991 to 1994 and became a first-round NFL Draft choice, playing six seasons with the Oakland Raiders. 'Napoleon was a legit 5-8, 5-9, he could bench press 430 pounds,' Huegli said by phone. 'A state-champion sprinter. He could suck the air out of the stadium every time he touched the ball. And again, the components of explosiveness, that fast twitch with athletic ability, Corbin has it. Similarly to Napoleon.' Another thing Huegli noticed about Corbin: his drive, which he found uncommon. At Lakeside, the strength staff stored the school's prowler sleds in a storage room inside the gymnasium. Athletes could use the sleds, pushing them heavy or light, fast or slow. Only thing: They couldn't be pushed on the hardwood floors of the gym. They had to be relocated to a turf field, 100 yards away and uphill. Carroll transferred everything himself, carrying the sled and the 45-pound bumper plates, a task that required five or six trips. This is the story Huegli tells when asked what made Carroll different. 'Not every kid does that,' he said. On the night he hit his 20th home run, Carroll walked out of the trainer's room inside a near-empty Diamondbacks clubhouse. In 2023, the year he started in the All-Star Game in his hometown and won National League Rookie of the Year, Corbin had hit 25 home runs. Last year, he rallied after the slow start and finished with 22. This season, Carroll said he feels like he's been hitting balls hard, with launch angles between 20 and 35 degrees. Most of his home runs early in the season had been to the pull side, something he'd like to get back to doing. Carroll's last two homers, both to the opposite field, had exit velocities below 96.5 mph, which ranked among the lowest of his career. Carroll couldn't recall when he first realized his power. It's just always been there. 'I guess I've never tried to put a limit on myself,' he told The Athletic. 'I've always tried to work on every part of my game, hitting for power would be no exception. I got a belief that I can damage the baseball, so I always want that to be a part of my game. I feel like that's when I'm at my best.' Advertisement Baseball numbers are difficult to project. Line drives are run down. A hot bat turns cold. Pitchers learn from mistakes. (Indeed, after hitting his 20th homer, Carroll went 0 for 9 in his next 10 plate appearances against San Diego, striking out six times.) Still, trying to approximate Carroll's power potential is a fascinating exercise. Easley says 35-plus is realistic, but recent history suggests 40 would be difficult for a player Carroll's size. Over the last 20 years, 59 players have hit 40 or more home runs in a season. Of that group, only three have weighed less than 200 pounds — Marcus Semien (who topped 40 homers in 2021), Alex Bregman (2019) and Alfonso Soriano (2006). Carroll isn't concerned about such things. 'My mindset is kind of if I can hit one a week, then I can look up at the end of the year and be in a pretty good spot,' he said. 'Anything additional to that is kind of just a bonus. I'm not trying to be a power hitter. I want to be a good hitter and hit a bunch of balls hard on the line. If they go, they go.' Before Sunday's series finale with San Diego, Easley sat outside the Diamondbacks indoor batting cage. He said when he first met Carroll in 2022, he thought he was a slasher — someone who hits doubles, triples and gets on base — 'which he is,' Easley said, but he didn't realize Carroll's line drives often leave the park. Asked if he had played with anyone of similar size and skill over his 17 big-league seasons, Easley looked down for about 10 seconds. José Reyes, a teammate with the New York Mets, could run like Carroll, he said, but he didn't have that kind of power. Same with Juan Pierre, a teammate with the then-Florida Marlins. 'Man, that's a tough one,' Easley concluded. Asked the same question, Lovullo, who played parts of eight major-league seasons, mentioned Brian Giles, a teammate in Cleveland, but the more he talked about the 5-11 outfielder, who was thicker than Carroll, the more he talked himself out of it. 'I want to believe Corbin is a little bit different,' Lovullo said. 'He's 1 of 1. I've known him now for several years. How hard he works … He's jacked. He's got some God-given ability combined with this incredible drive that helps him create some amazing torque. He's dynamic with his legs, his ability to chase balls down, hit for power. It's a full complement of tools. There's not a lot of them like that.' (Top photo of Corbin Carroll rounding the bases after a June 9 home run against Seattle: Zach Gardner / MLB Photos via Getty Images)
