logo
Supreme Court Urged by NBA To Clarify 37-Year-Old Law

Supreme Court Urged by NBA To Clarify 37-Year-Old Law

Newsweek7 days ago
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources.
Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content.
The National Basketball Association (NBA), along with support from the National Football League (NFL), is urging the United States Supreme Court to provide a definitive interpretation of the Video Privacy Protection Act (VPPA), a law enacted in the 1980s to protect consumer video rental and viewing records.
Why It Matters
As digital content and streaming services have redefined the modern viewing landscape, federal courts are divided on whether this decades-old law should apply to those accessing free online content.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 2nd and 7th Circuits have ruled that the law does apply to consumers of a videotape service provider's non-audiovisual goods and services, while the U.S. 6th Circuit Court of Appeals rejected this interpretation.
"Only this Court can resolve the split," Shay Dvoretzky and Raza Rasheed, attorneys for the NBA, wrote in a brief filed Wednesday.
Newsweek has reached out to the NBA for comment.
A general overall exterior view of the Supreme Court, on January 1, 2023, in Washington.
A general overall exterior view of the Supreme Court, on January 1, 2023, in Washington.
Aaron M. Sprecher via AP
What To Know
The case centers on Michael Salazar, who in 2022 filed suit against the NBA after subscribing to its free online newsletter and watching complimentary videos on NBA.com while logged into Facebook. Salazar alleges his video viewing history was shared with Meta, Facebook's parent company, without his consent, via tracking software incorporated on the NBA's website.
The NBA argues that Salazar is not protected under the VPPA because he subscribed to the NBA's free email newsletter, not its audiovisual content.
In October 2024, the 2nd Circuit ruled that Salazar was a "consumer" under the VPPA because he had exchanged personal information for access to NBA content. The 7th Circuit agreed with the 2nd Circuit's decision, but the 6th Circuit rejected those decisions, holding that the VPPA's protections only to those who subscribe to videocassette tapes or similar audiovisual materials.
"This case is an excellent vehicle for addressing both the VPPA split and whether Salazar had standing to begin with," attorneys for the NBA wrote in a brief.
Salazar's attorney, Joshua I. Hammack, argues that the Court should not consider the case because a final judgment has not been reached, and two amended complaints have been filed since the NBA petitioned the Court for certiorari.
"This case is far from an 'ideal' or 'perfect vehicle,'" Hammack wrote in a brief.
Newsweek has also reached out to Hammack for comment.
In May, the NFL filed a brief supporting the NBA's petition and emphasizing the potential industrywide repercussions.
The NFL argued that Supreme Court intervention is necessary to address a rise in class action lawsuits against content providers under the VPPA.
"Absent the Court's intervention, sports leagues and other online content providers will continue to face a slew of class actions under the VPPA," attorneys for the NFL wrote in the brief.
What is the VPPA?
The VPPA was passed by Congress in 1988 and signed into law by President Ronald Reagan. The law is also referred to as the "Bork bill" because it was passed after Robert Bork's video rental history became public during his Supreme Court nomination.
The law states that a "videotape service provider" who knowingly discloses information about any of its consumers is liable to provide relief.
What People Are Saying
Shay Dvoretzky and Raza Rasheed, attorneys for the NBA, in a brief filed Wednesday: "The parties agree that the petition presents an important, certworthy VPPA question. This case is an excellent vehicle to resolve that question and whether Salazar has Article III standing. The Second Circuit's decision on both questions was wrong, and it threatens widespread damage to the modern internet economy. The Court should intervene."
Joshua I. Hammack, attorney for Michael Salazar, in a brief: "Nothing about 'subscribing' is unique to audiovisual goods or services. There is simply no basis to rewrite the VPPA's definition of 'consumer' to impose a limitation that appears nowhere in the text."
What Happens Next
The NBA has filed a petition for a writ of certiorari to the Supreme Court. The Court has yet to decide whether it will hear the case.
Do you have a story that Newsweek should be covering? Do you have any questions about this story? Contact LiveNews@newsweek.com.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Lakers star Luka Dončić on offseason workouts, conditioning: 'My whole body looks better'
Lakers star Luka Dončić on offseason workouts, conditioning: 'My whole body looks better'

Yahoo

time3 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Lakers star Luka Dončić on offseason workouts, conditioning: 'My whole body looks better'

You can't criticize Los Angeles Lakers superstar Luka Dončić for much. After being the No. 3 overall draft pick in 2018, Dončić won the Rookie of the Year award. He then proceeded to make the first team All-NBA team in five of his first seven seasons. But despite that excellence, Dončić has never received high marks for his conditioning. He's been criticized for coming into the season out of shape and not taking care of his body in the same manner as other NBA superstars. Those concerns seem to be a thing of the past. After weeks of rumors about Dončić's offseason workouts and conditioning, the 26-year-old finally spoke about the work he's put in, saying, "My whole body looks better." Dončić has adopted a gluten-free, low sugar diet, taken part in intermittent fasting and engaged in two-a-day workouts while training in Croatia for the upcoming 2025-26 NBA season, per Men's Health. It's all an attempt for Dončić to return to the court in better shape than ever. While conditioning issues have followed Dončić throughout his career, last year was different. He battled a calf injury which limited him to just 50 games. A midseason trade to the Lakers also shook things up for the superstar. Following the Lakers' early playoff exit to the Minnesota Timberwolves, Dončić wanted to get to work immediately, per Men's Health. One day after that loss, Dončić texted Seager to start his offseason training program ASAP. 'So every summer I try my best to work on different things," he says. "Obviously, I'm very competitive. This summer was just a little bit different, you know. It kind of motivated me to be even better.' His team put him through weight training and pushed him into other sports as a way to allow Dončić to rest his basketball muscles. Dončić was told he could not pick up a basketball during the first month, something he initially pushed back on. That month ended quickly, and Dončić was able to get back on the court. While he didn't make any specific comments about his weight or weight loss, Dončić implied that he feels lighter. When asked about the 42-inch vertical leap he showed off at the 2018 NBA Scouting Combine, Dončić said he believes he could exceed that number now, per Men's Health. 'This year, we didn't measure the jumping yet,' he says. 'But I think it's a little bit higher.' It's tough to imagine Dončić getting much better on the court. Few players in NBA history have matched his statistical excellence, though he's yet to win a championship. Following the Lakers' early playoff exit, head coach JJ Redick made waves after suggesting the team needed to "get in championship shape" if it hoped to win a title. Many viewed that as a shot at Dončić' and his conditioning. Whether or not the remark was intended for Dončić, he heard it loud and clear. It certainly sounds like Dončić will report to Lakers camp in the best shape of his life. It also sounds like this will be the new normal for Dončić going forward, as he told Men's Health this was "just the start." That's a scary thought for opposing defenders. Dončić was already an MVP candidate prior to his intense offseason workouts. If he can push himself to finally win the award, that could be just the thing the Lakers need to take home yet another championship.

Lakers' Luka Doncic weight loss lands him cover of Men's Health, and Mavericks fans are depressed
Lakers' Luka Doncic weight loss lands him cover of Men's Health, and Mavericks fans are depressed

Yahoo

time3 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Lakers' Luka Doncic weight loss lands him cover of Men's Health, and Mavericks fans are depressed

Dallas Mavericks fans should probably shield their eyes. Luka Doncic, the generational superstar that Nico Harrison traded away in part due to concerns over his conditioning? Yeah, that guy is on the cover of Men's Health magazine. The headline: Luka Doncic Muscles Up. The sub-heading: The Skinny on the Lakers Star's Summer Shread. MORE: Luka Doncic opens up about 42-inch vertical leap Luka clearly found some motivation to whip himself into tip-top physical shape this offseason. The Los Angeles Lakers will be the beneficiaries as their new face of the franchise leads them into an exciting era. The Mavs, well, at least they have Cooper Flagg. But the man who led them into the 2024 NBA Finals is now on a Western Conference rival, and he's looking Herculean. Yeah, that trade may indeed age very, very badly. MORE NBA NEWS: Syracuse legend Carmelo Anthony named greatest college basketball player of the millenium Steph Curry provides clarity on his retirement plans Victor Wembanyama's real reason for training with Chinese monks revealed Damian Lillard explains how WiFi kept him close to new teammate Jrue Holiday Lakers cut ties with 2 guards to make room for Marcus Smart Clippers' Nicolas Batum makes French retirement announcement

Buccaneers rookie linebacker David Walker out with a torn ACL
Buccaneers rookie linebacker David Walker out with a torn ACL

Yahoo

time3 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Buccaneers rookie linebacker David Walker out with a torn ACL

TAMPA, Fla. (AP) — Buccaneers rookie linebacker David Walker tore an ACL and likely will miss the rest of the season. Walker, a fourth-round draft pick out of Central Arkansas, sustained the knee injury in Friday's practice. He had 10 1/2 sacks last season and was expected to bolster Tampa Bay's pass rush. The Buccaneers finished tied for sixth in the NFL with 46 sacks in 2024. Walker was competing for snaps with veteran Anthony Nelson behind starter YaYa Diaby in Tampa Bay's 3-4 defense. The Buccaneers signed two-time Pro Bowl edge rusher Haason Reddick and veteran linebacker Anthony Walker Jr. in free agency. ___ AP NFL: The Associated Press

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store