Review into Flamingo Land plans to be led by official who approved it
Scottish Government reporter David Buylla, who gave the £43.5 million project in Balloch planning permission, is now set to advise SNP ministers who have called in the decision for reappraisal, the Sunday Mail reports.
The recall, undertaken by Public Finance Minister Ivan McKee, means that ministers will now consider the proposals directly.
READ MORE: Campaign against Flamingo Land reaches milestone with 50,000 letters sent to minister
If it goes ahead, the resort would see a waterpark, a monorail, hotels, restaurants, a brewery and 104 woodland chalets built.
The plans have been met with criticism from local campaigners and politicians, which have been branded as "hysteria" by developers Lomond Banks.
According to the Sunday Mail, Buylla is now tasked with writing a new report, including recommendations to inform McKee's decision.
Scottish Government reporters are civil servants within the Planning and Environmental Appeals Division (DPEA), who decide on planning appeals.
Buylla is one of five principal reporters at the DPEA, while there are also three assistant chief reporters and one chief reporter.
Alannah Maurer, campaigner with the Save Loch Lomond campaign, told the Sunday Mail: 'You'd assume someone else would have been assigned. You have to consider professional integrity because how does he say anything other than what he previously said?
READ MORE: All the reasons why approving Flamingo Land in Scotland is wrong
'It's absolutely clear there is no democracy, particularly where planning is concerned. The developer can appeal but the public has no right of appeal.
'Our best hope is that ministers will see sense, pay attention to the public – but it's clear public opinion counts for nothing.'
Scottish Greens MSP Ross Greer, who has been involved with the campaign against Flamingo Land's plans, said ministers "cannot hide behind officials" when making their decision.
Ross Greer MSP 'For a start, they must do what did not happen at the appeal stage; speak to the community, to myself and others like the Woodland Trust who submitted substantial evidence against Flamingo Land's destructive plans," he told the paper.
'They absolutely must speak to the National Park's own planning experts, whose report advising their board to reject the application was clearly badly misunderstood by Government officials.
READ MORE: Cabinet minister refuses to confirm if two-child cap will be scrapped
'The Planning Minister should call a public hearing and come to his own decision based on the evidence. Rehashing the same flawed report from officials and waiting until after next year's election to sign it off would be totally unacceptable."
A Scottish Government spokeswoman said: 'Ministers decided to recall the Lomond Banks appeal as the proposed development raises issues of national significance in view of its potential impact on Loch Lomond and the Trossachs National Park.
'As this is a live planning appeal it would not be appropriate to comment further.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Record
7 hours ago
- Daily Record
Nicola Sturgeon was involved in 'political conspiracy' against Alex Salmond, claims ex-SNP minister
Nicola Sturgeon was involved in 'political conspiracy' against Alex Salmond, claims ex-SNP minister Kenny MacAskill renewed his calls for a public inquiry into the events surrounding an investigation into the late Alex Salmond. Alex Salmond and Nicola Sturgeon after the SNP election win in 2011 Nicola Sturgeon was involved in a "political conspiracy" against Alex Salmond, a former SNP justice secretary has claimed. Kenny MacAskill warned today there must be "no cover up in Holyrood or in St Andrew's House" as he renewed his calls for a public inquiry to examine the circumstances of an investigation into the former first minister, who died in October last year aged 69. The Alba leader, who quit the SNP in 2021 to join Salmond's fledgling party, has regularly demanded answers over a botched Scottish Government probe into claims of harassment made against Salmond in 2018. Complaints were made by two female civil servants but an internal Government investigation was later ruled to be unlawful. Salmond was awarded over half a million pounds in costs after a judge ruled in 2019 the investigation had been "tainted with apparent bias". The former SNP leader was separately charged that same year with sexual assault against nine women. He was cleared of all charges in court in 2020. "I think there has to be an inquiry because what happened to Alex Salmond was fundamentally wrong," MacAskill said in an interview with Go Radio. Article continues below SNP MSPs call for Israeli Defense Forces to be proscribed as a terrorist organisation READ MORE: "I think what we are seeing is obfuscation, to put it mildly, by the Scottish Government. There can be no cover up in Holyrood or in St Andrew's House. We require to know who did what, what was done, if that impacts upon Alex so be it, but I don't believe it does. I believe it will vindicate him because a manifest injustice was done towards him." Pressed on on whether Sturgeon was at the heart of a "political conspiracy" MacAskill continued: "I believe so. There was a political conspiracy to do down Alex Salmond. "I have no doubt that was a factor in his early death. He wasn't even 70 but what he had to endure. But he was vindicated in the civil courts with the Scottish Government chastised in the highest court in our land and in the criminal court a jury of his peers exculpated him." Sturgeon, who was first minister at the time of the investigation, has previously denied any suggestion of a conspiracy. Salmond himself alleged that some people had wanted to "remove me as a political threat". She told MSPs in 2019: "It seems to me that I am being simultaneously accused of being involved in a conspiracy against Alex Salmond, and also of colluding with Alex Salmond. "Nothing could be further from the truth in both of those - neither of those things are true. Since I found out about the investigation I have tried to do the right thing in a situation which, no matter what happened, was never going to be easy for me." Alex Salmond leaves the High Court in 2019 (Image: Getty Images ) In a 2021 interview with STV, Sturgeon was again asked about a conspiracy against Salmond. She said: "He has made claims, or he appears to be making claims or suggestions there was some kind of conspiracy against him or concerted campaign against him, there is not a shred of evidence about that, so this is the opportunity for him to replace insinuation and assertion with evidence. "I don't believe he can because I know what he is saying is not true but the burden of proof is on him. If he can't provide that evidence he should stop making these claims about people because they're not fair and deeply distressing." The former first minister was later cleared of breaching the ministerial code over her involvement in the Salmond saga. An independent inquiry in 2021 by senior Irish lawyer James Hamilton examined whether the first minister misled the Scottish Parliament over what she knew and when. A separate inquiry by MSPs into the Scottish Government's handling of harassment complaints against Salmond found there were 'fundamental errors' in its harassment procedure. Article continues below The Record asked the SNP for comment.
The Herald Scotland
8 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
Alba's Kenny MacAskill calls for Alex Salmond public inquiry
The Alba Party leader told presenter Bernard Ponsonby: "I think there has to be an inquiry because what happened to Alex Salmond was fundamentally wrong. I think what we are seeing is obfuscation, to put it mildly, by the Scottish Government. "There can be no cover up in Holyrood or in St Andrew's House. We require to know who did what, what was done, if that impacts upon Alex so be it, but I don't believe it does. I believe it will vindicate him because a manifest injustice was done towards him." Mr MacAskill was among the mourners for the former First Minister after his death last autumn. (Image: PA) In an exclusive interview published earlier today, Mr MacAskill had told The Herald on Sunday: "I will not forgive the behaviour of Nicola Sturgeon towards Alex Salmond. And indeed, the lies told by others. 'I've been involved with the independence movement for a long time. Even people in the SNP know that there are individuals who have taken actions that are currently under investigation by the authorities relating to Alex. 'Our position is that we will fully support the authorities in doing their job. That is what it has to be. It doesn't mean you give the SNP a blank cheque. I mean, we rightly criticise." Read more: Alba's Kenny MacAskill on party infighting, independence, and Scotland's energy 'I will never forgive Nicola Sturgeon', former Justice Secretary says 'A 1970s tribute act': Alba faces electoral ruin, former party boss warns Speaking to Mr Ponsonby, Mr MacAskill went on to say that he believed the Scottish Government's stance toward Mr Salmond may have contributed to his untimely death. He said: "There was a political conspiracy to do down Alex Salmond. I have no doubt that was a factor in his early death. "He wasn't even 70 but what he had to endure. But he was vindicated in the civil courts with the Scottish Government chastised in the highest court in our land and in the criminal court a jury of his peers exculpated him." Mr Salmond, 69, died last October while at a conference in North Macedonia. He had bitterly fallen with former SNP colleagues, including former First Minister Nicola Sturgeon, after allegations of sexual misconduct were levelled in 2018. Mr Salmond was later cleared of 13 charges in a High Court criminal case in March 2020. A bitter leadership contest between Mr MacAskill and Alba's only MSP Ash Regan resulted in the former being selected for the top spot in March. Speaking to the Herald on Sunday. Mr MacAskill said: 'It's been a testing occasion for us all. Alex's death was tragic back in October, and now we have had to stabilise the ship. 'It was obviously not simply a loss in terms of the political leadership and the inspiration he gave, but he was a personal friend.'
The National
11 hours ago
- The National
Review into Flamingo Land plans to be led by official who approved it
The Scottish Government recalled plans to build the resort on the banks of Loch Lomond last month, after it was announced the developers had been granted their appeal after it was rejected by the local authority. Scottish Government reporter David Buylla, who gave the £43.5 million project in Balloch planning permission, is now set to advise SNP ministers who have called in the decision for reappraisal, the Sunday Mail reports. The recall, undertaken by Public Finance Minister Ivan McKee, means that ministers will now consider the proposals directly. READ MORE: Campaign against Flamingo Land reaches milestone with 50,000 letters sent to minister If it goes ahead, the resort would see a waterpark, a monorail, hotels, restaurants, a brewery and 104 woodland chalets built. The plans have been met with criticism from local campaigners and politicians, which have been branded as "hysteria" by developers Lomond Banks. According to the Sunday Mail, Buylla is now tasked with writing a new report, including recommendations to inform McKee's decision. Scottish Government reporters are civil servants within the Planning and Environmental Appeals Division (DPEA), who decide on planning appeals. Buylla is one of five principal reporters at the DPEA, while there are also three assistant chief reporters and one chief reporter. Alannah Maurer, campaigner with the Save Loch Lomond campaign, told the Sunday Mail: 'You'd assume someone else would have been assigned. You have to consider professional integrity because how does he say anything other than what he previously said? READ MORE: All the reasons why approving Flamingo Land in Scotland is wrong 'It's absolutely clear there is no democracy, particularly where planning is concerned. The developer can appeal but the public has no right of appeal. 'Our best hope is that ministers will see sense, pay attention to the public – but it's clear public opinion counts for nothing.' Scottish Greens MSP Ross Greer, who has been involved with the campaign against Flamingo Land's plans, said ministers "cannot hide behind officials" when making their decision. Ross Greer MSP 'For a start, they must do what did not happen at the appeal stage; speak to the community, to myself and others like the Woodland Trust who submitted substantial evidence against Flamingo Land's destructive plans," he told the paper. 'They absolutely must speak to the National Park's own planning experts, whose report advising their board to reject the application was clearly badly misunderstood by Government officials. READ MORE: Cabinet minister refuses to confirm if two-child cap will be scrapped 'The Planning Minister should call a public hearing and come to his own decision based on the evidence. Rehashing the same flawed report from officials and waiting until after next year's election to sign it off would be totally unacceptable." A Scottish Government spokeswoman said: 'Ministers decided to recall the Lomond Banks appeal as the proposed development raises issues of national significance in view of its potential impact on Loch Lomond and the Trossachs National Park. 'As this is a live planning appeal it would not be appropriate to comment further.'
