Diggers and Dealers: Tim Hoff looks for more winners with his 2025 Diggers portfolio
After an enormously successful 2023 instalment, Canaccord's Tim Hoff has had reason to be chirpy about his Diggers and Dealers stock selections.
Powered by market darlings Spartan Resources (ASX:SPR) and Azure Minerals (ASX:AZS), a $10,000 investment in August 2023 would have netted $21,600 by last year's conference.
Last year, Hoff correctly predicted small cap punting would be a harder task in turbulent markets.
Spreading himself thinner across 13 small cap names, a 105% 12-month lift in copper explorer Prospect Resources (ASX:PSC) and 95% gain for South American silver stacker Andean Silver (ASX:ASL) proved the standouts of a kaleidoscopic mix of speculative names.
All up the gains and losses of a hypothetical 'Hoff Diggers portfolio' would have evened out to 10.85% on the year.
"Look last year we were sitting here and we thought it would be difficult," he said.
"And honestly I hadn't looked at the numbers until today and I was fairly surprised to see that the portfolio, the ideas that we came through with on average were up.
"When we break down some of the trends within that, you can see some of the exploration plays had a hard time.
"That is the nature of exploration and greenfields exploration. You can see gold and precious metals benefited from positive commodity pricing, so that that really flowed through. And then the base metals where we were a little bit split between the names we had there, we had a couple of winners and a couple of losers.
"When we take a step back, I feel like the year panned out roughly how we were thinking."
Another $10,000 investment would have taken the hypothetical portfolio to $11,085, or if Hoff's take from 2023 were compounded, a $23,944 pool would be sitting there to take off the table or go again.
So what is Tim Hoff eyeing this time around?
Looking for discoveries
The big thing Hoffy is looking for is small caps with the potential to make a discovery.
That's getting easier in the gold space, where record prices are stirring rising valuations, with exploration budgets lifting as capital raises become easier and less dilutive.
But it's a double-edged sword. Hoff is looking for stocks that can go multiple times, and a number of gold names are already running hard.
And it's not just the now heavily covered gold sector where discoveries and rerates are on the cards.
"Obviously we had Trump come through in November, and that's set a whole series of events in place like the bull run in gold pricing, with the rare earths sector certainly performing very well on the back of that.
"And so there's always something happening in this market and pockets of interest."
Hoff's 2025 Diggers portfolio
Prospect Resources (ASX:PSC)
Prospect is the only repeat entry in this year's picks from the Canaccord number cruncher.
It owns the Mumbezhi project in Zambia, where Prospect has already outlined one of the largest undeveloped copper deposits on the ASX with over 500,000t of copper metal at grades of 0.5% Cu.
That puts it right in the wheelhouse of neighbour First Quantum Minerals, which picked up a 15% stake in the junior this year as questions circle the long-term future of its nearby Sentinel mine.
Hoff is doubling down even after a ripping 12-month run.
"This is a coverage stock that I have on take-out watch. Right next door to their project in Zambia, you have 60 million tonnes of processing capacity.
" It's owned by First Quantum. In 2029, the grade falls from 0.5% to 0.3%, and 2034 they run out of ore. You've got billions of dollars of sunk cost infrastructure there. And having that sit idle is not a tenable situation for a company like First Quantum.
"So we think they'll get taken out. And if they don't we think that the project and the deposit has the potential to seriously grow tonnes from here, which is why I still think it's heavily undervalued at the moment.
" It's heavily discounted still by the market, which hasn't yet come to fully grasp what's going on there."
Loyal Metals (ASX:LLM)
A lithium refugee, Loyal had its big coming out party in July when it procured the Highway Reward copper-gold mine in Queensland.
It's now up 122% over the past month.
One of the world's highest grade copper mines historically, past production saw 3.65Mt at 5.7% Cu and another 260,000t of gold ore at 4.5g/t Au.
Since mining ended 20 years ago, copper prices have risen 680% and gold 1256%.
"It's a high-grade copper project. It was smaller tonnes, it's a smaller footprint, but Loyal are looking for depth extensions, and there's been nothing done on this project for 20 years. No major modern geophysics, no drill program.
" So they're looking for proximal discoveries, discoveries at depth or some targets that were never tested. So that's really exciting to us.
"Market cap's about $25 million at the moment. We're starting from a nice low base there."
Peak Minerals (ASX:PUA)
Peak Minerals is one of a number of small caps enjoying the emergence of the Cameroon exploration scene, where it and DY6 Metals (ASX:DY6) have made rutile discoveries and Canyon Resources (ASX:CAY) is progressing its Minim Mirtap bauxite project.
It was on a trip to Cameroon to see the latter that Peak piqued the interest of Hoff.
"They're in the process of discovering what looks to be significant rutile discovery. Now mineral sands, there are varying grades and assemblages from lower value to higher value.
"What they're discovering appears to me to be a really high value mineral sands discovery.
"The stock's performed really well over the last couple of months. But I think ... this is when we see global scale projects, often the market will trail the results. And I think if this was in Western Australia, it'd be a much bigger company already.
"The fact that it's in Cameroon and … I don't know anyone else who's been there, I think that holds investors back sometimes and provides the opportunity for those willing to look over the border."
Q2 Metals Corp (TSX-V:QTWO)
For the first time, Hoffy is taking his hunt for deep value global with TSX.V-listed Q2, which runs at a market cap of just C$117m.
That betrays the very large potential resource its attempting to drill out at the Mia lithium project in Quebec.
Lithium prices are, as is well known, in the dunny. But recent spot price increases and optimism that demand could soon overtake supply again has analysts thinking more proactively about underappreciated opportunities in the space.
"We've written research on this. We think there's 207 million tonnes of spodumene there at grades of 1.3% lithium or more," Hoff said.
"That puts this as potentially the sixth largest deposit in the world, sitting there with a fairly low market cap at the moment relative to that.
"So I think any recovery that we see in the lithium market will translate to names like this, where there's a huge valuation gap between Patriot and Q2. Q2 is further down the line, but 200 million tonnes, again, this is something really big and their exploration target recently was even bigger than that."
Torque Metals (ASX:TOR)
Hoff's last pick is his only gold name, the Tolga Kumova-backed Torque.
It has assets in Canada and Australia, primarily focused on the Paris gold project near Kambalda and Kalgoorlie in WA's Eastern Goldfields.
"Torque's got some really interesting discovery holes coming through for a 100-mil market cap business at the moment.
"Gold being that hot, it won't take long for the market's eyes turn to some of the results and you'll see the share price performance come behind that."
The views, information, or opinions expressed in the interviews in this article are solely those of the interviewee and do not represent the views of Stockhead.
Stockhead does not provide, endorse or otherwise assume responsibility for any financial product advice contained in this article.
At Stockhead, we tell it like it is. While Loyal Metals, DY6 Metals and Prospect Resources are Stockhead advertisers, they did not sponsor this article.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
33 minutes ago
- ABC News
Federal politics live: Treasurer urged to 'be bold' on productivity and ditch 'lazy' AI approach
Nationals frontbencher Bridget McKenzie has accused the government of being "lazy" and looking to artificial intelligence as a way of boosting productivity. Follow our live coverage below.
ABC News
33 minutes ago
- ABC News
Live updates: Australian share market to fall, Wall Street gains as Apple pledges $154b US investment
Australian stocks are set to open lower, despite Wall Street gaining as Apple shares climbed after news of its plans to announce a domestic manufacturing pledge. We'll bring you the latest on what's happening on the markets throughout the day in our live blog. Disclaimer: this blog is not intended as investment advice.
ABC News
an hour ago
- ABC News
Identity of NSW man behind $19m 'ethical' internet scheme horrifies customers
It was pitched as the opposite of the dark web, an "ethical" version of the internet, raising as much as $19 million from backers sold on an Australian man's promise of the "Lightweb". But after 12 years and funds from up to 2,000 "mum and dad" investors from all over the world, the Equilux Lightweb still has not launched. Many customers are now pulling out of the ambitious scheme after learning the man behind it has not been using his legal name, and that he has previously been sanctioned by the corporate regulator, the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC). The ABC can reveal that Lightweb's founder — David Stryker — is really David Dayan Sevelle, a NSW man the financial watchdog sued in 2006 for running an unregistered investment scheme that left 70 "unsophisticated" investors out of pocket to the tune of $13 million. The financial watchdog shut down the scheme and imposed permanent bans on Mr Sevelle. ASIC confirmed to the ABC it was now making "preliminary inquiries" into the Lightweb scheme. It comes as Mr Sevelle, currently residing in Thailand, has been holding weekly "meritocratic" training over Zoom, teaching his followers how to behave morally for when the alternative internet launches, while preaching that "transparency is key". Do you know more about this or have a similar story? Email The Lightweb claims to be a superior, safer version of the internet through its requirement that users verify their identity to stamp out paedophiles and other online criminals. "It was going to be a platform that was effectively impervious to corruption," said Sydneysider David Coffey, who was won over by the premise and ended up putting $160,000 into the Lightweb project. But Mr Coffey desperately wanted out as he learned more about the company's founder in 2023. "He [Sevelle] moved to Thailand, which really raised a hell of a lot of eyebrows," he said. "Then we found out about the ASIC stuff and I started to get really uneasy." Mr Sevelle declined to be interviewed by the ABC because: "We are preparing for a Website Launch [sic] and will do press releases accordingly at that time." He did send lengthy responses to questions via email. Those involved in the Lightweb scheme have not been buying shares. They have been pre-purchasing advertising slots, called broadcast certificates, for when the platform goes live. It means the venture is technically not an investment scheme, and therefore does not require a financial services licence. It also does not receive as much scrutiny from regulators. The ABC has obtained one broadcast certificate where Mr Sevelle signed off under the name David Stryker. In his statement to the ABC, Mr Sevelle said he had not lied about his real identity and was simply using a "professional name" the same way actors, writers and influencers did. He said it was a "privacy barrier" to protect "unwanted commercial IP theft attempts" and also because the digital currency industry "can be very dangerous with nefarious and bad actors". "I have never hidden behind this name and still operate my own company and register domain names and trademarks and IP under my name," he said. "I wonder if you were interviewing Marilyn Monroe [if she was alive], P!NK, John Wayne [if he was alive], Nicholas Cage, Emilio Estevez and Katy Perry and many others that you would be accusing them of being deceptive "fake namers" like you did me." An information pack that a sales agency distributed in 2017 promised massive returns on these broadcast certificates, projecting they would sell for between eight and 25 times their original price. The internal document also stated the Lightweb platform would be worth $10 billion when it finally launched. Mr Sevelle told the ABC, "We never promise a fixed rate of return", and said this document was not "authorised marketing content". "When discovered, our management team pulled the document from circulation immediately, and this led to, in part, the triggering of formal dissolution of the sales agency," he said. He went on to say he was confident "we will exceed the 25 per cent product value increase" in the future. The Lightweb program has expanded its offering and announced plans to create its own virtual currency, including one called the StrykerCoin. To date, the platform still does not have an active website or a product and missed its own most recent deadline of a May launch. Mr Sevelle said there had been multiple delays due to "outside influences" such as "limited early development funding", the COVID pandemic, and the cost-of-living crisis. He said he expected the platform to launch within 90 days after dealing with a "trademark challenge". The Lightweb project operates under companies registered in Australia, New Zealand, the UK and the US, including Create2tech Pty Ltd, Stryker Design, StrykerFusion and Stryker Design International. Mr Sevelle's third wife, Noppakao Yingnok, a Thai and Australian citizen, is registered as the sole director of these businesses. When the ABC asked Ms Yingnok questions about the operations of her companies, she said to "talk to David". Mr Sevelle said he shared responsibilities between himself, the leadership team, the consulting team, and his wife in managing the businesses and was a "key decision maker". An internal report from 2023 showed Mr Sevelle was not the director of the Lightweb business but appeared to have been making a sizeable amount of money. A company called Elleves Pty Ltd, which is "Sevelle" spelt backwards, was paid $250,000 in "consulting fees" in 2020 and 2021. Mr Sevelle is listed as the sole director of Elleves. In his statement to the ABC, Mr Sevelle said he had originally loaned money to the Lightweb companies to get them off the ground and that the $500,000 payment to Elleves Pty Ltd was an "accumulation over years" of uncharged fees. He claimed there was no direct benefit paid to him and that he was paid a salary of $50,000. Concerns among Lightweb members mounted when Mr Sevelle and Ms Yingnok moved overseas to Thailand, permanently, in early 2023. Around the same time, news of Mr Sevelle's real identity broke among his supporters, and his past was laid bare. ASIC sued Mr Sevelle in the Federal Court in 2006 for running a property venture that "made statements to clients that were misleading or deceptive" and for "improperly assisting clients to obtain loans to invest in the scheme". Mr Sevelle ran a slew of property companies, trading under the name Mega Money, operating in the Central Coast, Newcastle, Hunter Valley, South Coast and Canberra regions, with the intention of pulling together enough mum-and-dad investors to pay for stamp duty and development approvals on blocks of land, and sell them at a profit to developers. But ASIC froze the Mega Money companies by court order, and eventually they were all forced into liquidation. In an affidavit filed with the Federal Court, the court-appointed liquidator, Justin Walsh of Ernst & Young, said Mr Sevelle spent "significant sums of money" from the company on "personal purposes". Those included an $86,000 antique "sloop" yacht, moored in the Toronto Yacht Club, and also "a large number of cash withdrawals" from ATMs. "Large sums of money" also went into Mr Sevelle and his then-wife's personal house and two investment units. He was not married to Ms Yingnok at that time. Two of these properties were sold before the liquidator could lodge a caveat to protect creditor interests at the site. "The [company] accounts were replete with inconsistent treatment of recurring transactions, unexplained transactions, and fundamental balancing errors," the liquidator added. The "majority" of investors had borrowed against their homes to invest in the scheme, and many had dipped into their superannuation as well, Mr Walsh's report noted. Mr Sevelle was banned permanently through court-ordered enforceable undertakings from providing financial advice, dealing in financial products, and carrying on a financial services business, including through the promotion and operation of any managed investment scheme. Separately, ASIC also permanently banned Mr Sevelle from financial services. "It definitely affected our retirement," said a Mega Money investor from Maitland, near Newcastle. Another couple from the local area, who lost $90,000 from the property scheme, said of Mr Sevelle: "He could probably sell coal to Newcastle [like] ice to Eskimos. We fell into that trap quite easily." Mr Sevelle told the ABC that "there was no impropriety" in the Mega Money collapse and that he was not fined or charged over anything. "ATM withdrawals, antiques, jewellery, any personal purchases made were from post-income tax paid earnings for those personal purchases," he added. As Lightweb customers learned the full extent of Mr Sevelle's past, he released a lengthy statement to explain the situation and his decision to change his name. He claimed ASIC found a "glitch" in the way he ran his property companies where he was treating all his businesses as one, which meant he was over the limit of investment funds and was running an unregistered managed scheme. "I had been treated like a pariah for no reason other than one technical accounting glitch," he wrote. "I apologise I did not disclose this to you at the initial outset of the business recruitment process, but I am sure you will appreciate my position and my actions to best nurture the project. "I do not wish my name to be associated to this project till we are secure, launched and commercially sound. "I hope you can understand this explanation … Transparency is key." He signed off as "David Sevelle AKA David Stryker (professional name)." Despite the explanations, a 2023 company document showed 90 people demanded refunds from the Lightweb scheme. Customers had been promised full refunds, but Mr Coffey, the Sydneysider who put $160,000 into the Lightweb project, alleged the company was "putting up walls everywhere", including placing a limit on how much he would receive monthly. He ended up having to engage lawyers, and it took until the end of last year to get all his money back. "Our client is understandably concerned about the legitimacy of your business and ability to refund his investment pursuant to your agreement with him," the legal letter, addressed to Noppakao Yingnok and David Stryker, read. "Our client has since been advised that you will now be paying the remainder of the refund by way of $10,000 payments over 10 months. "Your company has no standing to set these repayment terms with our client. Your contract with our client provides that a full refund is available upon request." Mr Sevelle told the ABC that, for cashflow reasons, refunds of more than $10,000 could not be paid in a lump sum. "It is not prudent to do so, as we are not a bank," he said. "No-one was ever boxed into staying. No startups or scale-ups have ever refunded pre-launch that we are aware of." Mr Sevelle has previously told his customers on a video call that the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) has audited the business numerous times due to the number of self-managed super funds in the scheme. The ATO told the ABC it would not comment on specific cases or confirm if an investigation was underway. In a statement, a spokesperson said: "The ATO encourages anyone setting up an SMSF [self-managed super fund] to ensure they understand what is involved in running their own super fund, and that they are ready and able to meet these obligations." The ABC has spoken to multiple people, who did not want to be identified, who said the company's most recent sales rhetoric involved encouraging investors to mortgage their homes to obtain more money. Morgan, 26, from Newcastle, said her father was so taken with the Lightweb idea he was considering retiring early so he could put his long service leave into the scheme. His family convinced him not to, but he is now looking into mortgaging the family home. He has already put $40,000 into the scheme. "It's definitely caused a lot of tension, especially because I feel like Mum and Dad have worked so hard for everything they have, and to have someone convince my dad to hand that over, it's just mind-boggling, like it's insane," Morgan said. Barry Urquhart, 66, from Newcastle, bought $7,000 worth of broadcast certificates several years ago. When he tried to put in more money through his superannuation, he said his accountant would not authorise it. "He said it [the Lightweb] was nothing; it was just a dream," Mr Urquhart said. Mr Urquhart has since gotten his money back and reported the company to ASIC. Mr Sevelle said in his statement to the ABC that: "The truth is that if they [customers] are no longer in our organisation and they have been refunded what they were entitled to, they of course will not want us to succeed, as our success will then be their failure." "I am sorry for both you and I, that you did not see this as a bigger story of innovation, empowerment, job creation and unlimited opportunities," he said. Mr Sevelle "will dance you around like you're on Dancing with the Stars," said one Lightweb customer who did not want to speak on the record. "He likes to use so much financial technical jargon and acronyms to confuse the hell out of people," they said. Others have described Mr Sevelle as having the "gift of the gab" and went as far as saying it felt like a cult of personality. Mr Sevelle has been holding hours-long "moral" training sessions every week over Zoom for years, where he teaches his followers how to behave like "meritocrats" for when the Lightweb finally launches. Some of these sessions involve movie nights, such as watching The Big Short and Eat the Rich. "There were so many people who drank the Kool-Aid and were calling him the Messiah," said Mr Coffey, the Sydney customer who had taken his money out. "It was constantly reinforced how blessed we were to be in the company at this time of imminent launch … so we had better buy more of the upcoming new investments before it's too late," said another customer, on condition of anonymity. ASIC said it was "aware of concerns related to these entities and is making preliminary inquiries". The financial regulator added: "Speaking generally, super-switching misconduct is an increasing concern for ASIC." "We are seeing more and more reports of people being targeted by pushy, high-pressure sales tactics into switching their super into high-risk, complex schemes," a spokesperson said. "Other red flags include high-pressure sales tactics, poor or even non-existent product disclosure, and promises of unrealistically high returns." Mr Sevelle said he welcomed both ASIC and the ATO looking into the Lightweb businesses.
