PC leader's call to park overdose prevention van based on misleading information: Sunshine House
PC Leader Obby Khan said in a news release Thursday the federal government should put the brakes on Sunshine House's overdose prevention van, citing a 25 per cent reduction in overdose calls and a 29 per cent reduction in the administration of naloxone after its first RV was taken out of service in early July.
Data from the Winnipeg Fire Paramedic Service does show numbers went down month-over-month, with naloxone administrations dropping from 619 in June to 466, and patient numbers sliding from 340 to 264.
But Sunshine House's executive director, Levi Foy, says the figures are misleading.
"That doesn't actually take into account the overdoses that we have responded to or that community partners have responded to or that community members have responded to," he said. "It's misinformation."
Foy said the higher naloxone distribution in June could also indicate there may have been more kits of the opioid overdose medication out in the community that month, and that people may have had less need of emergency services.
"It's really hurtful that they would come out and they would launch this type of attack against a community-based organization without actually speaking to us, without visiting our site, without having any kind of engagement or full understanding of our relationship with WFPS," he said.
A city spokesperson said in an email there's often "significant fluctuations" in the data between months, and that many factors could be behind that, including drug availability, their potency, and the season.
"Over the past several years, as the drug crisis has heightened, we've also seen a shift where more residents, outreach agencies and substance users are carrying/using naloxone, without calling 911," the email said.
'Let's take a look at those numbers': PC leader
The mobile service, which lets people use substances under the supervision of staff trained in overdose response, first hit the road in the fall of 2022. The RV that used to offer the service was totalled on July 2 after a vehicle ran into them.
The Salvation Army donated a new vehicle — a decommissioned ambulance — to Sunshine House after the hit-and-run. The PCs said in the statement they've sent a letter to the federal health minister urging he to reject an exemption allowing Sunshine House to run a mobile injection site on the ambulance.
Khan is quoted as saying the data is clear, and that when the van is "taken off the road, drug activity goes down."
On Friday, the Tory leader acknowledged the data goes up and down over time, but he told CBC News the party is just calling for pause to see whether the numbers stay lower.
"Does this trend continue in August, in September?" he said. "Is that van actually enabling people to be stuck in this drug suspension that they're in, this addiction that they're in? So let's get more data.… We're simply saying let's take a look at those numbers."
Foy said injections only represents a fraction of the services the van offers and that more than 95 per cent of services they deal with are related to inhalation and smoking, which "never stopped in that time frame."
He said that the number of overdoses Sunshine House sees actually went up that month, from 11 in June to 27 in July.
"I think all of the information around toxic drug supply that's being shared across the sector and with community members has really improved our abilities to not have to rely on WFPS as much," he said.
"I'm really sad that … they are using this as a moment to kind of attack our services."
Manitoba PCs want halt to mobile overdose prevention site
3 hours ago
Sunshine House's mobile overdose prevention site is back on the streets of Winnipeg after a collision last month, but Progressive Conservative Leader Obby Khan argues the mobile program should be closed permanently.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CTV News
6 hours ago
- CTV News
‘So many deserving kids': Sask. Ride to the Max continues for 11th ride
Isaac had an opportunity to try out one of the bikes with the help of his mom, Jordan. (Hallee Mandryk/CTV News) A group of motorcyclists continued a decade-long tradition of riding for a good cause on Saturday in Martensville, Sask. 'One of the members of our club, years ago, his little boy had cancer. And so we started it then, and we've just kept it going ever since,' Jenz Wollny, the event organizer, said. Ride to the Max annually raises funds for families who have a child undergoing cancer treatment. The Jim Pattinson Children's Hospital connects a different family with the organizers each year. 'Whenever anyone wants to pick your own family, it really makes you feel special because there are so many deserving kids out there. So it's all for him. It's really special and fun for our whole family,' said James McCrimmon, father of the selected family, shared. James and Jordan McCrimmon have spent the last two and a half years in and out of hospital with their son, Isaac, who was diagnosed with leukemia at two years old. 'We're just overwhelmed. We are very excited. We've had a long couple of years, and anytime someone wants to celebrate us or him, we're happy about it. So we're very excited and grateful,' Jordan said. The funds from this event will help alleviate some of the financial burden that comes with lengthy hospital stays. Isaac is currently admitted at the hospital, but he was able to leave for the day to enjoy the over 50 motorcycles parading for him. 'We do a lot of split family time. He's at the hospital with me or James, and the other person is with the other two kids. So this has given us the ability to be together as a family and not have to work and deal with this at the same time,' Jordan said. The grand total won't be known for a little while, but Wollny says even after attending this event eleven times, the feeling of presenting the family with the funds is always special. 'Everybody believes it's a really good cause. It's amazing, it really is. Everybody's there, they see the family show up, and just see how happy they are to get a little extra money,' Wollny said. For the McCrimmons, it's a positive reminder that they have a loving community in their corner during a very difficult time. 'Fundraisers like these have let us be by his side for the last two and a half years without ever leaving. I don't think anyone will ever fully understand how much this actually helps us. It's pretty powerful,' James said.
CTV News
6 hours ago
- CTV News
Quebec clay tennis courts closing over asbestos concern
Several Quebec municipalities have closed their tennis courts over concerns about asbestos concentrations in clay products used to maintain them. Several Quebec municipalities have closed their tennis courts over concerns about asbestos concentrations in clay products used to maintain them. Samples that exceeded Canadian limits were found in a bag of clay in St-Sauveur. Julien Charest-Landry, St-Sauveur director of Public Works, said they were alerted several weeks ago about levels of asbestos in a bag of Har-Tru clay the city uses for its courts. 'It states the material could contain up to 0.1 per cent of asbestos. But the permitted limit in Canada is less than 0.1 per cent,' he said. While samples taken from the tennis courts showed no signs of asbestos, he says Environment Canada advised them to close their clay courts as a precaution while the investigation is underway. It started a domino effect of closures across the province. In Montreal, 32 clay courts were closed down across 5 boroughs, including Outremont, Verdun, LaSalle, Saint-Leonard and Pierrefonds-Roxboro. American company Har-Tru, the biggest provider of clay for courts in Quebec, said it's investigating the matter. 'Har-Tru anticipates a temporary hold on the import, sale, and use of Har-Tru materials in Quebec and perhaps other parts of Canada. We will work with authorities to remain in full compliance with the law and meet expectations. We are hopeful new testing, re-testing, and a collaborative process across the U.S./Canadian border will make this a brief disruption,' it said in a statement to CTV. Tennis Quebec Executive Director Julie Vezina said they are in contact with health authorities and members who may have concerns. 'At the moment no one has asked clubs to close, it's really just preventative measures,' she said. In Pointe-Claire's Valois Tennis Club, all five of its clay courts were open for play Friday. Facilities Manager Thomas Brown said they take precautions such as protective clothing and masks when handling the clay and spreading it each spring. He said the fact that no courts have tested positive for asbestos is a good sign. 'Anyone like us who lays down clay in April, there's probably something to be found in the bag but there's nothing to be found on the court,' he said. Still, he said they won't be touching any of the stockpiles of product they have at the club. Members are also holding their breath, hoping the club won't have to close. 'I hope the issue is addressed,' said James Shetler. 'But it's not going to stop me from playing.'
CTV News
8 hours ago
- CTV News
Don't blame us for hospital eyesore, Sudbury festival says in a statement
There are new calls for something to be done about the former Sudbury hospital building that was turned into a massive mural. The people behind Sudbury's Up Here festival are reminding residents that the mural painted on the former hospital in 2019 was supposed to be a swan song for the building, not a long-term fixture. In a statement Tuesday, festival officials said when they completed the massive mural on the former St. Joseph's Hospial, the idea was the building was being demolished within a year. 'We wanted to bid a vibrant and colourful farewell to this historic landmark by turning it into a bold piece of contemporary art — an endeavour that would leave a lasting — albeit a tiny bit, very slightly, barely even noticeably controversial — impression on the Canadian artistic landscape,' the statement said. 'Today … we find ourselves as disheartened as everyone by the lack of progress on the part of the property owners. We yearn for the old hospital to undergo a metamorphosis, to be revitalized and reintegrated into the fabric of our community. We agree with Mayor (Paul) Lefebvre's urgent desire to repurpose the building.' The 80,000-square-foot mural was completed by street artist RISK in summer 2019. While divisive even at time it was completed, the mural has since deteriorated, with the bright colours gradually blending in. The fact it is located in a prominent spot on the shores of Ramsey Lake has made it an especially visible source of frustration for many residents. Now owned by Panoramic Properties, the original plan was to convert the building into high-end condos. The company received approvals for its plans after a lengthy planning process, but by that time market conditions changed and the condo plan was shelved. Messages to Panoramic seeking comment for this story have not yet been returned. Last week, Lefebvre told a seniors group in a meeting that dealing with the former hospital is a priority. He said after he was elected, he met with Panoramic president Angelo Butera to find out what their plans are. 'First of all, it has to come down,' Lefebvre said. Hospital mural Greater Sudbury is considering implementing a derelict building bylaw that aims to prevent another fiasco like the former hospital on Paris Street. (File) 'So I am optimistic, however, that something will happen. That being said, I am also a realist ... If it doesn't happen soon, the city needs to move and do something.' The mayor promised there would be action on the hospital during his term. 'And you can quote me on that,' Lefebvre said. For its part, Up Here said the site should become 'a dynamic hub of creativity and cultural expression.' 'Regrettably, the delay in the building's evolution has left many of us frustrated and disenchanted,' the statement said. 'We implore Panoramic Properties to honour their obligation and swiftly undertake the necessary steps to fulfil the collective vision we hold for this cherished property.' Up Here declined a request from CTV News for an interview on their statement. With files from Ian Campbell
