Shubman Gill or Yashasvi Jaiswal for spot in Asia Cup squad? Ex-India player makes his argument
has a stronger case than
for a spot in India's squad for the upcoming Asia Cup, highlighting that the left-hander's game is better aligned with the demands of T20 cricket.
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now
The Ajit Agarkar-led selection panel is expected to meet on August 19 to finalise the squad for the tournament, scheduled from September 9 to 28 in the UAE. With Abhishek Sharma and Sanju Samson having established themselves as the preferred opening combination, the selectors face a tough call on whether to add another opener, and if so, who that should be.
Go Beyond The Boundary with our YouTube channel. SUBSCRIBE NOW!
EXCLUSIVE | Harbhajan Singh on Rohit Sharma, Virat Kohli, Shubman Gill, India vs Pakistan and more
Chopra argued that Jaiswal's style suits India's T20 template.
'As per T20 figures, Yashasvi is little ahead of Shubman. The way he plays T20 and the DNA of the team, he also marries that style,' he said on his YouTube channel on Saturday.
He also pointed out the challenge of accommodating Gill without disrupting the balance of the playing XI. 'Sometimes it also happens that if you pick Shubman as the third opener, who is your Test captain, the ODI vice-captain, now you have him on the bench in T20Is, that will not look very nice.
So the selectors will be thinking that if we are going to select Shubman, then we will have to give him a place in the eleven. Though picking Shubman is tempting, but I feel Yashasvi should be slightly ahead in this race.
'
With India's top order looking settled, Chopra questioned how either Gill or Jaiswal could fit in without shaking the line-up. 'But if that third opener is Shubman, do you want him to sit on the bench? If you don't make him sit and play in the eleven, who will he come in for? If that player's name is Sanju Samson, who will keep wickets?'
Poll
Is Yashasvi Jaiswal's aggressive style more suited for T20 cricket compared to Shubman Gill?
Yes No
He further explained why Samson's role complicated matters. 'That is the problem because we don't see Sanju Samson playing in the middle order. You would want him at the top. Tilak and Surya will play at number three and four. So, Sanju at fifth? That won't be a good story,' Chopra added.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Batting for continuity? For head coach Gautam Gambhir, it's all about the result
LONDON, ENGLAND - JULY 30: India coach Gautam Gambhir speaks with captain Shubman Gill during a net session at The Kia Oval on July 30, 2025 in London, England. (Photo by) New Delhi: Moments after India pulled off a miraculous draw in the fourth Test in Manchester last month, head coach Gautam Gambhir turned up at the press conference in his usual feisty avatar. It was the only Test during the two-month long tour in which India had been trailing England for almost four days. Gambhir wasn't merely there to express his glee or relief. He was there to reiterate that those who doubted his strategies weren't clued in. The coach feeds off the challenges thrown at him. In coming back from England with a 2-2 scoreline, he has been vindicated for some of the tough calls he took. The next six months, starting with the Asia Cup in UAE next month, will be the first time Gambhir will truly get to work on the T20I team for a period of time. Yet, the current T20I side is more his baby. His stint as India's head coach started with Suryakumar Yadav being propelled to T20I captaincy ahead of Hardik Pandya . With Rohit Sharma and Virat Kohli already retired from the format at the start of his stint, he could seamlessly drive home his philosophy in the dressing room. It didn't matter if India were the new T20I world champions. Go Beyond The Boundary with our YouTube channel. SUBSCRIBE NOW! 'T20 World Cup, T20 side for India should be selected from IPL,' Gambhir said on former India off-spinner Ravichandran Ashwin 's YouTube channel just before assuming the role with the Indian team. Gambhir isn't looking to rock the boat. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Drive, Sail & Save – The Budget-Friendly Way to Explore Europe! Learn More Undo But by now, it has been well established that he doesn't mind dragging established names out of their comfort zones. He is rarely inhibited while giving more responsibility to unheralded cricketers — be it Suryakumar Yadav and Manish Pandey at KKR in 2014 or backing Ayush Badoni at Lucknow Super Giants. Much of Washington Sundar's evolution as a Test allrounder is down to Gambhir's unwavering backing. Gambhir swears by continuity. Despite all the talk of flexibility, he seeks stability at the top. The chatter in Indian cricket is that he would prefer an all format captain soon to build a common culture. Gambhir has been very clear with his vision. He walked in with an idea to rebrand the T20 team. India have often been accused of not being able to move with the times in the shortest format. Gambhir has decided to address it with players who can be branded as T20 specialists. He doesn't mind if the pool swelled. That's why Ramandeep Singh and Mayank Yadav were given their opportunities last year. India's attacking brand of T20 cricket over the last 12 months is proof enough of how the Delhi man wants to go about his job. Poll Do you believe Gautam Gambhir's strategies will lead India to success in T20 cricket? Yes, absolutely No, I have doubts Maybe, it depends on execution I need more time to decide This is the format that brought him recognition as a tactician. He won two IPL titles with KKR as a captain more than a decade ago before returning as a mentor in 2024 and delivering their third. He also stands out, being quite bullish about 'results' rather than process. Those who share the dressing room with Gambhir say that the coach loves breaking the game up into 120 balls rather than looking at it as a 20-over entity. 'Every ball has to have an impact' is his go-to phrase. There's no room for getting comfortable. Roles are assigned as per skills, not batting numbers. He is comfortable with this facet of a modern-day T20 cricketer. Shivam Dube, for one, will always get preference since he can go up the order and blast the bowling if the openers get off to great starts. There are no designated finishers. Gambhir's inclination towards having allrounders stems from the need to have more options. The Asia Cup may give us a glimpse of how he wants to go about his business in the next few months, but nothing is cast in stone yet. With the success in Champions Trophy and England, things have started to fall in place for Gambhir. Till the transition button is pressed in ODIs, it won't be surprising to see a few unexpected moves in T20 cricket. Catch Rani Rampal's inspiring story on Game On, Episode 4. Watch Here!
News18
2 hours ago
- News18
'10 Saal Se Hain, Par Kuch Nahi Jeetaya': Ex-Pak Opener's Scathing Attack On Babar Azam
The Asia Cup is just around the corner, and all eyes will soon be on the much-anticipated India-Pakistan encounters, with the possibility of the two sides meeting thrice in the tournament. The former cricketers in our neighbouring country have already been talking about Pakistan's prospects against Suryakumar Yadav and Co., but most of them remain doubtful. Following their ODI series loss to the West Indies, experts are unsure whether Pakistan can put up a strong fight against India—or even make a solid impact in the competition overall. But they still hope the best for the team.
Hindustan Times
3 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Sanju Samson left hanging in Asia Cup drama as Shubman Gill debate rages: Opener? No. 5? Or left out altogether?
Sanju Samson has become the talk of Indian cricket. On one hand, speculation surrounds his next Indian Premier League (IPL) franchise after reports that he told Rajasthan Royals he wants to part ways before the 2026 season; on the other, he finds himself in the thick of the selection drama for the upcoming Asia Cup. The selectors are expected to announce the T20I squad on Tuesday at a press conference in Mumbai. Will Sanju Samson make the India Asia Cup squad?(AP) Samson should be a certainty, having smashed three centuries in his last 12 T20Is after being backed extensively as an opener. However, Shubman Gill's recent form in the Test series against England has reignited calls for his inclusion in the T20I squad. Given that the 25-year-old is also a top-order batter, his selection could push Samson down to the middle order or even leave him out altogether — a scenario former India cricketer Aakash Chopra warned 'would not be a good story' for the Kerala star. Speaking on the selection dilemma for the Asia Cup on his YouTube channel, Chopra said: "I do not think anyone needs to go out. It is important that you keep another opener with you. India did not pick a third opener (in the T20I series against England). They were not even thinking about who would open if either Abhishek Sharma or Sanju Samson loses form. If you do not keep the third opener here, you will have to keep him in the World Cup." "However, if Shubman Gill is the third opener, do you want to make him sit on the bench? If you don't do that and play him in the XI, in whose place will you play him? If that player's name is Sanju Samson, who will keep? That is the problem. You do not see Sanju Samson batting in the middle order. Suryakumar Yadav and Tilak Varma will play at number three and number four. Sanju at No. 5? That would not be a good story," he added. Chopra further explained that if a third opener is included, it won't be at Abhishek Sharma's expense but Samson's, which would make India's recent investment in him as an opener seem wasted. The Sunrisers Hyderabad star had put on a stunning show in the home series against England earlier this year, where he scored 279 runs in five matches at a strike rate of 219.68. "If the third opener plays, he cannot play in place of Abhishek Sharma. He will play in place of Sanju Samson, and you won't see Sanju Samson playing in the middle order. Then you will start feeling that you wasted the investment you made in the last 12 matches. Suddenly, from being the opener, he is out," he said. The former Indian batter also said that Gill's ability to fit into a destructive batting template was questionable, unlike Yashasvi Jaiswal, who he felt naturally suited that DNA. "What goes agaisnt Shubman? If you want to make a destructive team, can Shubman Gill become a part of that DNA? That is the big question. Yashasvi Jaiswal can definitely become a part of that DNA, but are they thinking about Yashasvi?" Chopra observed.
