Tax on ultra-rich: 'France has the opportunity to lead the way,' say Nobel Prize-winning economists
They have never been so wealthy and yet contribute little, relative to their ability to pay, to the public coffers: From Bernard Arnault to Elon Musk, billionaires have lower tax rates than the average taxpayer.
Pioneering research conducted in partnership with tax authorities in several countries demonstrates it: Ultra-wealthy individuals pay around 0% to 0.6% of their wealth in individual income tax – around 0.6% in a country like the United States and 0.1% in a country like France.
When including all other mandatory levies (corporate taxes, social security contributions, consumption taxes, etc.) and expressing their tax payments as a fraction of income, their effective tax rates turn out to be lower than those of middle-class or upper-middle-class taxpayers.
How did we get here? In short, because the ultra-wealthy can easily structure their wealth to avoid income tax, which is supposed to be the cornerstone of tax justice. In European countries, this optimization is achieved through the creation of family holding companies, in which dividends accumulate sheltered from taxation. In the US, the use of holding companies to dodge taxes has been prohibited since the 1930s, which explains why the wealthy are more heavily taxed there than in Europe – though some have still managed to find workarounds.
Fortunately, this situation is not the result of a natural law or some ancient fate: It stems from human decisions and political choices. There is no inevitability here. Not only is it necessary to impose a stronger burden of justice on billionaires, but more importantly, it is possible.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
LeMonde
3 hours ago
- LeMonde
European Commission dismisses interpreter over suspected espionage for Moscow
Interpreters are not merely translators; they are also among the few witnesses to confidential discussions between leaders. The European Commission was recently reminded of this after an incident – kept confidential until now – led to disciplinary action against a Franco-Ukrainian interpreter working for the institution. The incident took place on December 19, 2024, during a European Council meeting in Brussels, with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky in attendance. The findings of the internal investigation have since been forwarded to Belgian authorities, who will decide whether to pursue further investigations and whether the actions in question constitute Russian espionage. On that December day, the European Council was hosting Volodymyr Zelensky. The meeting was crucial: it was intended to determine the future of European support for Kyiv, which has been under attack by Russia since February 2022. The re-election of US President Donald Trump one month prior – who had promised during his campaign to end the war "in 24 hours" – changed the dynamic. On that day, European leaders sought to agree on a common position before the newly elected president returned to the White House.
Euronews
7 hours ago
- Euronews
Ex Real Madrid boss sentenced to one year in prison for tax evasion
A Spanish court has sentenced current Brazil national team and former Real Madrid manager Carlo Ancelotti to one year in prison for tax fraud. The Madrid Provincial Court handed down the sentence on Wednesday for the offence committed in 2014 and fined him just over €386,000 which he must pay to the tax authorities. The court has also acquitted him of similar charges relating to the 2015 tax year, due to a lack of evidence of his residence in Spain during that period. Despite the conviction, Spanish law stipulates that sentences of less than two years for non-violent offences and provided the person possesses no criminal record, serving time in prison is not mandatory. It is therefore likely that Ancelotti will settle his dues and avoid his prison term. The court ruling however establishes that, for a period of three consecutive years, the football coaching icon, whose career has seen him take the helm of top European sides including AC Milan, Bayern Munich, PSG and Chelsea, will not be able to obtain or claim public aid, subsidies, tax benefits or social security incentives in Spain. Ancelotti claims he followed Real Madrid's advice During the trial in April, Ancelotti claimed he has always acted on the legal advice of Real Madrid and its tax consultants, denying that he had any intention of defrauding the tax authorities. He added that he settled the outstanding debt with the tax office in December 2021 and asked that the mitigating factors of damages and procedural delays be taken into account. Carlo Ancelotti was in charge of Real Madrid across two stints, the first between June 2013 and May 2015, and the second from June 2021 until May 2025, when he ended his tenure at the club to take over a new challenge: leading the Brazilian national team to its record extending 6th World Cup title, scheduled to take place in the summer of 2026.
Local France
10 hours ago
- Local France
French police raid HQ of far-right Rassemblement National
The party of Marine Le Pen, the longtime standard bearer of the French far right, has come under increasing scrutiny in recent years. The 56-year-old politician, who has three times run for president, suffered a stunning blow in March when a French court convicted her and other party officials over an EU parliament fake jobs scam. The ruling, which Le Pen has appealed, banned her from standing for office for five years, effectively scuppering her ambition of running in 2027 presidential elections. Le Pen has asked her top lieutenant, 29-year-old party leader and member of European Parliament Jordan Bardella, to prepare to campaign in her place. News of the raid was made public by Bardella in a post on X (formerly Twitter) on Wednesday, in which he denounced the police probe as 'a new campaign of harassment'. 'Since 8:50 this morning, the headquarters of Rassemblement National — including the offices of its leaders — have been searched by around 20 armed police officers from the Financial Brigade, wearing bulletproof vests and accompanied by two investigating judges,' Bardella posted. 'All emails, documents, and accounting records of the leading opposition party are being seized, and at this stage we do not know the precise nature of the allegations on which this action is based. Advertisement 'All we know is that all the files relating to the latest regional, presidential, legislative, and European campaigns – in other words, all the party's electoral activity – are now in the hands of the courts. 'This spectacular and unprecedented operation is clearly part of a new campaign of harassment. It is a serious attack on pluralism and democratic alternation. 'Never has an opposition party been subjected to such relentless persecution under the Fifth Republic.' Contrary to Bardella's rabble-rousing rhetoric on, France's Parti Socialiste, the right-wing UMP (now Les Républicains), centrist MoDem and the hard-left La France Insoumise have all been subjected to similar judicial searches during the course of various investigations over the past decade. Police also carried out searches of former Health Minister Olivier Véran's office and home in 2020 when a probe was opened into the government handling of the Covid pandemic . Advertisement The Paris prosecutor's office said police had raided the party's offices as part of an investigation launched in July last year into alleged illegal campaign financing for the 2022 presidential and parliamentary elections, as well as the European polls last year. The investigation seeks to "determine whether these campaigns were notably funded through illegal loans from individuals to the party or RN candidates", the prosecutor's office added. It would also look into allegations the party had included inflated or fake invoices in its claims for the state to reimburse its campaign finances, said the office. Police also searched the offices and homes of several company bosses on Wednesday as part of the investigation covering the period of January 2020 to July 2024, it said. In a separate case, the EU's prosecutor said Tuesday it has launched a formal investigation into a defunct far-right group, which included France's RN, over the alleged misuse of European Parliament funds. According to the reports by a consortium of European media, most of the allegedly misused funds benefited companies belonging to a former adviser to Le Pen and his wife. No arrests have been made.
