'Radical reset' of housing policy needed as targets to be missed by 10,000 AGAIN
Housing targets will be missed by up to 10,000 units again this year and will fall short for the next several years, Extra.ie can reveal.
Officials in the Department of Housing have warned Minister James Browne that the number of new homes built this year is likely to fall 'somewhere in the low 30,000s', compared to a target of 41,000.
Internal briefing documents prepared for the Housing Minister, obtained by Extra.ie under Freedom of Information legislation, also raised concerns over the construction of desperately needed homes into the future.
Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael were accused of having 'misled' voters in the run up to last November's election, when they claimed 40,000 homes would be built last year but only 30,300 were delivered. 18/02/2025 Dublin Ireland. Fianna Fail Minister for Housing James Browne talking to the media on his way into today's cabinet meeting at Government Buildings. Photo: Sasko Lazarov/© RollingNews.ie
In a statement to Extra, Mr Browne admitted this year's output will fall far short of target.
He said it was 'difficult to see a pathway off the lower than expected base from 2024'.
The Fianna Fáil TD insisted he is 'interrogating every area' that is delaying delivery of housing and 'demanding faster outcomes as soon as possible'.
Ahead of the last election, the Government revised its housing targets upwards to account for Ireland's soaring population.
Over the course of this Government's lifetime, the aim is to build 303,000 new homes – starting at 41,000 this year and ramping up to 60,000 by 2030.
But there is already open admission within Government that their targets for 41,000 new homes this year and 43,000 next year will be widely missed, as the upward momentum in housing has evaporated.
The documents prepared for the minister highlight the 'almost complete retrenchment of private international capital since 2022' as a 'significant factor' that will affect the delivery of housing in the coming years. Housing Development: Pic: Getty Images
Institutional investors play a central role in the development of apartments and the 80% reduction in international capital since 2022 has led to a sizeable reduction in supply.
The officials highlight that the pipeline for new apartments is slowing, with a 39% dip in planning permissions in 2024 'reflecting a general downward trend from the peak in 2020 and 2021'.
This is already being felt in apartment completions which equated to 29% of all home completions in 2024, a drop of 7% from the previous year.
The officials wrote: 'Delivery of apartments will be potentially constrained in coming years given the fall in institutional investment since mid-2022, and its slow return to date.'
This depleted pipeline has placed the Government's housing targets beyond 2026 at risk, officials warned.
They stated: 'The decline in overall approvals, as well as apartment approvals, has implications in the longer term for the delivery of Government's revised housing targets, with approvals falling short of the quantum needed to hit targets in 2026 and subsequent years.'
Mr Browne said recently that he felt the Economic Social and Research Institute's prediction that 34,000 new homes would be built this year and 37,000 next year is probably broadly accurate. The internal documents prepared for Mr Browne by his officials in April state that an output in the low 30,000s this year is likely.
They wrote: 'Published forecasts project between 32,000 and 35,000 new homes will be completed in 2025 – the forecasts will fluctuate as the year progresses, but somewhere in the low 30,000 range seems most realistic at this stage factoring in early feedback from the construction sector.' Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage James Browne TD speaking to the media in the Government Press Center following today's Cabinet meeting, Dublin. Photo: Sam Boal/Collins Photos
The officials noted that while 'the emerging consensus from published forecasts' at the start of 2025 is between 32,000 and 35,000 new homes this year 'all forecasts should be treated with considerable caution at this stage'.
They stated: 'A degree of circumspection is advised as a more conservative projection of 30,000, give or take, is mooted by stakeholders closer to residential construction sector.'
Mr Browne said: 'I am seeing many of the same forecasts as are publicly available and most of them have the same trajectory for the year, which is in the low 30s, which seems realistic at this stage in the year – it would be difficult to see a pathway off the lower than expected base from 2024.'
He said that he is 'interrogating every area' that is delaying delivery of housing and 'demanding faster outcomes as soon as possible'.
Mr Browne added: 'I've been pulling together what's needed to boost delivery, including a revised National Planning Framework which will help increase our capacity and accelerate home building. The Housing Activation Office will hone in on the ground to address barriers impacting housing development.
'The buttons I press now may not feel like they have immediate impact but what I do now will impact home building for years and we have to get it right. I'm serious about that. Sorting out planning can be laboured – it is a rules-based process for many good reasons. That doesn't mean we aren't tackling it to speed it up.
'Measures to help scale-up delivery are being considered in the context of the next housing plan.'
The officials pointed to planning permissions for 49,212 units that have not commenced in Dublin as one potential solution over the medium term. Of those, 7,272 are on sites where construction had started while 5,875 are being held up as they are the subject of a judicial review.
Last week, Mr Browne announced plans to allow for the extension of planning permissions for developments that are set to expire and have not yet commenced.
The permissions can be extended for up to three years. The proposals will also allow planning permissions subjected to or going through a judicial review to apply for a retrospective suspension of the permission for the duration of the judicial review. Pic: Sam Boal/Collins Photos
Sinn Féin's housing spokesman Eoin Ó Broin told Extra: 'The ESRI and Central Bank, in their recent presentation to the Oireachtas Housing Committee, said that without a significant change in policy and investment, the new Programme for Government targets can not be met.
'All of the indicators are going in the wrong direction.
'Only a radical reset of housing policy, as recommended by the Housing Commission and Sinn Féin can start to undo the damage of years of bad Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael housing policy.'
Mr Browne is set to unveil his new housing plan next month, prior to the Dáil's summer recess. Viability is a core challenge facing the sector, particularly in relation to apartments, with the Department of Finance in the process examining proposals to tackle funding challenges.
It is expected that changes to apartment regulations will be made in an attempt to reduce the cost of building. The documents highlight the surge in the price of materials, which are now 33% higher than in January 2021.
Officials wrote: 'Input cost inflation quickened for the second month running and was the steepest for almost two years.'
The CSO's Wholesale Price Index for building and construction materials shows material input costs continue to rise.
The Government has also been deciding on whether to retain, replace or amend the Rent Pressure Zones, which limit annual rent increases to 2%. It appears removing the 2% cap is now the plan.
RPZs have been highlighted as a barrier to investment by institutional investors. Uisce Éireann has also warned that it will need an additional €2billion to connect new homes to the supply if it is to keep pace with increased housing targets.
The housing officials pointed to issues in water and energy connections as one reason for the shortfall in completions last year as well as the Government's incentivising of commencing new developments.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
an hour ago
- Irish Examiner
Rent pressure zones have 'discouraged' the supply of new homes, Dáil committee told
Rent pressure zones are 'not a good system' and have 'discouraged" the supply of new homes, an Oireachtas committee has heard. Members of the Housing Commission — whose landmark report on recommendations to fix Ireland's housing crisis was published over 12 months ago — also told the Oireachtas housing committee on Tuesday there had been a 'lack of emergency thinking and action' since its report came out. The Housing Commission was established in January 2022 as an independent body to examine Ireland's housing system and to make recommendations to shape long-term policy. This commission was made of representatives from across the housing sector, including developers and those delivering housing on the ground, and found Ireland's housing system has 'fundamentally systemic' failures. It made a slew of recommendations for a new approach to the housing sector to meet the needs of the Irish public, estimating there was an underlying undersupply of over a quarter of a million homes in the country. Since its publication, some members have been critical of what it called State inaction on taking up its recommendations. The Government has hit back at this, however, and insisted it was implementing the report. The appearance of Housing Commission members at the Oireachtas committee on Tuesday coincided with the Government publishing its controversial plans to reform the rental sector and its rent pressure zones. UCD professor of social policy Michelle Norris told the committee the commission proposed a 'comprehensive reform' of the system of rent pressure zones that had been 'introduced as an emergency measure in 2016 to regulate private rents and was never intended to be in place over the long term'. 'We propose replacing the RPZs with the reference rent system used to regulate rents in many other European countries," she said. Trinity College's Dr Ronan Lyons said, from the new Government proposals, vacancy de-control seemed to be the most important. This is where landlords would be able to set market rates for a property if a tenant moved out. Meanwhile, Michael O'Flynn, chief executive of the construction firm O'Flynn Group, said during covid-19 there was a highly coordinated approach across Government and they were similarly dealing with a housing 'emergency' now. 'Unfortunately, this approach has not been taken into the housing crisis, and the result is it's getting more and more challenging,' he said. 'The Housing Commission was a very serious attempt to provide a framework for Government to deal with the crisis in a holistic way. "It provided a strategic approach which, if adopted, would over the medium term, deal with the serious backlog of over 300,000 homes.' Read More Government yet again tinkering around the edges of the housing crisis with rent pressure zone plans
Irish Independent
an hour ago
- Irish Independent
Up to 13,000 retired civil servants and ministers checked for ‘serious' incorrect pension payments as one owes €280,000
Public Expenditure Minister Jack Chambers has revealed that the National Shared Services Office has begun a scoping exercise 'to establish the scale of the problem'. He said there are three cohorts of individuals impacted by the errors – and the liabilities range from a few hundred euros, up to €280,000. They include current and former ministers and office holders, retired senior civil servants and civil service retirees with work-sharing patterns. Mr Chambers said the errors span different time periods and have been detected in various ways. One issue relates to the incorrect application of pension deductions for most members of the current Government, ministers of state, some members of previous governments and recent office holders. The amounts involved range from hundreds of euros to the low €30,000s in terms of monies to be recouped. In addition, a number of ministers are due refunds ranging from hundreds of euros up to the low €20,000s. Some are unaffected. Another issue relates to 30 cases involving the administration of Chargeable Excess Tax, a tax on pension funds, and Withholding Tax, which is deducted from retirement lump sums, in relation to senior grade civil service pensioners. 'The liabilities for this cohort range from a few hundred euros to €280,000,' said the minister. Another issue relates to the miscalculation and under-payment of pensions for some work-sharing civil service retirees. These individuals were in receipt of allowances before they retired in the last 20 years or so. ADVERTISEMENT 'The issues that have been brought to my attention by the NSSO are completely unacceptable,' said Mr Chambers. 'The NSSO has responsibility for the essential function of the provision of pay and pensions to public and civil servants and it has failed in this fundamental duty. 'I have instructed the CEO of the NSSO that the multiple errors must be corrected by the NSSO as a matter of urgency, particularly regarding the treatment of retirees who had been on a work-sharing pattern in the civil service.' The NSSO provides human resources, payroll, pension and finance management services to public service bodies including government departments. Mr Chambers said he is committed to fully and comprehensively addressing the matter to ensure all money owed to the State is fully recouped and money owed to individuals is refunded, and to restore trust in the NSSO. He said a pool of 13,000 retirees will be checked although the number affected is likely to be much smaller. 'To be clear, this does not imply that all 13,000 will have anomalies, but all 13,000 will be checked,' he said. Mr Chambers said issues arose due to administrative errors in the NSSO and are not the fault of any of the individuals impacted. He said he updated cabinet on a number of 'serious and systemic' operational issues in the National Shared Services Office after they were brought to his attention recently. 'My department is in ongoing engagement with the NSSO to establish the full scale of the issues and their impact on payroll and pension matters,' he said. He said the NSSO is today publishing an information note on its website with detail on the issues identified so far. The minister said he will outline a series of actions he has already undertaken or will be undertaking shortly to address these issues. 'Certain initial issues within the NSSO were first brought to my attention in late March, and while the full facts and scale of the problems were still being established during this time further errors and issues were identified,' he said. He said he received an update on June 4 before advising cabinet this morning. Anyone with queries relating to work sharing pensions can contact the NSSO Customer Contact Centre via email payrollcontact@ or the phone line 0818 107 100.
Irish Independent
an hour ago
- Irish Independent
Targeted measures against child poverty in next Budget, Taoiseach Micheál Martin tells Dáil
Micheál Martin was responding to Sinn Féin leader Mary Lou McDonald, who raised the continuing increase in the cost of living. The Taoiseach accepted there had been high inflation since the Russian invasion of Ukraine in 2022, but "the Government had not, at that stage, yet brought in free school meals for all primary schools or free school books at the second level." He said cost of living packages in recent Budgets had a significant impact on many families, and were "making a real difference to children of poverty," The Taoiseach said: "We have to do more. We've had a series of cost-of-living packages, but we need better than cost-of-living packages on an annual basis. "I think unlike any other Government in Europe, we've been in a position to bring in those kind of packages. "But we need sustained, targeted child poverty initiatives -- which I'm working on with the Child Poverty Unit in my Department, to prepare for the forthcoming Budget." His comments once more indicate that there will be no general cost-of-living package of the type that previously included electricity bill credits, in Budget 2026. Nor are there any indications of any increases to universal measures, such as Child Benefit. Instead the Taoiseach has placed an emphasis on "targeted" measures to help families with children at risk of poverty.
