logo
Supreme Court Urged by NBA To Clarify 37-Year-Old Law

Supreme Court Urged by NBA To Clarify 37-Year-Old Law

Newsweek4 days ago
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources.
Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content.
The National Basketball Association (NBA), along with support from the National Football League (NFL), is urging the United States Supreme Court to provide a definitive interpretation of the Video Privacy Protection Act (VPPA), a law enacted in the 1980s to protect consumer video rental and viewing records.
Why It Matters
As digital content and streaming services have redefined the modern viewing landscape, federal courts are divided on whether this decades-old law should apply to those accessing free online content.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 2nd and 7th Circuits have ruled that the law does apply to consumers of a videotape service provider's non-audiovisual goods and services, while the U.S. 6th Circuit Court of Appeals rejected this interpretation.
"Only this Court can resolve the split," Shay Dvoretzky and Raza Rasheed, attorneys for the NBA, wrote in a brief filed Wednesday.
Newsweek has reached out to the NBA for comment.
A general overall exterior view of the Supreme Court, on January 1, 2023, in Washington.
A general overall exterior view of the Supreme Court, on January 1, 2023, in Washington.
Aaron M. Sprecher via AP
What To Know
The case centers on Michael Salazar, who in 2022 filed suit against the NBA after subscribing to its free online newsletter and watching complimentary videos on NBA.com while logged into Facebook. Salazar alleges his video viewing history was shared with Meta, Facebook's parent company, without his consent, via tracking software incorporated on the NBA's website.
The NBA argues that Salazar is not protected under the VPPA because he subscribed to the NBA's free email newsletter, not its audiovisual content.
In October 2024, the 2nd Circuit ruled that Salazar was a "consumer" under the VPPA because he had exchanged personal information for access to NBA content. The 7th Circuit agreed with the 2nd Circuit's decision, but the 6th Circuit rejected those decisions, holding that the VPPA's protections only to those who subscribe to videocassette tapes or similar audiovisual materials.
"This case is an excellent vehicle for addressing both the VPPA split and whether Salazar had standing to begin with," attorneys for the NBA wrote in a brief.
Salazar's attorney, Joshua I. Hammack, argues that the Court should not consider the case because a final judgment has not been reached, and two amended complaints have been filed since the NBA petitioned the Court for certiorari.
"This case is far from an 'ideal' or 'perfect vehicle,'" Hammack wrote in a brief.
Newsweek has also reached out to Hammack for comment.
In May, the NFL filed a brief supporting the NBA's petition and emphasizing the potential industrywide repercussions.
The NFL argued that Supreme Court intervention is necessary to address a rise in class action lawsuits against content providers under the VPPA.
"Absent the Court's intervention, sports leagues and other online content providers will continue to face a slew of class actions under the VPPA," attorneys for the NFL wrote in the brief.
What is the VPPA?
The VPPA was passed by Congress in 1988 and signed into law by President Ronald Reagan. The law is also referred to as the "Bork bill" because it was passed after Robert Bork's video rental history became public during his Supreme Court nomination.
The law states that a "videotape service provider" who knowingly discloses information about any of its consumers is liable to provide relief.
What People Are Saying
Shay Dvoretzky and Raza Rasheed, attorneys for the NBA, in a brief filed Wednesday: "The parties agree that the petition presents an important, certworthy VPPA question. This case is an excellent vehicle to resolve that question and whether Salazar has Article III standing. The Second Circuit's decision on both questions was wrong, and it threatens widespread damage to the modern internet economy. The Court should intervene."
Joshua I. Hammack, attorney for Michael Salazar, in a brief: "Nothing about 'subscribing' is unique to audiovisual goods or services. There is simply no basis to rewrite the VPPA's definition of 'consumer' to impose a limitation that appears nowhere in the text."
What Happens Next
The NBA has filed a petition for a writ of certiorari to the Supreme Court. The Court has yet to decide whether it will hear the case.
Do you have a story that Newsweek should be covering? Do you have any questions about this story? Contact LiveNews@newsweek.com.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Jets to have officials at camp to reduce penalties, says coach Aaron Glenn
Jets to have officials at camp to reduce penalties, says coach Aaron Glenn

Yahoo

time10 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Jets to have officials at camp to reduce penalties, says coach Aaron Glenn

FLORHAM PARK, N.J. (AP) — The New York Jets hope seeing more black-and-white stripes in training camp will result in fewer yellow flags during the season. Coach Aaron Glenn said Friday the team will often have officials at practice through the summer after the Jets, under the previous regime of coach Robert Saleh, led the NFL in penalties the last two seasons. New York rarely used officials during training camp practices during those summers. Many NFL teams hire officials for at least some of their camp practices, giving players the opportunity to get used to how plays are called in a non-game environment. 'I want the officials here as much as possible and they know that,' Glenn said. "It's no secret that we were the most-penalized team in the league last year, so that's one of the things that I want to nip in the bud early — making sure that the discipline part of what we do, that we fix that now. 'You cannot win games in this league with an undisciplined team, so all the penalties that we had last year, we're knocking those things out.' Last season, the Jets were penalized 137 times, five more than Tennessee and Baltimore, and finished 5-12 — with Saleh and general manager Joe Douglas both fired in the middle of the season. In 2023, New York was called for 124 penalties, nine more than Cleveland and Dallas, and went 7-10. 'The officials are going to be here and we're going to knock that out, all right,' Glenn said. 'I will tell you this: We are going to knock these penalties out. We're going to understand that undisciplined teams do not win games.' Philadelphia, last year's Super Bowl champion, ranked 11th in the NFL with 103 penalties. Kansas City, the AFC champion, was fourth with 94. The Los Angeles Rams, who won the NFC West, had the fewest penalties in the league with 91. Glenn said there are two types of calls on players during games: pre-snap penalties — 'the dumb penalties' — and competitive penalties, including pass interference. 'The competitive penalties, listen, you go back and forth with those, right?' Glenn said. 'Like P.I., guys are fighting. Those are competitive penalties. Holds, those are competitive. Now, false starts, jumping offside, hitting after plays, the dumb stuff, we've got to knock those out. And we control those. And those are the things I want to make sure we get rid of.' ___ AP NFL:

Mavericks' trade proposal sends former 15.7 PPG scorer to Charlotte
Mavericks' trade proposal sends former 15.7 PPG scorer to Charlotte

Yahoo

time10 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Mavericks' trade proposal sends former 15.7 PPG scorer to Charlotte

The Dallas Mavericks lucked out when they landed the No. 1 overall pick in the 2025 NBA Draft, selecting Duke standout Cooper Flagg. After adding Flagg and trading Luka Doncic for Anthony Davis last season, the team now boasts solid frontcourt depth. While the Mavericks appear to have a win-now mindset, they may consider flipping one of their frontcourt pieces for future assets. MORE: Blockbuster trade proposal sees LeBron James landing in Dallas Zach Roberts of recently compiled a mock trade that would reunite P.J. Washington with the Charlotte Hornets, who traded the forward to Dallas in February 2024. Here's Roberts' proposed trade: Mavericks receive: Pat Connaughton, 2031 first-round pick, 2031 second-round pick Hornets receive: P.J. Washington, 2030 second-round pick Washington has been a mainstay in Dallas' starting lineup since arriving there, but on a fully healthy Mavericks squad featuring Flagg, Davis, Dereck Lively and Daniel Gafford, it wouldn't be surprising to see him slide to the second unit. While the 26-year-old forward is a better player than Connaughton, Washington is also on an expiring contract. If Dallas decides against extending him this summer, trading him for future assets could be a logical move. The Kentucky product has been a reliable three-and-D contributor for the Mavericks and was part of their 2024 NBA Finals run with Doncic. Washington appeared in 57 regular-season games during the 2024-25 campaign, averaging 14.7 points, 7.8 rebounds, 2.3 assists, 1.1 steals and 1.1 blocks while shooting 38.1 percent from beyond the arc across 32.2 minutes per game. MORE NBA NEWS: Former 76ers guard drawing interest from Golden State in free agency 76ers linked to blockbuster trade proposal for four-time MVP LeBron James Old JJ Redick take on Marcus Smart resurfaces after ex-Celtic lands with Los Angeles Ex-Bucks star Damian Lillard shares daughter's hilarious reaction to Portland reunion Ex-Mavericks superstar Luka Doncic looking to put conditioning concerns to rest

Shedeur Sanders on not getting 1st-team reps with Browns: 'It's not in my control'
Shedeur Sanders on not getting 1st-team reps with Browns: 'It's not in my control'

Yahoo

time10 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Shedeur Sanders on not getting 1st-team reps with Browns: 'It's not in my control'

With NFL training camps well underway, rookie quarterback Shedeur Sanders is getting some reps with the Cleveland Browns in practice. Though Sanders has not been working much with the Browns' first-team offense, the rookie says that he's not thinking about it too hard. Sanders is one of four quarterbacks competing for Cleveland's starting job, alongside veteran Joe Flacco, fourth-year player Kenny Pickett and fellow rookie Dillon Gabriel. Although all four offer different strengths, Flacco and Pickett have been primarily working with the first team in training camp, while the two rookies work with backups. When asked why he didn't think he was getting first-team reps, Sanders said that he wasn't thinking about that. "That's not my place to answer," Sanders told reporters on Friday, via ESPN's Daniel Oyefusi. "I feel like it's not in my control, so I'm not even gonna think about that or have that even in my thought process." He also emphasized his gratitude to be training with Cleveland at all — a direct contrast to the bluster that seemed to trigger his stunning slide in the NFL draft. "There's a lot of people that wanna have the opportunity to be at this level, and I'm here, and I'm thankful to have the opportunity, so, whatever that is it is," Sanders added. As a result of the abundance of quarterbacks, Sanders has also been spotted practicing with members of the Browns' equipment team. But Sanders said that the targets didn't "faze" him, citing his college career between Jackson State and Colorado. "It doesn't really faze me. You gotta understand, we came all the way from an HBCU to a Power 5 (conference team), and now we here, so," Sanders said, via Oyefusi. "At this point you look around, there's nothing that's a challenge, I would say." Meanwhile, Sanders has other things to deal with as well: The rookie was cited twice for speeding after allegedly driving over 100 miles per hour on a Cleveland highway. But on Friday, Sanders seemed in good spirits on the issue. "I really don't even drive that much anymore," Sanders said with a laugh, via NFL reporter Andrew Siciliano. "I hope everybody learn from my situation, you know, to not drive fast at all." Also, via Siciliano, Sanders misses living near his brother, Shilo — at least partially because he misses Shilo's juicer. Who's in the lead for the Browns' starting QB job? The Browns' quarterback room is one of the oddest in the NFL, and the lack of a clear depth chart is affecting the dynamic. Flacco, despite being the most veteran player in the room, has chafed at the idea of being a mentor to the younger QBs; Gabriel and Sanders, as the two rookies, are trying to find a way to break through. Browns head coach Kevin Stefanski told reporters this week that all four of the quarterbacks have played well, and that they want to make a decision on who will start "sooner than later." In the meantime, tracking the four players' reps has been an easy way to try and gauge who might end up where on Cleveland's quarterback list. Drills this week have featured a rotation — Flacco, Pickett, Gabriel, Sanders — that points to the potential order. Additionally, in seven-on-seven practices on Wednesday (the Browns' first day of camp), Sanders was the only player to miss more than one of his throws, going 3-for-8. That performance may have something to do with why he's not getting as many first-team reps.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store