IND vs ENG: 'Too many captains…' — Ex-India spinner blames KL Rahul, Rishabh Pant for chaos at Headingley
The India team huddle (Photo by)
Former India spinner
Murali Karthik
has raised concerns about multiple players giving on-field instructions during India's first Test match against England at Headingley Cricket Ground, specifically pointing to
KL Rahul
and
Rishabh Pant
's involvement in field placement decisions alongside captain
Shubman Gill
.
The criticism comes after England's five-wicket victory over India in the opening Test of the Tendulkar-Anderson Trophy 2025, which has given them a 1-0 lead in the five-match series.
Go Beyond The Boundary with our YouTube channel.
SUBSCRIBE NOW!
The situation emerged on Day 5 of the Headingley Test, particularly after Prasidh Krishna claimed two wickets in the second session. Multiple senior players were observed giving different instructions on the field, creating what Karthik perceived as confusion in the team's leadership structure.
03:36
India Sweat it out at the Nets in Birmingham Ahead of the 2nd Test vs England
"At one point I felt there were too many captains," said Kartik on Cricbuzz. "I just couldn't understand that. KL Rahul was making hand movements, Rishabh Pant was also doing it, and so was Shubman Gill who is actually the man appointed as captain. I couldn't understand those multiple hand signals. You wouldn't want to complicate things. There is only one captain."
Karthik further elaborated on acceptable levels of senior player involvement versus what he witnessed during the match.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Unbelievable: Calculator Shows The Value Of Your House Instantly (Take a Look)
Home Value Calculator
Search Now
Undo
"A senior player making slight changes here and there, correcting someone slightly when they feel they are slightly in the wrong position, sending third man or short fine, mid-on, mid-off; these are all fine occasionally. However, so many players taking calls so frequently is not a good sign."
Quiz:
Who's that IPL player?
The Indian team has now moved to Birmingham for the second Test match, scheduled to take place at Edgbaston Stadium from July 2 to July 6, 2025.
Reports indicate that India's pace spearhead Jasprit Bumrah might miss the upcoming match due to workload management considerations.
Meanwhile, England has announced their squad for the second Test match, with Jofra Archer being included in the lineup. The England squad features Ben Stokes as captain, along with players like Shoaib Bashir, Jacob Bethell, Harry Brook, Brydon Carse, Sam Cook, Zak Crawley, Ben Duckett, Jamie Overton, Ollie Pope, Joe Root, Jamie Smith, Josh Tongue, and Chris Woakes.
The series, named the Tendulkar-Anderson Trophy 2025, continues to generate interest as both teams prepare for the crucial second Test. England's victory in the first Test has set the tone for what promises to be an engaging series between the two cricket powerhouses.
The match at Edgbaston will be crucial for India as they look to level the series, while England will aim to build on their momentum from the Headingley victory. The focus will be on how India addresses the leadership dynamics on the field, following Karthik's observations about the multiple decision-makers during the first Test.
Game On Season 1 continues with Mirabai Chanu's inspiring story. Watch Episode 2 here.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
United News of India
26 minutes ago
- United News of India
Praggnanandhaa wins UzChess Cup Masters 2025, becomes India's No 1 ranked player
Tashkent (Uzbekistan), June 28(UNI) Grand Master R. Praggnanandhaa has emerged as India's number one ranked Chess player after his victory in the UzChess Cup Masters 2025. 19 year old Praggnanandhaa secured a win against Uzbekistan's Nodirbek Abdusattorov in the final match to bag the title on Friday. As a result of this win, Praggnanandhaa, with a live elo rating of 2778.3, rose three positions to move past reigning classical chess world champion D. Gukesh (2776.6) to become the top-ranked Indian player. Praggnanandhaa is now also the World No. 4 ranked player. UNI RKM
Hindustan Times
30 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Rohit Sharma's key role identified in changing KL Rahul's fortunes: 'He was keen on bringing out his aggressive...'
Almost out of the blue, KL Rahul has graduated from being simply a highly-talented role-player in India's teams across formats to one of its senior statesmen, a leader of the batting attack with seniority now attached to his position and his expectations. At 32 years old and with his long-time teammates Rohit Sharma and Virat Kohli retiring from Test cricket, the versatile and capable Rahul continues to adapt to what his team needs from him most. Rohit Sharma played a key role in developing KL Rahul to continue striving towards greatness as a batter, even at 32 years old.(REUTERS) In 2025, he seems to have flicked a switch: now almost guaranteed to start Test matches as an opener, he began the tour of England with two fine innings, including a stylish century in the second innings in Leeds. In the ODI unit, Rahul was used as India's number six, and showed remarkable temperament and skill as he took to that role like a duck to water in the successful ICC Champions Trophy campaign. All this might not have been possible without the help of his captain Rohit Sharma and India's then-assistant coach Abhishek Nayar during his brief stint with the team. Speaking to ESPNcricinfo, Nayar revealed that one of the key duties he was prescribed was to help KL Rahul elevate his game to the consistency and ability that was always there in flashes. Also Read: KL Rahul's commitment to choosing 'country over his child' gets exuberant praise "When I first picked up that role, I remember I had a conversation with Rohit, and he said that one of the things he was really keen on me doing was working with KL and bringing out a more aggressive outlook to how KL played the game, and bringing the best out of him,' said Nayar, who served as coach when Gautam Gambhir took over the head coach position but was sacrificed after the BCCI's inquest following a horror spell in Test cricket to start with 6 losses in 8 matches. What did KL Rahul change to reach the best version of himself? It certainly translated for Rahul, who showed off a few switches in technique that became clear in the knockout rounds of the Champions Trophy. Scores of 41* against Australia in the semifinal, followed by a nerve-settling 34* in the final against New Zealand, saw him score positively while remaining in total control — two parts of his game that Rahul has always possessed but previously failed to combine efficiently. More than the scores themselves, the confidence with which Rahul took India home on both occasions spoke to a batter who had entered an excellent mental zone. On what exactly Nayar and Rahul worked on to achieve this, the coach held his cards close to his chest, but provided a fascinating glimpse. 'All I can tell you is, the way I've always tried to handle things is to first try and address the skill, and then use skill as a medium to address the mind. That's as much as I can tell you in terms of details. It's about using practice to give his mind reassurance with the plan that we have, and what he needs to do to execute it,' explained the former Mumbai batter. His 'aggressive outlook' also bore results in the IPL, where he shone with his new franchise Delhi Capitals, scoring 539 runs at a strike-rate of 149. After some seasons seeing his strike-rate criticised, the latest version of Rahul showed a willingness to go big from the off, and took away his earlier tendency to fall into a shell.
India Today
37 minutes ago
- India Today
The KL Rahul comeback: Are India reaping rewards of Rohit Sharma and Abhishek Nayar's work?
India batter KL Rahul has been enjoying some sensational form since the Border-Gavaskar Trophy. A gritty outing in Australia and then two fantastic performances in the Champions Trophy 2025 and Indian Premier League, KL Rahul is enjoying one of the best patches of his the absence of Virat Kohli and Rohit Sharma in the Test series against England, Rahul has started strongly as well, hitting a century in the second innings of the opening Test match. Former India batting coach Abhishek Nayar has revealed that Rahul's revival of form was one of the main projects he undertook during his tenure with the Indian I first picked up that role, I remember I had a conversation with Rohit, and he said that one of the things he was really keen on me doing was working with KL and bringing out a more aggressive outlook to how KL played the game, and bringing the best out of him because he believed strongly that KL would play a major role in the Champions Trophy, World Cup and everything going forward including the BGT [Border-Gavaskar Trophy] and the Tests in England," Abhishek Nayar told ESPNcricinfo in an Rahul's Comeback in 2024 The current KL Rahul is vastly different from the KL Rahul of 2023, who was heavily criticised for his outing in the ODI World Cup 2023 final. In that match, Rahul got stuck between gears and failed under the pressure of the big occasion against Pat Cummins' Australia Rahul was dropped from the T20 World Cup team in 2024 and was also let go by his Indian Premier League franchise, Lucknow Super revealed that drastic changes needed to be made in KL Rahul's technique and mentality, and the duo got to work during India's ill-fated Test series against New Zealand."Australia was going to be critical for him because it was almost like what if you didn't get runs there, then where is his career going? Because he was out of the T20 [squad]. Then this could also very well have been his last series. I told him, listen, we've got 15 days to prepare before we go to Australia. And take those 10 days there, we have got almost a month to prepare. What do you want to do? How do you want to approach this? What is your mindset?" Nayar former cricketer revealed that he fixed Rahul's skills first and then got working on the mental side of the game. KL Rahul's improved batting reflected in the Champions Trophy, where the batter finished matches with sixes, something that was not seen in his batting before."He spoke about what he's been doing and what worked for him in the past. And then I had a certain thought process, which was very different from his. Over hours and hours of conversation and trying to make him understand where I came from, eventually I got him to a place where he sort of trusted me to do certain things with him in regards to how he practises, in regards to trusting certain changes in his tactics, in regards to his stance, where he stands in the crease, what guard he takes," Nayar reported that Abhishek Nayar continues to work with KL Rahul in a personal capacity despite being sacked from the Indian team. Rahul would hope to continue his form and play some impactful innings in England.- EndsTune InMust Watch
