SMU's Rhett Lashlee Admits the College Football Playoff Made an Error
The SMU Mustangs made the inaugural 12-team College Football Playoff after losing a closely-contested ACC championship against Clemson. However, there was one team Mustangs coach Rhett Lashlee says should've gotten in.
Advertisement
SMU clinched the last spot over Alabama in the playoff, resulting in weeks of debate across college football. Many wondered if more teams meant a more problematic outcome for the Playoff Committee.
Lashlee feels SMU and Alabama should've both been included in the postseason. But if that's the case, who gets left behind?
'Well, I felt like we deserved to be in but after we came up short 12 hours before in that ACC championship game with Clemson," Lashlee said in an interview with The Next Round.
"I cannot say I felt great with the way it was shaping up to be either us or Alabama, which I'm not sure that's the way it should've shaped up. I think maybe we both should've been in.'
Advertisement
SMU ended the regular season with a top ten ranking at 11-1. Their only loss was to BYU in non-conference play. But the loss to Clemson was followed by a 38-10 Playoff defeat to Penn State in Happy Valley.
Related: SMU Football Faces Backlash After Team GPA Under Rhett Lashlee Surfaces
As for Alabama, they will have another chance to prove themselves as a worthy postseason contender in 2025. At 9-3, the late-season loss to Oklahoma killed off any chance of sneaking into the playoff. Under Kalen DeBoer, the Crimson Tide had three wins against ranked opponents, including No. 2 Georgia.
Related: Explosive Edge Rusher Hudson Woods Commits to SMU Football
SMU hopes to repeat the magic of last year in a wide open ACC. The game to watch will be a title game rematch at Clemson on Oct. 18.
This story was originally reported by Athlon Sports on Jun 11, 2025, where it first appeared.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
USA Today
8 minutes ago
- USA Today
Notre Dame rival Michigan finds out its fate from NCAA on ‘sign gate' scandal
While Notre Dame hasn't played Michigan since 2019, they are still viewed as a big rival for the Irish. On Friday, as the season approaches, the NCAA announced the penalty for the Wolverines surrounding its intricate sign stealing accusations as reported by Pete Thamel. Michigan will be on four years probation, a $50,000 fine with 10% of the budget for the football program, a fine that equates to all postseason revenue share, along with another fine of 10% of the costs of scholarships awarded. The total amount of fines could be close to $30 million. There will also be a 25% reduction in official visits during the 2025 and 2026 seasons, and multiple people got show clauses including its former head coach Jim Harbaugh for 10-years, who now is in the NFL with the Los Angeles Chargers. He previously was given a 4-year show cause penalty in 2024 for a different case. Both Connor Stallions (8-years) and Denard Robinson (3-years) also received show clauses, while current head coach Sherrone Moore got a 2-year show-cause order, and added another game suspension making it 3-games total. The Wolverines picked the games that Moore will not coach, which doesn't make any sense, as they opted for Moore to miss games three and four, while the NCAA added the first game of the 2026 season. He's also not allowed to coach or be with the team during those suspension weeks. It seems like Michigan got off pretty easy on this one, as there was no bowl or College Football Playoff ban, along with not vacating any of their wins during that period. Once again the NCAA has a questionable ruling on a team breaking the rules, one that impacted many during a run where the Wolverines made the CFP twice, winning it in 2024. Do you agree with the sanctions? Or are they too light? Contact/Follow us @IrishWireND on X (Formerly Twitter), and like our page on Facebook to follow ongoing coverage of Notre Dame news, notes, and opinions. Follow Mike on X: @MikeFChen
USA Today
8 minutes ago
- USA Today
Michigan receives massive fine from NCAA for Connor Stalions violations
The NCAA has announced the penalties for the Michigan football program due to the Connor Stalions sign-stealing case. And while at first glance they might seem relatively light, the actual fines are going to be massive. First, let's mention the show-cause orders. Jim Harbaugh and Connor Stalions will be kept away from the football program for ten and eight years, respectively. That might not seem like a big deal--neither is currently affiliated with the program--but there are downsides to not being able to bring back a recent National Championship-winning coach for recruiting or alumni services. Also, Denard Robinson will not be allowed back with the program for at least three years. The NCAA determined that it would not suffice for Sherrone Moore, who deleted text messages that could have been relevant to the investigation, to only be suspended for the two games Michigan self-disciplined him for. He will also be suspended for a third game. However, the NCAA is not making him take that suspension in the 2025 season, and he can use it to sit out a cupcake game in 2026. There are also relatively minor recruiting penalties. The big one, though, are the fines. The NCAA didn't simply levy a basic number for the fines. So when people see the top line amount of just $50,000, this might seem like a slap on the wrist. However, the other financial penalties are staggering. Let's break them down: First, the scholarships. Looking at Michigan's data for athletic scholarships and doing some rough math, 85 football scholarships (though now up to 105 are allowed) should average to about $6 million. So 10% of that is another $600,000 in fines. And the other two fines are even bigger. 10% of Michigan's football budget is absolutely massive. The numbers aren't public yet, but coaching salaries alone are well over $20 million. The total athletic budget is about $250 million (last year), and football is probably somewhere in the $65-85 million range. 10% of that is looking at around $6.5-8.5 million. Lastly, the postseason revenue. This number isn't fixed, and it depends on several factors. The Big Ten splits up all of its bowl revenue evenly between conference members (some newer members don't get a full share yet). Last year, between College Football Playoff bonuses and base contracts, the total number was over $160 million, or about $10 million per full-share school. In the Playoff era (before expansion), the yearly number could vary anywhere from $5-10 million. So Michigan losing two years of postseason revenue could by itself cost $20 million. All in all, the Wolverines are probably looking at well over $30 million in total fines. No wins were vacated, but this will be the largest fine in college athletics history--by a significant margin.
USA Today
38 minutes ago
- USA Today
Is Michigan coach Sherrone Moore suspended for Week 1? Head man to be on sidelines vs NMU
Case closed. The NCAA announced on Friday that Michigan football coach Sherrone Moore will not face further suspension in 2025 from the governing body for college athletics for his involvement in the Wolverines' sign-stealing scandal that surfaced during their 2023 season, which ended in their national championship, but he will miss a game next season. Moore, who was suspended by the Wolverines in a self-imposed sanction for Weeks 3 and 4 this year, will miss games vs Central Michigan and Nebraska. He will coach in Week 1 vs New Mexico and against his alma mater Oklahoma in Week 2. Moore was suspended for an additional game to be served in Week 1 of 2026 by the NCAA. REQUIRED READING: Divided opinions on Michigan sign-stealing scandal just part of college football tribalism Named as the successor to Jim Harbaugh − who returned to the NFL with the Los Angeles Chargers in January of 2024 and faces a one-year suspension and 14-year show-cause from the NCAA for recruiting violations in addition to this infraction − Moore is entering his second season in Ann Arbor as the Wolverines' head coach. After starting the season 4-1, Michigan went through a swift mid-season decline in late October/early November under Moore last year that featured losing four games in a five-game stretch. That span ultimately took the Wolverines from any chance at contention for the Big Ten title and earning a spot in the College Football Playoff. Michigan, which opens the season on Aug. 30 vs. New Mexico, was ranked No. 14 in the preseason US LBM Coaches Poll. Here's what to know from Aug. 15's release from the NCAA regarding Moore: Did the NCAA suspend Sherrone Moore? Sherrone Moore was suspended for a game in 2026, but will not face a further suspension in 2025. He will miss Weeks 3 & 4 vs Central Michigan and Nebraska, respectively, but he will still coach Weeks 1 & 2 vs New Mexico and Oklahoma, the latter of which is his alma mater. He will not coach Week 1 in 2026, which is slated to be vs Western Michigan in Ann Arbor. Why was Sherrone Moore being investigated by the NCAA? Moore was being investigated by the NCAA as part of its larger investigation into the Wolverines' program for their sign-stealing scandal that took place in 2023. The 39-year-old Moore was being accused of deleting 52 text messages with former Michigan football analyst Connor Stalions around the time of the initial investigation, which is against NCAA rules. Sherrone Moore suspension dates In hopes of attempting to lower the severity of the NCAA's punishments on Moore and the program, Michigan self-imposed a two-game suspension on Moore for the Wolverines' Week 3 matchup on Sept. 13 vs. Central Michigan and their Big Ten opener at Nebraska in Week 4 on Sept. 20. A thing to note about Moore's suspension from Michigan is that it wasn't issued for the Wolverines' marquee SEC non-conference matchup with Oklahoma in Week 2 or their Big Ten home opener against Wisconsin on Oct. 4 in Week 6. This is the second time that Michigan has issued a self-imposed suspension against Moore, as he was also suspended by the Wolverines for Week 1 of the 2023 season when he was serving as Michigan's offensive coordinator for his involvement in the NCAA recruiting violations during COVID-19 that the program committed. Interestingly, Moore was also issued a two-year show cause in addition to the suspension. Here's when Moore is scheduled to serve his suspension from Michigan: Sherrone Moore record In his first season as Michigan's coach, Moore led the Wolverines to an 8-5 overall record and a ReliaQuest Bowl win over No. 11 Alabama. Though widely considered an underwhelming season by the Wolverines, Moore still led Michigan to a win over Ohio State, the program's fourth consecutive win over the Buckeyes.
