Warren prods DOJ to sue to block Capital One-Discover deal
Sen. Elizabeth Warren, D-MA, urged the Justice Department to sue to block Capital One's pending acquisition of Discover, according to a letter she wrote Tuesday to the agency's antitrust leader, Gail Slater.
Warren cited an address Slater gave in late April warning of the risks that consolidation could again – after the 2007-08 financial crisis – create institutions that are 'too big to fail.'
'This transaction will reveal whether you back your words with action,' Warren wrote Tuesday.
The DOJ has 30 days to sue after banking regulators approve a merger application, Warren noted. The Federal Reserve and Office of the Comptroller of the Currency gave a green light April 18 to Capital One's $35.3 billion proposed transaction. Warren wrote the Fed on May 1, urging the central bank to reconsider.
'Absent a rescission of the Fed's approval order, the responsibility to prevent this dangerous transaction now falls to the DOJ,' Warren wrote Tuesday.
Slater, however, determined there wasn't sufficient evidence to challenge the Capital One deal in court, publications reported last month, citing people familiar with the decision.
Nonetheless, Warren pressed that the DOJ 'does not need to have previously filed an adverse comment with regulators' about a deal to attempt to block it. The senator Tuesday expressed disappointment that the DOJ had not filed such a comment – 'despite reportedly finding competitive concerns with the deal.'
Warren urged Slater to lean on the Clayton Act – and the DOJ's own updated merger guidelines – to block the Capital One deal, citing that a merger may violate antitrust law if it 'significantly increases consolidation in a highly concentrated market' or 'eliminates substantial competition between firms.'
Warren noted that during its initial evaluation of the Capital One-Discover merger last year, DOJ reportedly 'told regulators that it was concerned, in part, about the deal's impact on potential credit card users who had no credit' and that agency representatives showed concern that the transaction 'would harm competition in the subprime sector.'
Warren asserted, in particular, that Discover 'offers interest rates two percentage points lower than Capital One' to borrowers with nonprime credit scores – but that that offer would likely go away once the firms combine.
'Less competition among those with lower credit scores could mean Capital One can raise credit card rates for vulnerable families with limited alternative options, which could be the difference between getting by month-to-month and entering a financial downward spiral,' Warren wrote Tuesday.
Warren repeated concerns that, by acquiring Discover, Capital One would carry more than 30% of the nonprime credit score market, driving the Herfindahl-Hirschman Index – a legacy measure of market consolidation – up by roughly 400 points. For new-to-credit customers, she added, the Fed's analysis found 'the post-merger HHI would increase by 766 points to 1971.'
The DOJ last year withdrew guidelines that leaned heavily on HHI on the idea that the gauge is outdated. But even using it, a transaction that boosts HHI by 200 points or scores above 1,800 generally has been flagged as anticompetitive.
'A merger that creates a firm with a market share over 30 percent and increases HHI by more than 100 points is presumptively illegal under antitrust law,' Warren reiterated Tuesday.
Warren added that DOJ 'has previously been skeptical of deals 'that would enable firms to avoid a regulatory constraint because that constraint was applicable to only one of the merging firms.''
Capital One has said it aims to convert its debit portfolio to Discover networks, Warren asserted.
'The reason is clear: Discover is not only a card issuer but also a card network, which means it is not subject to the limit on debit card interchange fees imposed by the Durbin Amendment to the Dodd-Frank Act,' Warren said.
While Capital One, before the merger, wouldn't be able to charge merchants more, Discover can, she said.
'And in case there was any doubt about whether Capital One plans to raise swipe fees, the company told its investors that converting its debit and some credit products to Discover networks would be worth an estimated $1.2 billion,' Warren wrote Tuesday.
By moving some of its credit card volume to Discover's network – but not all of it – Capital One would retain the leverage to negotiate interchange fees as a credit card issuer with Discover's largest competitors.
Warren labeled that 'a recipe for coordination' among Discover, Visa and Mastercard.
'The solution to an anticompetitive market is not to anoint a new giant, but to fight to level the entire playing field, like the DOJ is doing with its lawsuit against Visa for monopolization,' Warren wrote Tuesday.
Warren argued, too, that a Capital One-Discover combination would put a damper on existing innovation.
She noted that in the February 2024 call announcing the deal, Capital One CEO Richard Fairbank admitted that his bank's Quicksilver card was a direct response to Discover's It card.
'As Capital One absorbs a major competitor, fewer players in this market could … diminish incentives for remaining firms to offer more generous rewards,' Warren warned.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
28 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Trump says Obama should be top target in DOJ probe into intel report
President Trump on Tuesday said that former President Obama should be targeted directly by the Department of Justice after his administration's report alleged Obama administration officials manipulated intelligence related to Russian interference in the 2016 election. Director of National Intelligence (DNI) Tulsi Gabbard has sent criminal referrals to the DOJ related to the report released on Friday that asserted the Obama officials engaged in a 'treasonous conspiracy.' When asked in the Oval Office on Tuesday, during a visit with Philippines President Ferdinand Marcos Jr., about whom the DOJ should target, Trump pointed to Obama. 'Based on what I read, and I read pretty much what you read, it would be President Obama. He started it,' Trump said. 'And [then-vice president Joe] Biden was there with him and [former FBI director James] Comey was there and [former DNI director James] Clapper, the whole group was there. [Former CIA director John] Brennan. They were all there in a room, right here, this was the room.' He added, 'If you look at those papers, they have him stone-cold and it was President Obama. It wasn't lots of people all over the place, it was them, too. But the leader of the gang was President Obama, Barack Hussein Obama, have you heard of him?' 'He's guilty, it's not a question,' Trump said. 'This was treason, this was every word you can think of.' He added that Gabbard told him that thousands of additional documents would be coming, and he called Obama the 'ringleader.' Friday's memo also cited former officials like Clapper, Brennan and Comey and comes after Trump has for years claimed the investigation into Russian interference in the 2016 election and whether his campaign colluded with Moscow was a 'hoax.' Trump in March signed a memo ordering the declassification of 'all files related to Crossfire Hurricane,' the name given to the FBI's investigation into Russian interference in the 2016 election. The president on Tuesday also was questioned about Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche reaching out to lawyers of Ghislaine Maxwell, a convicted sex offender and associate of disgraced financier Jeffrey Epstein, to set up a meeting with her. He said he didn't know anything about it but brought up Gabbard's report. 'The witch hunt that you should be talking about if they caught President Obama absolutely cold, Tulsi Gabbard. What they did to this country in 2016, starting in 2016 but going up all the way going up to 2020 and the election, they tried to rig the election and they got caught and they should be very severe consequences for that,' Trump said. Trump also said when he 'caught' former Democratic presidential nominee Hillary Clinton but he 'let her off the hook' because she was a wife of a former president. 'It's time to go after people. Obama's been caught directly,' he said. 'What they did in 2016 and in 2020 is very criminal, it's criminal at the highest level so that's really the things you should be talking about.' Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.


The Hill
an hour ago
- The Hill
NJ Democrats rip DOJ over removal of Habba successor
New Jersey Democratic Sens. Cory Booker and Andy Kim slammed the Trump administration on Tuesday for failing to uphold the court ordered appointment of Alina Haba's successor to serve as the state's interim U.S. attorney. Desiree Leigh Grace, Habba's first assistant, was tapped by the U.S. District Court for the District of New Jersey to lead the office upon the expiration of her 120-day temporary term. But, on Tuesday, Grace was 'removed' from the post by the Justice Department (DOJ). 'Trump's Department of Justice is once again criticizing a court that acted within its authority, continuing a pattern of publicly undermining judicial decisions and showing disregard for the rule of law and the separation of powers,' Booker and Kim said in a statement. 'The firing of a career public servant, lawfully appointed by the court, is another blatant attempt to intimidate anyone that doesn't agree with them and undermine judicial independence,' the duo continued. 'This Administration may not like the law, but they are not above it.' DOJ officials have accused the Democratic senators of plotting to oust Habba, who failed to be confirmed by judges for a long-term position. 'They forced out President Trump's pick, @USAttyHabba, then installed her deputy, colluding with the NJ Senators along the way. It won't work,' Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche wrote on social platform X, referring to Booker and Kim. 'Pursuant to the President's authority, we have removed that deputy, effective immediately,' he added. 'This backroom vote will not override the authority of the Chief Executive.' Attorney General Pam Bondi said, 'politically minded judges refused to allow her to continue in her position.' Habba received a considerable amount of backlash after initiating charges against Newark Mayor Ras Baraka (D) and Rep. LaMonica McIver (D-N.J.) stemming from an incident at a U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement facility in the Garden State. Both Baraka and McIver denied the accusations resulting in charges dropped against the Newark mayor. Baraka has sued Habba for damages over his arrest. A federal judge said the New Jersey mayor's arrest suggested a 'worrisome misstep' by Habba's office, noting the 'apparent rush' in bringing the case that culminated in the government's 'embarrassing' retraction of the charge. 'The people of New Jersey deserve a U.S. Attorney who will enforce the law and pursue justice for the people of our state without partisanship or politics,' Booker and Kim said on Tuesday, following Habba's failure to be retained as the state's top federal prosecutor.


Politico
2 hours ago
- Politico
Epstein fallout heads to Florida
Good morning and welcome to Wednesday. MAGA stalwarts' refusal to drop their calls for more information about the JEFFREY EPSTEIN investigation has been consuming Washington for weeks — an issue President DONALD TRUMP has worked to move on from. Police and prosecutors said Epstein sexually abused girls at his mansion in Palm Beach. And though politicos may not have known it, a different Florida location popped into the headlines Tuesday: Tallahassee. Deputy Attorney General TODD BLANCHE has asked for a meeting with GHISLAINE MAXWELL, the former socialite who was convicted of conspiring with Epstein in his child sex-trafficking scheme. She's serving out her 20-year prison sentence at Tallahassee's low-security Federal Correctional Institution. If DOJ officials meet here, a slew of cameras and MAGA influencers are likely to descend on Florida's capital. Blanche wants to interview Maxwell about others who possibly engaged in sexual abuse as demands to make more files public continue to rattle the MAGA base. Until recently, Trump and Republican officials were the ones demanding more information about Epstein, wanting to see a rumored 'client list' and further investigation into whether Epstein's death was a murder and not a suicide, as federal investigators have formally concluded. Seizing on the frustration, Democrats have begun to focus on the topic, bringing attention to how Trump and Epstein reportedly used to be friends (but apparently not close enough to survive a bankruptcy auction of a Palm Beach estate). Trump is not accused of any wrongdoing linked to Epstein. More reports have emerged about the Trump-Epstein relationship, including about a birthday card to Epstein which allegedly contained Trump's signature, over which the president sued The Wall Street Journal. Trump has denied the report, and POLITICO has not independently verified the card or its contents. The president's lawsuit against the Journal over the coverage has landed in the courtroom of DARRIN GAYLES in southern Florida. Adding yet another Sunshine State connection to the whole saga, the WSJ has hired former GOP Sen. GEORGE LEMIEUX, the previous CHARLIE CRIST chief of staff when he was governor, who now works at the Florida firm Gunster Yoakley & Stewart, per POLITICO's Josh Gerstein. The issue has been creating headaches for Hill Republicans. Up in Washington, the House Oversight Committee voted Tuesday for a motion to subpoena Maxwell to testify, report POLITICO's Hailey Fuchs and Meredith Lee Hill. Then House Speaker MIKE JOHNSON announced he was cancelling Thursday votes to avoid pressure from Democrats to hold procedural votes on releasing more documents about the investigation, per Meredith. 'TRANSLATION: Pres Trump's name is all over the Epstein files and they're TERRIFIED about releasing them,' taunted Rep. DARREN SOTO (D-Fla.) over X. But other Republicans do agree not enough is out there. Gov. RON DESANTIS has called on the Trump administration to release all the files, adding, 'There were obviously other people involved, and yet no one's been brought to justice.' The governor signed a bill into law in 2024 to have state grand jury records released from 20-year-old investigations and testimonies. That investigation led to Epstein landing a deal in which he avoided federal charges or extended prison time. For 13 months he was in a Palm Beach county jail where he was regularly allowed to leave. Where's RON? Gov. DeSantis is holding a press conference at 10 a.m. in Jacksonville with Florida first lady Casey DeSantis and Florida Surgeon General Joseph Ladapo. Have a tip, story, suggestion, birthday, anniversary, new job, or any other nugget that Playbook should look at? Get in touch at: kleonard@ and @leonardkl. ... DATELINE TALLAHASSEE ... LOCAL GOVERNMENT PROBE — Florida authorities plan to sweep into 10 to 15 cities and counties over the next few weeks as part of an aggressive new effort to scrutinize local spending. Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis outlined the plan Tuesday after new Chief Financial Officer Blaise Ingoglia and other top state officials said they were going to send officials to inspect spending records of the city of Gainesville and Broward County. Ingoglia, along with the governor's budget chief and the head of Florida's government efficiency task force, sent letters to the heads of those governments Monday demanding access to key personnel and the physical premises over a two-day period next week. Both of those governments are led by Democratic-controlled commissions. HARVEY WARD, the mayor of Gainesville, said in response to the audits that 'we're an open book. We are not trying to hide anything.' — Gary Fineout HOW SOON IS SOON? DeSantis told reporters Tuesday he is planning to name a new lieutenant governor 'soon' but said he still needs to 'vet people' for the job. The post has been vacant ever since JEANETTE NUÑEZ stepped down in February to become president at Florida International University. State Sen. JAY COLLINS has been seen as the frontrunner for the appointment, but the governor said there's 'different folks that want it.' He added that 'it'll be soon, but it's not necessarily going to be, you know, today or tomorrow.' — Gary Fineout HEARING SCHEDULE FOR 'ALLIGATOR ALCATRAZ' — A federal judge has scheduled an Aug. 6 hearing to decide whether to issue an order blocking activities at the newly built immigration detention center in the Everglades. U.S. District Judge Kathleen M. Williams, who took over the case last week, during a Monday status conference declined a request from environmental groups to issue an order immediately. — Bruce Ritchie — ''They chained me to the ground': Detainees at Alligator Alcatraz allege harsh punishment by guards,' by Tim Padgett of WLRN. — 'He was the suspect in brutal Florida Keys murder. Now he's in Alligator Alcatraz,' by David Goodhue of Florida Keys News. INSIDE STATE-LEASED PROPERTY — State officials leased property back to a company associated with the historically powerful Collier family for less than one-third of its value set by two appraisers, following a controversial land purchase approved last year by the Florida Cabinet. The lease involves 25,000 acres the state purchased for $122 million in a 2024 deal. A year earlier, then-state Senate President Kathleen Passidomo pushed for $850 million in the 2023-24 state budget that targeted southwest Florida and led to the deal. DEP Communications Director Alexandra Kuchta said this week that the two reports 'provided an initial framework for negotiations but did not fully reflect current agricultural conditions, including the fact that not all the acreage was in active production at the time of acquisition.' — Bruce Ritchie AG INVESTIGATION — 'Vice Mayor Linda Moore is under investigation by the Office of Statewide Prosecution for a 'Pride Tea Dance' — held last month at the Kilted Mermaid, a bar she owns — which may have violated state law concerning sexualized performances in front of children,' reports Treasure Coast Newspapers. — 'Florida attorney general: Call ICE hotline if your undocumented ex should be deported,' by Ana Goñi-Lessan of USA Today Network — Florida. — 'James Uthmeier joins 17 Attorneys General in legal fight for public prayer in high school sports,' by Drew Dixon of Florida Politics. — 'FHP arrests immigrant 'wanted for murder in Guatemala' during traffic stop, state says,' by Angie DiMichele of the South Florida Sun Sentinel. PENINSULA AND BEYOND POLICE BEATING VIDEO GOES VIRAL — 'A video showing Florida deputies punching and dragging a Black man from his car during a traffic stop has sparked nationwide outrage, with civil rights lawyers accusing authorities of fabricating their arrest report,' writes Jeff Martin of The Associated Press. TRI-RAIL CASH CRUNCH — South Florida's publicly funded passenger train is expected to run out of money following budget cuts of more than $27 million by the Legislature, reports Chris Persaud of the Palm Beach Post. Current spending will allow the service to keep operating for a couple years, but scheduled improvements won't happen. BRIGHTLINE ALSO STRUGGLES — Investors are anxious about reports Brightline was going to delay an interest payment, writes Bloomberg's Martin Z. Braun, Reshmi Basu and Eliza Ronalds-Hannon. They have been 'bouncing between Brightline calls and meetings as they try to understand the extent of the stress the company is under, according to people familiar with the matter who asked not to be identified because the conversations are private. 'With the prices of its junk bonds plummeting, some holders of the company's corporate bonds have held conversations with law firms about their options as the company tries to raise new equity and debt and comes under pressure to roll over a $985 million tax-exempt note in August, the people said.' ...HURRICANE HOLE... FEMA OFFICIAL OUT — The head of the Federal Emergency Management Agency's urban search and rescue unit, KEN PAGUREK, resigned, reports The New York Times' Lisa Friedman, telling colleagues he was 'frustrated by bureaucratic hurdles the Trump administration imposed that delayed the agency's response to deadly flooding in Texas.' CAMPAIGN MODE SPECIAL ELECTIONS SET — DeSantis on Tuesday issued executive orders that set special elections later this year for state Senate District 11 and state House District 90. DeSantis last week appointed Ingoglia to the job of chief financial officer creating a vacancy in the state Senate seat. State Rep. JOE CASELLO died last week after suffering a heart attack. The primary election will be held on Sept. 30 while the general election will be held on Dec. 9. The timeline for these special elections ensures that both seats will be filed before the start of the 2026 legislative session in January. — Gary Fineout PRIMARY CHALLENGE — MICHAEL THOMPSON, the former chair of Lee County GOP, has filed to challenge GOP Rep. TIFFANY ESPOSITO, reports Jacob Ogles of Florida Politics. TRUMPLANDIA AND THE SWAMP DEFUNDING PUBLIC MEDIA — 'Indian River State College — which owns WQCS-FM and stations WQCP, WQJS and WQCO — is bracing for a loss of about $250,000 in federal and state funding, according to a July 21 statement from Chris Puorro, IRSC Public Media associate vice president and general manager. It's about 14 percent of the station's revenue last year,' reports Jack Randall of Treasure Coast Newspapers. DATELINE D.C. THE NUMBERS ARE IN — Lobbying Disclosure Act revenue files show that Ballard Partners was the No. 1 firm in terms of revenue during the second quarter of 2025, reports POLITICO's Caitlin Oprysko. Ballard Partners earned $20.6 million, compared with $14 million in the first quarter of this year and $4.4 million in the second quarter of last year. — Rep. RANDY FINE (R-Fla.) secured a spot on the House Foreign Affairs Committee. FLOOD INSURANCE BILL — Rep. BYRON DONALDS introduced a bill Tuesday that would allow people to deduct flood insurance premiums from their taxable income. The Flood Insurance Relief Act was also introduced on the Senate side, by GOP Sens. RICK SCOTT and ASHLEY MOODY of Florida, and would be limited to individuals who have a gross income of $200,000 or people who file jointly making less than $400,000 combined. ODDS, ENDS AND FLORIDA MEN — 'Roy Black, one of the nation's premier defense lawyers, dies in Coral Gables at 80,' reports the Miami Herald's Jay Weaver. BIRTHDAYS: Fritz Brogan, co-founder and managing partner of Mission Group and former national chair of Maverick PAC … Charlie Justice, Pinellas County commissioner and former state representative ... Tracie Pough of Ballard Partners, former chief of staff for Rep. Debbie Wasserman Schultz.