Hundreds want this Hawthorn milk bar to open for dinner. But the council may not agree
'It's not a big deal if you don't live nearby, but it has disrupted our way of life.'
However, Sally Mills and Joe Tobin, from two other Barton Street households, told The Age they backed the restaurant plan.
James Laskie, meanwhile, has compiled a petition with 267 signatures supporting a six-hour trading extension. The majority list their addresses as within the broader Hawthorn suburb, but not right next door.
Although separate to the planning process, the petition was tabled at Boroondara Council's meeting last Monday ahead of a final vote on an amended permit next week.
But council officials have already recommended elected councillors reject it.
'The request for extended trading would result in activities on the site extending into more sensitive times and is not supported in this location, as echoed by objections made by nearby residents,' a report said.
It added that key concerns included noise from patrons and vehicles, traffic and parking congestion, disruption to the 'quiet and family-orientated character' of the area, and antisocial behaviour stemming from alcohol being served.
Laskie, however, said his restaurant would not be a boozy bar. Instead, he said his 'modest' application would facilitate a 'family-focused, seated dinner service to our existing clientele'.
'We believe that this would add a currently unavailable amenity to the area, that is in keeping with the character of the neighbourhood, and will only enhance the experience of its residents,' the Laskie siblings said.
'If granted these hours, we would close food service around 8pm, allowing for diners to enjoy their meals, coffee and drinks in a quiet and unrushed environment, as well as allowing staff to prep the cafe for the morning, clean, and close by 10pm.'
They described the objections as 'unwarranted, though understandable fears of select individuals'.
'We will continue to adapt our business to suit locals and the neighbourhood that underpin Barton Milk Bar's identity,' they said.
A council report found the Laskies had demand for expansion, but added: 'It is difficult to determine whether the demand is derived from a local community need.'
The Laskies remain hopeful councillors will overrule this planning advice.
Three objectors, who wanted anonymity to avoid inflaming neighbourhood tensions, indicated an appeal to the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal was possible if councillors supported the plan.
A City of Boroondara spokesperson said the municipality's planning scheme required 'a wide range of factors' be considered, but declined to comment further ahead of council's vote.
'These factors include amenity impacts, benefits to the local community, zoning controls and guidance, and submissions received during the public consultation period,' they said.
Baillieu, the former Victorian Liberal leader, added: 'Only a completely out-of-touch council could block a complete success.'
Councillors – including Baillieu's son, Rob, who was elected in a local teal wave last year – will decide the issue on Monday night.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Age
a day ago
- The Age
Allan's working-from-home push is an affront and a furphy
Premier Jacinta Allan can paint her latest foray into workplace relations any colour she chooses, but there is an overarching image that emerges. That is, this is at best good politics, not good policy. At last weekend's Victorian Labor state conference, Allan unveiled the government's new policy of seeking to enshrine in law a right for workers in the public or the private sector to work from home two days a week where reasonable. It would be the first such policy by a state. Self-evidently, that right could not extend to jobs that need to be performed on-site, such as emergency services. Consultation will be led by the Department of Premier and Cabinet. In spruiking the policy, Allan said it was good for families and the economy. 'If you can do your job from home, we'll make it your right – because we're on your side,' she said. There is no doubt there has been a revolution in working arrangements wrought by COVID-19. The workplace is a much more flexible environment than pre-pandemic, a development that has created opportunities for many people, especially those with caring responsibilities and disabilities. Loading The Australian Bureau of Statistics says about a third of the nation's employees work from home for part of the week. The premier could be seen to be merely acknowledging this trend and seeking to cement it into law. She could also be seen to be grasping at a distraction that will avert critical eyes from the performance of her government amid some controversial cuts as its strained budget position bites. If the plan puts pressure on the Liberals to declare their position with an election due next year, that could only be seen as a bonus. Federal Labor at this year's election was the beneficiary of Peter Dutton's ill-thought-out plan to force public servants back to the office. As The Age reports today, Labor considered new federal laws in this space – as it is entitled to do. The intervention of the Victorian government into the relationship between employer and employee seems more like Dutton's intervention but in the opposite direction. Businesses are not the same, and to bring into law a right to work from home two days a week without regard to the particular circumstances of a business is wrong. As an aside, how was two days arrived at? Allan hasn't said. How the policy would become a reality is not clear either. Victoria referred its powers to regulate private sector workplaces to the federal jurisdiction decades ago. The Age has reported warnings, as has The Australian Financial Review, from legal experts that the proposal would almost certainly fall foul of Section 109 of the Constitution, that is, if state and federal law cover the same area, federal law prevails. If the Victorian parliament enacts work-from-home legislation, this would be ripe for a High Court challenge.
Sydney Morning Herald
5 days ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
Hundreds want this Hawthorn milk bar to open for dinner. But the council may not agree
'Our house prices are going down because of this,' he told The Age, briefly stopping to tell a cafe-bound tradie that he couldn't park in front of his house. 'It's not a big deal if you don't live nearby, but it has disrupted our way of life.' However, Sally Mills and Joe Tobin, from two other Barton Street households, told The Age they backed the restaurant plan. James Laskie, meanwhile, has compiled a petition with 267 signatures supporting a six-hour trading extension. The majority list their addresses as within the broader Hawthorn suburb, but not right next door. Although separate to the planning process, the petition was tabled at Boroondara Council's meeting last Monday ahead of a final vote on an amended permit next week. But council officials have already recommended elected councillors reject it. 'The request for extended trading would result in activities on the site extending into more sensitive times and is not supported in this location, as echoed by objections made by nearby residents,' a report said. It added that key concerns included noise from patrons and vehicles, traffic and parking congestion, disruption to the 'quiet and family-orientated character' of the area, and antisocial behaviour stemming from alcohol being served. Laskie, however, said his restaurant would not be a boozy bar. Instead, he said his 'modest' application would facilitate a 'family-focused, seated dinner service to our existing clientele'. 'We believe that this would add a currently unavailable amenity to the area, that is in keeping with the character of the neighbourhood, and will only enhance the experience of its residents,' the Laskie siblings said. 'If granted these hours, we would close food service around 8pm, allowing for diners to enjoy their meals, coffee and drinks in a quiet and unrushed environment, as well as allowing staff to prep the cafe for the morning, clean, and close by 10pm.' They described the objections as 'unwarranted, though understandable fears of select individuals'. 'We will continue to adapt our business to suit locals and the neighbourhood that underpin Barton Milk Bar's identity,' they said. A council report found the Laskies had demand for expansion, but added: 'It is difficult to determine whether the demand is derived from a local community need.' The Laskies remain hopeful councillors will overrule this planning advice. Three objectors, who wanted anonymity to avoid inflaming neighbourhood tensions, indicated an appeal to the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal was possible if councillors supported the plan. A City of Boroondara spokesperson said the municipality's planning scheme required 'a wide range of factors' be considered, but declined to comment further ahead of council's vote. 'These factors include amenity impacts, benefits to the local community, zoning controls and guidance, and submissions received during the public consultation period,' they said. Baillieu, the former Victorian Liberal leader, added: 'Only a completely out-of-touch council could block a complete success.' Councillors – including Baillieu's son, Rob, who was elected in a local teal wave last year – will decide the issue on Monday night.
The Age
5 days ago
- The Age
Hundreds want this Hawthorn milk bar to open for dinner. But the council may not agree
'Our house prices are going down because of this,' he told The Age, briefly stopping to tell a cafe-bound tradie that he couldn't park in front of his house. 'It's not a big deal if you don't live nearby, but it has disrupted our way of life.' However, Sally Mills and Joe Tobin, from two other Barton Street households, told The Age they backed the restaurant plan. James Laskie, meanwhile, has compiled a petition with 267 signatures supporting a six-hour trading extension. The majority list their addresses as within the broader Hawthorn suburb, but not right next door. Although separate to the planning process, the petition was tabled at Boroondara Council's meeting last Monday ahead of a final vote on an amended permit next week. But council officials have already recommended elected councillors reject it. 'The request for extended trading would result in activities on the site extending into more sensitive times and is not supported in this location, as echoed by objections made by nearby residents,' a report said. It added that key concerns included noise from patrons and vehicles, traffic and parking congestion, disruption to the 'quiet and family-orientated character' of the area, and antisocial behaviour stemming from alcohol being served. Laskie, however, said his restaurant would not be a boozy bar. Instead, he said his 'modest' application would facilitate a 'family-focused, seated dinner service to our existing clientele'. 'We believe that this would add a currently unavailable amenity to the area, that is in keeping with the character of the neighbourhood, and will only enhance the experience of its residents,' the Laskie siblings said. 'If granted these hours, we would close food service around 8pm, allowing for diners to enjoy their meals, coffee and drinks in a quiet and unrushed environment, as well as allowing staff to prep the cafe for the morning, clean, and close by 10pm.' They described the objections as 'unwarranted, though understandable fears of select individuals'. 'We will continue to adapt our business to suit locals and the neighbourhood that underpin Barton Milk Bar's identity,' they said. A council report found the Laskies had demand for expansion, but added: 'It is difficult to determine whether the demand is derived from a local community need.' The Laskies remain hopeful councillors will overrule this planning advice. Three objectors, who wanted anonymity to avoid inflaming neighbourhood tensions, indicated an appeal to the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal was possible if councillors supported the plan. A City of Boroondara spokesperson said the municipality's planning scheme required 'a wide range of factors' be considered, but declined to comment further ahead of council's vote. 'These factors include amenity impacts, benefits to the local community, zoning controls and guidance, and submissions received during the public consultation period,' they said. Baillieu, the former Victorian Liberal leader, added: 'Only a completely out-of-touch council could block a complete success.' Councillors – including Baillieu's son, Rob, who was elected in a local teal wave last year – will decide the issue on Monday night.
