Irish renewable energy policy gets a badly needed reality check
renewable energy
and ambition to become an energy exporting country needed a hard reality check.
It has come in a series of reports to the Government from the National Economic & Social Council on what fulfilling that national aspiration entails beyond supporting policy.
Repeated political declarations of wanting to scale up renewable electricity – 40 gigawatts plus, many times current power demand – were too easily trotted out by governments getting uneasy about the
climate threat
on our doorstep and multibillion euro fines becoming more likely no matter how you divide up the carbon cake.
The first report published in April concluded Ireland's transition to a clean energy economy risks heading into 'strategic fog' with a lack of clarity and certainty about future reliability of the country's energy supply.
READ MORE
The second and third were published on Wednesday. The former concluded that cost-competitiveness challenges left unaddressed would make it impossible for the State to become a renewables exporter.
The issue is summed up by the observation that with 'approximately 50 per cent of Ireland's electricity produced from gas-fired power plants, [it] made Irish electricity prices the most exposed in Europe to resulting regional gas market volatility'.
[
Scrapped Amazon plant a sign of Ireland hitting the infrastructural buffers
Opens in new window
]
There is increasing vulnerability from 'fossil fuel import dependency', while our subsea gas pipelines and power interconnectors could become the target of malign actors.
The latter underlines the need for anticipation of needs and likely demand with an inevitable supply chain crunch, not helped by profound upheaval in global trade, over-reliance on China and lack of EU manufacturing capacity.
The international supply chain for wind technologies highlights our exposure to emerging bottlenecks with turbine components; critical raw materials, offshore substations and installation vessels. Meanwhile, ports are not fit for purpose – not to mention planning and permitting procedures.
These reports are not killing the dream of energy independence; a shift away from the most expensive electricity in Europe and an end to price volatility. They chart a way through the minefields.
In particular, 'Ireland's energy strategy must adapt to the reality that strategic trade dependencies will not cease but will instead take new forms', whether it's buying our renewables or co-operating on enhanced grid connectivity.
Furthermore, risk of geopolitical tensions affecting key oil and gas 'transit chokepoints' is increasing. It threatens the security of our energy supply, especially with reliance on gas supplies from the UK and crude oil from the US – after the putative tariff agreement between Trump and the EU this week, American LNG can be added to that list.
The case for getting off fossil fuels couldn't be clearer, and the NESC reports are grounds for conditional optimism. With more than ample offshore resources and the correct strategic approach, we can become a clean energy exporter.
Notwithstanding current uncertainties and high costs, Ireland could break into an international green hydrogen market, generating the fuel using offshore wind, provided strategic partnerships are formed with countries requiring large quantities of the fuel.
[
Taoiseach to 'delve into' Amazon's scrapping of Dublin plant over failure to secure power supply
Opens in new window
]
Taoiseach Micheál Martin this week convened a meeting of industry leaders and Government officials to address the challenge of accelerating offshore wind delivery. He knows there is a growing
risk of Ireland falling behind in the energy transition and implications this has for the country as a place to do business amid a data/AI revolution.
We must acknowledge the challenges honestly, he underlined, and 'work together to expedite the development of a sector that will be central to Ireland's economic and energy future'.
These NESC reports and on-the-ground know-how can help deliver the required push-through.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
12 minutes ago
- Irish Examiner
Simon Harris ‘eager' to progress trade talks to avoid further tariffs
Tánaiste Simon Harris has said he is 'eager' to see further progress on trade talks around certain sectors, including the drinks industry, as a wave of US tariffs takes effect. Mr Harris said that while some areas have been agreed as exempt from tariffs between the European Union and the US, he wants to 'tease through the detail' of other areas, citing the pharma sector in particular. US President Donald Trump's tariffs took effect from Thursday, with exporters in Ireland facing a new 15% rate applying to imports to the US. There is huge potential and scope for the EU and the US to work together in the interests of patients, their economies, and the pharma industry It is not yet clear whether the drinks industry will be exempt from the new wave of tariffs. The Tanaiste said it is 'absolutely essential' to maximise the number of areas that can apply zero-for-zero tariffs. 'Whilst there are some areas that have already been agreed as exempt from tariffs between the US and the EU, I'm very eager to see more progress made in more areas, including for the drinks industry, which is an important part of the Irish economy,' Mr Harris said in a statement on Thursday. 'We'll also need to continue to work in the time ahead to tease through the detail in relation to particular sectors. 'From a pharma point of view, my position remains the same, as does the position of the European Union. 'There is huge potential and scope for the EU and the US to work together in the interests of patients, their economies, and the pharma industry. 'In many ways, the EU and the US are interdependent when it comes to pharma. In the very first instance, it's vital that the US keeps its agreement in terms of a tariff rate of no higher than 15% on the pharma industry. 'But actually, in the time ahead, it's important that we seek to further improve that. US pharma companies need to have a base in the European Union – and Ireland has been a very constructive, very good home for those businesses. They've done very well in Ireland. Freight trucks at Rosslare Europort in Co Wexford, Ireland (Niall Carson/PA) 'We need to continue to make sure that nothing happens that causes disruption to the industry or to global supply chains. So, there's much work to do in the weeks and months ahead. 'We also must continue to control what we can control and continue to make our country, and our European Union, as competitive as possible, as good a location as possible to invest in and create jobs. 'We must also look for other opportunities to diversify markets for Irish business. While we want to continue to do business with the US and indeed want to grow business. It is important that we take every opportunity to identify new markets.' He said the Government will publish a new Market Diversification Action Plan this month.
RTÉ News
12 minutes ago
- RTÉ News
CCPC: No evidence of competition issues among food retailers
An investigation by the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission (CCPC) into the grocery retailer sector has found there is no evidence indicating any issues regarding competition among retailers in terms of food prices. In its report the CCPC says that although inflation analysis shows "significant price increases since 2021 that have a real impact on consumers" the available data on supermarket profits "does not indicate that margins are notably high when compared to international comparators". Official figures show Irish consumers experienced a 27% increase in grocery prices between 2021 and June of this year. The CCPC says that while this rise is significant, it remains below the EU average increase of 35% over the same period, adding that only four other EU member states have experienced smaller price increases since 2021. However, the agency's 2025 high-level analysis of the grocery retail sector notes that "one key driver of recent food price rises is the increase of some agricultural product prices, which have been higher in Ireland than the European average". The Commission says that "while grocery prices have increased significantly since 2021, they have done so at a slower pace than some of the key input costs, such as agricultural prices. "This suggests that competition in the grocery market has helped limit the impact of increased agricultural prices on Irish consumers," the report says. For its probe of grocery retailers the CCPC analysed market concentration including new entrants and expansion, national and international trends in grocery prices, as well as profit margins of major grocery retailers. It says that recent profit figures from grocery retailers "continue to be in line with the margin band estimated by the CCPC in 2023", which was between 1% and 4%. Tesco Ireland's operating profit margin for the year to Feb 2024 was 3.7% (down from 4% in the previous year), Musgrave's (which owns SuperValu and Centra) profit margin in 2023 was 2.4%, down from 2.5% the previous year. Aldi's profit margin in 2023 was 0.8%, down from 0.9% in 2022. Dunnes and Lidl do not publish accounts for their Irish operations, however, Lidl's UK accounts (which combine UK and Irish activities) for 2023/2024 show a profit margin of 2.1%. The CCPC says the profit margins for Irish supermarkets "align closely with those observed in the UK and other parts of Europe". The consumer watchdog also points out that "increased competition in the market over the last 20 years has brought sizeable benefits for consumers" and that "food price increases in Ireland have been well below the European average, and this coincides with increasing competition in the Irish market". The CCPC previously carried out a similar analysis of the retail grocery sector in 2023, which had similar findings, but amid sustained food inflation the Government asked the Commission to re-assess the sector. While the CCPC says it has not seen evidence to "justify an in-depth study of the grocery retail sector" it says it "remains a key market for the CCPC, which we will continue to review".
Irish Examiner
12 minutes ago
- Irish Examiner
No evidence of price gouging in supermarkets, says consumer watchdog
There is no evidence of price gouging in Ireland's supermarket industry, the State's consumer watchdog has said. Publishing the findings of its latest analysis of the sector, the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission (CCPC) has said while food prices have increased significantly in recent years in Ireland, 'there is no evidence that competition is not working in the Irish grocery retail sector'. 'Food price increases have generally remained below the European average, which coincides with increasing competition in Ireland,' it said. The data available on profit margins does not indicate that margins are notably high when compared to international comparators. The CCPC said the rate of increase for grocery prices was at a slower pace than some of the key input costs, such as agricultural prices, which suggests competition in the market has helped to limit the impacts. However, the review did point to 'upward pressures' in agricultural output prices in the last year as being an 'underlying factor in recent grocery inflation'. Social Democrats TD Jennifer Whitmore said price spikes in agri-food supply chains must be investigated, and said it was unacceptable the CCPC did not have access to all the relevant data for its analysis. 'Not all of the large supermarket chains publish their Irish profits,' she said. 'It is wholly unsatisfactory for the consumer regulator to be denied information that is necessary for it to do its job — and it is outrageous that the Government has not acted to force large supermarket chains to publish their profits.' Households feeling the pinch It all comes as households are still feeling the pinch to a much greater extent at the grocery tills, as new figures showed the cost of food was still rising at almost three times the rate of general inflation. The latest Consumer Price Index from the Central Statistics Office showed prices have risen 1.7% across the Irish economy in the past 12 months, while food and non-alcoholic drinks rose 4.7% in the same period. Consumers are also feeling a stronger pinch when it comes to eating and drinking out, according to the data. In the past 12 months, a drink in a pub has risen 3.7%, while the cost of restaurants, cafes, fast food and takeaways have risen 3.5%. Digging into the CSO data, it shows many common purchases at supermarket checkouts have surged in price in the past year. Beef and veal have risen by 23%, lamb and goat are up 17%, whole milk is up 12%, butter is up 19.4%, and chocolate has risen by 16%. Some of our favourite non-alcoholic tipples have also risen significantly, with coffee up 12.7% and fruit and vegetable juices up 7.4%. Breaking some of them down by average price, CSO statistician Anthony Dawson said: 'There were price increases in the 12 months to July 2025 for a pound of butter (+€1.08), Irish cheddar per kg (+70c), two litres of full fat milk (+28c), an 800g loaf of white sliced pan (+5c), and an 800g loaf of brown sliced pan (+3c).' In better news for consumers, the cost of transport (-2.8%) and clothing and footwear (-2.4%) have fallen in the past 12 months.
