Three September 11 victims' remains identified by new genetic techniques after nearly 24 years
New York City officials announced on Thursday, local time, that they had identified remains of Ryan Fitzgerald, a 26-year-old currency trader; Barbara Keating, a 72-year-old retired nonprofit executive; and another woman whose name authorities kept private at her family's request.
The three were already among the thousands of people long known to have died in the Al Qaeda hijacked-plane attacks of September 11, 2001, and long listed among the names on the national memorial in New York City.
But these families, like many others, never previously knew of any remains of their loved ones.
In all, nearly 3,000 people were killed when the hijackers crashed jetliners into the World Trade Center's twin towers, the Pentagon and a field in south-west Pennsylvania.
More than 2,700 of the victims perished in the fiery collapse of the twin towers, and about 40 per cent of those victims have not had any remains identified.
The new identifications were made through now-improved DNA testing of minute remains found more than 20 years ago amid the wreckage, the city medical examiner's office said.
"Each new identification testifies to the promise of science and sustained outreach to families despite the passage of time," chief medical examiner Dr Jason Graham said in a statement.
Ms Keating's son, Paul Keating, told media outlets he was amazed and impressed by the enduring endeavour.
"It's just an amazing feat, gesture," he told the New York Post.
He said genetic material from part of his mother's hairbrush was matched to DNA samples from relatives.
A bit of his mother's ATM card was the only other trace of her ever recovered from the debris, he said.
Barbara Keating was a passenger on the Los Angeles-bound American Airlines Flight 11 when hijackers slammed it into the World Trade Center.
She was headed home to Palm Springs, California, after spending the summer on Cape Cod, Massachusetts.
Ms Keating had spent her career in social services, including a time as executive director of the Big Brothers Big Sisters of South Middlesex, near Boston.
In retirement, she was involved in her Roman Catholic church in Palm Springs.
Mr Fitzgerald, who lived in Manhattan, was working at a financial firm at the World Trade Center, studying for a master's degree in business and talking about a long-term future with his girlfriend, according to obituaries published at the time.
The New York medical examiner's office has steadily added to the roster of 9/11 victims with identified remains, most recently last year.
The agency has tested and retested tens of thousands of fragments as techniques advanced over the years and created new prospects for reading genetic code diminished by fire, sunlight, bacteria and more.
It said it would continue to retest in the future.
"We hope the families receiving answers from the Office of Chief Medical Examiner can take solace in the city's tireless dedication to this mission," New York Mayor Eric Adams said in a statement.
AP
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
2 days ago
- News.com.au
Indigenous communities plead for action at plastic pollution talks
Indigenous communities from North America are at talks on a global treaty on plastic pollution in Geneva, pleading the case for the environment they depend upon, which is slowly being choked by microplastics. In the grounds of the United Nations headquarters, overlooking Lake Geneva and the Alps beyond, a chant suddenly drifted through the humid summer air: a "water song". Standing barefoot in a circle, six women and a young man from multiple North American Indigenous communities decided to do a spontaneous purification ritual. A melancholic second chant follows, dedicated to the well-being "until the seventh generation" of "all the delegates" from the 184 countries attempting to thrash out what would be the first international treaty on tackling the worldwide ever-growing scourge of plastic pollution. The UN-hosted talks, which began last Tuesday, resume on Monday for four more days, with oil-producing states and the so-called ambitious group of nations still far apart on what the treaty should encompass. The young man in the middle of the circle, wearing a hat with two feathers attached, hands each of the six women a bowl containing burning seal fat and plant powders. With both hands, Suzanne Smoke, from the Williams Treaties First Nations in Ontario, Canada, moved as if to catch the rising smoke, rubbing it on her face and body. - 'We carry knowledge' - Panganga Pungowiyi, an activist with the Indigenous Environmental Network, was also in the circle. She comes from Alaska, near the Bering Strait. She is asking negotiators to craft a plastic pollution treaty that ensures justice, particularly for the most vulnerable communities, she told AFP. "We carry knowledge; it's our responsibility -- our duty -- to share the information given to us by the ecosystems," Pungowiyi said, explaining her presence at the talks. Alaska is affected by toxic chemicals, some of which come from plastic or from oil exploration. "Toxic products travel to the north, through ocean currents and air currents," she said. Henri Bourgeois Costa, an environmental and plastic pollution expert at the Tara Ocean Foundation, explained Alaska's predicament. "Given the functioning of the major ecosystem cycles, Alaskan populations are already the most affected by mercury and PCB (polychlorinated biphenyl) pollution -- industrial heavy metals now banned in developed countries -- even though Alaska doesn't use them," he told AFP. The currents, which brought plenty of nutrients and schools of fish to the northwestern US state's residents, are now also bringing vast quantities of microplastics, he said. - Car tyres and salmon - A 2020 study from Washington State University demonstrated that a chemical additive used in the manufacture of car tyres, 6PPD, had "deleterious effects on the reproduction of salmon", one of the most widespread fish in Alaska, Bourgeois Costa said. A compound derived from 6PPD -- a preservative used to slow tyre degradation -- comes off the rubber onto the roads, and gets into the water cycle, the study showed. "No more fish -- no more seals: no more food," Pungowiyi said. People can see the diseases suffered by birds and mammals in the surrounding environment, which ultimately go on to affect their own children, she said. "We are exposed through food, water and forages, because we forage for our food," said Pungowiyi. - 'If animals die, we die' - Aakaluk Adrienne Blatchford, an activist from a small Alaskan village, who came to the Geneva talks with financial support from an association, put it bluntly: "If animals die, we die." She spoke at a conference staged on the sidelines of the negotiations, which are struggling to find a consensus that would stop the amount of plastic pollution from growing. "We rely on unhealthy products," Blatchford said, adding: "It's becoming harder and harder to maintain our food security." And "there is no alternative", she added, with prices as high as "$76 for an imported frozen chicken" at the supermarket. This is a trap for economically fragile populations living in "a symbiotic relationship with the world", she said. "We need a collective decision on how to handle this crisis," she insisted, hoping that the treaty will include a list of banned chemical additives. The plastics treaty talks are being held inside the UN's Palais des Nations complex. During the ritual, held beneath a tree in the grounds outside, Blatchford stood with her eyes closed, tears rolling down her face.
ABC News
4 days ago
- ABC News
Three September 11 victims' remains identified by new genetic techniques after nearly 24 years
Three 9/11 victims have been identified using new DNA technology as the effort to return the remains of the dead to loved ones continues after nearly a quarter of a century. New York City officials announced on Thursday, local time, that they had identified remains of Ryan Fitzgerald, a 26-year-old currency trader; Barbara Keating, a 72-year-old retired nonprofit executive; and another woman whose name authorities kept private at her family's request. The three were already among the thousands of people long known to have died in the Al Qaeda hijacked-plane attacks of September 11, 2001, and long listed among the names on the national memorial in New York City. But these families, like many others, never previously knew of any remains of their loved ones. In all, nearly 3,000 people were killed when the hijackers crashed jetliners into the World Trade Center's twin towers, the Pentagon and a field in south-west Pennsylvania. More than 2,700 of the victims perished in the fiery collapse of the twin towers, and about 40 per cent of those victims have not had any remains identified. The new identifications were made through now-improved DNA testing of minute remains found more than 20 years ago amid the wreckage, the city medical examiner's office said. "Each new identification testifies to the promise of science and sustained outreach to families despite the passage of time," chief medical examiner Dr Jason Graham said in a statement. Ms Keating's son, Paul Keating, told media outlets he was amazed and impressed by the enduring endeavour. "It's just an amazing feat, gesture," he told the New York Post. He said genetic material from part of his mother's hairbrush was matched to DNA samples from relatives. A bit of his mother's ATM card was the only other trace of her ever recovered from the debris, he said. Barbara Keating was a passenger on the Los Angeles-bound American Airlines Flight 11 when hijackers slammed it into the World Trade Center. She was headed home to Palm Springs, California, after spending the summer on Cape Cod, Massachusetts. Ms Keating had spent her career in social services, including a time as executive director of the Big Brothers Big Sisters of South Middlesex, near Boston. In retirement, she was involved in her Roman Catholic church in Palm Springs. Mr Fitzgerald, who lived in Manhattan, was working at a financial firm at the World Trade Center, studying for a master's degree in business and talking about a long-term future with his girlfriend, according to obituaries published at the time. The New York medical examiner's office has steadily added to the roster of 9/11 victims with identified remains, most recently last year. The agency has tested and retested tens of thousands of fragments as techniques advanced over the years and created new prospects for reading genetic code diminished by fire, sunlight, bacteria and more. It said it would continue to retest in the future. "We hope the families receiving answers from the Office of Chief Medical Examiner can take solace in the city's tireless dedication to this mission," New York Mayor Eric Adams said in a statement. AP
ABC News
4 days ago
- ABC News
Once 'America's best idea', National Parks are reaching their breaking point
US national parks are being forced to stay open despite operating on a "bare-bones" crew after cuts to staff and funding. Rangers say they can't sustain it. From the towering sandstone canyons in Zion, to the Rocky Mountain ranges at Grand Teton and the bubbling, rainbow geysers at Yellowstone — there's a reason millions flock to America's national parks every year, including 726,000 Australians in 2024 alone. Famously coined "America's best idea" by Pulitzer Prize-winning American novelist and environmentalist Wallace Stegner, the parks are "absolutely American, absolutely democratic … they reflect us at our best rather than our worst", he wrote. But what happens when the "best" of America starts to fall apart? Valentine's Day 'massacre' To the untrained eye, Yosemite National Park hasn't changed a bit. Neither has Glacier National Park, the Grand Canyon, Yellowstone National Park and America's other 59 national parks and 433 park units spanning 85 million acres. But just six months into the Trump administration, the parks are dangerously understaffed and dangerously underfunded, all the while being forced by the government to remain open. At least 1,000 probationary NPS workers were abruptly dismissed in February in what is known as the "Valentine's Day massacre" — part of US President Donald Trump and Elon Musk's DOGE efforts to shrink the federal government workforce. An additional approximately 3,400 people from the US Forest Service (USFS), who were responsible for the preservation and health of America's forests and grasslands in conjunction with the NPS, were also fired. Weeks later, a court ordered their reinstatement, but the damage had already begun. Since January 2025, the NPS has lost 24 per cent of its permanent staff — 4,000 people — according to a report in July from watchdog-advocacy group National Parks Conservation Association (NPCA), a "staggering reduction" that has left parks across the country "scrambling to operate with bare-bones crews" during peak visitation. The Trump administration has initiated the most damaging budget cuts in Park Service history: in May, he proposed cutting more than $US1 billion ($1.5 billion) from the Park Service budget in fiscal 2026, stating there was an "urgent need to streamline staff". His "Big Beautiful Bill" gutted the $US267 million of previously committed funding for staffing, and the NPS is set to take another $US176 million cut in budget for the 2026 fiscal year. There are fewer rangers to educate and protect the public, slower emergency response times, reduced hours at visitor centres, delayed maintenance and conservation of the parks, and more strain on already overburdened staff who remain, according to the report. People demonstrate during a protest against federal employee lay-offs at Yosemite National Park in March. ( AFP: Laure Andrillon ) Bryce Canyon National Park is renowned for its distinctive hoodoos. ( Reutesr: Kaylee Greenlee ) The NPS has lost older rangers with years of experience in the parks. ( Reuters: Kaylee Greenlee ) The National Park Service operates 433 park units across 85 million acres. ( Reuters: Kaylee Greenlee ) Kristen Brengel, senior vice-president of government affairs at the NPCA, told the ABC that thousands of Park Service staff have been pushed out since January. The losses were driven by an ongoing hiring freeze delaying seasonal hiring, terminations, early retirement buyouts, deferred resignations and pressured buyouts like the administration's "Fork in the Road" — an email sent to over 2 million federal employees by the Office of Personnel Management (OPM) offering staff their full salary until September 2025 if they resigned. And it's not sustainable, Ms Brengel said. "They may have to close down some of the parks because they just don't have enough staff," she said. "Park superintendents across the country are saying we can't do this long-term. "We can't have this few staff, it's not going to be good for parks, especially with visitation so high." The NPS recorded its highest summer visitor numbers on record in 2024, with a record-breaking 331.9 million recreation visits, according to data released in March. Yellowstone National Park reported that May was its busiest on record with 566,363 recreational visits, an 8 per cent increase from a year ago and a nearly 20 per cent increase from May 2021. Australian travellers were among the top five visiting US national parks, accounting for 726,000 recreational visits across the country in 2024, according to new figures from the US National Travel and Tourism Office (NTTO). "So many stories are told through our national parks," Ms Brengel said. "Our national identity is wrapped in them." Yellowstone National Park reported this May was its busiest on record, with 566,363 recreational visits. ( AP: Jacquelyn Martin ) Even while slashing budgets, the Trump administration is pushing for parks to stay open. In April this year, Security of Interior Doug Burgum — a billionaire with ties to the oil and gas industry whose pick promoted backlash from environmental advocacy groups — ordered all parks to remain "open and accessible" and to ensure that the NPS provided "the best customer service experience for all visitors". But past and present park rangers, advocacy groups and experts say the decisions across the past six months have left staff morale at an all-time low and devastated the agency's ability to ensure visitor safety, deliver basic services and protect park resources. Alex Wild, a park ranger of 13 years who lost his job in the Valentines Day Massacre, said to imagine the park as a "human body" that had sustained a "major injury". "It's doing what is called compensation, where it works extra hard to maintain basic functions," said Mr Wild, who was reinstated as Wilderness Park Ranger at Yosemite National Park in March. "You can only sustain that for so long before things start to fall apart." Yellowstone holds the largest bison population on public lands with approximately 5,450 of the mammals. ( Reuters: Go Nakamura ) A play on "Smokey Bear", the advertising icon of the US Forest Service in the Wildfire Prevention Campaign. ( Reuters: Craig Hudson ) The NPS recorded a record-breaking 331.9 million recreation visits to the national parks in 2024. ( Reuters: Kaylee Greenlee ) A park ranger leads a program at the Fountain Paint Pot geothermal area in Yellowstone National Park. ( Reuters: Kaylee Greenlee ) Becoming 'almost impossible' to do the job Phil Francis was earning $US1.65 an hour at a textile mill in 1972 when a friend working as a seasonal ranger in the NPS encouraged him to apply to become a park ranger. "After a summer of giving programmes, hiking trails and interacting with the public, I sort of fell in love with it," he said, going on to serve for 41 years in the NPS as a ranger and superintendent in parks across the country, including Great Smoky Mountains National Park, Yosemite, Shenandoah and Kings Mountain National Military Park. He said park staff had "a great mission and a great purpose". "As they say, our breath starts turning green because we love the job so much." Phil Francis said the parks' mission and purpose made it easy for rangers to "love their job so much". ( Supplied: Phil Francis via the National Park Service ) Mr Francis was the deputy superintendent of the Great Smoky Mountains National Park for 11 years. ( AFP: Patrick Gorski ) The NPS staff have "an array of responsibilities to protect and preserve", says Mr Francis, who serves as the executive council chair of the Coalition to Protect America's National Parks after retiring in 2013. "Whether it's maintenance of parks, design of buildings, law enforcement responsibilities, administrative responsibilities or safety of employees and visitors — we need the whole team to be present," he said. "And when you're trying to do it with fewer and fewer people, it becomes almost impossible to do the same job we once were able to do." At the time Mr Wild was fired, he was the park's only EMT (Emergency Medical Technician). "I honestly can't imagine how the parks will operate without my position, I mean, they just can't," he said. Mr Francis said park employees had saved people's lives with their training and commitment. "So, it's a political decision to try and keep the public happy, but they're also putting the parks and the public at risk," he said. He warned the effects were already beginning to manifest: beaches left unpatrolled, interpretive programming reduced, historic buildings shut down, campgrounds closed and higher-graded staff being redirected. "National parks cannot properly function at the staffing levels this administration has reduced them to," said NPCA's president and CEO, Theresa Pierno. "And it's only getting worse." Staff stretched thin A park ranger at Grand Teton National Park in Wyoming. ( Reuters: Kaylee Greenlee ) The secretary of the interior pledged in February to add nearly 8,000 additional seasonal positions to the NPS, but halfway through the summer, only about 4,500 have been filled. It came too little, too late, says Ms Brengel, accusing the secretary of the interior of "band-aiding the situation". She said that the order from Mr Burgum to keep the parks open, combined with the seasonal hiring process beginning too late, meant that staff were being pulled from their specialised projects. "So instead of trail maintenance or revegetation, staff are being placed on visitor centres because they don't have enough people," she said. An NPS seasonal interpretation ranger leads a natural and cultural history discussion about the park in Glacier National Park. ( Reuters: Kaylee Greenlee ) Rangers move dirt and unearth beaver tracks near an information exhibit in Glacier National Park. ( Reuters: Kaylee Greenlee ) Invasive oxeye daisies are pulled from the shores of Lake McDonald at Glacier National Park. ( Reuters: Kaylee Greenlee ) An NPS seasonal interpretation ranger leads a fossil walk program in the Grand Canyon National Park. ( Reuters: Kaylee Greenlee ) It also means law enforcement staff are being moved to work in the visitor centre and forgoing other functions, she added. Mr Francis also pointed to the dangers of losing the more experienced park rangers. "Everybody is trying to be an asset — but it's not the same as someone who's been working there for 20 years." The NPCA said the loss of older rangers to early retirement buyouts represented "not just a staffing shortage, but also the loss of decades of institutional knowledge and specialised experience". In July, multiple fast-spreading wildfires forced evacuations in parts of the Grand Canyon. ( Reuters: Kaylee Greenlee ) Impact on economy and tourists America's National Park System exists as less than one-fifteenth of 1 per cent of the federal budget — despite contributing over $US55 billion to the nation's economy. The local economy in Utah had grown from "frozen burritos at the gas station" to a world-class food and dining economy that relied on the millions of tourists who streamed into the parks every year, Ms Brengel said. "Even the smallest park unit in America benefits the gateway community, the community just outside of it," she said. "If the visitation ever comes down, even in the next year or so, it would hurt so many people's business model," she added. "The price to pay for making bad decisions on the parks is pretty high." In July, Mr Trump signed an executive order called Making America Beautiful Again by Improving Our National Parks, calling on the NPS to charge foreign visitors an increased entrance fee. According to the order, the price hikes will only occur in parks that already charge admission, which is only about 100 of the 433 park units across the country. "The increased fee revenue from foreign tourists will raise hundreds of millions for conservation projects that improve our national parks," the White House wrote. Mr Francis said the fees wouldn't be enough to compensate for cuts to staffing and budget, though he wasn't opposed to the idea as long as it didn't turn off visitors. "Parks are for everyone," he said. The parks "preserve the full spectrum of our national identity", says NPS. ( Reuters: Kaylee Greenlee ) A National Park Service ranger conducts a walking tour in the Everglades National Park in Florida. ( AFP: Joe Raedle ) Visitors ride horses near the Teton Range of the Rocky Mountains in Grand Teton National Park. ( Reuters: Kaylee Greenlee ) Yellowstone is most famous for its scorching-hot geysers. ( Reuters: Kaylee Greenlee ) Those with green breath can't look away Ms Brengel said that current staffing levels could not be maintained. "We can get away with it for this summer, but people will start to notice by next summer," she said. And while many would turn and run from such a problem, those with "green breath" can't look away. Protests have broken out across the country, while advocacy groups and rangers alike — dubbed Park Protectors —say Congress needs to "step in to reject these ideas of both understaffing and underfunding the parks". On August 23, Park Protectors across the country will take part in a nationwide one-day event organised by the NPCA, which they say will be a "national moment to show love for our parks and demand accountability for the devastating impacts threatening them". Demonstrations broke out across the country. ( Reuters: Yuri Avila ) "Something nature has taught me resonates in this moment: creatures together accomplish what lone ones can't," said Mr Wild.
