MS heavy hitters back insurance company over Coast policyholders in bad-faith Katrina case
Policyholders Paul and Sylvia Minor initially filed their lawsuit against USAA in August 2008, almost two years after the hurricane. Paul Minor, a former trial attorney with a nationally recognized practice, has since moved to Louisiana, where his wife Sylvia died of breast cancer in 2009. Her estate, represented by their two children, has carried on the case.
Both sides have appealed decisions made at the trial court level in Jackson County, making the lawsuit the longest-running among hundreds policyholders filed against their insurance companies after Katrina. The Category 3 hurricane devastated the Coast almost 20 years ago, packing damaging winds and a record storm surge.
USAA is asking the Supreme Court for a re-hearing of its recent split decision upholding a jury's punitive damages verdict of $10 million in the estate's favor, plus about $458,000 in extra damages that went to attorney's fees. The high court added $4.5 million in attorney's fees for the estate.
State Insurance Commissioner Mike Chaney, former Gov. Haley Barbour and a host of business and insurance interests have lined up in USAA's corner. They filed friend of the court briefs that support the insurer's position.
'Maintaining this nearly $15,000,000 combined award turns back the clock to an era that the Legislature ended two decades ago,' USAA argues in its motion for a rehearing, referring to the state Legislature's decision to curb large jury awards through tort reform.
Lawyers for the Minor estate argue the awards should stand and chastised the insurance commissioner for filing a brief in support of USAA.
'Commissioner Chaney would have this court decide that the only way an insured homeowner, an insurance consumer he is sworn to protect, may recover punitive damages is if the homeowner can prove fraud or malice on the part of the insurance company in adjusting a claim,' the policyholder brief says. 'Apparently, Commissioner Chaney finds it perfectly acceptable that USAA refused to pay the insureds' boathouse and other claims for seven years while the claim was pending and then only on the eve of trial.'
USAA essentially argues the Supreme Court is misinterpreting state law as adopted by the Legislature. The law, USAA says, would allow for punitive damages only if the insurance company had acted with gross negligence that disregarded 'the safety of others.'
The Minors never argued their safety was at risk, USAA contends, saying, 'Any injuries were 'purely economic.' '
The court instead made its decision based on 'gross and reckless disregard for the insured's rights,' USAA says.
Chaney's brief says that large punitive damage awards hinder his ability to maintain a competitive and affordable property insurance market in Mississippi, where rates are among the highest in the nation.
Former Gov. Barbour, an attorney, headlines another friend of the court brief. The Mississippi Chamber of Commerce, Gulf Coast Business Council, Mississippi Bankers Association and other influential groups signed onto the brief.
If it's not reversed, the brief says, the punitive damages award could represent a return to Mississippi's old reputation as a 'judicial hellhole' where juries delivered large punitive damage verdicts referred to as 'jackpot justice.'
David Baria, an attorney representing the Minor estate, said the friend of the court brief from Barbour that lists all the business groups in support is designed to 'intimidate' the Supreme Court justices.
The estate argues in its brief that the definition of safety includes being safe from injury or loss. Financial loss, the estate argues, would be included.
When USAA initially adjusted the Minors' claim, the company offered the couple $37,245.86 for structural losses. USAA offered the couple another $67,864.23 in contents coverage shortly before the trial. The Minors had paid for more than $2 million in coverage on their home, other structures and contents.
A Circuit Court jury in Jackson County found in 2013 that the Minors were owed more than $1.5 million. The judge had ruled before trial that the Minors were not entitled to punitive damages, a decision the Mississippi Court of Appeals reversed in 2017.
The Supreme Court's most recent decision upheld a jury's subsequent punitive-damages verdict and awarded the additional $4.5 million in attorney's fees that the estate incurred during appeals.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hill
44 minutes ago
- The Hill
Trump's economy: A weak link in MAGA's chain
President Trump has given Democrats so much ammunition in so many policy areas that it's tempting for us to respond incoherently. That may be his plan. His one big ugly bill will deprive millions of Americans of medical care and food. The president has abused his constitutional power to launch an attack against Iran. He has terrorized millions of immigrants who came to the land of the free to seek political freedom and economic opportunity. His Supreme Court has terminated longstanding legal doctrines that guaranteed abortion rights and political liberty for all of our citizens These grievances are all good reason to end Trump's reign of terror, but not the best way of stopping him and MAGA before they do even more damage. His handling of the economy got off to a bad start and will only get worse as his economic policies take full effect. The economy shrunk in the first quarter of 2025. This was the first quarterly contraction in three years. Trump's Achilles Heel is his failure to bring prices down on Day One of his second term as he promised during the 2024 campaign. One of the best pieces of advice that a Democratic strategist has ever given any candidate was James Carville's admonition to Bill Clinton that 'it's the economy, stupid.' To take Trump and MAGA down, Democrats must take the less sexy route and focus like a laser beam on his failure to keep prices from going up. That means talking about the price of eggs instead of the rule of law. The cost of living is a concrete overcoat for hard-working and cash-strapped families. The rule of law is an abstract concept you can't use to feed your kids. The authorities never nailed Chicago gangster Al Capone for murder, gambling, prostitution or bootlegging, but the feds put him out of business for tax evasion — not dramatic but highly effective. The November 2024 national exit poll illustrates the challenge that Democrats must confront on the economy. Trump (81 percent) had a four-to-one edge over Kamala Harris (18 percent) with people who indicated that their vote was based on the economy. The GOP presidential candidate actually beat his Democratic opponent among voters in households where the income was under $50,000 a year. These low-income voters were once the bedrock of the New Deal and the winning Democratic coalition. Franklin Delano Roosevelt must be spinning in his grave. The upset win for Assemblyman Zohran Mamdani over former New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo in the New York City Democratic mayoral primary offers a template for electoral success. Michelle Goldberg wrote in the New York Times that, 'Mamdani won because of his relentless focus on affordability and our quality of life, and his ebullience, optimism and authenticity.' Hopefully, his win will start a trend that will bring victory to Democrats and progressives for years to come. Democrats can link Trump's failures in several policy areas to his devastating record. His draconian deportment of immigrants working in construction and on farms will raise home and food prices even higher. Trump's attack on Iran could destabilize the Middle East which almost always brings higher gasoline prices. Attacks on his hurtful actions to deprive millions of Americans of food and medical care must always include the kicker that the president is executing these outrages to pay for tax cuts for bankers, billionaires and fat cats and plutocrats. To keep the MAGA rot from spreading, Democrats and progressives need message discipline. That's difficult since we're free spirits by nature — Republicans fall in line while we fall in love. The only way to slow MAGA down is for Democrats to win the House in 2026. Then we can end the Trump regime with a Democratic presidential victory in 2028. The best way to win is to focus like a laser beam on the sorry state of the Trump economy. We need a progressive administration that values Dreamers more than deportation, diplomacy over violence and freedom over fascism. Beating Trump on the economy is the key to ending destructive MAGA immigration and racial policies and building a Supreme Court that will preserve our civil liberties. Brad Bannon is a national Democratic strategist and CEO of Bannon Communications Research which polls for Democrats, labor unions and progressive issue groups. He hosts the popular progressive podcast on power, politics and policy, Deadline D.C. with Brad Bannon.
Associated Press
an hour ago
- Associated Press
Ohio governor signs 2-year, $60 billion budget that includes funding for football stadium
Ohio Gov. Mike DeWine has signed a two-year, $60 billion operating budget that flattens the state's income tax and sets aside $600 million in unclaimed funds for a new Cleveland Browns stadium. The Republican governor signed the budget late Monday night, about 45 minutes before the midnight deadline. He also issued 67 line-item vetoes, including one that would have cut funding for homeless shelters 'that promote or affirm social gender transition' and another that would have forced public libraries to keep materials on sexual orientation and gender identity away from those under 18. He also rejected lawmakers' plan to limit how much money school districts could carry over to 40% and another that would have required candidates for local school board races to be identified with partisan labels on the ballot. The moves mark the largest number of vetoes DeWine has issued since becoming governor in 2019. His previous record was 44 in 2023. The governor defended his decisions during a news conference Tuesday, noting that state lawmakers can now vote to override the vetoes and put the items back in the budget if they desire. The budget had been approved by the Republican-controlled state Legislature last week. GOP leaders touted its $1 billion in income tax relief, pathways to address Ohio's property tax crisis, and that it trims spending at administrative agencies and curtails regulations. Democrats voted uniformly against the bill, alongside a handful of Republicans, casting it as a collection of misguided policy tradeoffs that prioritize the wealthy over the middle class. The budget phases in a single flat-tax rate of 2.75% over two years, affecting anyone making over $26,050 annually. Those making less would continue to pay nothing. The plan eliminates the existing 3.5% rate for those making over $100,000 annually by the 2026 tax year. It also includes the $600 million Haslam Sports Group, owner of the Browns, which requested that the state help build a new domed stadium in suburban Brook Park south of Cleveland. DeWine had proposed doubling taxes on sports betting to help the Browns, as well as the Cincinnati Bengals and other teams who might seek facility upgrades. But the Legislature used some of the $4.8 billion in unclaimed funds the state is holding on to — in small sums, residents left behind from dormant bank accounts, uncashed checks and forgotten utility deposits. Currently, there's a 10-year time limit before that money reverts to the state. 'This is a win for taxpayers, and it will provide significant money to things that improve the quality of life in Ohio,' DeWine said of the stadium money. In a statement issued Tuesday, the Browns called the budget approval a 'tremendous milestone for our organization' and said DeWine and the Legislature worked together 'to find a responsible way to support such a transformative project.' Lawmakers who represent Cleveland and surrounding communities, mostly Democrats, have blasted the proposal as a gift to the team's billionaire owners. Democrats outside the Legislature have threatened to sue if DeWine signed the plan, arguing it would be unconstitutionally raiding the unclaimed funds without due process.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Senate passes Trump's big tax breaks and spending cuts bill as Vance breaks 50-50 tie
WASHINGTON (AP) — Senate Republicans hauled President Donald Trump's big tax breaks and spending cuts bill to passage Tuesday on the narrowest of margins, pushing past opposition from Democrats and their own GOP ranks after a turbulent overnight session. The outcome capped an unusually tense weekend of work at the Capitol, the president's signature legislative priority teetering on the edge of approval or collapse. In the end that tally was 50-50, with Vice President JD Vance casting the tie-breaking vote. Three Republican senators — Thom Tillis of North Carolina, Susan Collins of Maine and Rand Paul of Kentucky — joined all Democrats in voting against it. "The big not so beautiful bill has passed,' Paul said after the vote. The difficulty it took for Republicans, who have the majority hold in Congress, to wrestle the bill to this point is not expected to let up. The package now goes back to the House, where Speaker Mike Johnson had warned senators not to deviate too far from what his chamber had already approved. But the Senate did make changes, particularly to Medicaid, risking more problems as they race to finish by Trump's Fourth of July deadline. The outcome is a pivotal moment for president and his party, which have been consumed by the 940-page 'One Big Beautiful Bill Act,' as it's formally titled, and invested their political capital in delivering on the GOP's sweep of power in Washington. Donald Trump acknowledged it's 'very complicated stuff,' as he departed the White House for Florida. 'I don't want to go too crazy with cuts," he said. "I don't like cuts.' What started as a routine but laborious day of amendment voting, in a process called vote-a-rama, spiraled into a round-the-clock slog as Republican leaders were buying time to shore up support. The droning roll calls in the chamber belied the frenzied action to steady the bill. Grim-faced scenes played out on and off the Senate floor, amid exhaustion. Senate Majority Leader John Thune of South Dakota was desperately reaching for last-minute agreements between those in his party worried the bill's reductions to Medicaid will leave millions without care, and his most conservative flank, which wants even steeper cuts to hold down deficits ballooning with the tax cuts. The GOP leaders have no room to spare, with narrow majorities. Thune could lose no more than three Republican senators, and two — Tillis, who warned that millions of people will lose access to Medicaid health care, and Paul, who opposes raising the debt limit by $5 trillion — had already indicated opposition. Attention quickly turned to two other key senators, Lisa Murkowski of Alaska and Collins, who also raised concerns about health care cuts, as well as a loose coalition of four conservative GOP senators pushing for even steeper reductions. Murkowski in particular became the subject of the GOP leadership's attention, as they sat beside her for talks. She was huddled intensely for more than an hour in the back of the chamber with others, scribbling notes on papers. Then all eyes were on Paul after he returned from a visit to Thune's office with a stunning offer that could win his vote. He had suggested substantially lowering the bill's increase in the debt ceiling, according to two people familiar with the private meeting and granted anonymity to discuss it. Senate Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer of New York said 'Republicans are in shambles because they know the bill is so unpopular." An analysis from the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office found 11.8 million more Americans would become uninsured by 2034 if the bill became law. The CBO said the package would increase the deficit by nearly $3.3 trillion over the decade. And on social media, billionaire Elon Musk was again lashing out at Republicans as 'the PORKY PIG PARTY!!' for including the $5 trillion debt ceiling in the package, which is needed to allow continued borrowing to pay the bills. Senators insist on changes Few Republicans appeared fully satisfied as the final package emerged, in either the House or the Senate. Collins had proposed bolstering the $25 billion proposed rural hospital fund to $50 billion, offset with a higher tax rate on those earning more than $25 million a year, but her amendment failed. And Murkowski was trying to secure provisions to spare people in her state from some food stamp cuts, which appeared to be accepted, while she was also working to beef up federal reimbursements to hospitals in Alaska and others states, that did not comply with parliamentary rules. What's in the big bill All told, the Senate bill includes $4.5 trillion in tax cuts, according to the latest CBO analysis, making permanent Trump's 2017 rates, which would expire at the end of the year if Congress fails to act, while adding the new ones he campaigned on, including no taxes on tips. The Senate package would roll back billions of dollars in green energy tax credits, which Democrats warn will wipe out wind and solar investments nationwide. It would impose $1.2 trillion in cuts, largely to Medicaid and food stamps, by imposing work requirements on able-bodied people, including some parents and older Americans, making sign-up eligibility more stringent and changing federal reimbursements to states. Additionally, the bill would provide a $350 billion infusion for border and national security, including for deportations, some of it paid for with new fees charged to immigrants. Democrats fighting all day and night Unable to stop the march toward passage, the Democrats tried to drag out the process, including with a weekend reading of the full bill. A few of the Democratic amendments won support from a few Republicans, though almost none passed. More were considered in one of the longer such sessions in modern times. One amendment overwhelmingly approved stripped a provision barring states from regulating artificial intelligence if they receive certain federal funding. Sen. Patty Murray of Washington, the ranking Democrat on the Appropriations Committee, raised particular concern about the accounting method being used by the Republicans, which says the tax breaks from Trump's first term are now 'current policy' and the cost of extending them should not be counted toward deficits. She said that kind of 'magic math' won't fly with Americans trying to balance their own household books. ___ Associated Press writers Joey Cappelletti, Darelene Superville and Kevin Freking contributed to this report.
