First Nations say Alberta data centre strategy won't attract big tech players
The chiefs of the Alexander First Nation, Paul First Nation, Enoch Cree Nation and Alexis Nakota Sioux Nation outlined their concerns this week in an open letter to Premier Danielle Smith and members of her government.
'There are shovel-ready proposals backed by major industry players aligned with government objectives that will be left stranded without a change in proposed policy,' the chiefs wrote.
'Alberta should be a premier destination for hyperscale data centre investment. But strengths only matter if we act on them. Right now, Alberta's ability to execute and deliver on its promise is in question.'
Data centres are huge facilities housing the computing firepower needed for artificial intelligence and other applications. It can take an enormous amount of power to run and cool them. The chiefs say the amount of power the Alberta Electric System Operator has allotted to new projects falls short.
Story continues below advertisement
The Alberta Electric System Operator said earlier this month that it has received requests from 29 proposed data centre projects representing more than 16,000 megawatts — more than 11 times the City of Edmonton's load.
It said it will allow the connection of up to 1,200 megawatts of large load projects between now and 2028.
Get daily National news
Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up
By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy
'Alberta has never seen this level and volume of load connection requests,' said AESO CEO Aaron Engen.
'As the system operator, we are responsible for ensuring that new project connections do not compromise grid reliability. Because connecting all large loads seeking access would impair grid reliability, we established a limit that preserves system integrity while enabling timely data centre development in Alberta.'
The Alberta government has set a goal of attracting $100 billion in data centre investment over five years.
Story continues below advertisement
But the chiefs wrote that the limit sends the wrong signal to tech powerhouses like Meta and Amazon.
'The hyperscalers 'don't build small.' They think in gigawatts, because their global operations require that scale,' they wrote.
'Under the current proposal, not even one such flagship project may be fully realized here without years of delay, since 1,200 megawatts total divided among many projects signals that Alberta isn't prepared to accommodate a true hyperscaler's needs.
'This sends an unintended but clear message to investors that Alberta's actions do not match its ambitions.'
The Alberta government supports the 'balanced approach' the AESO is taking, said the press secretary for Affordability and Utilities Minister Nathan Neudorf.
'Alberta aims to be the destination of choice for AI data centres in North America,' Ashli Barrett said in a written statement.
'At the same time, our government will always put the well-being of Albertans first and ensure data centre projects will not compromise the affordability or reliability of the electricity that millions of Albertans, First Nations, and our local industries depend on.'
Barrett added the 1,200-megawatt limit is short-term and should not be thought of as a cap.
'It will enable data centre projects in advanced stages of planning and development to get started, while government works to develop a long-term framework for data centres, which will provide additional pathways for data centres projects to meet their power needs, including encouraging them to bring their own power.'
Story continues below advertisement
Chief Tony Alexis of the Alexis Nakota Sioux Nation northwest of Edmonton said his community is looking at taking an equity stake in a project, and discussions are in the early stages.
He said First Nations want more than to be consulted — they are ready to invest.
'Our nations have been growing. We've got young populations and this industry can bring some real training, some jobs, some long-term prosperity for our community,' Alexis said in an interview.
'Alberta is aiming for a championship-level digital economy. We just need the stadium doors open wide enough so that the star players can participate and everyone wins.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Global News
an hour ago
- Global News
Skipping the U.S. and taking a vacation to East Coast this year? It will cost you.
In September 2024, Natasha Beitman Brener and her husband decided to take a three-week vacation to Canada's East Coast. Beitman Brener, a lawyer in Kingston, Ont., spent about six months planning the trip, looking at various options to stay in Prince Edward Island, Nova Scotia and New Brunswick. 'We are young, we don't have all the money in the world, we have a mortgage. So we went on this trip and we thought, 'oh, this will be affordable compared to something like Japan' . … We were going to cook our own food,' she said in a recent interview. They rented a recreational vehicle in Montreal for about $6,000, and between campground parking fees, gasoline, groceries, park passes, a round of golf, and a couple of dinners out, Beitman Brener said the total added up to $15,000. 'It was the most incredible trip. We loved it. It was worth it. It was incredible. The East Coast is so extraordinary,' she said. 'But it was $15,000 and we talked to our friend — they went to Japan for three weeks for the same price, with flights. And I said to my husband, 'well, we could have gone to Japan for the same price.'' Story continues below advertisement This year, as a trade war grinds on with the United States, Canadians who decide to vacation within their country are realizing their patriotism comes with a hefty price tag — and some are choosing to scale back their plans. For Alick Tsui, a St. John's, N.L., resident, a recent five-day, two-person trip to Port Rexton, N.L., cost him about $3,000. He is avoiding spending his dollars in the United States because of U.S. President Donald Trump's trade war and comments of annexing Canada. But high prices are forcing him to cut costs for future trips in Canada. 'Before I would stay for four nights, now I may cut it down to three nights. But that won't change my plan to travel.' Get breaking National news For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy Tsui said he and his wife try to save money with 'economical' lunches from gas stations. 'But nighttime, we try to find whatever we can to have a good meal. Not expensive, but a good meal,' he said. The couple went to Vietnam and Thailand earlier this year for about 10 days; that trip cost about one-third the price that he usually pays for a week's vacation in Canada. Beitman Brener, meanwhile, says she wanted to take a mother-daughter vacation this month after the lawyer had some unexpected time off. The duo sought to travel within Canada on a budget of $3,000 for four nights and five days. They too are avoiding travelling to the United States. Story continues below advertisement She looked into several locations, including Quebec City and Manitoulin Island in Ontario, but — even with sharing a hotel or Airbnb room — their accommodation costs would have been about $3,000. Along with food and gas, the total would have been about $6,000, she said. They couldn't justify the cost so they chose to spend two nights at a boutique hotel in their hometown. The fact each vacation has to be planned down to every meal because of high costs has removed some of the joy of taking a spontaneous holiday in Canada, she said. A scan of individual round trip flights from Toronto to cities on the East Coast for the week of Aug. 18 -23 showed prices to Halifax ranging from around $700 for Flair Airlines to nearly $1,700 for WestJet; about $1,200 via Air Canada to $2,500 via Air Transat to St. John's; and between $1,500 and $3,000 on Air Canada to Charlottetown. A vehicle rental for five days the week of Aug. 18 -23 in Halifax, St. John's, and Charlottetown ranged from an average of $1,500 for an SUV to $1,000 for a sedan. For the week, hotel rooms in Halifax, St. John's and Prince Edward Island ranged from around $200 a night to $500. Richard Powers, associate professor at University of Toronto's Joseph L. Rotman School of Management, said two main reasons can help explain why travel within Canada is so expensive — lack of competition among airline services and fallout from COVID-19. Story continues below advertisement Airlines haven't reinstated some of routes they cut down at the height of the pandemic, he said. How long the fallout from COVID-19 will last is anybody's guess, Powers said. 'That's the million-dollar question.' When it comes to accommodation, he said the high prices can be blamed on minimal supply. 'I'm just booking Vancouver for the fall, and I'm having trouble finding a place for under $500 a night,' he said. 'That's a lot.' Restaurant bills in Canada add up — when compared with those in Europe — because of the tipping culture that adds 15 to 20 per cent for each meal, he said. With the push to support Canadian tourism, Powers said, people are willing to pay 'a bit of a premium.' 'How much premium is the question? And it's almost getting out of control.'
Global News
2 hours ago
- Global News
B.C. legislator enraged by American state senator's ‘nonsense' pitch to join U.S.
A British Columbia legislator said he went from 'disappointed' to 'enraged' after receiving a pitch from a Republican state senator for Canada's four western provinces to join the United States. Brennan Day, with the Opposition B.C. Conservative Party, said his office had to first confirm the authenticity of the 'nonsense' letter from Maine Sen. Joseph Martin after receiving it last week. Martin's three-page pitch said if B.C., Alberta, Saskatchewan and Manitoba were to seek admission to the United States after referendum votes, it would have to be as full American states. 'This would not be annexation. It would be adoption — welcoming home kindred spirits, who were born under a different flag but who desire to live under our Constitution and accept our responsibilities, customs, and traditions,' he wrote in the letter shared by Day. Martin said in the letter that his appeal is not a 'fantasy of empire' but a 'vision deeply rooted in American tradition' that would give the four provinces a chance to 'leave behind failing ideologies.' Story continues below advertisement 'For too long, Canadian citizens have been subjected to an illusion of freedom administered through bureaucratic means,' he wrote, adding that the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, 'while lofty in rhetoric, provides no absolute protection.' Get breaking National news For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy He said this was in contrast to the U.S. Bill of Rights. Martin said 'millions of people currently frustrated by central authority, moral decay, and bureaucratic suffocation' would be rewarded by 'liberty' if the four provinces were to join the United States. 'The welcome mat is out,' he concluded. Day said the most shocking part of the letter was its attack on Canadian institutions, like the Charter of Rights, parliamentary government, monarchism, bilingualism, multiculturalism, and the dismissal of those cornerstones as 'political baggage.' Day said in an interview that Martin needed to look at 'how heavy his luggage' is. He said Martin's party was 'hauling around wheeled trunks' of baggage in the United States where the Constitution was 'being torn up by Republicans.' Day said it was not clear why Martin wrote to him, but suspected it might be due to 'rhetoric' coming out of Alberta that led Martin to believe British Columbians would be interested. Martin did not immediately respond to a request for comment left by voice mail and text. Story continues below advertisement Day said he had written a response to Martin, in which he acknowledged that Canada has problems. 'But we don't fix them by surrendering our identity, as you suggest,' Day said in his response. 'We fix them by doing what Canadians have always done — rolling up our sleeves, listening to each other, and finding common ground.' Day said in his interview that the 'overwhelming majority of Canadians' like themselves just as they are. 'We have got a lot of work to do in improving our services, and making sure that we are spending our money wisely, and getting good value for it,' Day said. 'But I don't think anybody here looks south and goes, 'we want more of that.''
Global News
3 hours ago
- Global News
Marooned by Air Canada flight attendant strike? Here are your options
You were planning to catch a flight and the dreaded text pops up on your phone: your flight has been cancelled. Now what? More than 10,000 Air Canada flight attendants are off the job after a strike deadline passed Saturday without a deal. The airline had already cancelled 500 flights on Friday in anticipation of the full stoppage and all flights will be halted during the work stoppage. Air Canada has said that, in the event of a strike, it would try and book customers on another flight, including those operated by other carriers. 'However, available capacity on our airline and on other carriers is limited due to the summer travel peak, meaning the possibility of rebooking you within an acceptable time frame is low,' Air Canada said in an online notice Friday. Story continues below advertisement 'If your travel is disrupted, you can always choose a refund.' Before the stoppage, Air Canada had offered free flight changes to customers booked between Aug. 15 and 18 and travel credits for any unused non-refundable fares. Personal finance and travel expert Barry Choi had planned to travel home from Europe next week on Air Canada. He said he's confident a deal will be worked out before his return trip on Aug. 22, but he came up with a contingency plan anyway. Get breaking National news For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy 'I personally booked a backup flight just in case, in the worst, worst case scenario,' he said from Rotterdam, Netherlands. Choi said he did so because he had the luxury of ample loyalty rewards to afford a transatlantic flight much pricier than the one he initially booked. Getting back was also time sensitive — his wife has tickets to an Oasis concert back home two days after their scheduled arrival. If not for that, they may have stayed longer. 'I know not everyone has that luxury, but just having a backup plan is good to know, even if you don't want to book that flight right away,' said Choi. Doing some research and finding three or four backup flight options with Air Canada partners is a good idea when you're finally able to get on the line with an agent. Story continues below advertisement 'The more information you can provide the agents when you get hold of them, the better your odds. So always just be prepared,' said Choi, advising anyone with travel booked further out into September to just sit tight for now. He adds that travellers should look into the details of their credit card travel insurance 'inside out' right away to find out what expenses are covered, and what aren't, if it takes a few days to line up a flight home. Choi recalls being taken aback a few years ago when he booked a hotel stay to cover a flight delay only to find out after he made the claim that his insurance only covered $100 a night. It's also worth looking into whether a policy will cover travel to an alternative airport — taking a train to fly out of Edinburgh, Scotland, back to Canada instead of London Heathrow, for example. 'Just knowing what you're entitled to, keeping those receipts and making a submission in time will greatly help you reduce your costs overall.' Lesley Keyter, founder and CEO of Calgary travel agency The Travel Lady, said insurance may cover disruptions due to labour action, provided it wasn't a 'known event' when the policy was purchased. 'If you're thinking now, 'Oh, next week I want to go somewhere and I'll just take out travel insurance and that will cover me,' that won't happen,' she said. Story continues below advertisement Keyter also cautions that any reimbursements for extended stays won't arrive quickly. 'It's going to take a while for that to go through the whole machinery, so you have to have that cash on you to be able to afford those extra costs in-destination.' For those with flights connecting to a cruise or tour, it could get tricky. It's fairly straightforward if the airfare was booked through a cruise line. Not so when they're booked separately. 'If you just booked an air ticket yourself with Air Canada flying across to Rome and then maybe you're jumping on a cruise ship, that's two completely separate tickets and the cruise line does not care about Air Canada having the strike,' said Keyter. 'If you're going on a cruise or a tour or there's an occasion, a date that has to be stuck to, get there a day or so earlier so it gives you a little bit of wiggle room in case things like this happen.'
