Ditching ‘Malay first' stance alone won't draw non-Malay support, says analyst
PETALING JAYA : A political analyst has dismissed as insignificant Perikatan Nasional chairman Muhyiddin Yassin's attempt to consign his 'I am Malay first' declaration to the past, saying it was unlikely to boost the opposition coalition's non-Malay support.
Akademi Nusantara's Azmi Hassan said the presence of PAS, with its perceived hardline religious views, remains the biggest factor deterring non-Malays from supporting the opposition coalition.
He also said Muhyiddin's statement was unlikely to water down support for PN as the Malay vote remains largely intact behind PAS.
'Malay support for PN is not so much because of Bersatu but because of PAS.
Play
Azmi Hassan.
'I don't think this (statement by Muhyiddin) would unsettle PAS leaders, as they have never said that they were fighting for the Malays. Their struggle is to protect the sanctity of Islam as a religion.
'Of course, indirectly they are saying they'll fight for the Malays, since nearly all Malays are Muslim, but never in PAS's political struggle have they said that they are targeting or trying to protect the Malays,' he told FMT.
Oh Ei Sun, of the Singapore Institute of International Affairs, agreed. He said PAS was fundamentally a religion-oriented party rather than race-centric.
Oh believes Muhyiddin backtracked on his 'Malay first' declaration as part of efforts to revive his political relevance, both within his party and coalition as well as in the national arena.
He said Bersatu had successfully snapped up a handful of Chinese leaders from other parties over the past few months. However, he questioned whether the move would be successful in wooing the community's support.
AdChoices
ADVERTISING
Oh Ei Sun.
'I think Bersatu realises that it cannot match PAS in attracting Malay support or Umno in distributing resources to the Malays.
'So it is attempting to break new ground by being acceptable to non-Malays as well.
'In politics, such gambles have to be undertaken from time to time when the political fortunes are low,' he said.
On Sunday, Muhyiddin acknowledged having said 'I am Malay first' in 2010, but claimed that it was 'no longer important'.
The former prime minister said he has never seen himself as 'only Malay', insisting that he was 'a Malay who cares for all Malaysians'.
The pronouncement drew barbs from DAP veteran Lim Kit Siang, who challenged him to put his words into action by leading a campaign urging Malaysians to put nationality before ethnicity.
Meanwhile, Umno chief Dr Akmal Saleh accused Muhyiddin of simply changing his stance 'in the pursuit of power'.
However, Urimai chairman P Ramasamy hailed Muhyiddin's shift as a timely and vital step towards PN becoming a coalition that can represent all Malaysians.
Ramasamy said this could make PN an inclusive alternative for non-Malays ahead of the next general election. However, he urged the coalition to avoid the Barisan Nasional model of non-Malay parties being subservient to their Malay counterparts and 'politically emasculated'.
Azmi said BN was successful over a period of 60 years because Umno, MCA and MIC looked out for the interests of the respective communities they represented.
In contrast, he said PKR has struggled to position itself as a multiracial party despite being one on paper, and needs the likes of Amanah and DAP to boost its standing among Malay and Chinese voters, respectively.
Azmi said the same model could prove successful for PN provided it has a strong partner capable of garnering non-Malay support. However, the issue for PN was that there is no party outside of DAP capable of commanding such support presently.
'(PN can) forget about Gerakan. They've been unsuccessful in elections over the last two to three years,' said Azmi.
Oh also dismissed Ramasamy's view, saying: 'it will be 'same old, same old', with Malay and Islamic supremacy coupled with non-Malay and non-Muslim decorations'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Malay Mail
14 minutes ago
- Malay Mail
White sea of solidarity: Over 100,000 expected at Dataran Merdeka for Gaza on August 24
KUALA LUMPUR, Aug 18 — Over 100,000 participants from across the country are expected to gather at Dataran Merdeka this Sunday for the 'Malam Himpunan dan Selawat — Malaysiaku Bersama Gaza', the highlight of the Sumud Nusantara Carnival 2025. The event, jointly organised by the Malaysian Consultative Council of Islamic Organisations (Mapim) and Cinta Gaza Malaysia (CGM), is held under the patronage of Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim, with the support of Communications Minister Datuk Fahmi Fadzil, Minister in the Prime Minister's Department (Religious Affairs) Datuk Mohd Na'im Mokhtar and Minister in the Prime Minister's Department (Federal Territories) Datuk Seri Dr Zaliha Mustafa. Mapim chief executive officer Datuk Sani Araby, who is also the carnival director, said the gathering is especially meaningful as it coincides with the National Month celebration. 'We want Dataran Merdeka to become a sea of white as a symbol of Malaysian solidarity with the struggle in Gaza. 'As we celebrate independence, it is meaningful for us as a free nation to reflect on the suffering of our brothers and sisters in Gaza and Palestine and help them break free from the Zionist apartheid regime,' he said in a statement today. Meanwhile, CGM chief executive officer and Sumud Nusantara project director Nadir Al-Nuri said the gathering would amplify Malaysia's voice of solidarity on the world stage. 'It will also be translated into action through the Global Sumud Flotilla, with activists from 39 countries joining a peaceful mission to sail towards Gaza, similar to the Madleen and Handala vessels,' he said. The public is invited to attend with their families, dressed in white in solidarity with Gaza and Palestine, to join Maghrib prayers and solat hajat led by Sheikh Abdul Karim Al-Makki, followed by a religious lecture. The programme will culminate with a special address by the prime minister, the Sumud Nusantara Declaration for Gaza, the symbolic flag-off of the Sumud Nusantara Flotilla delegation, and the recitation of Qunut Nazilah. The three-day carnival from Aug 22 to 24 will also feature various attractions, including the VR Gaza Time Tunnel by Mapim, a hot air balloon show, Havoc Food Festival, exhibitions by various agencies, the launch of the 'Gaza 101' Malaysia Projects Compendium, Kids World Hall and film screenings on Gaza's struggle. Over 1,000 vehicles from across the country and eight foreign nations are also expected to join a solidarity convoy, carrying Palestinian flags to Dataran Merdeka in a rare display of unity in Malaysia. Public facilities, including prayer spaces, will be available, but attendees are advised to bring mats, prayer rugs and umbrellas, and are encouraged to use public transport for convenience and smooth traffic flow. — Bernama
Malay Mail
14 minutes ago
- Malay Mail
Home minister: Police will investigate alleged Jalur Gemilang violations professionally and responsibly
KUALA LUMPUR, Aug 18 — Home Minister Datuk Seri Saifuddin Nasution Ismail stressed that police will investigate any offence involving the improper display of the Jalur Gemilang, professionally and responsibly. He said that if investigations reveal malicious intent, appropriate legal action will be taken against those involved, including under the Emblems and Names (Prevention of Improper Use) Act 1963, or the Minor Offences Act 1955 (Act 336). 'If there is an offence, a police report should be lodged and an investigation will follow. If it is proven to be done with malicious intent, charges will be brought. However, if the matter is blown out of proportion to the point of creating unrest, that would not be healthy in the current climate of our country. 'When there is a clear violation of the law, trust that the police will carry out their duties responsibly, to ensure that the nation remains peaceful and secure,' he said, during a ministers' briefing session at the Dewan Rakyat, today. Saifuddin Nasution also urged all parties, including the public, political leaders and civil society, to play their role in safeguarding national peace and harmony. On the issue of national security threats, Saifuddin said the country's enforcement and defence agencies continue to step up security measures, as Malaysia remains a target for infiltration, including by Mossad and Israeli agents. He added that swift action by the authorities has led to the arrest of individuals and groups, including locals, suspected of being involved in terrorism-related activities. '…we have arrested local citizens, students, civil servants and other individuals. Some have been brought to court, some are still on trial, others are under remand. A few months ago, we also uncovered and detained more terrorist cells, including foreigners from Bangladesh. 'National security threats remain present around us. Extremist ideologies such as militancy, terrorism and radical movements still exist, and infiltration by foreign agents continues. I am stating this based on facts,' he said. Meanwhile, on the recent attack involving the son of former economy minister Datuk Seri Rafizi Ramli, Saifuddin said police are continuing to provide security support to the family of the Pandan Member of Parliament. He added that Rafizi's son is also still under medical observation at the hospital. 'In terms of security, the police will provide the best possible support. At the same time, we want to avoid any perception that the police respond quickly only when a minister's family is involved, but are slow to act in cases concerning ordinary citizens,' he said, when winding up the briefing session, after it was debated by six government and opposition MPs. Earlier, Saifuddin's briefing session lasted for almost 30 minutes after the end of the question-and-answer session, and was debated by Datuk Matbali Musah (GRS-Sipitang), Datuk Seri Takiyuddin Hassan (PN-Kota Bharu), Mohd Sany Hamzan (PH-Hulu Langat), Datuk Seri Saifuddin Abdullah (PN-Indera Mahkota), Syahredzan Johan (PH-Bangi) and Afnan Hamimi Taib Azamudden (PN-Alor Setar). He said that further clarification on the questions and issues raised during the session would be provided, during the winding-up of the debate on the 13th Malaysia Plan (13MP) motion for the ministry. — Bernama
New Straits Times
44 minutes ago
- New Straits Times
'I'm not racist,' says Rayer amid Dewan Rakyat exchange
KUALA LUMPUR: Jelutong member of Parliament RSN Rayer has denied being racist following a heated exchange in the Dewan Rakyat last week during the debate on the 13th Malaysia Plan (13MP), Utusan Malaysia reported. The DAP MP said his comments had been misinterpreted after he questioned whether Pas could be considered a "Parti Ajaran Sesat" (deviant teaching party), a remark that drew strong reactions from Pas lawmakers. "I am not racist. Just look at my TikTok account, all communities receive allocations. "As a DAP MP, I represent a party that was not founded on racial lines. "DAP upholds the principles of social democracy and defends the rights of all communities. "We are 'colour blind' and always extend assistance to anyone in need," he said. Rayer said his remark was made in response to Marang MP Tan Sri Abdul Hadi Awang, who had claimed during the debate that Kuala Lumpur faced problems because it was led by DAP. "I was disappointed because I have always regarded Abdul Hadi as a respected leader who debates with solid arguments. "But his claim was baseless. "I rose and politely asked the Speaker, not to attack or insult anyone, but to respond. "I said, would you accept it if I called Pas a 'Parti Ajaran Sesat'? "I was merely quoting former Pagoh MP Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin, who had once said the same thing," he said. Rayer said that he had no personal enmity with Pas, noting that the two parties once worked together under the Pakatan Rakyat coalition. "At the time, I was the Seri Delima assemblyman in Penang and had no issues with Pas. "In fact, I still keep and display a photograph of the late Pas spiritual leader, Datuk Nik Abdul Aziz Nik Mat, at my service centre in Jelutong. "Pas then was very different from today," he said. Responding to claims that he had been instructed to be confrontational in parliament, Rayer said his interjections were his own spontaneous reactions in defence of the government. "As a government MP, it is my duty to defend the government. "That was not something I was instructed to do. "My approach in parliament is different from how I am in my constituency," he said. Citing an example, Rayer said he interjected during the speech by Kota Baru MP Datuk Seri Takiyuddin Hassan, who had alleged that the government was ignoring the welfare of the Indian community. "If I had not stood up, he would have continued with his incitement. "But when I interjected, it was misinterpreted as though I was trying to silence him. "Do we want to remain trapped in this 'silo mentality', with Indians in their way, Malays in theirs and Chinese in theirs? "If so, how can we build a truly inclusive and united future?" he said.
